The property was very nice. One bedroom is connected to another bedroom and requires you to walk through to access the shared bathroom. This was the only thing I would have changed about the home. Everything was clean and Jennifer was a pleasure to work with.

I had great communication with Jennifer. She was prompt to respond to questions and concerns. The Starfish house looks just like the pictures. It was very tastefully decorated with a beachy vibe. There was plenty of room for our party of 7. The cabana outside is key for keeping cool in the shade. The Cabana Club membership is a nice added bonus. We enjoyed our stay. The only thing to complain about, is we had to leave.

Our family had a wonderful vacation in this lovely home. Perfect location, plenty of room and very clean. Great communication with owner and would definitely stay again!

The house is much bigger than it appears in the pictures. I was shocked at the size of the living area. Plus hats off to the cleaning crew. Not a spec of dust or dirt anywhere. Way cleaner than the Marriott's we stayed in on the trip there.

This has been the best family trip!! First, Jennifer responded very quickly to every question we had! Even the ones we had a week before we arrived! This home is beautiful! The tiki hut out back allows you to enjoy the view under the shade! The kayaks we fun for a little evening ride around the canals and inlet. We had plenty of space for our family of 7! Sunset park is a nice evening walk from here! The pool and cabana club, where we had a great time, is just around the corner! I would highly, highly recommend the Starfish! There are many so amenities, it is cozy and we hope to stay again in the future!

Great, clean, inviting home. Had a great time! Will return soon!

We really enjoyed our stay at the Starfish house! The location was great! We are missing the beautiful turquoise waters already! The home had everything we needed for a comfortable stay. We loved the outside patio area and even saw some manatees right off the dock! We enjoyed having access to the pool and beach at the Cabana Club. We also loved that we could dock the boat that we rented in the backyard. We had a good time snorkeling and fishing in the area! We hope to stay again another time!

The Starfish House was everything it was advertised to be and even better. We were able to relax and enjoy from the moment we arrived. I would not hesitate to stay here again.

Had a great time visiting Key Colony again. The house was gorgeous and had most of what we needed. The house and property looked exactly like that photos. We had really good communication with the property manager... Jennifer was wonderful. A few things about the property that weren't ideal, but not big problems... I cook a lot and would've liked more substantial cooking utensils in the kitchen. Plastic//rubber spatula's, etc. don't work well in a hot skillet or with heavy meat patties, steak, etc. Ended up using the grill utensils which were big and a little awkward but got the job done. There might've been one, but couldn't find a mixer in the kitchen (found a blender but no mixer). There was a minor plumbing issue in one of the two bathrooms. Since it was just the two of us, it was almost a non-issue. We notified Jennifer and she's addressing the issue. Overall a great property and good choice for us.

We loved our stay. Everything was as advertised and expected.

Great property in a perfect location. It suited our family of 6 well along with my wife's parents. This is one of those properties that definitely deserves a 5 star review. It pains me to give it 5 stars only because that could lead to it becoming more popular and not being available next time I want to rent it, but they definitely deserve the 5 stars in my opinion. The owner has great communication skills and the property has everything we needed for some relaxing family time. The cabana club access was a bonus to be able to enjoy the pool and private beach. I was a little worried about parking before I got there but found that my 29 ft boat fit just fine on the dock and there was ample parking out front for my trailer, truck and wife's car as well. There is a comfy tiki hut and table on the back area along with bait freezer, and kayaks. Thanks for making our trip a great success!

Stayed here with my wife, brother in law, sister in law, and my two and four year olds. House is very clean and easily accessible. If you are bringing smaller children you may need to childproof a little when you arrive. Pool access was wonderful and the ability to dock a boat out front is really nice. Overall a win!

Everything was perfect & better than described. There was a little of everything, very spacious & felt at home. The best was the back yard when the tiki hut, Kayaks & daily visitors down the canal. Will definitely be back soon. Jennifer was easy to reach for quick questions.

We had a wonderful vacation in KCB. Great home and patio area with tiki hut to shield the afternoon sun while enjoying a beer. Dock was perfect for 25ft boat. Easy access to ocean and bay.

Jennifer made everything easy for us the house was really nice she checked on us periodically she always responded to any text or calls answering questions for us we really enjoyed our stay we are already making plans for next time

This downstairs unit of the starfish house was just as described. The unit was clean, beds comfortable, and the kitchen fairly well equipped. Many thoughtful details at this rental to help make guests comfortable. The outdoor area was the highlight of this rental. Kayaks to use, a tiki hut to sit under in the shade and a canal to fish in and watch boats come in or dock your own. The evenings are so beautiful and breezy here. The cabana club is strict and has a lot of rules but the staff was friendly to us. My kids enjoyed being here nearly every day. Drinks and food are not astronomically priced. Plenty of snacks and ice cream available before 5pm and food available until 6. My kids were always sad to leave at 7 when they closed but this was a natural ending time for the day to go eat dinner and relax for the evening at home. The beach area is just so-so, but we knew when coming to the keys we were not coming for the beaches. I recommend driving and parking for cabana club or biking. Walking was a little long. Sombrero beach is about 17 min away. Turtle Hospital 13 min away. Dolphin Research Center 11 min away (heavily recommend). Bahia Honda state park 27 min away. Key west about 75 min away. Key colony is a very quiet community off the main drag of hwy 1. We appreciated this. We like a more relaxed and low key feel to our vacations. Still a few little restaurants and shops available. Jennifer was amazing to communicate with. Prompt, clear, and helpful. She resolved any and all minor issues that came up as quickly and as well as she could.

Great house located 20 yards from the canal. Super easy to access your boat, and easier access to the gulf, and the atlantic. Located at the end of the canal also is big plus. Jennifer was outstanding answered every question we ask, and she responded almost immediately. I would recommend this house and, Jennifer without any hesitation. We are and will definitely stay there agian.

One of the best rentals I’ve ever stayed in! Jennifer was so nice and made our stay perfect. Her home is so nice and clean. A great location too. We will be back!

We stayed here as a family of six and had more than enough room. The space was clean and the canal was awesome. The kids fished daily from our backyard. Manatees swam up one night and hung out with us for an hour. One street over was a playground and park area with bocce ball and we taught the kids to play. Added bonus when we wanted a quiet night in. The host was responsive but respectful and left us alone unless we asked her a question. Would stay here again.

Great location! There’s even an urgent care less than 5 min away! Enjoyed the Cabana Club! Park and basketball courts a very short walk. Kids loved it. Enjoyed having the dock for a boat we rented. Short drive to many good restaurants and the grocery store! Quiet and peaceful! Just what we needed. Marianela was super helpful and always very responsive!

This house was so cozy and clean. Decorated just like a little beach pad and had everything we needed to get started. It was inviting and close to all the "keys hotspots". The owner was so easy to work with. We loved the back patio and enjoying the sun as well as heading up to the cabana club - what a great perk!

Very nice place to stay in Marathon. Clean, comfortable. Great location for docking boat at house. Great communication from property manager. Thanks for a great stay!

Great Location! Lots of activities in the area. Beautiful property. It was perfect for our family getaway.

Very clean and comfortable house! Great location for boating! Marianela is very sweet and a pleasure to deal with!

We felt the property was well maintained and very clean. It comfortably fit our party of 8. The large living space was especially good for our gatherings in the air conditioning.

I’ve rented plenty of properties around the Keys, but this has to be one of my favorites. Everything is renovated and new inside with very nice decor. The access to the main waterway is quick and easy, and the dock can hold a good sized boat. Rooms were very nice and the communication with the owner was very helpful and nice. All in all a great vacation home.

Great place, loved the open floor plan! Would definitely stay here again! Owner was very nice and responded quickly to any questions. Thank you for sharing your beautiful home!

Excellent location and nice home. Lots of room and great location.

Spacious, light filled and immaculately clean. Kitchen is fully equipped for cooking, which we did a lot of. Marianela is responsive and very professional. Everything was as advertised- no surprises.

Second time renting this home. Property is just like the pictures. Wonderful community.

Very nice and easy to deal with. Would definitely come back

We stay at this property every year and would never stay anywhere else. We rent a boat that is in our "backyard" canal and the location is PERFECT. Marianela is so kind and generous and the house is absolutely picture perfect. We can't wait to go back every year.