Peace of Paradise: Pvt., swing bar, pool, beach!
4.9
Outstanding(51 Reviews)House in North Captiva Island, FL
10 guests · 4 bedrooms · 2 baths
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Free cancellationFull refund if you change your mind
Includes essentialsGarden, Pool, Kitchen or Kitchenette and more
About this house rental
(In recent news...The fall of 2024 was a challenging one for North Captiva Island due to hurricanes passing through. Peace of Paradise faired incredibly well but we want all of our guest to understand that there will be signs of recovery around the island over the coming months. We greatly appreciate your understanding as other homeowners and island teams work to make the beautiful updates needed. We absolutely appreciate your business. Thank you!)
Are you familiar with what it takes to vacation on North Captiva Island, FL?
(If you are, you're welcome to jump down to the "We'd like to welcome you to Peace of Paradise!:" section below. - The island is excited to have you back!)
NEVER VACATIONED ON NORTH CAPTIVA ISLAND? Here are some VERY important things to note:
1) There are no roads/bridges to this island. All vacationers and homeowners access the island either by ferry boat, chartered boat, private boat, or via small, private aircraft. The journey is as enchanting as the destination.
Upon arrival, our guests are greeted at the ferry dock by our Property Management team and escorted in golf carts to Peace of Paradise. Use of two 4-person golf carts is included in your rental.
2) There are no major grocery stores on the island. All vacationers and homeowners provision their houses either by personally shopping prior to leaving the mainland or by hiring a personal shopper or management team to do the shopping for them.
Yes, there is some legwork involved in planning a vacation on NCI but the effort is worth it because this is what makes NCI so special!...Step away from the real world, relax...and PLAY!
We'll guide you every step of the way! As soon as your reservation is confirmed, you'll receive a link to our Digital Guidebook which will guide you through the planning process step-by step! If you ever still have questions, you can reach out to me (Molly) as I'm a very attentive host!
--We’d like to welcome you to Peace of Paradise! --
Hosted by Cowboys and Mermaids Vacation Rentals
"Peace of Paradise is just that. It is a peaceful, idyllic getaway that allows you rest and relaxation or fun and adventure if you want it." - Barbara
As soon as your reservation is confirmed, you'll receive a link to our Digital Guidebook which will guide you through the planning process step-by step, including companies we highly recommend (such as Island Girl Charters for ferry travel to the island). If you ever still have questions, you can reach out to me (Molly) as I'm a very attentive host!
4 bedroom * 9 bed (2K, 1Q, 6T) * 2 bath * Up to 10 guests
--FEATURED AMENITIES --
*Old Florida Style Circular Home on top of Under The House Outdoor Dining/Lounging Space
*Open Concept Inside Living on a Single Level (about 12 stairs to the house)
*Private Heated Pool w/ Waterfall
*2 Four-Person Golf Carts
*Outdoor Bar w/ Swing Seats, Smart TV & Beverage Cooler
*3 Hammocks Over White Sand
*High End Coffee Station
*Members Only Beach Parking 7min walk or 2 min Golf Cart Ride
*Digital Guidebook
*4 Fat Tire Bikes
*Personal Concierge Service Upon Arrival and Departure
*RO Filtered Water
*Airstrip Membership Use for Private Pilots
"The 2 golf carts were amazing, and probably our favorite part of our stay. We enjoyed rides around the island just exploring all the beauty North Captiva has to offer." -Andrew
--ESCAPE & UNWIND--
Step away from the hustle-bustle of daily life. Pour a tropical drink and lounge beside the turquoise waters of your own private, resort-style pool. Listen to the splashing of the pool's waterfall and the palm fronds rustling above, as family and friends begin making new favorite memories.
Great location on North Captiva Island; you're just a quick golf cart ride away from your members-only beach entrance, a 600 acre nature preserve, the island's restaurants, gift shops/cream shops, and favorite spots for dolphins and manatees to hang out! Come enjoy Peace of Paradise on the idyllic North Captiva Island!
--INDOOR LIVING--
BEDS & BATHS:
*Accommodates up to 10 guests in comfort.
*First Master: king sized bed, wall of tall windows
*En suite bathroom: double sinks, custom-tiled shower w/ two shower heads, jetted soaking tub
*Second Master: king sized bed
*Queen Bedroom
*Bunk Bedroom: two sets of triple bunks
*Shared bath between these bedrooms: two free standing sinks with storage, tub/shower combo
KITCHEN: Peace of Paradise's kitchen is sure to please all levels of culinary expertise! Fully stocked and featuring double ovens, Frigidaire range set into Labradorite countertops, Calphalon knife set, variety of pots and pans, and ample William Sonoma dishware.
DINING: The dining table by the kitchen can accommodate 8 people and there's extra seating for 4 more at the kitchen island. Outdoor dining table (under the house) seats 10.
Please Note: North Captiva does not have a grocery store (see note at the top of this listing), you'll want to come prepared, but no worries, the owners of Peace of Paradise and their management team are not new to this rodeo. The digital guide book you'll receive upon booking will walk you step by step through the process. Take this opportunity to meal plan some favorites or try some new, tantalizing tropical recipes - key lime pie anyone? Dining-in or carrying-out from the four island restaurants or inviting in a local chef to prepare you a meal to remember are always memorable options!
--OUTDOOR LIVING--
UPPER LEVEL DECK: Just a step out from the living room, comfortable overstuffed seating for morning coffee or an evening cocktail.
GROUND LEVEL LIVING SPACE: Ready to be wowed? Tucked under the stilted (20 feet) house, you and your friends/family will enjoy a beautifully private, outdoor living space. Large circular sectional, dining table seats 10 comfortably, 3 colorful hammocks over a giant sandbox, Bamboo Bar - swing seating, beverage cooler, a flat screen TV.
POOL AREA: Private, heated pool featuring turquoise water and a cascading waterfall. Variety of lounge seating and sun umbrellas
GRILL AREA: Weber propane grill, KettlePizza charcoal pizza oven
--NORTH CAPTIVA ISLAND ADVENTURE--
Peace of Paradise is the perfect location for quick adventures around NCI. The island is just 4 miles long and 1/2 mile wide at its widest and Peace of Paradise is centrally located so, you're never far from a new spot to explore. Your reservation at Peace of Paradise includes the use of 2 four-person golf carts and 4 fat tire bikes.
NATURE PRESERVE: Hike or bike 600 Acres
VISIT THE BEACHES: 2 minute golf cart ride from the house. Member's Only Beach Parking Included in Reservation
RENT A TOY: Boats & Fun on NCI rents a large variety of toys! Boat rentals for exploring neighboring islands, kayak rentals for paddling among the dolphins, a paddle board to gain a completely different vantage point, or jet ski rentals to really get your zoom on. They also rent fishing equipment for fishing from the beach which is an island favorite.
CHARTER EXCURSIONS - There's no shortage or captains who offer excursions! Deep Sea fishing, anyone?
DIGITAL GUIDEBOOK: Our digital guidebook (link provided upon completing your reservation) will point you in the right direction for all of these activities and MORE.
--THE DETAILS--
ENTERTAINMENT & TECHNOLOGY:
-Starlink high speed internet
-50" smart tv in living room w/ DVD player
-Over 100 DVDs
-Small TVs in each of the adult bedrooms w/ built-in DVD players
-Large indoor/outdoor portable speaker Bluetooth compatible
EXTRA CONVENIENCES:
*Two front load washing machines & two front load dryers - convenient for light packing.
*All bed linens, bath towels, pool towels, kitchen towels and washcloths provided. Extra pillows & blankets.
*Shampoo & Conditioner, liquid hand soap, laundry pods, dishwasher pods, liquid dish soap provided.
*Two pack & plays, indoor baby gate, solid-wood high chair for our youngest vacationers.
*Basic kitchen spices, plastic wrap & aluminum foil
*Two hairdryers & one curling iron
FUN & SPORTS EQUIPMENT:
-Four fat tire bikes and helmets - bikes are maintained frequently but we cannot guarantee their condition - bikes are provided in AS IS condition
-Large cooler for beach trips or keeping drinks cold near the pool
-Corn Hole (beanbag toss) game
-Variety of children's sand and pool toys
-Assorted family friendly games & puzzles
COOKING & DINING:
-Fully Stocked Kitchen: Pots & Pans, Dinnerware, Large Variety of Glassware, Assorted Bakeware
-Gourmet Coffee Station: Coffee Grinder, Coffee Maker, Espresso Machine
-2 Ovens
-Small Appliances: Crock Pot, Toaster, Electric Griddle, Electric Juicer, Blender
-Large Weber Propane Grill
-KettlePizza Charcoal Pizza Grill
RESERVING PEACE OF PARADISE:
*We accept instant booking but please reach out prior to booking if you have any questions; Molly, the host, is happy to help.
*After booking, you will receive a digital guidebook. This handy tool works like an App on your phone and will walk you through all the steps required for planning a vacation on NCI such as...scheduling a taxi from the airport, which method you'll choose for acquiring your groceries, selecting a ferry option, and details on connecting with our property management team.
*Please sign the rental contract within 48 hours of booking. Your reservation is not confirmed until this has been properly filled out and returned.
*Get excited! A vacation of a lifetime is waiting for you! We look forward to having you as guests!
--POLICIES--
-Rental Agreement must be signed and returned w/in 48 hrs of making reservation
-No events or parties
-No smoking or drug use
-No pets
-Must be 24 or older to book
-NO ONE WITHOUT A VALID DRIVERS LICENSE MAY DRIVE A GOLF CART
-No driving golf carts on the beach or in the nature preserve
-Bikes are provided in AS IS
Are you familiar with what it takes to vacation on North Captiva Island, FL?
(If you are, you're welcome to jump down to the "We'd like to welcome you to Peace of Paradise!:" section below. - The island is excited to have you back!)
NEVER VACATIONED ON NORTH CAPTIVA ISLAND? Here are some VERY important things to note:
1) There are no roads/bridges to this island. All vacationers and homeowners access the island either by ferry boat, chartered boat, private boat, or via small, private aircraft. The journey is as enchanting as the destination.
Upon arrival, our guests are greeted at the ferry dock by our Property Management team and escorted in golf carts to Peace of Paradise. Use of two 4-person golf carts is included in your rental.
2) There are no major grocery stores on the island. All vacationers and homeowners provision their houses either by personally shopping prior to leaving the mainland or by hiring a personal shopper or management team to do the shopping for them.
Yes, there is some legwork involved in planning a vacation on NCI but the effort is worth it because this is what makes NCI so special!...Step away from the real world, relax...and PLAY!
We'll guide you every step of the way! As soon as your reservation is confirmed, you'll receive a link to our Digital Guidebook which will guide you through the planning process step-by step! If you ever still have questions, you can reach out to me (Molly) as I'm a very attentive host!
--We’d like to welcome you to Peace of Paradise! --
Hosted by Cowboys and Mermaids Vacation Rentals
"Peace of Paradise is just that. It is a peaceful, idyllic getaway that allows you rest and relaxation or fun and adventure if you want it." - Barbara
As soon as your reservation is confirmed, you'll receive a link to our Digital Guidebook which will guide you through the planning process step-by step, including companies we highly recommend (such as Island Girl Charters for ferry travel to the island). If you ever still have questions, you can reach out to me (Molly) as I'm a very attentive host!
4 bedroom * 9 bed (2K, 1Q, 6T) * 2 bath * Up to 10 guests
--FEATURED AMENITIES --
*Old Florida Style Circular Home on top of Under The House Outdoor Dining/Lounging Space
*Open Concept Inside Living on a Single Level (about 12 stairs to the house)
*Private Heated Pool w/ Waterfall
*2 Four-Person Golf Carts
*Outdoor Bar w/ Swing Seats, Smart TV & Beverage Cooler
*3 Hammocks Over White Sand
*High End Coffee Station
*Members Only Beach Parking 7min walk or 2 min Golf Cart Ride
*Digital Guidebook
*4 Fat Tire Bikes
*Personal Concierge Service Upon Arrival and Departure
*RO Filtered Water
*Airstrip Membership Use for Private Pilots
"The 2 golf carts were amazing, and probably our favorite part of our stay. We enjoyed rides around the island just exploring all the beauty North Captiva has to offer." -Andrew
--ESCAPE & UNWIND--
Step away from the hustle-bustle of daily life. Pour a tropical drink and lounge beside the turquoise waters of your own private, resort-style pool. Listen to the splashing of the pool's waterfall and the palm fronds rustling above, as family and friends begin making new favorite memories.
Great location on North Captiva Island; you're just a quick golf cart ride away from your members-only beach entrance, a 600 acre nature preserve, the island's restaurants, gift shops/cream shops, and favorite spots for dolphins and manatees to hang out! Come enjoy Peace of Paradise on the idyllic North Captiva Island!
--INDOOR LIVING--
BEDS & BATHS:
*Accommodates up to 10 guests in comfort.
*First Master: king sized bed, wall of tall windows
*En suite bathroom: double sinks, custom-tiled shower w/ two shower heads, jetted soaking tub
*Second Master: king sized bed
*Queen Bedroom
*Bunk Bedroom: two sets of triple bunks
*Shared bath between these bedrooms: two free standing sinks with storage, tub/shower combo
KITCHEN: Peace of Paradise's kitchen is sure to please all levels of culinary expertise! Fully stocked and featuring double ovens, Frigidaire range set into Labradorite countertops, Calphalon knife set, variety of pots and pans, and ample William Sonoma dishware.
DINING: The dining table by the kitchen can accommodate 8 people and there's extra seating for 4 more at the kitchen island. Outdoor dining table (under the house) seats 10.
Please Note: North Captiva does not have a grocery store (see note at the top of this listing), you'll want to come prepared, but no worries, the owners of Peace of Paradise and their management team are not new to this rodeo. The digital guide book you'll receive upon booking will walk you step by step through the process. Take this opportunity to meal plan some favorites or try some new, tantalizing tropical recipes - key lime pie anyone? Dining-in or carrying-out from the four island restaurants or inviting in a local chef to prepare you a meal to remember are always memorable options!
--OUTDOOR LIVING--
UPPER LEVEL DECK: Just a step out from the living room, comfortable overstuffed seating for morning coffee or an evening cocktail.
GROUND LEVEL LIVING SPACE: Ready to be wowed? Tucked under the stilted (20 feet) house, you and your friends/family will enjoy a beautifully private, outdoor living space. Large circular sectional, dining table seats 10 comfortably, 3 colorful hammocks over a giant sandbox, Bamboo Bar - swing seating, beverage cooler, a flat screen TV.
POOL AREA: Private, heated pool featuring turquoise water and a cascading waterfall. Variety of lounge seating and sun umbrellas
GRILL AREA: Weber propane grill, KettlePizza charcoal pizza oven
--NORTH CAPTIVA ISLAND ADVENTURE--
Peace of Paradise is the perfect location for quick adventures around NCI. The island is just 4 miles long and 1/2 mile wide at its widest and Peace of Paradise is centrally located so, you're never far from a new spot to explore. Your reservation at Peace of Paradise includes the use of 2 four-person golf carts and 4 fat tire bikes.
NATURE PRESERVE: Hike or bike 600 Acres
VISIT THE BEACHES: 2 minute golf cart ride from the house. Member's Only Beach Parking Included in Reservation
RENT A TOY: Boats & Fun on NCI rents a large variety of toys! Boat rentals for exploring neighboring islands, kayak rentals for paddling among the dolphins, a paddle board to gain a completely different vantage point, or jet ski rentals to really get your zoom on. They also rent fishing equipment for fishing from the beach which is an island favorite.
CHARTER EXCURSIONS - There's no shortage or captains who offer excursions! Deep Sea fishing, anyone?
DIGITAL GUIDEBOOK: Our digital guidebook (link provided upon completing your reservation) will point you in the right direction for all of these activities and MORE.
--THE DETAILS--
ENTERTAINMENT & TECHNOLOGY:
-Starlink high speed internet
-50" smart tv in living room w/ DVD player
-Over 100 DVDs
-Small TVs in each of the adult bedrooms w/ built-in DVD players
-Large indoor/outdoor portable speaker Bluetooth compatible
EXTRA CONVENIENCES:
*Two front load washing machines & two front load dryers - convenient for light packing.
*All bed linens, bath towels, pool towels, kitchen towels and washcloths provided. Extra pillows & blankets.
*Shampoo & Conditioner, liquid hand soap, laundry pods, dishwasher pods, liquid dish soap provided.
*Two pack & plays, indoor baby gate, solid-wood high chair for our youngest vacationers.
*Basic kitchen spices, plastic wrap & aluminum foil
*Two hairdryers & one curling iron
FUN & SPORTS EQUIPMENT:
-Four fat tire bikes and helmets - bikes are maintained frequently but we cannot guarantee their condition - bikes are provided in AS IS condition
-Large cooler for beach trips or keeping drinks cold near the pool
-Corn Hole (beanbag toss) game
-Variety of children's sand and pool toys
-Assorted family friendly games & puzzles
COOKING & DINING:
-Fully Stocked Kitchen: Pots & Pans, Dinnerware, Large Variety of Glassware, Assorted Bakeware
-Gourmet Coffee Station: Coffee Grinder, Coffee Maker, Espresso Machine
-2 Ovens
-Small Appliances: Crock Pot, Toaster, Electric Griddle, Electric Juicer, Blender
-Large Weber Propane Grill
-KettlePizza Charcoal Pizza Grill
RESERVING PEACE OF PARADISE:
*We accept instant booking but please reach out prior to booking if you have any questions; Molly, the host, is happy to help.
*After booking, you will receive a digital guidebook. This handy tool works like an App on your phone and will walk you through all the steps required for planning a vacation on NCI such as...scheduling a taxi from the airport, which method you'll choose for acquiring your groceries, selecting a ferry option, and details on connecting with our property management team.
*Please sign the rental contract within 48 hours of booking. Your reservation is not confirmed until this has been properly filled out and returned.
*Get excited! A vacation of a lifetime is waiting for you! We look forward to having you as guests!
--POLICIES--
-Rental Agreement must be signed and returned w/in 48 hrs of making reservation
-No events or parties
-No smoking or drug use
-No pets
-Must be 24 or older to book
-NO ONE WITHOUT A VALID DRIVERS LICENSE MAY DRIVE A GOLF CART
-No driving golf carts on the beach or in the nature preserve
-Bikes are provided in AS IS
Amenities
Pool
Air conditioner
Kitchen or Kitchenette
Internet / Wifi
Parking
Laundry
Dishwasher
TV
Garden
Family friendly
Map of North Captiva Island, FL
Reviews
4.9
Outstanding(51 Reviews)4.9
We enjoyed the layed back relaxing atmosphere. Golf cart rides and pool were phenomenal. Very nice property.
4.9
Such a wonderful oasis for the week!
As first time visitors to North Captiva Island we appreciated all the communication and helpful tips prior to our arrival. That communication continued throughout our stay. The house is well appointed with everything you need. The pool was splendid and having two golf carts that were brand new was a real treat.
Great place and excellent customer service
4.9
We loved the island and the home. Top notch service and lovely accommodations - We can’t wait to be back!!
4.9
Loved the home and location. Would love to return.
4.9
property was absolutely beautiful. Very relaxing vacation!!
A couple hiccups, but they were fixed, just annoying having repairmen in and out while vacationing.. but things happen!
4.9
We had great communication with the owner throughout our stay, and property managers for most of our stay. The house was beautiful with easy access to the beach! Fully equipped for our needs and lots to do right at the house.
The only minor thing is that the bunk room was fairly tight, and definitely would have been chaotic had we needed more than one or two of the beds.
4.9
Enjoyed a little adventure to North Captiva from cold Minnesota! Had a great time walking the shell covered beaches and catching up with family in a quiet, relaxing place. Great home to stay at! Communication and planning was amazing, highly recommend.
4.9
Multi generational family vacation that didn’t disappoint! North Captiva is a fantastic place and Peace of Paradise was a lovely home away from home. The pool and outdoor space was the highlight of the home. Kitchen is stocked for all of our cooking needs. Highly recommend
4.9
The house was super cute and clean, the outside bar with swings was super fun and having a shower outside was convenient. The pool was nice with the waterfall very calming. The pool lights at night did not work. It was nice having 2 golf carts.
4.9
The house was in great, clean shape and was as described. Communication with the owner and Tortuga was fantastic. The downstairs patio was perfect for games and dinner straight off the grill. We would stay here again!
4.9
This was our second trip to the island and it lived up to everything we remembered! Peace of Paradise is a wonderful place. The downstairs bar and hammock area, along with the pool are AMAZING. Whenever we were not at the beach this is where we were. The house was clean and decorated so cute. The beach is only a short trip away, and "town" (aka the restaurant/bar) was close too! Clean up is still on-going on the island, but it's still the most relaxing place!
4.9
We loved our Captiva Island vacation! The design of the round home and all its windows for natural light was so lovely. The home was clean and had such beautiful style and decor. The kitchen and grill amenities were fabulous. We very much enjoyed the outdoor features and all the seating areas. The pool is situated nicely for sun and shade, and we really loved the waterfall feature for a peaceful sound while enjoying the patio area. The beach was just a five minute walk along a quiet and pleasant road. The whole island is quiet and peaceful. We absolutely loved how secluded and peaceful it was…no cars, no big buildings, the beaches were wide and open and not crowded. And our kids had a blast at the beach every morning, playing in the sand and water as it came in and the many shells there were to find (I loved this too!). We then spent a couple hours at the pool in the high sun if the afternoon, and then went back to the beach for the late afternoon and sunset. It was fabulous. A truly magical place. And worth some of the logistical effort (shuttle, grocery planning, and ferry) to get there. Molly, the owner, was very thorough with trip planning information and promptly in touch, as was the concierge service they have hired to take care of anything for you during your stay. We would love to stay here again!
4.9
Our family had an amazing time at Peace of Paradise. House was perfect for my husband and I and our 4 boys.
All the amenities that came with the house were well used and great.
We appreciated the communication with the owners as well as the entire Tortuga team!
Great home, great location.
4.9
Beautiful Place
This place met all our expectations. We have such a wonderful vacation here.
4.9
A Perfect Trip!
This home was more than we could ask for! It was clean, well-stocked and had a beautiful outdoor living area. The pool was perfect after long days at the beach. We will definitely be back!
4.9
Great trip
Photos of property are accurate. The kitchen is well stocked and had everything needed to make big family dinners. The outside area and pool were perfect and there was great access to the beach.
4.9
Paradise for sure!
Our stay at Peace of Paradise was exactly that - Paradise! The house was clean and well equipped with everything we needed. There were plenty of towels for swimming and showering. Our kids loved the triple bunk room. Plenty of space for our family of 8 to spread out in. The pool area had a very tropical feel with beautiful landscaping. The area is surrounded by trees, making for the perfect amount of privacy for our family. (Highly recommend bug spray!!) The waterfall rock feature into the pool made for a relaxing feel. The 2 golf carts were amazing, and probably our favorite part of our stay. We enjoyed many rides around the island just exploring all the beauty North Captiva has to offer. We did have 2 minor issues with one of our golf carts, but the owner Molly promptly had it serviced, and we were back on the road within hours. (Shout out to Derrick at Pieces of Eight Golf Cart Repair for taking care of us so quickly and professionally). Our experience with Tortuga Properties was good. They assisted us throughout the entire process and efficiently supplied us with anything we needed. We would absolutely recommend Peace of Paradise to anyone looking for a fun, relaxing family vacation on the island. We hope to come back very soon and enjoy it all over again! Thanks again Molly for renting your beautiful home to us. We made memories that will last a lifetime! - Brian & Julie Martin
4.9
Great house with lots of amenities. The reverse osmosis drinking water was great. Kitchen, patio, pool were all well furnished and easy and fun to use. It's a beautiful house. Only two drawbacks we found: beach is probably a 10 minute walk but if you're bringing cooler/umbrellas/etc, you need a golf cart... for the price we thought we'd be closer to the beach. Also the walls are thin :)
4.9
Great house
Great house with lots of amenities. The reverse osmosis drinking water was great. Kitchen, patio, pool were all well furnished and easy and fun to use. It's a beautiful house. Only two drawbacks we found: beach is probably a 10 minute walk but if you're bringing cooler/umbrellas/etc, you need a golf cart... for the price we thought we'd be closer to the beach. Also the walls are thin :)
4.9
Peace of Paradise is just that. It is a peaceful, idyllic getaway that allows you rest and relaxation or fun and adventure if you want it. We had a family of 8 (5 adults and 3 kids aged 6 to 11) and it was the perfect size with 4 bedrooms. The house was well equipped and had plenty of spreading out space. The pool was beautiful and always warm. The views from the deck were wonderful and we still miss sitting there every monring to drink our coffee. We saw a lot of North Captiva, including the planes landing at the airstrip and lots of sunsets at the beach. We also took a trip to Cabbage Key, where we saw the Manatees very close up!! Lovely home and island.
4.9
Family Celebration of Nana and Papa's 50th Anniversary
Peace of Paradise is just that. It is a peaceful, idyllic getaway that allows you rest and relaxation or fun and adventure if you want it. We had a family of 8 (5 adults and 3 kids aged 6 to 11) and it was the perfect size with 4 bedrooms. The house was well equipped and had plenty of spreading out space. The pool was beautiful and always warm. The views from the deck were wonderful and we still miss sitting there every monring to drink our coffee. We saw a lot of North Captiva, including the planes landing at the airstrip and lots of sunsets at the beach. We also took a trip to Cabbage Key, where we saw the Manatees very close up!! Lovely home and island.
4.9
North Captiva is a special place, made all the more enjoyable by having such a lovely home to stay in and attentive property managers to assist you. Tortuga staff were waiting for us at the dock with a trailer for our luggage and groceries, and our two golf carts. We followed Duncan to the house and he pointed out a few areas of interest along the way. We needed nothing during our stay, but I am confident that Tortuga would have handled any issues with ease. They also arrived promptly for our departure. Island Girl Charters is a seamless operation as well.
Don't fret about the groceries - you can easily bring whatever you need, and there are options to have more delivered if necessary. We enjoyed a casual dinner at Mainstay and another meal at The Boathouse (reservations needed there.)
We would definitely stay at Peace of Paradise again. I am kind of...um...picky...about vacation rentals and will look at pretty much every house and every review, so you can probably trust my judgement on this. I will add a few details though, in case anyone wants to obsess over them. :)
Location was perfect. A very quick golf cart (or bike ride) to the beach or the nature preserve. The carts were well maintained.
There is no club membership, but we didn't miss it at all, especially with having such a nice pool at the house.
There are so many comfortable places to relax. Internet was not great, but all the more reason to unplug and enjoy. We appreciated all the things that you don't want to have to think about bringing: dish pods, laundry pods, soap, shampoo, conditioner. Beds are comfortable, towels are plentiful, appliances are all good. What else can I say? Molly obviously cares about her guests.
Did I mention the dolphins, manatees and crazy amount of seashells? Oh, and don't miss sunset on the beach - it's a bit of a thing - everyone goes...
4.9
Paradise Indeed!
North Captiva is a special place, made all the more enjoyable by having such a lovely home to stay in and attentive property managers to assist you. Tortuga staff were waiting for us at the dock with a trailer for our luggage and groceries, and our two golf carts. We followed Duncan to the house and he pointed out a few areas of interest along the way. We needed nothing during our stay, but I am confident that Tortuga would have handled any issues with ease. They also arrived promptly for our departure. Island Girl Charters is a seamless operation as well.
Don't fret about the groceries - you can easily bring whatever you need, and there are options to have more delivered if necessary. We enjoyed a casual dinner at Mainstay and another meal at The Boathouse (reservations needed there.)
We would definitely stay at Peace of Paradise again. I am kind of...um...picky...about vacation rentals and will look at pretty much every house and every review, so you can probably trust my judgement on this. I will add a few details though, in case anyone wants to obsess over them. :)
Location was perfect. A very quick golf cart (or bike ride) to the beach or the nature preserve. The carts were well maintained.
There is no club membership, but we didn't miss it at all, especially with having such a nice pool at the house.
There are so many comfortable places to relax. Internet was not great, but all the more reason to unplug and enjoy. We appreciated all the things that you don't want to have to think about bringing: dish pods, laundry pods, soap, shampoo, conditioner. Beds are comfortable, towels are plentiful, appliances are all good. What else can I say? Molly obviously cares about her guests.
Did I mention the dolphins, manatees and crazy amount of seashells? Oh, and don't miss sunset on the beach - it's a bit of a thing - everyone goes...
4.9
Wonderful Vacation
We had an amazing time in this beautiful home! It had everything we needed! Location is great!
4.9
This is a great property with a wonderful outdoor space!! Only thing missing is a minifridge in the Tiki bar!! Adults and kids both had a wonderful relaxing time at Peace of Paradise
4.9
This beautiful home had everything we could possibly need! Enjoyed the pool, the good carts and the location! Very secluded little island for a fun getaway. This home has been very well maintained and loved
4.9
Relaxing
This is a great property with a wonderful outdoor space!! Only thing missing is a minifridge in the Tiki bar!! Adults and kids both had a wonderful relaxing time at Peace of Paradise
4.9
Lovely home
This beautiful home had everything we could possibly need! Enjoyed the pool, the good carts and the location! Very secluded little island for a fun getaway. This home has been very well maintained and loved
4.9
Went to the island with my family and extended family and we had a wonderful time! What a unique trip for us first-timers - no cars, only golf carts was quite an experience! The Weather was near perfect (in March) in the 70's, we did some lounging on the beach and a lot of swimming in the pool/ocean and went shelling everyday.
Peace of Paradise was lovely! Molly has the property maintained well :-) It felt a little more secluded than some of the other houses on the island which was great for gathering at the pool. We could be found at the downstairs, outside bar/BBQ area most of the time when we weren't at the beach - great use of space! So inviting, the lighting was perfect too. The private outdoor heated pool was a great size for our group of 7 as well.
The house itself is round which made for interesting use of space in the bedrooms but not too hard to work around. All the helpful information about getting to the island and ordering groceries was VERY helpful too. We made great use of the reverse-osmosis water filter system in the house too which helps to combat the sulfur taste of the tap water.
Tortuga management: we experienced a few slight "glitches" with communication but overall was a good company to work with. Duncan took us on a island tour the first night and helped get us acclimated to North Captiva.
We would gladly come back to stay at Peace of Paradise again unless we bring more than 10 people :-)
4.9
Wonderful Island Getaway!
Went to the island with my family and extended family and we had a wonderful time! What a unique trip for us first-timers - no cars, only golf carts was quite an experience! The Weather was near perfect (in March) in the 70's, we did some lounging on the beach and a lot of swimming in the pool/ocean and went shelling everyday.
Peace of Paradise was lovely! Molly has the property maintained well :-) It felt a little more secluded than some of the other houses on the island which was great for gathering at the pool. We could be found at the downstairs, outside bar/BBQ area most of the time when we weren't at the beach - great use of space! So inviting, the lighting was perfect too. The private outdoor heated pool was a great size for our group of 7 as well.
The house itself is round which made for interesting use of space in the bedrooms but not too hard to work around. All the helpful information about getting to the island and ordering groceries was VERY helpful too. We made great use of the reverse-osmosis water filter system in the house too which helps to combat the sulfur taste of the tap water.
Tortuga management: we experienced a few slight "glitches" with communication but overall was a good company to work with. Duncan took us on a island tour the first night and helped get us acclimated to North Captiva.
We would gladly come back to stay at Peace of Paradise again unless we bring more than 10 people :-)
4.9
Great time! Weather was terrific. Everyone couldn't have been nicer. Kids enjoyed the pool and beach
Our stay was great. Staff was on top of any issue or concerns as well as making sure we had great seafood while we were there. The island is beautiful.
4.9
Lives up to its name
This rental is truly special: clean, beautiful and well-cared for. Duncan, Valerie and the team provided excellent support before, during and at the end of our trip. Peace of Paradise certainly lives up to its name. We will definitely be back!
4.9
First time on the island. The mgt and the process information were very helpful. I would do it again!
4.9
Great place to stay on N Captiva
First time on the island. The mgt and the process information were very helpful. I would do it again!
4.9
Great house and property managers!
4.9
Peace of Paradise
Great house and property managers!
4.9
Absolute GEM of a vacation rental!
What a beautiful home!! We felt so comfortable there.
This house is so kid friendly it was hard to lure them off the property! I’m not even kidding!! From the sandbox to the hammocks, pool with the toys and outdoor living areas there wasn’t really a reason to leave…except the beach, of course!! We maxed out at 10 people (4 adults/6 kids (9months-11yrs) for half the time but it never once felt crowded. There were plenty of beds, dishes, towels and space!
When we first booked it I was a little nervous about the white couch and kids but Laurie with Tortuga assured me this was a kid loving home and to just enjoy. She was right! The kids loved it and everything looked as it did when we arrived. This place made our yearly relaxing vacation even more so!! We will be back!
4.9
Wonderful accommodations, location was perfect, close to where we needed to go, beach, etc. perfect size for our family. Kids loved the pool area. Outdoor shower was a must.
4.9
Amazing!
Great time with all accommodations to rest and relax!
4.9
Christmas21
As advertised. Beautifully appointed. Easily accommodated 11, considering the bunks in the 4th bedroom. Super pool, golf carts, and bikes. Only drawback was the lack of closet space. Would rent again in the future.
FAQs
How much does this house cost compared to others in North Captiva Island?
The average price for a rental in North Captiva Island is $1,151 per night. This rental is $822 above the average.
Is parking included with this house?
Yes, parking is listed as an amenity at Peace of Paradise: Pvt., swing bar, pool, beach!. For more information, we encourage you to contact the property about where to park.
Is there a pool at this house?
Yes, a swimming pool is available for use at Peace of Paradise: Pvt., swing bar, pool, beach!. Enjoy the water!
Is Peace of Paradise: Pvt., swing bar, pool, beach! pet friendly?
Unfortunately, this house is not pet-friendly. Try searching again and filter for "Pets Allowed"
What amenities are available at Peace of Paradise: Pvt., swing bar, pool, beach!?
We found 10 amenities for this rental. This includes pool, air conditioner, kitchen or kitchenette, internet / wifi, and parking.
Explore similar vacation rentals in North Captiva Island
Explore all rentals in North Captiva IslandStart earning One Key rewards
BEACHFRONT, HEATED POOL, KAYAKS/SUP, LANAI W/ GULF VIEWS, 85' DOCK, 2 GOLF CARTS
House
in Captiva12 guests · 5 bedrooms · 6 baths
Garden · Pool · Kitchen or Kitchenette
The best choice in North Captiva Island for House, for $2,289 per night for your (business stay, family stay, couples stay, getaway vacation, etc.)
$$$$
1 Min to Beach, New Luxury pool home, Gulf sunrise and sunsets, club option
House
in Captiva18 guests · 7 bedrooms · 6 baths
Garden · Pool · Kitchen or Kitchenette
Looking to create some memories in North Captiva Island? Look no further than our House, 1 Min to Beach, New Luxury pool home, Gulf sunrise and sunsets, club option . Enjoy top-rated amenities including Air conditioner, Dishwasher and Internet / Wifi, and more.
$$$$
Bluefin Beach House, Luxury Home with Pool & Spa on North Captiva, 2 Golf Carts
House
in North Captiva12 guests · 4 bedrooms · 5 baths
Pool · Kitchen or Kitchenette · Air conditioner
Indulge in a peaceful retreat at Bluefin Beach House, Luxury Home with Pool & Spa on North Captiva, 2 Golf Carts, our elegant House in North Captiva Island. Enjoy amenities including Air conditioner, Dishwasher and Internet / Wifi, and more.
$$$$
Captivation - Sunrise-to-sunset views–walk to beach– 2 golf carts, bikes, pool
House
in Captiva14 guests · 4 bedrooms · 5 baths
Pool · Kitchen or Kitchenette · Air conditioner
Looking for a memorable stay in North Captiva Island? Our House might just be what you're looking for. Enjoy amenities including Air conditioner, Dishwasher and Internet / Wifi, and more during your stay.
$$$$
Start earning One Key rewards
Serendipity is BACK - Complete remodel April 2024 - Pool; 2 Golf Carts
House
in Captiva10 guests · 4 bedrooms · 4 baths
Pool · Kitchen or Kitchenette · Air conditioner
Discover the beauty of North Captiva Island with a stay at Serendipity is BACK - Complete remodel April 2024 - Pool; 2 Golf Carts, a top rated House with amenities such as Air conditioner, Dishwasher and Internet / Wifi, and more.
$$$$
Beachfront
Exclusive BEACHFRONT home in North Captiva, Florida.
House
in Captiva10 guests · 4 bedrooms · 5 baths
Kitchen or Kitchenette · Air conditioner · Internet / Wifi
Are you ready to indulge in a relaxing getaway? Our House in North Captiva Island has everything you need for a rejuvenating stay. Treat yourself to Exclusive BEACHFRONT home in North Captiva, Florida. 's exceptional amenities, such as Air conditioner, Dishwasher and Internet / Wifi.
$$$$
Special summer pricing! Luxury Beach House, Private Pool, just steps to beach
House
in Captiva12 guests · 4 bedrooms · 3 baths
Garden · Pool · Kitchen or Kitchenette
Most favorited
This inviting House in North Captiva Island can fit your needs for many types of vacations, at $1,885 per night.
$$$$
At the Beach: Heated Pool, Golf Cart, Club Access, Winter Dates Avail! Book Now
House
in Captiva10 guests · 5 bedrooms · 5 baths
Pool · Kitchen or Kitchenette · Air conditioner
This House for $1,979 in North Captiva Island, is perfect for your next (business stay, family stay, couples stay, getaway vacation, etc.)
$$$$
BLUE MANGO -- Tropical Seclusion Steps from the Beach
House
in Captiva10 guests · 5 bedrooms · 4 baths
Garden · Pool · Pets allowed
This House for $1,752 in North Captiva Island, is perfect for your next (business stay, family stay, couples stay, getaway vacation, etc.)
$$$$
Start earning One Key rewards
438 - Reel Laxing North Captiva
House
in Captiva10 guests · 4 bedrooms · 3 baths
Garden · Pool · Kitchen or Kitchenette
Soak up the beauty of North Captiva Island in our House, 438 - Reel Laxing North Captiva. With a range of amenities such as Air conditioner, Dishwasher and Internet / Wifi, you'll feel right at home.
$$$$
Tropical Family Oasis: Pool, Spa, Golf Cart
House
in Upper Captiva10 guests · 4 bedrooms · 3 baths
Garden · Pool · Kitchen or Kitchenette
Enjoy the best of North Captiva Island in our House, Tropical Family Oasis: Pool, Spa, Golf Cart. A stunning property with amenities including Air conditioner, Dishwasher and Internet / Wifi, and more.
$$$$
Key Lime Time: Private Pool and Panoramic Gulf Views
House
in North Captiva12 guests · 5 bedrooms · 5 baths
Garden · Pool · Kitchen or Kitchenette
Experience the best of North Captiva Island with this House available for $2,201. This property is equipped with amenities including Air conditioner, Dishwasher and Internet / Wifi, and more.
$$$$
Flamingo Beach: Beach Front, Swim Spa and Endless Relaxation
House
in North Captiva12 guests · 6 bedrooms · 3 baths
Garden · Pool · Kitchen or Kitchenette
Experience the best of North Captiva Island with this House available for $1,860. This property is equipped with amenities including Air conditioner, Dishwasher and Internet / Wifi, and more.
$$$$
Start earning One Key rewards
The MAINE DECK - BRAND NEW DESIGNER HOME WITH PRIVATE POOL AND 2 GOLF CARTS
House
in Captiva12 guests · 4 bedrooms · 4 baths
Pool · Kitchen or Kitchenette · Air conditioner
Soak up the beauty of North Captiva Island in our House, The MAINE DECK - BRAND NEW DESIGNER HOME WITH PRIVATE POOL AND 2 GOLF CARTS. With a range of amenities such as Air conditioner, Dishwasher and Internet / Wifi, you'll feel right at home.
$$$$
Luxury beach home! Completely remodeled! Open Nov 1! Huge 5Bd 5 bth! Sleeps 16!
House
in Captiva13 guests · 5 bedrooms · 5 baths
Pool · Kitchen or Kitchenette · Air conditioner
Looking for a business stay, family stay, couples stay, getaway vacation, or traveling to North Captiva Island, at $1,696 per night for your next great vacation.
$$$$
Gulf of Mexico Beach House, Private Pool, 360 Island Views, Airstrip Membership
House
in North Captiva14 guests · 6 bedrooms · 2 baths
Pool · Kitchen or Kitchenette · Air conditioner
Looking to create some memories in North Captiva Island? Look no further than our House, Gulf of Mexico Beach House, Private Pool, 360 Island Views, Airstrip Membership. Enjoy top-rated amenities including Air conditioner, Dishwasher and Internet / Wifi, and more.
$$$$
Oasis: Pool, Hot Tub, Golf Cart & Stunning Views
House
in Captiva10 guests · 3 bedrooms · 4 baths
Garden · Pool · Kitchen or Kitchenette
Enjoy the best of North Captiva Island in our House, Oasis: Pool, Hot Tub, Golf Cart & Stunning Views. A stunning property with amenities including Air conditioner, Dishwasher and Internet / Wifi, and more.
$$$$
Start earning One Key rewards
Private Island Luxury w/ new pool! steps to beach
House
in Captiva14 guests · 5 bedrooms · 6 baths
Pool · Kitchen or Kitchenette · Air conditioner
The best choice in North Captiva Island for House, for $1,858 per night for your (business stay, family stay, couples stay, getaway vacation, etc.)
$$$$
Start earning One Key rewards
Sail Away on North Captiva Island- Off Grid and Out of this World
House
in Captiva10 guests · 4 bedrooms · 5 baths
Air conditioner · Internet / Wifi · Laundry
The best choice in North Captiva Island for House, for $2,103 per night for your (business stay, family stay, couples stay, getaway vacation, etc.)
$$$$
Start earning One Key rewards
Beachfront 3-Bedroom Oasis on North Captiva Island
House
in Captiva10 guests · 3 bedrooms · 4 baths
Pool · Pets allowed · Kitchen or Kitchenette
Discover the beauty of North Captiva Island with a stay at Beachfront 3-Bedroom Oasis on North Captiva Island, a top rated House with amenities such as Air conditioner, Dishwasher and Internet / Wifi, and more.
$$$$
North Captiva Island travel inspiration
Read our blogGuides
Top Things to Do in Miami: From Beaches to Culture
Guides
The Best Things to Do in Orlando: Attractions, Food, and Family Fun
Guides
Things to Do in Galveston, Texas
Guides
Top Things to Do in Myrtle Beach
Guides
Ski Trip Packing List: What to Bring Skiing or Snowboarding
Trends
VacationRenter Holiday Travel Trends 2023
Featured Rentals
Architectural Vacation Rentals: Experience the Beauty of Unique Properties
Featured Rentals
Sustainable and Eco-Friendly Vacation Rentals Around the World