Welcome to The Garnsey! Fully renovated + 145' of private beach

10.0

Outstanding(19 Reviews)

House in Fayette, NY

10 guests · 5 bedrooms · 3 baths

Reasons to book

Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating

Free cancellationFull refund if you change your mind

Top-tier experienceOne of the higher cost properties in the area

About this house rental

If the dates you need are not available for The Garnsey, please search for The Backlund which we also own!

Recently purchased and fully renovated in 2019… bringing it back to life! This colonial lake house has amazing history dated back to the late 1700s. We’ve truly fallen in love with its old charm (but new feel) and want to share it with you!

The Garnsey can comfortably hold up to 10 guests with 4 large bedrooms (2 king beds + 2 queen beds + sectional sofa) and 2.5 bathrooms. Wait until you see the master ensuite! Free high speed WIFI access and TVs in each bedroom/living space.

The chef’s kitchen is an open concept layout with a custom island for the whole crew to enjoy meals and time together! Equipped with a dual fuel range, dishwasher, refrigerator with filtered water/ice, microwave, toaster, blender, pots/pans, dishes, and silverware. You will also have a Keurig coffee maker fully stocked with kcups and teas ready to brew!

The mudroom has an additional refrigerator if needed for drinks or extra food you may want to bring, a front loader washer and dryer, and a custom wash station.

You’ll have a large private beach front just a short (somewhat steep) walk down from the house for fishing, cookouts, or just to enjoy the view. The house’s upper balcony is a beautiful spot to take in sunrises as well! A new seasonal dock will be installed and available from May 15th – September 15th with public access boat launch available just 1.5 miles down the road at Cayuga Lake State Park if bringing/renting a boat.

Another great spot to enjoy is the outdoor cookout area on the paver patio in the backyard with a propane grill, patio set, and chiminea for fires at night.

Contactless check in with combination code access is as easy as it gets! We are local so if anything is needed during your stay, we will do our best to accommodate.

Considerations when booking:

- Route 89 is a busy road and has to be crossed to walk down to the lake shore.
- There are no stairs down to lake shore so the walk down the hill may be steep for some.
- The showers are located on the 2nd story so stairs will be required to shower.
- Main access to enter the house is through the garage.
- Any additional guests require pre-approval.
- No parties/events unless pre-approved.

***Please note that we will thoroughly clean and disinfect between each stay to prevent the spread of COVID19***

Amenities

Air conditioner

Kitchen or Kitchenette

Internet / Wifi

Fireplace

Parking

Laundry

Balcony or Patio

Dishwasher

Garden

Map of Fayette, NY

Nearby attractions

Taughannock Falls State Park

24.1 mi

Taughannock Falls Gorge Trail

24 mi

Ithaca Falls Natural Area

31.9 mi

Sciencenter

31.9 mi

$$$$

Welcome to The Garnsey! Fully renovated + 145' of private beach

$$$$

10.0

Outstanding(19 Reviews)

House in Fayette, NY

10 guests · 5 bedrooms · 3 baths

Reasons to book

Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating

Free cancellationFull refund if you change your mind

Top-tier experienceOne of the higher cost properties in the area

About this house rental

Amenities

Air conditioner

Kitchen or Kitchenette

Internet / Wifi

Fireplace

Parking

Laundry

Balcony or Patio

Dishwasher

Garden

Map of Fayette, NY

Nearby attractions

Taughannock Falls State Park

24.1 mi

Taughannock Falls Gorge Trail

24 mi

Ithaca Falls Natural Area

31.9 mi

Sciencenter

31.9 mi

Reviews

10.0

Outstanding(19 Reviews)

10.0

Apr 2024

Finger Lakes Solar Eclipse may have been cloudy but we could not have asked for a better place to view it than at Lake Cayuga shoreline at the Garnsey. The sky got erie dark and the birds were silent. It was an incredible experience to share with family from all over the country. The adults had a blast attending local wineries/breweries and the local parks were fun to hike and explore My grandson appreciated all the toys/puzzles available to keep him amused. The home is lovely. Do not hesitate to book this property. The location, accommodations, and view are spectacular.

10.0

Jul 2023

The Garnsey is second to none! <3

10.0

May 2023

Charming house—lovely porch with lake views, spacious backyard, lakeside fire pit, views from the living room and at least 2 bedrooms…wonderful place! FYI, if you have small children, there is a road between the lake and the house. It was no problem for us—we had drinks and appetizers while viewing sunset over the lake and cocktails by the fire pit in the evening. Fun stay!

10.0

May 2023

Great location for us girls to visit a bunch of wineries! The house was beautiful and very comfortable. There wasn’t a thing the owners hadn’t thought of to make our stay perfect!

10.0

Jan 2023

Beautiful, spacious, and clean home. Property contact very helpful and gracious. If possible, will definitely return.

10.0

Oct 2022

I stayed at Missy’s place for my bachelorette party and I cannot say enough positive things about it! From the second we walked in we were blown away by the adorable personal touches. Everything was spotless, there were fun games to play, the property was beautiful, the location was perfect.. the list goes on! I can’t wait to come back in the summer and take advantage of the lake!! Also Missy is incredibly responsive and sweet and helpful. Beyond a 10/10. Book now!!

10.0

Sep 2022

What an amazing property. This house made our bachelorette weekend perfect. Beautiful bedrooms with oodles of pillows, wonderful kitchen, extra fridge space, and a lake front view that makes you want to get up and sing! Also a host that checks in regularly to make sure you’re never wanting. Would stay again and again ❤️

10.0

Aug 2022

The home was immaculate and very well appointed. The host was gracious and has a knack for hospitality. The home was equipped with everything our family needed to enjoy the lake and area. The private boat house had kayaks and fishing poles, the dock was new and in great shape. It was perfect for us as we rented a pontoon while staying there. We would defiantly rent this home again!

10.0

Jul 2022

Wonderful Property

Wonderful Property

We loved our stay at the Garnsey House! Melissa was so attentive and a wonderful host. The house was great for our family. We enjoyed the beautiful view from the front porch and evenings in the back by the grill! Highly recommend!!!!

10.0

Jul 2022

Beautifully Appointed

Beautifully Appointed

This property was perfect. The host was very responsive. Four couples traveled from CT to Seneca Falls to celebrate a 95th birthday. The Garnsey house was clean, beautifully appointed, well stocked, with an amazing view of Cayuga Lake. The back patio was very welcoming. Will try to come back here!

10.0

Jun 2022

Beautiful house and view!

Beautiful house and view!

This is such an amazing house on Cayuga Lake! Our group of 8 had more than enough space to spread out and there were options to keep us all entertained during our stay. Also, the view can't be beat. We loved drinking our morning coffee out on the front porch and enjoyed the fire pit down by the lake every night. There are plenty of things to do between 15-30 mins away from the property too, so we had an endless list of things to explore. Finally, I want to make sure I convey how wonderful of a host Missy is. She was super responsive to all of my questions and even went out of her way to provide a few members of our group with fishing poles so we didn't have to rent them. I will definitely be staying here again if I'm traveling in the Finger Lakes region!

10.0

Mar 2022

Weekend Getaway

Weekend Getaway

The house was gorgeous and so well prepared. Our group had a wonderful time. Looking forward to staying again

10.0

Oct 2021

Amazing Stay

Amazing Stay

We had SUCH a wonderful experience at this house! The house itself is absolutely gorgeous...the pictures don't do it justice. We were blown away! Everything was perfect and provided for. The rooms were large and gave enough space for my 4 year old to play and the adults to relax. All the furniture was super comfortable. Checking in and out was a breeze. It was easy to walk across the road to the lake and fire pit, and we had a great night under the stars making s'mores the one night. There is also a large backyard and chiminea which we utilized as well. It's so close to so many great wineries and breweries and the suggestions provided were awesome! Thanks again for the perfect stay!! Would highly recommend!

10.0

Oct 2021

Beyond Amazing!!

Beyond Amazing!!

First impression was that this home is beautiful, breathtaking and so comfortable, Final impression was that, and more!! Spending time in this luxury farmhouse was incredible, The hostess, Missy was so gracious and available quickly for every single question. She pays attention to all the fine details. I would not hesitate to book this property again! The group hopes to come back soon, So many memories made in this beautiful home!! Thank you for letting us stay and have the best weekend of 2021!!!

10.0

Sep 2021

Finger lakes with a view

Finger lakes with a view

As our first trip in the Finger Lakes, it did not disappoint! We have stayed in many homes off VRBO and this was by far the best. Not a thing was needed and everything you could imagine needing was at your finger tips. The view from the front porch was stunning and great to sit with a up of morning coffee. The host was so attentive to questions and comments throughout the process of booking to departure. I only wish we could have stayed longer!

10.0

Sep 2021

Great house with great hosts

Great house with great hosts

This was our first lake vacation as a family and the house and hosts could not have been any better. The house was even better than it appears in the pictures and the hosts were great. They provided all necessary information in advance and were extremely helpful before and during our stay.

10.0

Aug 2021

Week by the lake

Week by the lake

This is a beautiful house with lake views from almost every room. Melissa is a very accommodating and responsive host. And the lake front area is substantial. We particularly enjoyed kayaking and even just sitting on the dock and observing the great variety of wildlife. We regularly saw heron, osprey, a family of swans and a couple of times, a bald eagle flew overhead. Overall, we had a lovely time. But there are a few issues to be aware of. One, the road between the house and the lake is 55 mph. So, if you have someone who has mobility issues, that can be a problem for reaching the lake. Also, there is a lot of plant growth in the water, so it is not so inviting for swimming--although we had a lovely time lounging in floats. Finally, when we booked, the website listed two beds in the fourth bedroom, but there was only one when we arrived--although there were blow up mattresses available.

10.0

Jul 2021

Amazing Lake House!

Amazing Lake House!

We picked this lovely house to accommodate a larger group of 10 for my sister's bachelorette party. The house was immaculate and the lake front was awesome. The house was fully equipt and had exactly what we needed to host a couple of wine dinners. The bedrooms are beautiful with so many thoughtful touches throughout the house. Great location close to several wineries and other outdoor adventures. We thoroughly enjoyed every minute of our stay. So much fun, Highly recommend!!!

10.0

Jun 2021

Beautiful property by the lake

Beautiful property by the lake

Beautiful house by the lake. Perfectly appointed, clean and stocked on essentials. Melissa, the property manager, was super attentive and was quick and eager to assist us. Location was superb for finger lakes activities and visits. We had a very special week celebrating our daughter’s Cornell graduation.

FAQs

How much does this house cost compared to others in Fayette?

The average price for a rental in Fayette is $367 per night. This rental is $174 above the average.

Is parking included with this house?

Yes, parking is listed as an amenity at Welcome to The Garnsey! Fully renovated + 145' of private beach. For more information, we encourage you to contact the property about where to park.

Is there a pool at this house?

We didn’t find pool listed as an amenity for this house. It may be worth double checking if a pool is important for your stay.

Is Welcome to The Garnsey! Fully renovated + 145' of private beach pet friendly?

Unfortunately, this house is not pet-friendly. Try searching again and filter for "Pets Allowed"

What amenities are available at Welcome to The Garnsey! Fully renovated + 145' of private beach?

We found 10 amenities for this rental. This includes air conditioner, kitchen or kitchenette, internet / wifi, fireplace, and parking.

Explore similar vacation rentals in Fayette

Explore all rentals in Fayette

6.0

Average(2 Reviews)

Seneca Falls Cottage on Cayuga Lake Wine Trail!

House

in Seneca Falls

Kitchen or Kitchenette · Air conditioner · Internet / Wifi

Looking for a memorable stay in Fayette? Our House might just be what you're looking for. Enjoy amenities including Air conditioner, Dishwasher and Fireplace, and more during your stay.

$$$$

Welcome to The Garnsey! Fully renovated + 145' of private beach

House in Fayette, NY

Reasons to book

About this house rental

Amenities

Map of Fayette, NY

Nearby attractions

Welcome to The Garnsey! Fully renovated + 145' of private beach

House in Fayette, NY

Reasons to book

About this house rental

Amenities

Map of Fayette, NY

Nearby attractions

Reviews

FAQs

How much does this house cost compared to others in Fayette?

Is parking included with this house?

Is there a pool at this house?

Is Welcome to The Garnsey! Fully renovated + 145' of private beach pet friendly?

What amenities are available at Welcome to The Garnsey! Fully renovated + 145' of private beach?

Explore similar vacation rentals in Fayette

Fayette travel inspiration

Related vacation destinations

Keep exploring