Waterfront Cottage Perfection

5.0

Outstanding(157 Reviews)

Cottage in Montauk, NY

4 guests · 2 bedrooms · 1 bath

Reasons to book

Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating

Great for petsBring all your friends and family, even the furry ones

Top-tier experienceOne of the higher cost properties in the area

About this cottage rental

Perfect Sunsets any time of year —this magical two-bedroom waterfront cottage on bucolic Fort Pond is as close as it gets to perfection. Every room looks out upon the most beautiful waterfront and sunset vistas all year. A designer's home is beautifully decorated with mid-century modern furniture and spectacular landscaping, enhancing the privacy felt on this gem of a property. It features a large living area with ribbon remote control gas fireplace, a dining table, a state-of-the-art kitchen, sofa and a bathroom with a large glass-enclosed rain head shower with access to the outdoor shower from the inside. Ideal for couples, singles, or small families (dogs accepted with a $250 fee, and crated when left alone). Maximum sleeping capacity 4 people. (The sofa should not used for overnight guests and the backs do not go down). The cottage has plenty of outdoor furniture, a table for 8, a gas Weber grill, and stairs to the water—perfect for standup paddleboards or kayaking. A short walk to town (5 minutes), the best restaurants, the Jitney, and beaches

The cottage comes with linens, towels, beach towels, a fully equipped kitchen, and many beautiful pieces of vintage table settings and glassware for entertaining. (2) standup paddleboards, (2) Kayaks, and (2) bikes. You will be asked to sign a waiver for the use of the equipment.

The cottage is thoroughly cleaned and disinfected between each guest. All surfaces are disinfected with Clorox. All white linens are washed in warm water with bleach. All throw pillows and throws are washable and are cleaned between each guest.

$250 per week for cleaning and garbage removal. Excessive garbage will be an additional $75.
$250 Pet Fee per dog, maximum 2 dogs.
No Cats

East Hampton/Montauk Rental Registry Certificate Number 22-550 (2022-2024)
Suffolk County Tax Number: HMT23-196

Amenities

Air conditioner

Pets allowed

Kitchen or Kitchenette

Internet / Wifi

Fireplace

Parking

Laundry

Balcony or Patio

Dishwasher

Garden

Family friendly

Map of Montauk, NY

Nearby attractions

Montauk Point State Park

6.8 mi

Mystic Aquarium

37.4 mi

Montauk Lighthouse Museum

8.4 mi

Mystic Seaport Museum

36.2 mi

££££

Waterfront Cottage Perfection

££££

5.0

Outstanding(157 Reviews)

Cottage in Montauk, NY

4 guests · 2 bedrooms · 1 bath

Reasons to book

Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating

Great for petsBring all your friends and family, even the furry ones

Top-tier experienceOne of the higher cost properties in the area

About this cottage rental

Amenities

Air conditioner

Pets allowed

Kitchen or Kitchenette

Internet / Wifi

Fireplace

Parking

Laundry

Balcony or Patio

Dishwasher

Garden

Family friendly

Map of Montauk, NY

Nearby attractions

Montauk Point State Park

6.8 mi

Mystic Aquarium

37.4 mi

Montauk Lighthouse Museum

8.4 mi

Mystic Seaport Museum

36.2 mi

Reviews

5.0

Outstanding(157 Reviews)

5.0

Aug 2024

Cottage in Montauk was an absolute dream. Blown away by the beauty and charm of this magical property. Highlights were the gorgeous, sprawling outdoor space with lovely landscaping and privacy, sunset views over the pond with direct water access and stylish decor. Extremely comfortable beds and relaxing atmosphere. Location of cottage was perfect - short walk to town and beaches. Owner was very professional with easy check in / check out - extremely helpful with insider recommendations on the area. A perfect beach oasis and can’t wait to return again soon!

5.0

Aug 2024

We had an absolutely fantastic stay at Laura's house in Montauk. The property was everything we hoped for and more. The stunning water view was a highlight of our mornings and evenings, providing a serene backdrop that made our stay truly memorable. The outdoor space was generous and beautifully maintained, perfect for relaxing or playing games. I especially loved the amazing outdoor shower! Laura's hospitality was top-notch. She was attentive and made sure we had everything we needed for a comfortable stay. Her attention to detail and warm welcome made us feel right at home. We can't recommend this place enough. Five stars all around!

5.0

Jul 2024

Lovely location decoration on a lake with water views and sunsets

5.0

Jun 2024

Absolutely fabulous cottage for our small family with an amazing and gracious host. Stunning and lush Montauk property that we truly enjoyed.

5.0

Jun 2024

We had an amazing stay at Laura’s cottage. She has clearly put a lot of detail into the interior and exterior - making it a perfect getaway for my husband and I and our dog. It’s walkable to a lot of popular Montauk spots and the beach. The views are beautiful especially at sunset. We hope to go back one day!

5.0

Jun 2024

This property is absolutely stunning, spotless, and well-stocked, inside and out. It’s hard to want to leave the beautifully furnished house, but the outdoor shower is a dream, and the plantings, landscaping, and numerous outdoor seating areas add so much to the stay. We had an amazing time, and look forward to scheduling another stay. I haven’t even mentioned proximity because the property is so nice, but you practically can’t be any closer to the adorable town center.

5.0

Jun 2024

Laura is an excellent host. She provides a beautiful cottage in pristine condition on peaceful Fort Pond! Our dog enjoyed her swimming and we enjoyed stunning sunsets in the evenings and relaxing with a good book or a quiet kayak around the pond. We would gladly visit again. We enjoyed the gas fireplace on the cool evenings too! Don’t hesitate to book!

5.0

May 2024

A much needed break from the city on this idyllic property with spectacular sunsets. The cottage is far enough away to feel private and secluded but walking distance to the town—we arrived by Jitney. It’s well equipped with high end appliances and tableware. The owner has thought of everything down to the bathrobes in each room. We will be back!

5.0

May 2024

A beautiful house on an view property. We loved it and especially appreciated the owner giving us a few tips about what to do when it was raining! Thank you!

5.0

May 2024

Such a beautiful property with views over the lake. Perfectly furnished, light filled and a concise well outfitted kitchen. So clean with wonderfully comfortable beds and linens. We cooked a dinner at home and the kitchen was so well equipped and easy to cook in. A fire in the fire place made for a perfect evening at home. Really can’t get any better than this place. We will be back!

5.0

May 2024

We stayed for a long weekend. The house is exactly as pictured (if not better). The yard has everything you could want - including grill and many places to sit. The host was also very responsive when we had a few questions. We would definitely return!

5.0

May 2024

This adorable home exceeded our expectations. It was spotless, well-designed and what a view! Don't hesitate to book this charming home.

5.0

Apr 2024

For those who love the tranquility and beauty of Montauk, this beautifully decorated and landscaped cottage, is nestled among a naturally wooded landscape, overlooking a large peaceful lake with breathtaking sunsets! The hostess was friendly, helpful and accessible, getting back to my questions within minutes, and made us feel welcomed. The whole experience was charming! Both my husband and I and our two Rottweilers had a wonderful time and look forward to going back!

5.0

Mar 2024

From the warmness and generosity of the owner to the gorgeously decorated and serene property, we couldn’t have had a better stay! Everything was spotless, fully stocked with everything you could need. Location is walking distance to everything. It is simply spectacular!

5.0

Dec 2023

Our second trip to the house -- both in deep winter when the sublime light across the Pond illuminates this serene and private little paradise. Can't wait to return.

5.0

Nov 2023

Very clean and cozy. Amazing views. Had such a lovely time.

5.0

Oct 2023

Property was as listed. Beautiful views and property. Tranquil decor. Close to everything. Lovely

5.0

Oct 2023

Love this place, second time here. Place is private, clean, well appointed and close to all.

4.0

Oct 2023

Very nice stay and beautiful views

4.0

Aug 2023

The house is very clean and well decorated. It sits on a nice property overlooking a pretty lake. It is a short walk into town and the beach. The host was responsive to our texts, but was rude upon checkout. Not a great ending to our vacation to have the host be so unfriendly and rude as we were leaving.

5.0

Jul 2023

Wonderful property

5.0

Jul 2023

My family and I loved our stay. The house was beautiful and very welcoming. The view and the yard were delightful. Nothing but good things to say about this property and location.

5.0

Jun 2023

The cottage is just beautiful. Peaceful, gorgeous view and perfect location. Highly recommend!

5.0

Jun 2023

Lovely home would stay again for sure!

5.0

Jun 2023

Laura is a wonderful host. Her cottage is beautiful and clean and the perfect place to relax and enjoy Montauk!

5.0

May 2023

It was even better than described in the listing. The house was well equipped and very updated. We loved the fenced yard and all the outdoor amenities. We walked to the beach every morning and to restaurants and shopping several times a day. This property has the most amazing sunset view, which we enjoyed each evening. Highly recommend this one.

5.0

May 2023

Fantastic cottage, perfect place to explore Montauk from. Highly recommend.

5.0

May 2023

Great location would absolutely stay again

5.0

May 2023

This waterfront house was amazing for our weekend in Montauk, attending a family wedding. Every amenity we needed, central location, and absolutely gorgeous design. Highly recommend!

5.0

May 2023

We wanted peaceful and relaxing and we woke up to birds and the calming sounds of the water lapping the rocks outside. The place is immaculately decorated, Laura is a pleasure is communicate with, the place is spotless, fully equipped with everything you could need for cooking and dining in. It was absolutely beautiful and we will definitely reach out to her to stay at her house again. It was exactly what we needed. Highly recommend to anyone wanting a two bedroom house on the pond within walking distance of town and five minutes drive to Gosmans, ten to the lighthouse. Perfect vacation spot. Loved every minute.

5.0

Apr 2023

The cottage was gorgeous and nicely appointed. Beautiful sunsets over the lake and close to everything.

5.0

Mar 2023

Absolutely stunning cottage on the lake. Surpassed our expectations for a winter getaway! Close to restaurants and hiking trails. Panoramic view of the lake with amazing sunsets. Decorated beautifully and everything was immaculate! Laura is a gracious host who responded promptly to our needs. We almost had to cancel our trip last minute and Laura agreed to change our dates, no problem no additional fees. We will definitely be returning!!

5.0

Feb 2023

This beautifully renovated cottage with a great view of the water (and an awesome gas fireplace) was exactly what my husband I needed as a winter escape from the city. The cottage has everything you could think of - comfy beds, new appliances, every cooking tool, great coffee/espresso maker, wonderful gas fireplace - the works. There are many great hiking/walking trails nearby. The area guidebook at the cottage was very thorough. Owner was terrific to communicate with and answered immediately with any questions. We will be back again!

5.0

Jan 2023

Wonderful relaxing time at this spa like oasis. Centrally located and thoughtfully decorated with all the comforts of home.

5.0

Dec 2022

The only thing better than a lovely rental home is one that has a kind hearted owner. Laura’s home and surrounding views are nothing short of amazing. Perfect energy and space to wake up on this Christmas morning. The home provided a much welcomed retreat for some R&R during a different kind of holiday season for me. From start to end the process was smooth and simple. We came with a pet and he was more than happy to run the grounds. If you are debating, look no further and book it, you won’t be disappointed!

5.0

Nov 2022

Great

5.0

Nov 2022

The house is very updated with all the high-end amenities needed (kitchen, bathroom) and the layout was perfect to maximize the usable space and the incredible views. Added bonus is a hedged enclosed yard that is really beautiful! We’ll be back for sure.

5.0

Oct 2022

The Cottage is a luxury. The large windows offers a beautiful view of the pond and the most beautiful sunsets. The well appointed bedroom are fitted with top of the line linens in crisp white. The main bath is spacious with plush white towels. The storage closet offers and abundance of pillows and blankets. I can't forget to mention the gas fireplace. Turn it on and set the mood for a romantic evening. WE enjoyed our stay.

5.0

Oct 2022

My fiancé and I have stayed at this listing several times and it had yet to disappoint. Laura is the most incredible host! Every exchange we have had has been so warm and inviting! We bring our yellow lab and have the most incredible weekend getaways enjoying the chic, cozy and comfortable cottage, the beautiful yard space overlooking the lake, and the breathtaking sunsets! The town and beach are are just a few short minutes drive down the road. Laura leaves an awesome list of restaurant recommendations that ALL panned to be incredible are literally just minutes away from the house! There are so many amenities availbel including kayaks and bikes to really enjoy the heart of Montauk! Perfect for couples or small families! Literally my favorite place to be in New York!

5.0

Oct 2022

We had an amazing stay and cannot wait to go back. Laura was fantastic and made the process seamless. This house was perfect.

FAQs

How much does this cottage cost compared to others in Montauk?

The average price for a rental in Montauk is £574 per night. This rental is £162 less expensive than the average.

Is parking included with this cottage?

Yes, parking is listed as an amenity at Waterfront Cottage Perfection. For more information, we encourage you to contact the property about where to park.

Is there a pool at this cottage?

We didn’t find pool listed as an amenity for this cottage. It may be worth double checking if a pool is important for your stay.

Is Waterfront Cottage Perfection pet friendly?

Yes! This cottage is pet-friendly. For more information, we recommend contacting the booking provider about animal policies.

What amenities are available at Waterfront Cottage Perfection?

We found 12 amenities for this rental. This includes air conditioner, pets allowed, kitchen or kitchenette, internet / wifi, and fireplace.

Explore similar vacation rentals in Montauk

Explore all rentals in Montauk

Long Story Short

Waterfront Cottage Perfection

Cottage in Montauk, NY

Reasons to book

About this cottage rental

Amenities

Map of Montauk, NY

Nearby attractions

Waterfront Cottage Perfection

Cottage in Montauk, NY

Reasons to book

About this cottage rental

Amenities

Map of Montauk, NY

Nearby attractions

Reviews

FAQs

How much does this cottage cost compared to others in Montauk?

Is parking included with this cottage?

Is there a pool at this cottage?

Is Waterfront Cottage Perfection pet friendly?

What amenities are available at Waterfront Cottage Perfection?

Explore similar vacation rentals in Montauk

Montauk travel inspiration

Related vacation destinations