Service was amazing. People were so pleasant and helpful. Room was great. View of bay, boats and pool was very nice. Will definitely stay here again.

Service was amazing. People were so pleasant and helpful. Room was great. View of bay, boats and pool was very nice. Will definitely stay here again.

The Mollie Pritchard is a lovely old school hotel with a lot of charm. The rooms do not have a refrigerator but they will put one in the room if you ask for one ahead of time. I would give it 5 stars except that we were assigned a room on the ground floor, which is actually the basement. So the ceiling was low and it felt small and dark. These rooms are called “delux” and you must take stairs to get to it. We didn’t ask to switch rooms because we were only staying 1 night and were too busy and tired to make the effort. I would advise if you are staying here to make sure you get a room accessible by elevator. Everything was clean and the bed was comfortable I would stay here again, but not in the basement

The Mollie Pritchard is a lovely old school hotel with a lot of charm. The rooms do not have a refrigerator but they will put one in the room if you ask for one ahead of time. I would give it 5 stars except that we were assigned a room on the ground floor, which is actually the basement. So the ceiling was low and it felt small and dark. These rooms are called “delux” and you must take stairs to get to it. We didn’t ask to switch rooms because we were only staying 1 night and were too busy and tired to make the effort. I would advise if you are staying here to make sure you get a room accessible by elevator. Everything was clean and the bed was comfortable I would stay here again, but not in the basement

We arrived in a rain storm. The valet did not help us with our luggage. They had one person working the reception desk to check in, despite a wedding and two bridal showers. It was very slow. The rooms are super small and what was supposed to be a queen bed was a full. The bathroom needs some serious updating. The location is beautiful and the lobby is nicely appointed.

We arrived in a rain storm. The valet did not help us with our luggage. They had one person working the reception desk to check in, despite a wedding and two bridal showers. It was very slow. The rooms are super small and what was supposed to be a queen bed was a full. The bathroom needs some serious updating. The location is beautiful and the lobby is nicely appointed.

Rooms could use some upgrades around the entertainment in room (TV, Service Provider, Ability to Cast etc)

Rooms could use some upgrades around the entertainment in room (TV, Service Provider, Ability to Cast etc)

Love the bar area -- staff were very helpful.

Lovely common area including bar. Staff very nice. Rooms are remarkably small. Bathroom needed work. Grout and sealant in bathrooms were discolored and quite dirty. No ventilation so room was a bit humid.

Cute and clean hotel. Drawback, no elevator to room in 100 numbers

Cute and clean hotel. Drawback, no elevator to room in 100 numbers

Rooms are kind of old fashion but not terrible. Pricey for the size of the rooms. The bathrooms should be updated fr

The room was a little smaller than I expected, but ok for 1 person. The restaurant was wonderful with great food & attentive staff. And of course the location on the Navesink was Phenomenal!

Really nice location. Restaurants were good. We walked into town to see a show. Loved how you could sit and look at the dock and boats. Pretty!

Everything was great, can't wait to go back.

The view of the bay

Great Italian restaurant across the street

Great Italian restaurant across the street

I understand it is historical but the ceiling looked like it had mold on it. The bathroom door had so many coats of paint you needed 2 hands to get it open and closed. I actually got stuck in it for this reason. Toilet tank cover was cracked. Toilet ran constantly. We had 3 rooms in our party and all rooms had similiar complaints. And the guy working Saturday night of our stay was the rudest person ever. Would never go back or recommend. We were there for a wedding at their sister hotel next door the Oystet Point which was very nice.

I understand it is historical but the ceiling looked like it had mold on it. The bathroom door had so many coats of paint you needed 2 hands to get it open and closed. I actually got stuck in it for this reason. Toilet tank cover was cracked. Toilet ran constantly. We had 3 rooms in our party and all rooms had similiar complaints. And the guy working Saturday night of our stay was the rudest person ever. Would never go back or recommend. We were there for a wedding at their sister hotel next door the Oystet Point which was very nice.

We loved it!!

We loved it!!

Molly pitcher was a beautiful spot on the water right by it all

The views are awesome

Great and beautiful place . Only con is the room is really small with queen bed . Two people can get in the way .

it was very nice to get away, the hotel pool room was kept extremely clean and staff were kind , would be back Denise S

it was very nice to get away, the hotel pool room was kept extremely clean and staff were kind , would be back Denise S

Nice quaint Inn with clean rooms, comfortable beds and a friendly staff.

Lovely hotel that is rustic, but charming. Nice location and close to many beaches and dining options.

Nice quaint Inn with clean rooms, comfortable beds and a friendly staff.

Lovely hotel that is rustic, but charming. Nice location and close to many beaches and dining options.