The Pridwin Hotel

8.8

Outstanding(79 Reviews)

Hotel in North Fork, NY

4-Star Hotel

Reasons to book

Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating

Free cancellationFull refund if you change your mind

Great price for your budgetOne of the lowest cost properties in the area

About this hotel

The Pridwin is a waterfront resort located on Shelter Island with 33 well-appointed guest rooms and 16 private cottages an all-American restaurant and lively lounge with water views a full service spa-scenic pool and seasonal activities for every ag.

Amenities

Pool

Air conditioner

Internet / Wifi

Parking

Balcony or Patio

Hot tub or spa

Wheelchair accessible

Beachfront or waterfront

Gym or Fitness Center

Garden

Family friendly

Map of North Fork, NY

Nearby attractions

Yale Peabody Museum of Natural History

Available Rooms

1 King • 215 ft²

Sleeps 2

You'll be directed to Booking.com for availability & pricing

1 King • 215 ft²

Sleeps 2

You'll be directed to Booking.com for availability & pricing

1 King • 226 ft²

Sleeps 4

You'll be directed to Booking.com for availability & pricing

1 King • 226 ft²

Sleeps 2

You'll be directed to Booking.com for availability & pricing

1 King • 645 ft²

Sleeps 4

You'll be directed to Booking.com for availability & pricing

$$$$

The Pridwin Hotel

$$$$

8.8

Outstanding(79 Reviews)

Hotel in North Fork, NY

4-Star Hotel

Reasons to book

Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating

Free cancellationFull refund if you change your mind

Great price for your budgetOne of the lowest cost properties in the area

About this hotel

Amenities

Pool

Air conditioner

Internet / Wifi

Parking

Balcony or Patio

Hot tub or spa

Wheelchair accessible

Beachfront or waterfront

Gym or Fitness Center

Garden

Family friendly

Map of North Fork, NY

Nearby attractions

Yale Peabody Museum of Natural History

Available Rooms

1 King • 215 ft²

Sleeps 2

You'll be directed to Booking.com for availability & pricing

1 King • 215 ft²

Sleeps 2

You'll be directed to Booking.com for availability & pricing

1 King • 226 ft²

Sleeps 4

You'll be directed to Booking.com for availability & pricing

1 King • 226 ft²

Sleeps 2

You'll be directed to Booking.com for availability & pricing

1 King • 645 ft²

Sleeps 4

You'll be directed to Booking.com for availability & pricing

Reviews

8.8

Outstanding(79 Reviews)

100% verified reviews

7.0

Aug 2023

Great

View

Sllow check in

8.0

Aug 2023

It is a lovely hotel and the staff is friendly, but the staff needs more training and attention to d

The hotel is well designed, furnished, landscaped and is very clean

The Staff is friendly, but many are young people here on work visas so often they could not answer questions. Communication in general was not great.We did not receive the printed summary of weekly activities until shortly before we left. The Wednesday night BBQ while pleasant, did not have labels on dishes and there were not enough servers.

7.0

Aug 2023

Good

the scenery, smores, cocktails, pool, lunch.

breakfast was not great, sausage cold, service took a long time

8.0

Aug 2023

Cute hotel, nice location, service could be more efficient- overall we would return.

Very pretty hotel and very clean

Breakfast price is too high for what it is. Concierge was not really helpful, after receiving tip he never got back to us with our outstanding requests. We also asked for a baby crib which was confirmed by email but had to wait another hour when we arrived to actually get it.

9.0

Jun 2023

Absolutely charming, beautifully appointed property with every amenity you could ever want!

Location is beautiful and charming. The hotel decor is beautiful, tastefully done, so charming, and high quality. My room was simple but very nicely appointed, immaculate, and bed was comfortable. Cocktails, dinner, and breakfast were superior! My dinner entree was really top notch in both flavor and presentation. All staff were very professional and extremely courteous.

The only criticism I had was the checkin and checkout process seemed inordinately slow. The staff while extremely polite, friendly, and professional seemed alittle unsure of the computer systems. The wait staff, again, couldn't have been nicer or more polite, but very green. The ones I encountered were young, teenage and 20 somethings, who clearly didn't have much, if any, restaurant experience. I realize it's not easy to find professional wait staff as seasonal workers for destination vacation properties.

10.0

Jun 2023

Great hotel with awesome staff , food , amenities and location.

Staff was very customer friendly - going out of their way to serve and make the stay exceptional. Property - It is recently renovated so everything is in top condition Food - Restaurant food is exceptional

Arrangement with booking.com - The reservation through Booking.com said breakfast is included but when we arrived the hotel stated change in terms with those bookings. Hotel gave 40 USD credit for each day. Would have been better to know this before hand.

9.0

Nov 2022

A luxury look back in time

Recently renovated, super clean and modern but takes you back in time. Lots of amenities. Fire places and fire pits everywhere. Loved that they had an Entire game room!! Very cool idea. Staff were all excellent. Beautiful view of water when walking around.

Fire alarm in room had a high pitched noise, water pressure was low and the design of the shower got water all over. It's an old building so you hear a bit in the rooms if your neighbors are noisy. 18$ cocktails at bar. At least they provided ear plugs.

9.0

Oct 2022

we were made to feel very welcome and the hotel had a nice feel to it. the views are spectacular

fantastic location, friendly staff, comfortable room. beautifully curated common areas

a full length mirror would be useful, the shower was a real disappointment, lovely shower cubicle but the overhead shower head was small and the flow not great, would have expected a rain type shower head. these are picky things because it is a truly stunning hotel.

9.0

Oct 2022

the IT hotel on the island

Overall property is nice. It's a small island so getting to and from Points of Interest from the Pridwin as as hub is a convenience. We also came across the Chequit hotel, and ended up having a lunch there, so no regrets electing Pridwin. The views from the hotel bar and restaurant are enchanting. FYI the Pridwin is recently acquired under new management. This was my first time, but just an FYI to future guests.

Breakfast and mattress frame. I'm certain for most people the mattress frame is fine, but there were a few times I was laying on the bed face down looking through my phone, and when you get off the bed without sitting upright your tibia will hit the wooden frame. I'm six foot, pretty athletic, not clumsy, and yet both my tibias are bruised :(

10.0

Oct 2022

we can’t wait to go back next year!

beautiful setting

there was nothing not to like, everything was great, great friendly staff and very clean

10.0

Sep 2022

Above and beyond

We enjoyed everything about our stay. There were not many workers so we saw the same few working tirelessly all day and night to ensure that guests were welcomed, taken care of and attended to. The grounds are amazing and the recent renovation was extremely well done and thoughtful- updated while keeping the character and charm. Fireplaces on in and out provided a lovely atmosphere. The pool was sunny and warm even at the end of September and the kayaks, boats and paddle boards were easily available. The setting is ideal and the food is outstanding. Every dish- breakfast (limited but always replenished and delicious) lunch and dinner.. amazing. They even made me special coffee upon request each morning. There were plenty of places to sit, relax, talk, read and just take in the view. I grew up nearby but never ventured to the pridwin. Can’t wait to go back!!

10.0

Sep 2022

Perfect quiet retreat for a few nights away from the city

Lovely hotel, right on the water with a (very) little beach across the street on the water, paddle boards and kayaks, quaint room, amazing breakfast included, s;mores at night, great views and sunsets!

10.0

Sep 2022

It was great!

location

liked everything

10.0

Sep 2022

Gorgeous location and would stay again!

Beautiful property and location, most gorgeous views and very nice staff.

It was a busy weekend, so took a long time to get food at the restaurant, but very delicious.

9.0

Sep 2022

definitely coming back next year just hoping the kinks are worked out with the staff.

absolutely beautiful! the food was delicious. the room felt. little small but the bathroom was fabulous

the staff needs work. not enough people to handle the load. we waited 25 min at dinner before anyone even asked us what we wanted to drink and 3 times a bus boy started to put the wrong food on our table. we also had a charge on our final bill that wasn’t ours ($267) and it took a while to iron out because of some important issue management was dealing with but it was removed.

5.0

Aug 2022

disappointed

I was over charged by more than 1000.00 I have called 3 times. They apologized and promised a call back. no one ever called back

I was over charged by 1000.00 can not get any help.

9.0

Aug 2022

the best hotel in shelter island

the location is phenomenal and the waterside pool is a gem

nothing

9.0

Aug 2022

I will be back!!!

Beautiful views of the Peconic, glorious pool, tasteful updates and clean, quiet and airy rooms.

Room did not have a refrigerator Shower water pressure could have been better.

7.0

Aug 2022

The design and location were gorgeous, service was terrible.

A beautiful property. Design upgrades were gorgeous. The service was terrible, left you very frustrated.

Terrible service, dinner was 3 hrs, concierge never got back to you. Computers were down when I checked out and over charged my credit card. It never ends.

9.6

Sep 2019

Pridwin-A Perfect Getaway

The Pridwin has a serene charm that takes you back to an era long ago. The room was clean, quiet and a beautiful water view.

We would have liked a refrigerator in the room for convenience.

7.9

Sep 2019

Good

Location

Dated

6.3

Sep 2019

Pleasant

Location and gardens. Very nice setting

Rooms very old and outdated Needs major renovations to justify price charged

FAQs

How much does this hotel cost compared to others in North Fork?

The average price for a rental in North Fork is $1,158 per night. This rental is $1,027 less expensive than the average.

Is parking included with this hotel?

Yes, parking is listed as an amenity at The Pridwin Hotel. For more information, we encourage you to contact the property about where to park.

Is there a pool at this hotel?

Yes, a swimming pool is available for use at The Pridwin Hotel. Enjoy the water!

Is The Pridwin Hotel pet friendly?

Unfortunately, this hotel is not pet-friendly. Try searching again and filter for "Pets Allowed"

What amenities are available at The Pridwin Hotel?

We found 11 amenities for this rental. This includes pool, air conditioner, internet / wifi, parking, and balcony or patio.

Explore similar vacation rentals in North Fork

Explore all rentals in North Fork

9.0

OutstandingNo Reviews

Premier Waterfront Cottage 3

House

in Riverhead

Garden · Pets allowed · Kitchen or Kitchenette

Experience the best of North Fork with this House available for $150. This property is equipped with amenities including Air conditioner, Internet / Wifi and Laundry, and more.

$$$$

The Pridwin Hotel

Hotel in North Fork, NY

Reasons to book

About this hotel

Amenities

Map of North Fork, NY

Nearby attractions

Available Rooms

The Pridwin Hotel

Hotel in North Fork, NY

Reasons to book

About this hotel

Amenities

Map of North Fork, NY

Nearby attractions

Available Rooms

Reviews

FAQs

How much does this hotel cost compared to others in North Fork?

Is parking included with this hotel?

Is there a pool at this hotel?

Is The Pridwin Hotel pet friendly?

What amenities are available at The Pridwin Hotel?

Explore similar vacation rentals in North Fork

North Fork travel inspiration

Related vacation destinations