Whaling Captain Pierson's Apartment TOO
Apartment in Sag Harbor, NY
5 guests · 2 bedrooms · 1 bath
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Great for petsBring all your friends and family, even the furry ones
High-end valuePrice for this property is higher than average in the area
About this apartment rental
Whaling Captain Pierson's Apartment is at a waterfront property and is an apartment in one of the contributing homes which define Sag Harbor as a historic village. The house is a 7 minutes’ walk from the center of historic Sag Harbor Village. It is the only house and apartment offering a vast, picturesque, panoramic view of beautiful Sag Harbor Cove from Main Street as well as spectacular sunsets.(See my other listings entitled, "Whaling Captain Pierson's Apartment" and "Whaling Captain Pierson's Cottage".)
If you do not see the booking availability desired, look at my other postings of Whaling Captain's Pierson's Apartment and Whaling Captain Pierson's Cottage. Or, if your party is larger than one apartment can accommodate consider booking both apartments and the cottage.
Whaling Captain Pierson's Apartment Too is on Captain’s Row within the main house. The property is surrounded by nature and the apartment overlooks the cove and has views of Otter pond. Whaling Captain Pierson's Apartment Too is a first floor completely private apartment of which nothing is shared other than the hallway of the main house. Once inside of Whaling Captain Pierson's Apartment Too no one enters or exits but those guests of your party.
Whaling Captain Pierson's Apartment Too’s antique furnishings reflect both a classical and whimsical ever evolving sensibility without feeling stuffy or old. The kitchen consists of stainless steel appliances. The kitchen is fully outfitted with plates, silverware, stainless steel pots and pans, cups, saucers, salad bowls, coffee maker, coffee press, food processors, toaster, toaster oven, basic condiments, sugar, sugar substitutes, coffee, etc. The apartment is a two-bedroom apartment which has one queen size bed in the master bedroom and one double size bed in the second bedroom. Additionally, the day bed in the living room is a single bed that can sleep one person. Window AC units will provide cooling during the summer in both bedrooms and cast iron radiators provide heating in the winter. The apartment has a full bathroom with a washer and dryer right off the bathroom. The apartment has a private deck and private sun porch. The apartment guests have welcomed access to the property’s private beach, expansive grounds and parking.
Common amenities are TV, Cable TV, and Wireless Internet with laptop friendly workspaces.
The Apartment is ideal for allowing privacy to loving couples, the single visitor or the various types of creative and performing artists who are looking for a haven to relax and/or create. Experience the Apartment’s environment or just be part of its inspiring, healing, spirit and soul uplifting surroundings.
During the day you may see ducks waddling, bunny rabbits with small white tails scurrying, orange breasted birds frolicking and turtles meander across the lawn. Also, deer can be seen nibbling the grass and white swan(s), ospreys, ducks or seagulls flying around or swimming in Sag Harbor Cove.
Guests should feel free to use any of the various chairs, tables or benches situated on the front porch, the front lawn and the grounds.
Sag Harbor Cove is where my private beach behind the property is located for water access to sun-bathing, sculling, canoeing or fishing if you rent or buy the equipment from one of the specialty shops in the Village.
Bicycles can be locally rented and used to explore more of Sag Harbor and other surrounding areas not within walking distance.
Long Wharf beach, Long Beach and Haven’s Beach are 3 public beaches in relative close proximity to the house. Long Wharf beach is in the center of the Village of Sag Harbor within the 7 minutes walking distance from the house. However, the other two beaches are within a comfortable bicycling distance from the house rather than by car. One would need a car’s parking pass obtained from Sag Harbor’s municipal building to be able to take one’s car to the beach for beach parking. Only a limited number of car parking passes are available in the Village per season.
Guests can always text, email or call me with any questions, concerns or just for places to go and/or visit during or after their stay.
Breakfast, lunch and dinner can be obtained from the Cove Deli which is just across the street from the house/apartment.
Sag Harbor is a vibrant year-round village with plenty of activities both cultural and family oriented alike. There is a performing arts theater, gyms and spas, yoga studios, art exhibits, festivals and parades which occur throughout the year. There is also a variety of antique, clothing and novelty shops as well as many restaurants, bars and beaches.
Sag Harbor can be reached in 2 hours by car from New York City, the Hampton Jitney or the Long Island Rail Road. The Hampton Jitney stops in the center of the Village of Sag Harbor. The Long Island Rail Road’s Bridgehampton station is 15 minutes to and from the Apartment by taxi or car.
If you have a car or rent one, there is plenty of parking available on the street along the property.
If you do not see the booking availability desired, look at my other postings of Whaling Captain's Pierson's Apartment and Whaling Captain Pierson's Cottage. Or, if your party is larger than one apartment can accommodate consider booking both apartments and the cottage.
Whaling Captain Pierson's Apartment Too is on Captain’s Row within the main house. The property is surrounded by nature and the apartment overlooks the cove and has views of Otter pond. Whaling Captain Pierson's Apartment Too is a first floor completely private apartment of which nothing is shared other than the hallway of the main house. Once inside of Whaling Captain Pierson's Apartment Too no one enters or exits but those guests of your party.
Whaling Captain Pierson's Apartment Too’s antique furnishings reflect both a classical and whimsical ever evolving sensibility without feeling stuffy or old. The kitchen consists of stainless steel appliances. The kitchen is fully outfitted with plates, silverware, stainless steel pots and pans, cups, saucers, salad bowls, coffee maker, coffee press, food processors, toaster, toaster oven, basic condiments, sugar, sugar substitutes, coffee, etc. The apartment is a two-bedroom apartment which has one queen size bed in the master bedroom and one double size bed in the second bedroom. Additionally, the day bed in the living room is a single bed that can sleep one person. Window AC units will provide cooling during the summer in both bedrooms and cast iron radiators provide heating in the winter. The apartment has a full bathroom with a washer and dryer right off the bathroom. The apartment has a private deck and private sun porch. The apartment guests have welcomed access to the property’s private beach, expansive grounds and parking.
Common amenities are TV, Cable TV, and Wireless Internet with laptop friendly workspaces.
The Apartment is ideal for allowing privacy to loving couples, the single visitor or the various types of creative and performing artists who are looking for a haven to relax and/or create. Experience the Apartment’s environment or just be part of its inspiring, healing, spirit and soul uplifting surroundings.
During the day you may see ducks waddling, bunny rabbits with small white tails scurrying, orange breasted birds frolicking and turtles meander across the lawn. Also, deer can be seen nibbling the grass and white swan(s), ospreys, ducks or seagulls flying around or swimming in Sag Harbor Cove.
Guests should feel free to use any of the various chairs, tables or benches situated on the front porch, the front lawn and the grounds.
Sag Harbor Cove is where my private beach behind the property is located for water access to sun-bathing, sculling, canoeing or fishing if you rent or buy the equipment from one of the specialty shops in the Village.
Bicycles can be locally rented and used to explore more of Sag Harbor and other surrounding areas not within walking distance.
Long Wharf beach, Long Beach and Haven’s Beach are 3 public beaches in relative close proximity to the house. Long Wharf beach is in the center of the Village of Sag Harbor within the 7 minutes walking distance from the house. However, the other two beaches are within a comfortable bicycling distance from the house rather than by car. One would need a car’s parking pass obtained from Sag Harbor’s municipal building to be able to take one’s car to the beach for beach parking. Only a limited number of car parking passes are available in the Village per season.
Guests can always text, email or call me with any questions, concerns or just for places to go and/or visit during or after their stay.
Breakfast, lunch and dinner can be obtained from the Cove Deli which is just across the street from the house/apartment.
Sag Harbor is a vibrant year-round village with plenty of activities both cultural and family oriented alike. There is a performing arts theater, gyms and spas, yoga studios, art exhibits, festivals and parades which occur throughout the year. There is also a variety of antique, clothing and novelty shops as well as many restaurants, bars and beaches.
Sag Harbor can be reached in 2 hours by car from New York City, the Hampton Jitney or the Long Island Rail Road. The Hampton Jitney stops in the center of the Village of Sag Harbor. The Long Island Rail Road’s Bridgehampton station is 15 minutes to and from the Apartment by taxi or car.
If you have a car or rent one, there is plenty of parking available on the street along the property.
Amenities
Air conditioner
Pets allowed
Kitchen or Kitchenette
Internet / Wifi
Parking
Laundry
Balcony or Patio
Dishwasher
TV
Garden
Map of Sag Harbor, NY
RRRR
Ratings and reviews
10.0 / 10.0
I recently had the pleasure of staying at Paris's incredible home, and I cannot say enough positive things about my experience. From the moment I arrived, it was clear that this would be a fantastic stay. - First and foremost, the home itself is absolutely beautiful. Every detail has been thoughtfully considered. The space was spotless and inviting, making it easy to feel right at home; what set this stay apart was Paris. He ensured that I had everything I needed, was incredibly responsive, and provided excellent recommendations for things to do and places to eat; he made me feel welcome from the start and was always available to answer any questions or provide assistance.
I cannot wait to stay here again!
10.0 / 10.0
Cozy, comfortable and quiet, this absolutely charming 'cottage / luxury home' has incredible views of the water. The manager was very respectful of our privacy.
8.0 / 10.0
Stay was fine. Place is quaint and well located. Only bedrooms were air conditioned ( July 15 &very hot outside) master bed is small ( double?) Pillows could use a refresh.
10.0 / 10.0
My elderly mother, my two cats (who have never traveled), and I all had such a relaxing, refreshing, and incredible experience thanks to Paris and Clifton’s attentiveness to detail and welcoming spirit. The house was more than expected when we arrived. The photos on here are fantastic and thorough, but they don’t really show how close to the water you are which was the best surprise! The view, particularly from the screened sunroom, kitchen, and deck, is breathtakingly serene. It, along with the beautiful, historic home filled with so many charming antiques and interesting details, matched with Paris’ warm welcome and telling us of the history of the home all immediately immerse you in the spirit of Sag Harbor. We had only traveled one hour east to come here, but it felt like we had been transported hundreds of miles away. And the best part was that the 2 cats also loved it! They specifically enjoyed the screened sunroom. It was such a relief to be able to bring them with us and Paris and Clifton were so easygoing and inviting towards them and us which enabled us to truly relax. I did make sure to “cat proof” the home when we arrived (I brought my own bedding, put away anything I thought they could break, and covered any upholstered furniture with throw blankets), but that was all my doing as I wanted to be a considerate guest, having brought my pets with me.
I really can’t say enough good things about this home. The location is ideal. It’s right on the cove with a large piece of beautiful property and still only a few minutes from all the shops and restaurants down on Main Street in Sag Harbor. We had only two days of sunshine while there and two cloudy days, but the sunsets on the water on the sunny days were unmatched to any I’ve ever seen and we enjoyed them directly from the screened sunroom in our beyond immaculate and spacious apartment. This place is perfect for any person of any age (my mother has a slightly hard time walking and the very few steps she had to navigate were not a problem, which was a big relief)! It was stocked with just about any item you can imagine, especially the gorgeous kitchen, and the attention to the small details - even the antique toilet paper holder and the fantastic smelling sachet bag in the bedroom closet - made this place a warm, gorgeous, and very comfortable place to stay, all thanks to Paris and Clifton. I would stay here again, no question, and you should as well!
10.0 / 10.0
GREAT location in Sag Harbor - walking distance to everything in the village, while providing the quiet and waterfront views of a great escape. The host welcomes you personally with a wonderful story of the history of this old captain's house. While restaurants are within a 10 minute walk, there is also shopping if you want to stock up the fridge and hang out close to the property. The beds are comfy and the cable works. Nature close by - saw 3 deer on an early Sunday walk. Great alternative to the hotels in the village, we were so happy we chose this option.
10.0 / 10.0
We adored staying here. Large apartment, immaculately clean, simple and charming decor located a few blocks away from downtown. Perfect for an evening walk to and from any of the great restaurants on Main Street. Bedding was immaculately fresh and clean, an important factor for me. View of the water is beautiful with a cup of coffee in the morning and a glass of wine at night. My husband and I and our two pups felt entirely comfortable and can't wait to return. Paris was a lovely host!
10.0 / 10.0
Better than described
Very happy stay, nicer in person.
10.0 / 10.0
Super Location and great historic building!
Wonderful stay at a very historic residence. Loved all the great antiques that are furnishing the place. Can not beat the location to downtown. Thanks
10.0 / 10.0
The most perfect property and host!
This property and the host was absolutely one of our best ever! We have been to Sag Harbor multiple times but this was our first stay with Paris. It could not have been more perfect. The charm of the furnishings and the property itself with the new updated amenities were amazing. The house itself is out of a magazine with the furnishings, the views, and the charm all unmatched anywhere else. The location could not be better, and the entire experience will make us return again soon!!
10.0 / 10.0
Relaxing long weekend
We found our time in Sag Harbor delightful. The house was charming and very clean with a beautiful view of the water. It was very convenient to town and we walked in every morning for coffee and breakfast. The neighborhoods were also fun to walk through. Our host was very informative, helpful and available. The only downside is that we could her very easily the people above us moving around late into the evening but otherwise everything else was great
10.0 / 10.0
Fall Weekend getaway
wonderful accommodations in Sag Harbor. Minutes from the downtown, great views of the bay! Very spacious.
10.0 / 10.0
Indian Summer in Sag Harbor
The apartment is comfortable for the body and a pleasure to the eye. Ending the day with a cocktail on the deck as the sun set was always a treat. As a runner, putting together a 6 -8 mile route in the neighborhood was easy and safe from traffic...beautiful water views and historic houses abound. Paris and Clifton are attentive owners.
10.0 / 10.0
Peaceful and Quaint
We had such a wonderful stay at Paris and Clifton's property. They were very accommodating and the house was beautiful and only a short walk into town. We hope to return soon!
10.0 / 10.0
Lovely Place
Paris was great to work with and his place is lovely. Right on the water and a short walk to town. We had a great time and would definitely stay again.
10.0 / 10.0
Excellent stay again!
This might be our 8th visit to this beautiful home since 2017 and this house is our peaceful respite amidst this chaotic world. The sunsets are to die for and the property is exquisite and so comfortable. The hosts are beautiful people and we adore them so much, so kind and helpful, always with a genuine smile. My mother says they feel like family. We will definitely be back again soon for another stay at what has become our family peaceful getaway sanctuary :)
10.0 / 10.0
Great Sag Harbor location for get away short stay.
Paris and Clifton are gracious hosts of this well located property that combines its proximity to town with the tranquil setting and views. The perfect summer stay involves simple meal preps in a gorgeous kitchen to enjoying bouillabaisse at a local restaurant the Bell and Anchor. Always pick up wine in the area at Channings Daughters and take in a beach day at Cooper's Beach. Catch a wonderful touring act at Stephen Talkhouse and produce at a local farmer's market among other highlights.
10.0 / 10.0
great location
Exactly as described. Convenient to all of Sag Harbors attractions. All appliances work well. Good value, lots of space.
10.0 / 10.0
Awesome Historic Home
It may be missing some of the creature comforts like central air, but what it lacks it modern amenities, it more than makes up for in charm. The property is filled with cool antiques and the location really couldn’t be beat. Just a few minutes walk to shops and restaurants - and on that spectacular pond! We loved it and would totally return. The beds were a bit firm for our liking, but again, we just chalked it up to the experience. Owners were very welcoming and helpful.
10.0 / 10.0
Second visit...and hope to return!
We couldn’t wait to return Paris and Clifton are the ultimate hosts...there if you need them ASAP and also just completely welcoming and charming. We love the feel of a house and the view of the water and sunset from the kitchen and living room. The farmhouse table and outdoor table for eating or just relaxing. The decor is elegant and simple. And being able to bring my dog who loved the view of the rabbits and the short walk to town. Also great bookstore one house away and a little deli for any last minute stuff. I got to see the cottage too and that’s just as lovely. It gets harder to leave each time!
Thank you, Paris and Clifton!!!
8.0 / 10.0
Great location!
Traditional Hamptons house, great decor, beautiful views of the water, walking distance to town…lovely VRBO.
10.0 / 10.0
Just perfect and even better in person
My (83) year old mother and I and my small dog escaped covid nyc and rented the downstairs apartment. It felt like we were guests in someone’s wonderful tastefully decorated old (in a good way) house. Communication was great. Everything felt clean and safe. And having a nice kitchen with a farmhouse table overlooking the inlet at sunset—wow. It’s a nothing walk to town too. And having the screened in porch, washer/dryer, two bedrooms, we just enjoyed relaxing at the house. We even booked the only 4 days available this summer to return in 3 weeks. Nice too that the hosts are near and respond quickly to texts. We can’t wait to go back!
10.0 / 10.0
Charming Sag Harbor Getaway
Paris and Clifton were terrific hosts and my family and I enjoyed our stay at their home in Sag Harbor.
10.0 / 10.0
Short stay yet felt like a month. Cozy and charming space.
My daughter and her husband had just a small window to pull away from work. Our off season stay was restful and relaxing and Paris was both warm and welcoming. Thanks for sharing your home with us!
10.0 / 10.0
Peaceful ,stunning views.
Had a wonderful get away .
Wonderful location and beautiful views from the property .
Looking forward to my next stay.
Franklin
5.0 / 10.0
Had a wonderful get away . Wonderful location and beautiful views from the property .Looking forward to my next stay.Franklin
10.0 / 10.0
So nice we didn't want to leave!
Love this cute place. Great views. Cant wait to go back:)
10.0 / 10.0
Fall Weekend getaway
We stayed in the main house apartment located on the 1st floor, which was very spacious. @ large bedrooms, comfortable living area, Huge Kitchen with everything you need. Wonderful views water. Plus all these other little rooms here and there. A few minute drive to downtown, quaint with excellent restaurants and good shopping. Ferry is a few minutes away to Shelter Island to visit Northshore.
10.0 / 10.0
Absolutely wonderful place
The decor was top notch. The view was spectacular. The location was great being able to walk to restaurants, shops and wine stores. Being in a walking residential area really made walking our dog a very pleasant experience. Everything was great. Especially the kitchen. I could just live in the kitchen. We will be back. Thank you, Paris!!!
10.0 / 10.0
Happy We Found These Lovely Accommodations
We had a lovely four night stay in this charming apartment, with beautiful views of Sag Harbor. The apartment was immaculate and comfortable. Easy walking distance to town with great restaurants. And easy access to surrounding areas as well. We loved being here at this time of year and hope to return again next year. Thank you Paris and Clifton. And the bottle of wine was a wonderful touch and very much appreciated and enjoyed. Thanks again.
10.0 / 10.0
We thoroughly enjoyed our visit to Sag Harbor and especially the stay at Paris is beautiful home.
The location was great, the view was spectacular and the home was spotless and comfortable. It's an easy walk into town and a quick drive to Montauk Highway or over to the fairies to the North Fork. We loved it and we'll be back again next year!
10.0 / 10.0
Whaling Captain Pierson apt #2
This waterfront property is a unique space, within walking distance of the town for groceries, restaurants etc... and with beautiful views of the sunset over the water. It has everything you need for your stay and the hosts could not be more accommodating and helpful. I will definitely be returning for another visit!
10.0 / 10.0
Charming apartment in magical setting
If you are looking for a true Sag Harbor experience, this place could not be more perfect for it. Well appointed charming apartment in an old captains house in Main Street. Perfect location a short walking distance to the center of town and with the most AMAZING waterfront view and sunsets! Truly special!
10.0 / 10.0
A soft place to land during hard times
Our family of three spent six weeks in Whaling Captain Pierson's Apartment TOO during the early days of the CoVid-19 outbreak in New York City and beyond. It wasn't a typical time to stay in this historic home, as the weather was often too cold to enjoy the magnificent two acres that surround the 250 year-old domicile. And the quarantine prevented us from taking advantage of the town, which is a ten minute walk away. But the unobstructed view of the Sag Harbor inlet was a constant salvation during this impossible time in our history, each sunset more magnificent than the one before it, and all of them beacons of hope for healthier times. Paris and Clifton are consummate hosts; our wish is only that we could have gotten to know them better, if not for the wretched virus that kept us at a distance. But they provided whatever we needed, from the bottle of French red wine when we arrived to a new toaster when the old one went on the fritz. The beds were comfortable and the country kitchen a haven for our nightly dinners, constant snacking, and endless Zoom conferences. The fisherman in the family enjoyed the mud room at the side entrance of the house, which was also the perfect spot to leave groceries to air out before disinfecting them. For anyone staying for such a long length of time, and with more than two people, we might suggest a greater abundance of eating utensils and plate ware. But honestly it would be a dream to return during sunnier and warmer days, and enjoy the gorgeous lawn and private beach beyond the marsh -- from where you can pull a kayak or paddle board into the water, or just take a refreshing swim.
10.0 / 10.0
Beautiful and charming 💕
What a find!! So beautiful- charming and beautifully decorated. Like a chic boutique hotel in the best location. The owner is genteel and very knowledgeable. The place is a treasure. I hesitated to share because I want this gem available for me!!! A+++
10.0 / 10.0
Wonderful host and property!
We had a great long weekend at this property. Paris is a gracious host and the accommodations are so comfortable.
10.0 / 10.0
Lovely property
Comfortable accommodations.
10.0 / 10.0
Wonderful sag harbor home
My husband, daughter and dog and I spent an idyllic weekend in Paris’s beautiful apartment. It is every bit as delightful as stated in other reviews I read. Paris is friendly and welcoming and the place is great. Beautiful view comfy beds, authentic decor and a terrific kitchen overlooking the water. The location is ideal. Close to Canios books and a short walk to town. We will be back!
10.0 / 10.0
Terrific place
Great place to stay. Already planning to return.
10.0 / 10.0
Absolutely Perfect
What a beautiful place. So charming. We loved every second.
10.0 / 10.0
Incredible Property, we’ll be back!
I highly recommend staying at this property, it was just as it appears in the photos. The owner, Paris was extremely kind and made us feel right at home in this cozy 2 bedroom apartment. Quiet, private, serene are the words that come to mind when I look back on our stay. I highly recommend staying here for solo or small group travel. Clean, great decor, full kitchen and an awesome sun room that’s great for breakfast or any meal!
FAQs
How much does this apartment cost compared to others in Sag Harbor?
The average price for a rental in Sag Harbor is R 18,237 per night. This rental is R 11,628 less expensive than the average.
Is parking included with this apartment?
Yes, parking is listed as an amenity at Whaling Captain Pierson's Apartment TOO. For more information, we encourage you to contact the property about where to park.
Is there a pool at this apartment?
We didn’t find pool listed as an amenity for this apartment. It may be worth double checking if a pool is important for your stay.
Is Whaling Captain Pierson's Apartment TOO pet friendly?
Yes! This apartment is pet-friendly. For more information, we recommend contacting the booking provider about animal policies.
What amenities are available at Whaling Captain Pierson's Apartment TOO?
We found 10 amenities for this rental. This includes air conditioner, pets allowed, kitchen or kitchenette, internet / wifi, and parking.
Explore similar vacation rentals in Sag Harbor
Explore all rentals in Sag HarborSag Harbor travel inspiration
Read our blogGuides
Top Things to Do in Gulf Shores, Alabama: Adventure and Fun Await
Local Culture
Exploring Miami’s Wynwood District: Street Art, Food, and More
Guides
Fun Things to Do in Ocean City, Maryland
Local Culture
A Foodie’s Guide to the Best Dining in Orlando, Florida
Guides
Top Things to Do in Oahu and Honolulu
Guides
Top Things to Do in Fort Lauderdale, Florida
Guides
Top Things to Do in Miami: From Beaches to Culture
Guides
The Best Things to Do in Orlando: Attractions, Food, and Family Fun