The Mermaid & The Alligator

9.4

Outstanding(178 Reviews)

Hotel in Key West, FL

Reasons to book

Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating

Includes essentialsGarden, Pool, Air conditioner and more

Book with confidenceWe partner with the top travel sites so you know you're getting a great deal on the perfect rental

About this hotel

Boasting an outdoor swimming pool, a garden as well as a shared lounge, The Mermaid & The Alligator is situated in the centre of Key West, less than 1 km from South Beach.

Amenities

Pool

Air conditioner

Internet / Wifi

Balcony or Patio

Hot tub or spa

Garden

Map of Key West, FL

Nearby attractions

The Key West Butterfly and Nature Conservatory

0.7 mi

Mallory Square

1.4 mi

Southernmost Point of the Continental U.S.A.

0.8 mi

The Hemingway Home and Museum

0.6 mi

Available Rooms

1 Queen • 172 ft²

Sleeps 2

You'll be directed to Booking.com for availability & pricing

1 King • 279 ft²

Sleeps 2

You'll be directed to Booking.com for availability & pricing

1 King • 398 ft²

Sleeps 2

You'll be directed to Booking.com for availability & pricing

1 King • 215 ft²

Sleeps 2

You'll be directed to Booking.com for availability & pricing

1 King • 269 ft²

Sleeps 2

You'll be directed to Booking.com for availability & pricing

$$$$

The Mermaid & The Alligator

$$$$

9.4

Outstanding(178 Reviews)

Hotel in Key West, FL

Reasons to book

Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating

Includes essentialsGarden, Pool, Air conditioner and more

Book with confidenceWe partner with the top travel sites so you know you're getting a great deal on the perfect rental

About this hotel

Boasting an outdoor swimming pool, a garden as well as a shared lounge, The Mermaid & The Alligator is situated in the centre of Key West, less than 1 km from South Beach.

Amenities

Pool

Air conditioner

Internet / Wifi

Balcony or Patio

Hot tub or spa

Garden

Map of Key West, FL

Nearby attractions

The Key West Butterfly and Nature Conservatory

0.7 mi

Mallory Square

1.4 mi

Southernmost Point of the Continental U.S.A.

0.8 mi

The Hemingway Home and Museum

0.6 mi

Available Rooms

1 Queen • 172 ft²

Sleeps 2

You'll be directed to Booking.com for availability & pricing

1 King • 279 ft²

Sleeps 2

You'll be directed to Booking.com for availability & pricing

1 King • 398 ft²

Sleeps 2

You'll be directed to Booking.com for availability & pricing

1 King • 215 ft²

Sleeps 2

You'll be directed to Booking.com for availability & pricing

1 King • 269 ft²

Sleeps 2

You'll be directed to Booking.com for availability & pricing

Reviews

9.4

Outstanding(178 Reviews)

100% verified reviews

10.0

Apr 2024

Our stay at M&A was very comfortable and we had everything that we needed and more to make it so.

The staff was extremely friendly. We were able to get into our room early on the day of arrival. The location was perfect for our needs and very comfortable.

The ceiling in our Treetop room was a little bit of a challenge but it did not detract from the overall feel of the property.

10.0

Feb 2024

One of bed B&B we have ever stayed in.

Grounds filled with well manicured foliage. Manager couldn’t have been more embracing. Outdoor hot tub. Great breakfast.

Slightly away from downtown.

9.0

Nov 2023

Beautiful old Victorian style share house

Very nice old Victorian home with plenty of character. great location in centre of town

I didn’t realise it was a share house but rooms were very separate and secure so enjoyed the experience. I arrived at 5:50pm and found door locked and a note saying staff leave at 6. Then saw staff leaving and she just said ‘read the letter for instructions’ and left

10.0

Oct 2023

An excellent place to unwind and relax in a serene and holistic environment.

The property got a calm, clean and a holistic serenity. It offered a healthy breakfast and other food and drink supplies with mindfulness for the health and wellness.

The carpet on the staircase to treetop room was unclean and perhaps in need of change

10.0

Jul 2023

Great staff, great service and wonderful stay! Highly recommend!!

Loved the room and the plunge pool. Breakfast was wonderful! Very clean and cool inside which was great a scorching Key West! Very accessible to very thing!

There was nothing we didn’t like except the rooster which isn’t the inn’s responsibility!! LOL

10.0

Jul 2023

It is an excellent property with great friendly and helpful staff. Will stay here every time I come back to Key West

It is the best ever

Nothing

9.0

Apr 2023

I would definitely stay at the Mermaid and Alligator again!

The Mermaid and the Alligator is an adorable, extremely clean facility. The manager and employees were lovely and accomodating.

10.0

Apr 2023

Great find, great location, pricey.

Unique B&B in the heart of downtown KW. Close to everything!

A bit on the pricey side (>$600) especially for FL residents during the off-season (post-Easter) - also, no military discount offered for active duty personnel or retirees during the NAS KW Airshow weekend.

10.0

Apr 2023

Our stay was great other than what was listed above

We like everything there, except for what you’re getting ready to read below

For happy hour they advertise drinks and hors d’oeuvres from 4 to 5. There was no drinks or hors d’oeuvres. They had wine which we love, but they could have had a better brand of wine, other than Sutter home and the hors d’oeuvres were, Doritos corn chips, or a pack of planters peanuts. I believe they call that snacks not hors d’oeuvres. maybe replace those with a charcuterie board. And I think their bicycles should be complementary to their guest instead of costing $20 each to rent.

10.0

Apr 2023

We will definitely stay with you again and will recommend to others

Staff excellent Location perfect

7.0

Apr 2023

Cozy and romantic stay in the center of Key West

Good location, nice overall atmosphere of the structure and garden. The room was cozy and very clean. Really enjoyed the happy hour with wine and snacks

Definitely needs some improvement for the price. Room on the smaller size, could use a mini fridge. The pool is nice but always dirty due to trees and plants, could use a net to help clean up (even by guests).

9.0

Mar 2023

I loved Key West.

Facility

They confiscate your car keys. Then leave all keys in a bowl in the kitchen. I can only imagine the assumed liability in case of theft or misuse. The worst part is that there was no description of this policy prior to booking.

10.0

Jan 2023

Beautifullly updated property with lots of ammenities. The Caribbean Queen was my room and I would definitely be excit

The property was immaculately clean and looked like something from a magazine! The room was comfortable and well appointed and there were makeup removers available in the bathroom. the balcony was large and comfortable and the walk out doors were heavenly! The back porch/yard area were lush and shaded and perfect for our delicious breakfast!

I don’t like feather pillows as I’m allergic but that seems nitpicks to even mention as the rest of the property was superb!

10.0

Nov 2022

This was a lovely tranquil and truly beautiful place!

Sophisticated facility, beautiful gardens, lovely little pool and great place to relax No children and pets allowed to it was perfect for an adult getaway Excellent hospitality

It was all fantastic

10.0

Nov 2022

Diana and staff are so attentive. they make you feel right at home.

Hands down best B&B in Key West it’s comfortable , private and very clean 🤩

7.0

Oct 2022

nice staff but will not stay here again

beautiful landscape but bug spray was needed if you sat in the garden area

our bed was hard as a rock. we slept bad the entire trip. other B and AB’s that we have stayed have a nice soft mattress cover

7.0

Oct 2022

pleased but it could have been better. for the price I paid I expected more.

it was in walking distance to duval street

no tv , parking is tight! the detachable shower head did not work.

8.0

Oct 2022

Nice visit

Good Breakfast. Quiet Guest House

Limited Parking, but workable

9.0

Aug 2022

Relaxing and Private Stay

Absolutely wonderful! Beautiful property! The breakfasts were delicious, plus snacks and wine for happy hour were a wonderful surprise. The pool was surprisingly large and had jets. We stayed in the bamboo room which had a private patio which was fabulous to relax and drink coffee on. I would highly recommend to anyone!

The bike rentals were more expensive than other rents nearby so we ended up going elsewhere for less. Also the parking is double parked so you might end up with someone blocking you in, in which you would have to move their car. Wasn’t a huge deal because most of the time we biked or walked to wherever we needed to go!

8.0

Aug 2022

our room was a beautiful, private place to recharge.

great room and decor. we loved the French doors to the patio area which was interesting, beautiful, peaceful, private and just a wonderful place to hang out when we had free time.

naturally, I would have loved the property to be closer to Duval.

10.0

Aug 2022

wonderful paradise , a hidden gem ❤️

ambience amazing , close to LaTeDa fabulous martinis and food . ask for John ❤️very walkable to the quiet end lull of duval

nothing

9.0

Aug 2022

great

great breakfast, good quality food, 24 hour available beverages great menu

a little bigger pool

10.0

Aug 2022

Great location, comfortable bed, excellent staff! Definitely recommend!

this is my first experience staying in a B&B. I loved that it was very centrally located so you could walk a lot of places, the staff was very nice, the breakfast provided was excellent. The bed was comfortable, our room had a really nice tub… The only thing I will say that was negative was how hot it got in the room. We had the tree top room, which is on the third floor. And it was the middle of summer in Florida. Lol. There is an AC unit up there, but they should maybe consider getting a second smaller one closer to the bed. Once it was nighttime, it wasn’t bad. And we didn’t spend much time in the room during the day, but when we did, it was a little bit hot. Other than that, I would definitely stay here again!

The room got a little warm during the day

10.0

Aug 2022

We loved it!

Location and the staff.

Nothing

10.0

Jul 2022

it’s a good place for your holiday or weekends 👏

amazing 🤩

nothing

FAQs

How much does this hotel cost compared to others in Key West?

The average price for a rental in Key West is $760 per night. This rental is $317 less expensive than the average.

Is parking included with this hotel?

Parking is not specified as an available amenity at The Mermaid & The Alligator. For more information, we encourage you to contact the property about where to park.

Is there a pool at this hotel?

Yes, a swimming pool is available for use at The Mermaid & The Alligator. Enjoy the water!

Is The Mermaid & The Alligator pet friendly?

Unfortunately, this hotel is not pet-friendly. Try searching again and filter for "Pets Allowed"

What amenities are available at The Mermaid & The Alligator?

We found 7 amenities for this rental. This includes pool, air conditioner, internet / wifi, balcony or patio, and hot tub or spa.

Explore similar vacation rentals in Key West

Explore all rentals in Key West

8.5

Excellent(527 Reviews)

Caribbean House

The Mermaid & The Alligator

Hotel in Key West, FL

Reasons to book

About this hotel

Amenities

Map of Key West, FL

Nearby attractions

Available Rooms

The Mermaid & The Alligator

Hotel in Key West, FL

Reasons to book

About this hotel

Amenities

Map of Key West, FL

Nearby attractions

Available Rooms

Reviews

FAQs

How much does this hotel cost compared to others in Key West?

Is parking included with this hotel?

Is there a pool at this hotel?

Is The Mermaid & The Alligator pet friendly?

What amenities are available at The Mermaid & The Alligator?

Explore similar vacation rentals in Key West

Key West travel inspiration

Related vacation destinations