NEWLY RENOVATED WITH POOL, HOT TUB, AND FIREPLACE!

9.6 / 10.0

Outstanding(37 Ratings)

House in Shelter Island, NY

6 guests · 3 bedrooms · 3 baths

Reasons to book

Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating

High-end valuePrice for this property is higher than average in the area

Includes essentialsGarden, Pool, Kitchen or Kitchenette and more

About this house rental

Sleeps 4 adults (max) or total of 6 with kids.
Perfect family getaway.
Shelter Island Rental License #: 2023-V-0018

Weekly and Monthly Discounts for Winter Rentals!

Stay at our newly renovated, light filled home! In the warmer months lounge by the heated pool in the private tree-filled yard, relax in the hot tub that overflows into the pool, nap in the shade of the pool house, then rinse off in the outdoor shower. Read a book in the hammock or on the porch rocking chairs. BBQ on the big back deck and hang out by the outdoor fire pit to roast marshmallows in the evening. **Pool & hot tub CLOSED NOVEMBER - MAY.
In the colder months, stay in the mid-century modern style living room, play board games and watch a movie on Netflix with a roaring fire in the stone fireplace or walk to the best sledding on the island. Cook in our well appointed kitchen and eat while watching the sunshine and stars through the dining room skylight. You will never have to leave the house for an incredibly relaxing vacation! Perfect for a family get away any time of year (we also have toys, pool toys, and a Wii with lots of games) or for a place just to get away from it all.

And when you want to get out to explore Shelter Island - we are less than 1 mile from beautiful Sunset Beach! Beach by day, have a cocktail at the bar to watch the sunset in the evening! Walking distance to the public golf course. Or take the Ferry to Greenport or Sag Harbor for an easy trip! Ride the bikes to town for lunch. From the house it's an easy walk to the ice cream shop and Ice Pond Park.

The house is situated on a very quiet, dead-end street with a beautiful, tree filled, and large yard. We have privacy for relaxing, but are close enough to Shelter Island Heights, the North Ferry to Greenport, the South Ferry to the Hamptons, and other conveniences to make this the perfect vacation location.

We'll provide you with maps and tips for exploring the island's beaches and restaurants. Before purchasing this house we rented on Shelter Island for many years, so our goal is to make your stay as perfect as we can.

IMPORTANT:
- PLEASE DO NOT PUT IN A BOOKING REQUEST UNTIL WE HAVE HAD AN EMAL EXCHANGE ON VRBO.
-**Must be 30 years or older to rent the house. Families encouraged. 4 adults maximum. Hot Tub and Pool are Closed November - Mid May.

House Details:

Central Air and Ceiling Fans in each room.
Bedroom 1 - 1 Queen Bed (sleeps 2); private back deck; full bathroom with shower
Bedroom 2 - 1 full bed (sleeps 2)
Bedroom 2 - 1 twin bunk bed, 1 twin bed, 1 expandable twin bed (from Bo Concept) (sleeps 3 children)
Bathroom 2 - clean and renovated with bathtub and shower
Pool - Heated and beautiful. Open Mid May - October **Note: Swimming only. There is no diving. The pool is not deep enough.**
Hot Tub - Open Mid May - October
Pool House with Outdoor Shower - Open May - October
Washer/Dryer
Kitchen with Stainless Steel appliances
WiFi, basic cable and Apple TV with Netflix

The premises are equipped with exterior security cameras. Cameras are not monitored for guest safety in any way and should not be relied on by guests for personal security or security of their belongings. Cameras may be used to enforce and verify compliance with rental policies.

Amenities

Pool

Air conditioner

Kitchen or Kitchenette

Internet / Wifi

Fireplace

Parking

Laundry

Balcony or Patio

Dishwasher

Hot tub or spa

Garden

Family friendly

Map of Shelter Island, NY

Nearby attractions

Montauk Point State Park

39.7 mi

Mystic Aquarium

46.9 mi

Gillette Castle State Park

38.9 mi

Montauk Lighthouse Museum

41.5 mi

$$$$

NEWLY RENOVATED WITH POOL, HOT TUB, AND FIREPLACE!

$$$$

9.6 / 10.0

Outstanding(37 Ratings)

House in Shelter Island, NY

6 guests · 3 bedrooms · 3 baths

Reasons to book

Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating

High-end valuePrice for this property is higher than average in the area

Includes essentialsGarden, Pool, Kitchen or Kitchenette and more

About this house rental

Amenities

Pool

Air conditioner

Kitchen or Kitchenette

Internet / Wifi

Fireplace

Parking

Laundry

Balcony or Patio

Dishwasher

Hot tub or spa

Garden

Family friendly

Map of Shelter Island, NY

Nearby attractions

Montauk Point State Park

39.7 mi

Mystic Aquarium

46.9 mi

Gillette Castle State Park

38.9 mi

Montauk Lighthouse Museum

41.5 mi

Ratings and reviews

9.6 / 10.0

Outstanding(37 Ratings)

10.0 / 10.0

Jul 2024

We have been coming to Jennifer’s house for seven years now, and it’s our favorite place. We spend hours at the pool and hot tub, and the kids love the rope swing in the front yard. Jennifer is one of the best hosts - she responds quickly and helps make our stay as comfortable as possible. We love her place!

10.0 / 10.0

Jun 2024

This was our 2nd Summer here and it was even better than we remembered. Home is comfortable, clean and well equipped. Pool, hot tub & yard are fabulous and spacious. Secluded, but close enough to walk to Sunset Beach, public golf course, ice cream shop and several eateries in the Heights area (in day time on 'country roads') . Great for couples as well as families with children as back & front yards are expansive. Ferries make both North & South Forks easy access, but there is plenty to do on Island. Host Jennifer is gracious and very responsive to even the smallest inquiries. Highly recommend this property.

10.0 / 10.0

Nov 2023

Jennifer’s place was cozy and well appointed. She was easy to reach prior to check in and booking. Highly recommend.

10.0 / 10.0

Jul 2023

A really special property and a special mention to Jennifer who went out of their way to remove a hornet nest that had appeared in the garden within 12 hours of bringing it to their attention. We loved every minute here and will be back for sure

10.0 / 10.0

Jul 2023

Everything about our stay is perfect. The owner is very friendly and helpful. We are grateful that she shared with us her beautiful house!

8.0 / 10.0

Jun 2023

This was so relaxing and a much needed time alone. Beautiful place.

10.0 / 10.0

Jun 2023

What a lovely retreat! Beautiful property and surprise upgrades throughout the home; a delight as soon as you open the front door. Gorgeous and spacious backyard, pool, hot tub and pool house. Even better than the photos. The kitchen upgrades were chef quality and had every imaginable appliance including a high end juicer and coffee maker. Tastefully decorated but not overdone; comfortable beds throughout, along with a plethora of video games, children's toys and an interesting book collection in the MBR. Easy walk to 'Sunset Beach', several restaurants, bagel shop and ice cream parlor but don't miss an opportunity to explore the rest of the Island, beaches and nature trails. Host Jennifer was extremely available to answer any questions and an ample 'house book' provided many suggestions for activities, dining and adventures. We are already looking at next year's calendar to rent again!

10.0 / 10.0

Apr 2023

We love visiting Jennifer’s house and have been coming for years. It is always clean, peaceful, and well-equipped with anything we would need. Jennifer is the best host and communicates thoroughly. It’s a terrific experience all around!

10.0 / 10.0

Jan 2023

The host, Jennifer, is absolutely amazing. She is very responsive and the home is very clean, well located and we made ourselves at home immediately. We would definitely go back to this home again.

10.0 / 10.0

Oct 2022

Our stay in JENNIFER’s house was perfect. The description of the house is very accurate and I believe that it is even nicer. The garden is beautiful and it gives the house a very special atmosphere. Jennifer was always prompt to answer any doubts we had. Thank you. I can imagine enjoying the house in a warmer time of the year: beach, bbq and swimming pool. I might have to try this!

8.0 / 10.0

Sep 2022

I would recommend renting this property

10.0 / 10.0

Sep 2022

A modern, clean, well-appointed house with everything you'd need for a fantastic and zen-filled vacation. The tranquility of gazing skyward at the beautiful landscape from the hot tub/pool might just be the meaning of life. Swimming, fireplace, grill, bikes, beach stuff – basically all you need in great condition to enjoy the natural splendor of Shelter Island.

10.0 / 10.0

Sep 2022

This was our second stay in this home and it did not disappoint. Clean, well appointed home and on a lovely street on Shelter Island. Jennifer is a great host and her home is fantastic. Looking forward to returning!

10.0 / 10.0

Aug 2022

Very comfortable home, convenient to most of what you need while on the island. Rear deck/yard/pool provide a great option for those times when you want to stay at home. The home is well prepared to be your ‘home away from home’.

10.0 / 10.0

May 2022

Jennifer’s place is a dream! It was the perfect rental for my husband and I and our two year old. Very child friendly and safe, which was appreciated. The house is lovely and decorated in a way that is calming but not overwhelming with things a toddler could break. Great amenities. Hopefully we can come back some time when the weather is nice and we can use the pool!

5.0 / 10.0

Nov 2021

"Hi Jennifer, I just wanted to let you know how much our family’s time at your home on Shelter Island meant to us. Your care and pride in your family’s respite shines through as soon as you step through the door. Although we always try to leave a home as clean and tidy as when we arrive, we felt so endeared to your hospitality we talked as a family how to keep things nice, avoid cup rings on wooden pieces, watch for any issues, add to your shell collection on the front porch railing, leave a few things for the freezer and pantry! Thank you for having thought of all of the little things which a family might need in the kitchen, we loved cooking and eating together in your well stocked (essentials and spices and gadgets and more!) It was a restful and healing stay for us. We all enjoyed the pool and, especially I, the hot tub, so relaxing and such a treat to be outdoors a little longer this season. Thank you for sharing your quiet little getaway with our family! Best wishes, Jennifer October 2021

5.0 / 10.0

Sep 2021

Jennifer's house is lovely in every way, elegantly simple, thoughtfully designed and in excellent working order. It was a delight to be there for ten days. I highly recommend this property.

5.0 / 10.0

Aug 2021

Hi we traveled as a family of four adults (including grandparents) and our two children ages 6 and 2.5yrs old) in the month of July 2021. We had a wonderful time and would not hesitate to recommend this property to others. Our kids had the best time at the pool and hot tub area and in the garden. The house was very clean, had everything you needed and was very cozy and comfortable as well. Its a great option for a quiet family vacation and traveling with small children. We may be biased because Shelter Island holds a special place in our hearts but the house and surrounding grounds were beautiful and held their own. We are really thankful for being able to stay there and would love to return!

5.0 / 10.0

Jun 2021

Beautiful home. Grounds and property were beautiful. Home had everything you needed. Had some issues and the owner response was immediate and checked back to make sure things were working correctly.

5.0 / 10.0

Jun 2021

This property is so beautiful and peaceful. The pool and hot tub are wonderful. The house is very nicely decorated with lots of cute touches. We had awful weather, but made the most of it. The home has all you need.

5.0 / 10.0

Oct 2020

We had a great time at this house. Shelter island is beautiful and the house is located near the end of a quiet street. It has a large private yard and a wonderful pool and spa. You are on a neighborhood street but it feels very private. Jennifer was very nice and helpful with any questions we had. We would go back if the opportunity arrises.

4.0 / 10.0

Oct 2019

We had a great time at the house. The pool and hot tub are great, and they heat up fairly quickly. The bedrooms are nice, as are the bathrooms. The living room is comfortable with lots of games available. We liked the availability of pool floats and bikes. The location is also great. The one downside was the electric stove/oven. Otherwise, we had a wonderful time at the house and would definitely rent it again!

5.0 / 10.0

Aug 2015

The newly renovated house was clean and beautifully decorated with comfortable beds and a fully equipped kitchen. The grounds around the house were equally as beautiful with a large wooded front yard with fire pit and swing, and a large backyard with a gorgeous pool and hot tub. My family included 8 year old twins, a couple of 19 year olds, and 4 adults and there was something for everyone including books and toys for the smaller ones, and a great pool house where the teens could have their privacy. The house is walking distance to the local ice cream store, and very close to the ferry, Sunset Beach (Crescent Beach) and the supermarket. It was a perfect vacation for all. The owner was very helpful and responsive as well. We can't wait to go back!

5.0 / 10.0

Jul 2015

We stayed with another couple and had a 4y, 3y and 1y old with us. The house is newly renovated and everything is in top notch shape. It is child friendly and the pool and jacuzzi are just the right size. We loved the outdoor fire pit and watched fire flies in the evening will grilling marshmallows. The house is very close to Sunset Beach (Crescent Beach) and a short drive to the supermarket. The owner is very responsive and friendly, and answered within the hour. We will be back!

5.0 / 10.0

Jul 2015

We loved our stay at this location, which was perfect for three adults and two older teens. Amazing pool / hot tub area, with tons of pool toys and a wonderful yard for games. The house is bright, cheerful and very clean, and feels modern yet cozy. Everything feels new or very well maintained. The owner is very responsive, and the instructions / recommendations very thorough. Families with small kids in Shelter Island may find the dining options a bit expensive - not a problem if you're willing to cook, which we did most nights in the gas grill. Overall, a great house and highly recommended!

5.0 / 10.0

Jun 2015

The nicest owner and super friendly. Our first time renting a house with my husband and toddler. They made it worth the 3hr drive from NYC. Didn't even know there is a huge strawberry farm in Long Island. We rented the house with 2 couples and they all enjoyed the pool and the whole house. The light up pool and the jacuzzi was our favorite. The grill was nice and big , we cooked 50% of the days. It was solo much fun being there and listening to music outside while playing batminton and volleyball ( we brought our own net). Over all great price and worth every penny.

FAQs

How much does this house cost compared to others in Shelter Island?

The average price for a rental in Shelter Island is $1,130 per night. This rental is $559 less expensive than the average.

Is parking included with this house?

Yes, parking is listed as an amenity at NEWLY RENOVATED WITH POOL, HOT TUB, AND FIREPLACE! . For more information, we encourage you to contact the property about where to park.

Is there a pool at this house?

Yes, a swimming pool is available for use at NEWLY RENOVATED WITH POOL, HOT TUB, AND FIREPLACE! . Enjoy the water!

Is NEWLY RENOVATED WITH POOL, HOT TUB, AND FIREPLACE! pet friendly?

Unfortunately, this house is not pet-friendly. Try searching again and filter for "Pets Allowed"

What amenities are available at NEWLY RENOVATED WITH POOL, HOT TUB, AND FIREPLACE! ?

We found 13 amenities for this rental. This includes pool, air conditioner, kitchen or kitchenette, internet / wifi, and fireplace.

Explore similar vacation rentals in Shelter Island

Explore all rentals in Shelter Island

8.0 / 10.0

Very good(22 Ratings)

House on Chase Creek

Bed and Breakfast

in Shelter Island Heights

1 sofa bed, 1 queen bed

Garden · Air conditioner · Internet / Wifi

Indulge in a peaceful retreat at House on Chase Creek, our elegant Bed and Breakfast in Shelter Island. Enjoy amenities including Air conditioner, Fireplace and Internet / Wifi, and more.

$$$$

NEWLY RENOVATED WITH POOL, HOT TUB, AND FIREPLACE!

House in Shelter Island, NY

Reasons to book

About this house rental

Amenities

Map of Shelter Island, NY

Nearby attractions

NEWLY RENOVATED WITH POOL, HOT TUB, AND FIREPLACE!

House in Shelter Island, NY

Reasons to book

About this house rental

Amenities

Map of Shelter Island, NY

Nearby attractions

Ratings and reviews

FAQs

How much does this house cost compared to others in Shelter Island?

Is parking included with this house?

Is there a pool at this house?

Is NEWLY RENOVATED WITH POOL, HOT TUB, AND FIREPLACE! pet friendly?

What amenities are available at NEWLY RENOVATED WITH POOL, HOT TUB, AND FIREPLACE! ?

Explore similar vacation rentals in Shelter Island

Shelter Island travel inspiration

Related vacation destinations