Modern, luxury 5-bed, 4.5-bath w/full basement! Now booking for 2024!
5.0
Outstanding(71 Reviews)House in Tisbury, MA
12 guests · 5 bedrooms · 5 baths
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Includes essentialsGarden, Kitchen or Kitchenette, Air conditioner and more
Book with confidenceWe partner with the top travel sites so you know you're getting a great deal on the perfect rental
About this house rental
Pirate's Reef is a NEW and beautifully decorated residence that offers 5 spacious bedrooms (2 master suites!) with 4.5 bathrooms, full finished basement with wet bar and combo pool table/table tennis, and accommodates up to 12 guests.
This is the PERFECT vacation home for you and your guests. This home is nestled behind the historic Shearer Cottage on a quiet lane in East Chop, located just minutes away from all the charm and activities that Oak Bluffs has to offer. The beach, harbor, and town are all just a pleasant 15 minute walk away, or less than a 5 minute drive/bike ride. Guests will enjoy the private, wooded area of the home's setting, allowing one to truly experience the magic of Vineyard "island living."
Each floor features 1 master suite and 1 living room, making it quite comfortable for multiple families, large groups, and entertaining. Pirate’s Reef has custom carpentry, a gas fireplace, central air conditioning, ceiling fans, a Weber gas grill, and a fire pit to help create those special memories outside. The home has blazing fast 1,000 mbps (1 gigabyte) WiFi, for when you want to stream your favorite TV shows and movies from the multiple Samsung SmartTVs throughout the home, or if you want to go live on Instagram #getawaysociety #piratesreef. The high-speed internet is ideal for those who want to “work-from-anywhere,” which in this case is the beautiful and serene island of Martha’s Vineyard.
The main level has a gourmet kitchen with a breakfast bar, a Keurig coffee maker, dishes, utensils, pots, pans, along with a gas range, and stainless steel appliances. The dining room has a large farmhouse table that seats at least 8 people. The living room has a 55” SmartTV with access to apps such as Netflix, Hulu, and Amazon Video, along with a DVD player. The main floor master bedroom has a king bed, flat screen TV, two large closets, and the bathroom has a huge walk-in shower.
The second level has 4 bedrooms. The upstairs master bedroom has a king bed, flat screen TV, and an en suite bathroom. The upstairs living room/bedroom has a sliding door and a private bath, flat screen TV, sleeper sofa, and a twin bed. The 4th bedroom has a full and twin bed and shares a Jack and Jill bathroom with the 5th bedroom, which has a queen and twin bed.
The full finished basement provides even more SPACE. Upon walking downstairs you'll immediately notice the warm hue of the hardwood floors, gray furniture, and gorgeous granite countertops on the wet bar. To top it off, the basement also contains a pool table and 65" SmartTV to ensure a good time will be had by all!
Off the living and dining room there is a wraparound deck with a Weber gas grill and outdoor seating, which provides a great environment for cookouts and gathering with friends and family. An outdoor shower enables you to rinse off after a long day at the beach. The washer and dryer is located in the unfinished basement. There is also ample parking in the driveway for 6 cars. This is a quintessential Martha's Vineyard vacation home and will exceed your expectations!
Note: The guest house above the garage is NOT part of the home rental.
Minimum age to rent is 25 years-old.
NO pets and NO smoking. Please do not move the furniture.
The cleaning fee covers cleaning, linens, towels, and the cost of laundering. Guests are subject to an additional $250 cleaning fee if grill not cleaned adequately after use.
We have consulted sources such as the Centers for Disease Control (CDC), Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), and World Health Organization (WHO). We are also implementing best practices from some of the top medical and hospitality institutions in the world to ensure we have the best cleaning and disinfecting protocols. Please rest assured that a clean home for our guests is of the utmost importance to us.
This is a Getaway Society vacation rental home. Please ask us about our portfolio of homes in Martha's Vineyard, Hilton Head, Orlando, Gatlinburg, Sandbridge Beach (Virginia), Broken Bow (Oklahoma), and the Pocono Mountains. Our vacation rental properties are perfectly located and stylishly designed to help you create an amazingly memorable experience on every single getaway. Visit our website for more information.
This is the PERFECT vacation home for you and your guests. This home is nestled behind the historic Shearer Cottage on a quiet lane in East Chop, located just minutes away from all the charm and activities that Oak Bluffs has to offer. The beach, harbor, and town are all just a pleasant 15 minute walk away, or less than a 5 minute drive/bike ride. Guests will enjoy the private, wooded area of the home's setting, allowing one to truly experience the magic of Vineyard "island living."
Each floor features 1 master suite and 1 living room, making it quite comfortable for multiple families, large groups, and entertaining. Pirate’s Reef has custom carpentry, a gas fireplace, central air conditioning, ceiling fans, a Weber gas grill, and a fire pit to help create those special memories outside. The home has blazing fast 1,000 mbps (1 gigabyte) WiFi, for when you want to stream your favorite TV shows and movies from the multiple Samsung SmartTVs throughout the home, or if you want to go live on Instagram #getawaysociety #piratesreef. The high-speed internet is ideal for those who want to “work-from-anywhere,” which in this case is the beautiful and serene island of Martha’s Vineyard.
The main level has a gourmet kitchen with a breakfast bar, a Keurig coffee maker, dishes, utensils, pots, pans, along with a gas range, and stainless steel appliances. The dining room has a large farmhouse table that seats at least 8 people. The living room has a 55” SmartTV with access to apps such as Netflix, Hulu, and Amazon Video, along with a DVD player. The main floor master bedroom has a king bed, flat screen TV, two large closets, and the bathroom has a huge walk-in shower.
The second level has 4 bedrooms. The upstairs master bedroom has a king bed, flat screen TV, and an en suite bathroom. The upstairs living room/bedroom has a sliding door and a private bath, flat screen TV, sleeper sofa, and a twin bed. The 4th bedroom has a full and twin bed and shares a Jack and Jill bathroom with the 5th bedroom, which has a queen and twin bed.
The full finished basement provides even more SPACE. Upon walking downstairs you'll immediately notice the warm hue of the hardwood floors, gray furniture, and gorgeous granite countertops on the wet bar. To top it off, the basement also contains a pool table and 65" SmartTV to ensure a good time will be had by all!
Off the living and dining room there is a wraparound deck with a Weber gas grill and outdoor seating, which provides a great environment for cookouts and gathering with friends and family. An outdoor shower enables you to rinse off after a long day at the beach. The washer and dryer is located in the unfinished basement. There is also ample parking in the driveway for 6 cars. This is a quintessential Martha's Vineyard vacation home and will exceed your expectations!
Note: The guest house above the garage is NOT part of the home rental.
Minimum age to rent is 25 years-old.
NO pets and NO smoking. Please do not move the furniture.
The cleaning fee covers cleaning, linens, towels, and the cost of laundering. Guests are subject to an additional $250 cleaning fee if grill not cleaned adequately after use.
We have consulted sources such as the Centers for Disease Control (CDC), Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), and World Health Organization (WHO). We are also implementing best practices from some of the top medical and hospitality institutions in the world to ensure we have the best cleaning and disinfecting protocols. Please rest assured that a clean home for our guests is of the utmost importance to us.
This is a Getaway Society vacation rental home. Please ask us about our portfolio of homes in Martha's Vineyard, Hilton Head, Orlando, Gatlinburg, Sandbridge Beach (Virginia), Broken Bow (Oklahoma), and the Pocono Mountains. Our vacation rental properties are perfectly located and stylishly designed to help you create an amazingly memorable experience on every single getaway. Visit our website for more information.
Amenities
Air conditioner
Kitchen or Kitchenette
Internet / Wifi
Fireplace
Parking
Laundry
Balcony or Patio
Dishwasher
TV
Garden
Family friendly
Map of Tisbury, MA
Reviews
5.0
Outstanding(71 Reviews)5.0
Beautiful property! Our every need was met! Carrington our host was extremely attentive and available to answer our questions. Will definitely recommend to others!!
5.0
Great house and Corrington was a pleasure to work with.
5.0
The property is exactly as advertised. The only potential “surprise” was how incredibly well stocked the kitchen was upon arrival (we expected very basic supplies, but were pleasantly surprised to find everything we could possibly need). The house was large, had plenty of sleep and relaxation space, was clean, and properly advertised on the listing. The host was easy to communicate with and provided updates as needed throughout (at one point I let him know a couple light bulbs were dead but that I didn’t need him to do anything during our trip. He replied immediately and offered to come by and replace if we wanted that day). Everything was easy and you should have no hesitations about staying here.
5.0
This is the most perfect home - everything we needed and more for a large multi-family vacation! The different levels and gorgeous outdoor living space allowed for privacy when needed and multiple hangout spots. The open kitchen, large dinning table, and living room shared space made for dancing in the kitchen while preparing meals, at the same time as intense family card games around the dining room table, and others binging favorite shows on the big screen smart tv - with quick breaks for stiff ping pong competitions in the amazing finished basement, followed by perfect nights with s’mores around the outdoor fireplace! We’ve rented for close to 15 years on the other side of OB by Waban/Niantic Park, and so weren’t sure if the location would work for kids (and adults) walking and biking into town - especially at night when teens going to the arcade - but it was a PERFECT location for everyone! Cannot wait to go back again. Thank you, thank you for the BEST house for our annual family trip!
5.0
Large home with plenty of room for extended family. Located in quiet neighborhood close to Oak Bluffs, would highly recommend.
5.0
The location, size, layout, and amenities of this house are wonderful. The owner was very good at communicating, and always got back to us promptly.
And although the owner attempted and mostly succeeded at fixing all of our issues promptly, we were disappointed in certain aspects of the house, mainly related to organization and neatness of closets, kitchen cabinets and drawers, as well as the quality of toilet paper, towels, and such. Hopefully what we pointed out to him has been addressed, and if so, this is a wonderful place to stay and enjoy all that the Vineyard has to offer.
5.0
Great
5.0
This lovely home was the nicest rental my family and friends have had the pleasure of visiting. Every room was clean, up-to-date, spacious, and comfortable. More than enough bathrooms for everyone! Plenty of beach equipment and games/entertainment for a rainy day. The kids didn't want to leave! The finished basement and beautiful outside space are a bonus. Plus, the location is ideal in a quiet neighborhood close enough to walk to the beach and downtown Oak Bluffs. We had an amazing long weekend getaway!
Thank you for making the reservation process and check-in/out so easy and convenient! We would love to stay here again!
5.0
This house was a great find for our MV stay. We had a mix of small kids and adults and the house had everything we needed to enjoy our stay from the # of beds & baths, the bonus room downstairs & spacious side yard with fire pits. The only down side to our stay was there were ticks that we found on us and the kids after playing in the yard that we had to worry about throughout our stay. Perhaps we visited at the height of tick season (June) and this house is in a secluded area in the woods so not necessarily surprising but would advise others to continually use bug spray when in the yard. House is great location to local beaches & downtown OB and we enjoyed walking everywhere. Overall we would love to stay again here next year!
5.0
We were visiting family for thanksgiving and had a great time. There were a couple of issues like a clogged drain and scratched pans that the property manager immediately resolved. He brought a whole new set of pots and pans. We would definitely stay at this property again.
5.0
This was such a beautiful home, inside and out! We loved everything about it. It had everything we could possibly need, and even more. Carrington was helpful and friendly, and good response time each time we reached out. Will definitely stay here again!
5.0
My friends and I just spent 3 nights at this gorgeous East Chop property. Everyone in the group gives it 5 stars. First off, the location is prime. It's less than a 5 minute drive to the OB dock and 10 minutes to VH. You can easily walk down to the marina and over to Circut Ave.
The house and property itself were an absolute delight. The house is equipped with everything you could possibly need and then some. The large kitchen, dining space, living room with gas fireplace, and the bonus basement living room and bar, made this house perfect for 10 guests. With 5 bedrooms and 5 bathrooms everyone had enough space to stretch out and have privacy. I think our favorite feature was the outdoor space - the gas fire pit on the deck was awesome for morning coffee lounging. The fireplace in the yard was perfect for the evening fires, which came stocked with firewood. The yard is a great size for gathering a group for lawn games or a yoga session.
The property manager was fantastic at coming to our rescue we when realized some light fixtures were not working properly. We arrived during a storm and had a surge, so they arranged a convenient time for it to be addressed and then fixed quickly. We also received an extra propane tank for our stay and plenty of firewood!
Note - follow the GPS carefully. The location is a bit tricky with narrow dirt roads that break off. It's totally worth it for the peaceful location. You might even see deer like we did a few times.
If you're looking for a spacious place to stay with great indoor/outdoor entertaining space, plus close to town, this property is it! Enjoy your stay! We'll be counting down until our next one. Cheers!
5.0
This property was the perfect fit for our family. Plenty of room to spread out, impeccably clean, functional layout, and lots of extras. Highly recommend & would love to come back very soon.
5.0
Annual MV Vacation
Beautiful property! Perfect location for walking to Oak Bluffs/Circuit Ave and small local beaches. Fully equipped kitchen to meet all your needs! Our host, Carrington, always responded within 30 minutes to any email questions! We would highly recommend this property.
5.0
Beautiful Property
2 families stayed at this lovely property for a mini getaway. The home included all of the amenities to keep the kids and adults entertained during the stay. We would definitely book again. The owner is very responsive and helpful.
5.0
Great Stay!
The property was perfect for our family of 10 staying for a week in Martha's Vineyard. The amenities were awesome and a very short walk or bike ride into Oak Bluffs. We took advantage of the outdoor fireplace and grill on several occasions. I would highly recommend this property.
5.0
Easy to rent, great condition , Would highly recommend !!!
5.0
Very nice house in great location - quiet setting within easy walking distance to Oak Bluffs. The house has everything required to make a stay on MV easy and was perfect for our family visit. The host is very helpful and communicates quickly to answer any questions. Overall I highly recommend the property.
5.0
Great house for a family MV holiday
Very nice house in great location - quiet setting within easy walking distance to Oak Bluffs. The house has everything required to make a stay on MV easy and was perfect for our family visit. The host is very helpful and communicates quickly to answer any questions. Overall I highly recommend the property.
5.0
MVY Birthdays
Easy to rent, great condition , Would highly recommend !!!
5.0
We were very pleased with the property. There was more than ample both community space and private space. Property was exceptionally clean and the beds were very comfortable. The host, Carrington responded very quickly. The caretaker, Jeremy, was also very good and responsive. We will definitely stay here again and highly recommend it.
5.0
Very Ebjoyable
We were very pleased with the property. There was more than ample both community space and private space. Property was exceptionally clean and the beds were very comfortable. The host, Carrington responded very quickly. The caretaker, Jeremy, was also very good and responsive. We will definitely stay here again and highly recommend it.
5.0
A Thanksgiving to remember
We decided to move our Thanksgiving celebration to MV this year to make reuniting with family extra special. We found the most perfect house! Carrington is the most responsive owner that I have ever worked with and we have been renting on the island for over 10 yrs! No question was ever too small for him to answer immediately both before booking, after booking and during our stay. The house is just as beautiful in person as it is in the photos. It is equipped with EVERYTHING you could ever need. Just remember we made our full family Thanksgiving feast using all of the things in house. The house was super clean and extremely comfortable. We did get turned around a bit driving to the house the first time on the bumpy road, but quickly figured it out. We were cozy by the fire places and all through the house. We didn’t walk, but it is such a short to Circuit A e and beaches. We can’t wait to experience all that this house has to offer in the summer. Thanks, Carrington for everything!
5.0
The house is even better in-person. The space is highly functional, including a "hangout" basement and an excellent fire-pit in the side yard. The location is ideal for walking into the bluff. Carrington was very welcoming and responsive. Overall, our group was very happy and would stay again.
5.0
Great place to stay on the Vineyard
The house is even better in-person. The space is highly functional, including a "hangout" basement and an excellent fire-pit in the side yard. The location is ideal for walking into the bluff. Carrington was very welcoming and responsive. Overall, our group was very happy and would stay again.
5.0
Second time and addition of outdoor fire pit made this amazing place even better for our group. Perfect for our group of 8 50 year old dudes and has everything you need. Great place
5.0
Great place for 8 guys
Second time and addition of outdoor fire pit made this amazing place even better for our group. Perfect for our group of 8 50 year old dudes and has everything you need. Great place
5.0
Open floor plan (kitchen, living room, dining room) is great for larger groups. Furnished Basement with pool/ping pong table an added plus for groups needing extra space (ie with kids). Outdoor fireplace also a positive.
5.0
House set up great for groups
Open floor plan (kitchen, living room, dining room) is great for larger groups. Furnished Basement with pool/ping pong table an added plus for groups needing extra space (ie with kids). Outdoor fireplace also a positive.
5.0
We had a wonderful time! The house was perfect for our needs and within walking distance to oak bluffs. Carrington was a wonderful host and answered all of our questions quickly when we had them. Hated to leave!
5.0
Summer fun!
We had a wonderful time! The house was perfect for our needs and within walking distance to oak bluffs. Carrington was a wonderful host and answered all of our questions quickly when we had them. Hated to leave!
5.0
The house is great and very spacious for a group. Easy check in process and the owners were very communicative.
5.0
We had such a wonderful stay on the Vineyard this Memorial Day. After a long quarantine, this was the perfect house to get together with girl friends and reunite. Despite terrible weather, we got to enjoy the cozy house, which was perfectly set up for groups. The main floor had an open living/kitchen area with plenty of seating for all, and the basement provided the same experience! Plenty of beds and bathrooms that made every room feel like a master bedroom. Information was shared clearly in the lead-up and everything went very smoothly. Highly recommend!!
5.0
Great house for a group
The house is great and very spacious for a group. Easy check in process and the owners were very communicative.
5.0
It was everything we hoped it would be!
We rented this house for my mother's 73rd birthday. There were six adults and four littles and we all had the space we needed! The house was clean and Carrington made everything easy. Bonus: you can walk to the beach. We'd stay again for sure.
5.0
Memorial Day girls trip
We had such a wonderful stay on the Vineyard this Memorial Day. After a long quarantine, this was the perfect house to get together with girl friends and reunite. Despite terrible weather, we got to enjoy the cozy house, which was perfectly set up for groups. The main floor had an open living/kitchen area with plenty of seating for all, and the basement provided the same experience! Plenty of beds and bathrooms that made every room feel like a master bedroom. Information was shared clearly in the lead-up and everything went very smoothly. Highly recommend!!
5.0
Fantastic family Vacation!
We so enjoyed staying in this beautiful home! It’s convenient to Vinyard Haven, and set in lovely surroundings! We enjoyed the deck at different times of day, and in the evening with the fire pit. My niece and daughter in law both had to work one day, and the work station in the basement was perfect for remote meetings. Had a small issue with a door that sticks, and Carrington was very attentive and helpful!Note: rent your bikes from Anderson’s....they have been a family owned business since 1973, and were so helpful!! We visited all the towns during our stay, but decided that Oak Bluff/Vineyard Haven were our favorite areas. Will definitely be back for a future family getaway!
5.0
Owner was communicative and the property was amazing! Highly recommend!
5.0
Beautiful home
Owner was communicative and the property was amazing! Highly recommend!
5.0
Amazing stay, beautiful house, welcoming host
The house is spacious, comfortable and well set up for an extended family to have a relaxing and fun time together. The host was a pleasure to deal with from start to finish. I highly recommend this beautiful property!
FAQs
How much does this house cost compared to others in Tisbury?
The average price for a rental in Tisbury is $858 per night. This rental is $1,313 above the average.
Is parking included with this house?
Yes, parking is listed as an amenity at Modern, luxury 5-bed, 4.5-bath w/full basement! Now booking for 2024!. For more information, we encourage you to contact the property about where to park.
Is there a pool at this house?
We didn’t find pool listed as an amenity for this house. It may be worth double checking if a pool is important for your stay.
Is Modern, luxury 5-bed, 4.5-bath w/full basement! Now booking for 2024! pet friendly?
Unfortunately, this house is not pet-friendly. Try searching again and filter for "Pets Allowed"
What amenities are available at Modern, luxury 5-bed, 4.5-bath w/full basement! Now booking for 2024!?
We found 11 amenities for this rental. This includes air conditioner, kitchen or kitchenette, internet / wifi, fireplace, and parking.
Explore similar vacation rentals in Tisbury
Explore all rentals in TisburyTisbury travel inspiration
Read our blogGuides
Top Things to Do in Miami: From Beaches to Culture
Guides
The Best Things to Do in Orlando: Attractions, Food, and Family Fun
Guides
Things to Do in Galveston, Texas
Guides
Top Things to Do in Myrtle Beach
Guides
Ski Trip Packing List: What to Bring Skiing or Snowboarding
Trends
VacationRenter Holiday Travel Trends 2023
Featured Rentals
Architectural Vacation Rentals: Experience the Beauty of Unique Properties
Featured Rentals
Sustainable and Eco-Friendly Vacation Rentals Around the World