Amazing stay!

as a luxury, real estate agent and travel agent, I was very excited to stay at Barren Cove in Sag Harbor for a day and check it out for some fabulous clients who are thinking of having an event there. Unfortunately, our flight was delayed 15 hours from LAX to New York because of bad weather and Barren Cove and Expedia don’t have any type of accommodations or policies to give a credit or cancel. I spent hours on the phone with Expedia. He was in touch with Barr’s Cove, as well as with the manager at Barren Cove and emailed and they would not give me a refund or even a credit towards the future visit. I would love to explore this property for my clients, but unfortunately, I was not able to and they did not make it easy , it looks beautiful in the pictures. It was recommended by a friend that lives in Sag Harbor.

This hotel is amazing. A wonderful resort. The entire staff is friendly and accommodating. Kristen the front desk was so nice and welcoming. We met two young pool area servers from Ireland who were so lovely. We had a wonderful two nights there. The walking around Sag Harbor downtown Main Street for our morning walks and for dinner was so easy and fun. We even rode their bikes around the parking lot since we hadn’t been on bicycles for way too long.

General Manager and Staff did not follow standard safety guidelines and I did not appreciate the responses and follow up.

I recently stayed at Baron's Cove, & unfortunately, it was one of the most disappointing hotel experiences I've ever had. The primary issue was the shockingly rude & disrespectful behavior of the staff, which overshadowed any positive aspects of the hotel. From the moment I arrived, it was clear that guest service was not a priority. I was met with dismissive attitudes & curt responses. They acted as if my presence was an inconvenience rather than a valued guest. Throughout my stay, I encountered several issues that required staff assistance: drink & dining delays of over an hour, and ignoring the Do Not Disturb sign. Each time I sought help, the staff seemed annoyed by my request & responded in a manner that was both unhelpful & disrespectful rolling their eyes & muttering as they walked away. Instead of resolving my problems, they made me feel like a nuisance. I'd hoped that the management might be more understanding, but my interactions with them were equally disappointing. When I attempted to address my concerns about the staff’s behavior, I was met with defensiveness & a lack of accountability. It seemed like they were more interested in dismissing my complaints than addressing the issues at hand. While the hotel's amenities & location were satisfactory, the staff's rude behavior left a sour taste the staff's rude behavior left a sour taste that overshadowed my entire stay. A hotel experience should be welcoming & accommodating, & they failed miserably in these aspects.

Lackluster front desk staff. Lovely restaurant and live entertainment at night, exceptional. Breakfast staff amazing.

Lovely rooms, property and staff... Elegant from start to finish.

Such a cute place right on the water. Loved the pool area. It was close to Main Street so was able to walk to all the restaurants and shops in town. Plenty of parking as well.

Rooms are VERY average and WAY TOO EXPENSIVE- my 1,700.00 a night room was worth about 600.00 a night. The decor was cheap, the shower was awful- the whole thing was more like a cheap motel.

No room service Band / music at night noisy Coffee in morning didn’t offer muffind

Wonderful relaxing mini resort - pricey but everything in Sag is!! coffee every morning VERY NICE! The staff is very eager to assist - kitchen need of more staff?? slow and perhaps a bell of some sort at front desk..

Barons Cove is very nice but you need to get a room Upstairs otherwise all night long you here running around from kids etc.. The place is very nice the views on the upper area you see the boats on the water which is beautiful . Dinner at the restaurant didnt have many options though. Breakfast was great.

We loved this hotel. Wonderful staff, great room with beautiful views. Very good restaurant.

Water views

Loved this cute cozy hotel. The location is so convenient to restaurants. The vibe is so calm and relaxing. Definitely looking forward to our next stay here.

Great location. Best spot in all of the Hampton. They had free bikes to ride around. Nice view. Great breakfast. I love this place.

We loved everything about our stay - the location, the cleanliness, the service, Kristen at the front desk :-), the food (we had breakfast and brunch at the hotel during our two days there) - can't wait to go back to Baron's Cove!!!!

Lovely place

It never disappoints

Very nice spot in Sag Harbor. Very convenient walking distance to the town.

Nice place and very good room.

The hotel is stunning, they did not spare any details. The front desk team is exceptional and was helpful with everything needed. The bar is serving unique and delicious cocktails. Great location in walking distance to the Main Street restaurants and shopping. Will be staying here for all future trips out to the hamptons area.

Very nice experience. Rooms are excellent and the facility is well kept. Dininh and entertainment options over easter weekend worked well. Bar serice was a bit hit and miss at times. That said, all the staff are very friendly and helpful.

Excellent establishment

Very nice hotel and staff.

First time visiting the Hamptons in many years. This property is conveniently situated to downstream sag harbor with lovely shops and dining. I did upgrade the room to one with private patio and pool adjacent. This made a big difference in comfort during our stay. They also have a gorgeous sister property, The Pridwin, on Shelter Island which guests are welcome to enjoy as well. Usually there is a free boat shuttle to the Pridwin, though sadly not running the days of our stay. The food at the restaurant is very good with an ample selection of choices. The staff..especially Kristen at the front desk, were very welcoming, warm and helpful!! Really enjoyed our time here!!

Great stay!

Best place in Sag!

Bar/Lobby area is outstanding. Lobby Singer was great. Bike's and paddleboards were outstanding

A terrific place for an upscale vacation in Sag Harbor.

It was a great location. Staff was moody, and food quality was mediocre. I would book elsewhere next time.

The staff was very accommodating