Luxurious Private Island off Harbour Island - Pool, Beach, Boats, Staff

Start earning One Key rewards

Fridge, microwave, dishwasher, coffee/tea maker

4.9

Outstanding(26 Reviews)

House in North Eleuthera

17 guests · 7 bedrooms · 6 baths

Reasons to book

Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating

Includes essentialsPool, Kitchen or Kitchenette, Air conditioner and more

Book with confidenceWe partner with the top travel sites so you know you're getting a great deal on the perfect rental

About this house rental

Middle Cay is a 2-acre private island located 5 minutes from Harbour Island, Eleuthera. It is a quick 45-minute plane ride from Florida. Airport Code is ELH. American, United, Delta all fly into this airport. Once you land you can be on our private island in less than 15 minutes. From there, our boat captains will take you to Harbour Island anytime you like.

Our island is home to two open-concept villas with picturesque Caribbean views from every room, making Middle Cay ideal for multi-family getaways and group vacations. The island’s breathtaking appeal, vibrant wildlife, heated pool, private beach, and convenient location will leave you with an unforgettable luxury experience.

The estate boasts lush tropical greenery as palm and coconut trees decorate the private beachfront, pool overlooking the ocean, multiple lounge spaces, outdoor dining area, beach volleyball court, and 2 private docks. The crystal-clear warm waters make it easy to spot bright tropical fish, and maybe even a sea turtle or two. Our linens are the highest quality European cooling sheets made with Giza cotton. All toiletries are from Hermès.

We are committed to making your stay as seamless and special as possible. Our staff will arrange for your travel between the island and the airport (~15 min total duration). Our housekeeper will provide daily light touch housekeeping (4 hours) and do your laundry.

We have two captains on staff and two boats, a 34 ft intrepid and a 22 ft pursuit. Our captains will take you to Harbour Island, 5 minutes away, with its famous shopping, restaurants, beach, and night life, as often as you would like, any time of the day or night. (Boat fuel is an extra charge.)

We have 3 kayaks, 3 paddle boards, 3 under water scooters, snorkeling equipment, and more. All of these activities are included as part of your stay on our island.

Bedroom Details

Main House
Bedroom 1 - Master: King size bed, ensuite bathroom with walk-inshower, Dual vanity, Terrace, Ocean view
Bedroom 2: 2 Full-size beds, ensuite bathroom with walk-in rain shower
Bedroom 3: 2 Twin size beds (can convert to a king), access to hallway bathroom with walk-in shower
Bedroom 4: King size bed, ensuite bathroom with walk-in shower

Cottage
Bedroom 5: King size bed, ensuite bathroom with walk-in rain shower, balcony
Bedroom 6: 2 Double size beds, ensuite bathroom with walk-in rain shower
Bedroom 7: Twin size bunk bed, trundle bed, access to hallway half bathroom, balcony

Features & Amenities

Main House
Fully equipped kitchen with breakfast bar
Formal dining area with seating for 10 in main house, 6 in cottage
Satellite television
Wi-Fi
Air conditioning throughout
Back-up generator

Cottage
Fully equipped kitchen with breakfast bar
Formal dining area with seating for 6
Satellite television
Wi-Fi
Air conditioning throughout
Back-up generator

Outdoor Features
Private beach
Heated pool
Private dock
Alfresco dining with seating for 16
Terrace
Beach volleyball
Charcoal barbecue
Outdoor living area
Outdoor furniture
Fire pit
Sun loungers
3 Kayaks
3 Paddle board
Snorkeling equipment
3 Underwater sea scooters
Boat - 34 ft Intrepid wi/captain (fuel at extra cost)
Boat - 22ft Pursuit w/captain (fuel at extra cost)

Staff & Services Included:

Daily light-touch housekeeping
Boat captains
Concierge services

Extra cost:

Chef
Butler
Massage therapist
Spa treatments
Our captains can take you fishing, to feed the pigs, to visit a sand bar, feed the turtles, or visit a nearby island.

Amenities

Pool

Air conditioner

Kitchen or Kitchenette

Internet / Wifi

Parking

Laundry

Balcony or Patio

Dishwasher

Family friendly

Map of North Eleuthera

Nearby attractions

Spanish wells fishing Charters

9.8 mi

Glass Window Bridge

8.6 mi

Da Salty Pig Adventures

10.6 mi

Golding Cay

19.2 mi

Luxurious Private Island off Harbour Island - Pool, Beach, Boats, Staff

4.9

Outstanding(26 Reviews)

House in North Eleuthera

17 guests · 7 bedrooms · 6 baths

Reasons to book

Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating

Includes essentialsPool, Kitchen or Kitchenette, Air conditioner and more

Book with confidenceWe partner with the top travel sites so you know you're getting a great deal on the perfect rental

About this house rental

Amenities

Pool

Air conditioner

Kitchen or Kitchenette

Internet / Wifi

Parking

Laundry

Balcony or Patio

Dishwasher

Family friendly

Map of North Eleuthera

Nearby attractions

Spanish wells fishing Charters

9.8 mi

Glass Window Bridge

8.6 mi

Da Salty Pig Adventures

10.6 mi

Golding Cay

19.2 mi

Reviews

4.9

Outstanding(26 Reviews)

4.9

Jul 2024

It is hard to describe what a wonderful place Middle Cay is. Our family of 13 (8 adults and 5 children ages 5-8) just spent the best week ever there. This island offers everything but especially Mother Nature in all of her glory. The accommodations were perfect, when in the main house you felt like you were on a boat. The staff was excellent, the food delicious and having the boat was a major plus. The children went out on it every day, Vincent (the captain) took them to so many special places, swimming with turtles, swimming with stingrays, snorkeling on shipwrecks, tubing and just finding starfish. On the island we kayaked with a manatee and sea turtles. The little ones caught lizards and had hermit crab races. I feel like I have only touched the surface of this amazing island. Sonal, the owner is great to work with! There were lots of tears when it was time to leave, we all wanted to stay forever! Memories of a lifetime

4.9

Mar 2024

We all had a terrific time! The property was beautiful, really gave the island feel! The staff was excellent as well,very friendly and professional!!! The property will not disappoint you!! It was one of our top family vacations!!

4.9

Nov 2023

Group was me, my husband, two 8 year old sons, my brother, his wife and their 17yo and 13yo. The property has gorgeous views in all directions, lush vegetation, and the island is large and spread out. For two families traveling together with kids of different ages, the two (very nice) houses setup was super helpful. The biggest surprise about the island was the wildlife in the cove b/t the island and Eleuthera - many manatees would swim up let you scratch their backs that everyone would rush to the kayaks/paddle boards/snorkeling gear whenever they could to say hi to our new friends. For activities off island the boat captain took us out a bunch of times and we went tubing, looked at the sea turtles and other wildlife, saw the pigs on Spanish Wells, anchored on a beach off Eleuthera to swim and look for sea biscuits, snorkeling, or just to go for short boat rides. The staff was excellent and friendly and would help us with anything we needed. The chef made delicious restaurant quality meals (I know where she trained so not surprised). The proximity to Harbour Island is a great bonus bc it's a five minute ride across - we went to lunch at one of the beach hotels once while kids played on pink sands and one night went to dinner in town, the boat would wait and you'd text and boom you're home. The owner was v communicative on a group WhatsApp chat that included the house manager, anything we needed we got. In conclusion, a wonderful stay and I'd love to go back.

4.9

Oct 2023

What a beautiful vacation with wildlife we had. All the places we visited and all marine life were amazing. Beautiful beaches. That part was truly amazing. The property is def in need of renovations and repair. Pool filtration not working, sparking electrical wires outside during rain, electrical issues with lights dimming, a small building falling apart with items strewn about around it, rusted out canoe, kayaks missing oars, promised activities unavailable, leaking air conditioners in home causing slip hazards, broken floor tiles, stained floors, broken trash can….a lot that needs love and attention. The owner is communicative. The chef and housekeepers were great. The captain a little shady. The biggest issue is the amount of money requested for items before and after the trip. I priced groceries when I went on the island with what was purchased for us. These charges didn’t add up. I was charged a golf cart fee. There was no cart. We paid cash to rent two from someone on harbour island on two different days. We were charged several times for ice. One charge was $47, another $55. I saw four bags of ice during the trip. I also was asked to pay $1800 for boat fuel (stating we went out on both boats every day). This is absolutely untrue. We used one boat but sometimes our captain was out on that boat doing his own thing. The second boat only took us out fishing for one hour on one day. It all seemed a little shady. I did pay an upfront$5000 through PayPal for groceries/fuel.

4.9

Aug 2023

We had an amazing experience from the time we were picked up at the dock, until returning to the dock. The property is very well maintained daily, and the housing was perfect for my family on 19. There was something for all ages to enjoy on the island. The staff was very friendly and accommodating. Chef Jasmine prepared wonderful meals three times per day and the food was 5-star restaurant worthy. The daily boat trips to feed the pigs, turtles, and sting rays was special and the water is beautiful. Our older boys also got to fish and dive for conch which was a lot of fun for them. It was also nice to be able to boat a few minutes over to Harbour Island to shop and have lunch at The Dunmore. Lastly, the owner, Sonal, was very helpful and available for anything we needed before we got there and throughout our stay. I highly recommend this property! :) :)

4.9

Oct 2022

We had ages 5-82 years old and this experience was amazing for everyone of us! Sonal the owner begins communicating with you right away and is always available for questions or concerns. She takes great pride in this property. The property has snorkel gear, paddle boards, kayaks, fishing poles, underwater scooters... and the amount of sea life around the island is incredible. The boatmen-Sydney, Cornell and EJ were absolutely amazing. Every single day was filled with unbelievable adventures to remote beaches, tourist spots (pigs, swings, turtles), bone fishing, snorkeling like I have never experienced (reefs, star fish, sting rays, tons of fish, lobster, conch, turtles...), conch diving, Harbour Island, Spanish wells, Eleuthera, the Atlantic (gorgeous blue water and snorkeling)...... We had one day of big water and we felt completely safe with these experienced boatmen and this big boat. Jasmine the chef prepared meals that exceeded every expectation. We ate lunch out one day and nobody wanted to eat out again-Jasmine is a very gifted chef with a glowing personality!! My mother in law spent a couple of days relaxing on the island reading while the rest of us were adventuring- she couldn't get over the number of lounging spaces to relax:) The gardener was so king and opened coconuts for the kids to drink daily. We loved boating over to Harbour Island in the evenings to body surf on the pink beaches before dinner. Traveling in October was perfect- the weather was wonderful, the water was 84 degrees, and there was not congestion anywhere. I cant imagine having an experience this comprehensive at another rental in the Harbour Island area.

4.9

Oct 2022

The property is fantastic and the staff is superb!

4.9

Mar 2022

My husband and I (and 10 of our closest friends) booked our Middle Cay trip to celebrate his & his best friends 40th Birthdays. And let's just say, this was a trip of a Lifetime! From Arrival to Departure - Everything was AMAZING! First the airport transportation and boating to the house was SUPER EASY! Seriously. Nothing to it. Once we arrived to Middle Cay, we were Greeted with drinks and appetizers on the dock and each morning you're awaken with aromas of coffee and breakfast... it was all quite dreamy. Some mornings we got up before the staff had arrived to island - and we would watch them approach and arrive to the island via boat and it was neat to see. The Staff was incredible! Sophie and her team handled food, activities, housekeeping, You Name it! They really catered to our every need. We couldn't have asked for better service! Chef Vincent prepared delicious meals All day. Every day. We literally ate off island for 2 meals... we were All very pleased with all things food! We were celebrating birthdays, and Chef made a cake with Candles and the staff even Decorated the Dining Room with Balloons, streamers and Happy Birthday décor. It was SO THOUGHTFUL and made the night even More FUN!! Captain Sidney and Scott were great and made sure we were having a great time on the water and on our island outings. Always going above and beyond with chairs, umbrellas, drinks and food. The boats and other equipment were all Top Notch! Several of our guests used the underwater motor scooters and had the Best time exploring coral reefs. After returning home, we texted each other and All of our first thoughts when we woke up at home that morning - "Where's Sophie???!!!" We are all so Happy we made the trip to Middle Cay. We WILL be back! and will talk about this trip for years and YEARS to come... Middle Cay would be GREAT for a Multi-Family Trip too. Both houses are BIG and each has a full kitchen. Great communal areas, Inside and Outside. and Lots to do On and Off, Middle Cay. So Yes, BIG RECS from this Group of 12!

4.9

Mar 2021

The most amazing trip ever! We had initially booked it for three days but one day in and we ended up extending for the week! It was perfect in every way. The island is only 10 minutes away from the airport and only a 5 minute ride to harbor island. The island is surrounded by mangroves which brings in lots of sea life. Turtles, dolphins, stingrays, starfish and even manatees! The island itself offers a lot of activities including snorkeling, kayaking, fishing, beach volleyball, a captain with a boat and a chef! We watched the sunrise from the infinity pool and watched the sunset from the dock, which were both breathtaking. The staff working at the island are very helpful and incredibly kind. My fiancé proposed to me while on this trip and our host Sonal helped him out with the location and helped arrange everything. The trip was absolutely perfect and we were so sad to leave. We are looking forward to going there again as soon as we can!

4.9

Feb 2020

We had a party of 17, half kids and half adults. Everyone was blown away. We had a fantastic time and would love to return. Highly recommended for a memorable family vacation!

4.9

Dec 2019

Excellent private resort in a beautiful location.

FAQs

How much does this house cost compared to others in North Eleuthera?

The average price for a rental in North Eleuthera is $634 per night. This rental is $9,409 above the average.

Is parking included with this house?

Yes, parking is listed as an amenity at Luxurious Private Island off Harbour Island - Pool, Beach, Boats, Staff. For more information, we encourage you to contact the property about where to park.

Is there a pool at this house?

Yes, a swimming pool is available for use at Luxurious Private Island off Harbour Island - Pool, Beach, Boats, Staff. Enjoy the water!

Is Luxurious Private Island off Harbour Island - Pool, Beach, Boats, Staff pet friendly?

Unfortunately, this house is not pet-friendly. Try searching again and filter for "Pets Allowed"

What amenities are available at Luxurious Private Island off Harbour Island - Pool, Beach, Boats, Staff?

We found 10 amenities for this rental. This includes pool, air conditioner, kitchen or kitchenette, internet / wifi, and parking.

Explore similar vacation rentals in North Eleuthera

Explore all rentals in North Eleuthera

Beachfront

4.1

Excellent(18 Reviews)

The Cove Eleuthera

Resort

in Gregory Town

1 king bed

Garden · Pool · Pets allowed

Looking for a Resort in North Eleuthera, this Resort for $104 per night for your business stay, family stay, couples stay, getaway vacation, on your next trip.

$$$$

Luxurious Private Island off Harbour Island - Pool, Beach, Boats, Staff

House in North Eleuthera

Reasons to book

About this house rental

Amenities

Map of North Eleuthera

Nearby attractions

Luxurious Private Island off Harbour Island - Pool, Beach, Boats, Staff

House in North Eleuthera

Reasons to book

About this house rental

Amenities

Map of North Eleuthera

Nearby attractions

Reviews

FAQs

How much does this house cost compared to others in North Eleuthera?

Is parking included with this house?

Is there a pool at this house?

Is Luxurious Private Island off Harbour Island - Pool, Beach, Boats, Staff pet friendly?

What amenities are available at Luxurious Private Island off Harbour Island - Pool, Beach, Boats, Staff?

Explore similar vacation rentals in North Eleuthera

North Eleuthera travel inspiration

Related vacation destinations