Sunset Paradise Cottage
4.9
Outstanding(107 Reviews)Cottage in Cayuga Lake, NY
8 guests · 5 bedrooms · 2 baths
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Great for petsBring all your friends and family, even the furry ones
Includes essentialsGarden, Pets allowed, Kitchen or Kitchenette and more
About this cottage rental
Welcome to "Sunset Paradise”! A 4 bedroom, 2 bath picturesque lakefront cottage located on the eastern shore of Cayuga Lake in the heart of the beautiful Finger Lakes region of New York State. This property features a fully screened in porch, upper and lower decks, a relaxing 6-person hot tub, a private dock with a large sun deck, 1 boat lift, & 1 PWC lift. Fish off the dock, float on a tube (we can rent ours!), relax in the oversized hammock or enjoy a paddle in the 2 kayaks provided for use.
This 4 bedroom, 2 bath property can sleep up to 8 guests and has parking for 6 vehicles. It features a fully screened in porch, upper and lower decks with panoramic views of the lake, a relaxing 6-person hot tub available for use year-round, a private dock with a large sun deck, 1 vertical boat lift (max 4500lbs) and 1 PWC lift (max 1000lbs). Cast a line off the dock for some great fishing, float peacefully in an inflatable tube (we have 2 available for rental!), relax in the oversized hammock or enjoy a paddle around the lake in the 2 kayaks provided for use.
Take a step inside of “Sunset Paradise” to find an immaculately clean, fully furnished, and comfortable living space. A fully stocked kitchen with seating for 6 and a spacious living room with a SMART TV, couches, a double fold out sleeper sofa, and views of the lake greets you immediately. Continue on to find 4 bedrooms and 2 full baths, with sleeping arrangements as follows:
First Floor Bedroom 1: Queen Size Bed, 2 Large Closets
First Floor Bedroom 2: Queen Size Bed
Second Floor Bedroom 1: Queen Size Bed, Sitting Area, Desk, TV, 1 Large Closet
Second Floor Bedroom 2 (this room is accessed by walking through second floor bedroom 1): (2) Twin Beds. Full bath attached
Pillows, sheets, towels, and other linens are provided for your convenience. Heating and air conditioning are provided throughout for comfort in all seasons. This property is equipped with cellular service, 100mbps+ high speed internet & Wi-Fi, and a SMART TV/ DIRECTV. Strictly no smoking. Pets are allowed with an additional $200 pet fee which covers up to 2 pets. Please notify us at booking if you wish you bring a pet. Due to high demand, there is a strict no refund policy on any bookings that include a local event or holiday weekend.
Situated on the eastern shore of Cayuga Lake this comfortable, fully furnished and equipped four-bedroom cottage can be yours to enjoy. Sit back and enjoy your favorite beverage from the cozy living room, in the year-round 6-person hot tub on the large lower deck just a few feet from the water or under the remote controlled awning on the large upper deck.
Guests will have access to the entire property.
Feel free to contact us anytime by phone, text, or email. We want to make your stay as comfortable as possible!
The road this cottage is located on is nice and quiet to ride bikes or take a walk with lake views. There is a state park a few minutes down the road with a playground for kids and boat launches. The surrounding area offers numerous experiences to enjoy. Here are some of our favorites:
*Visit The Spa at the Inns of Aurora
*Enjoy at meal at Dugans Country Grill
*Tour the famous MacKenzie-Childs estate & world famous pottery
*Hike at nearby Long Point State Park
*Wine tasting on the Cayuga Wine trail
*Tour the historic Wells College
*Wells College Golf Course
*Shop in historic Aurora
*Have a fantastic meal at the Aurora Inn
*Encourage exploration at the Sciencenter in Ithaca, NY
*Birdwatch eagles, osprey, and a variety of ducks
*Greek Peak Mountain Resort
*Enjoy a meal at Aurora Brewery
You will need a car to get around. This property has room for 6 cars to park.
The shoreline and lake floor is rocky/slippery. We recommend bringing/wearing water shoes for safety.
Please note that the advertised nightly rate is based on a total of up to 6 guests. While we welcome up to 8 guests at this property, additional fees will apply beyond the count of 6. Please input an accurate guest count when booking to ensure proper pricing. As always, please reach out to us with any questions or concerns.
Spring, Summer, Fall and Winter rentals available.
Looking for more? We have 2 other properties on the same road: “Sunset Oasis” and “Sunset Haven”. “Sunset Paradise” and “Sunset Oasis” are next door to each other and “Sunset Haven” is located 300ft down the road. Renting multiple is a great option for big groups!
Come prepared to enjoy every day. Get up early to see the change in the color of the hills across the lake as the sun rises or watch an afternoon storm roll down the lake leaving the air clean and fresh. Enjoy the lake breeze and the sound of waves lapping against the dock. Fish off the end of the dock in one of the best fishing spots on the lake or enjoy a paddle around the lake in a kayak. Be amazed at the spectacular sunset at the end of the day. Roast marshmallows around the firepit.
There is plenty to see and do! Whatever you choose, we are sure that you will have a fabulous time at “Sunset Paradise”!
We expect guests to respect our home as if it was their own. We also require that the house is left in the condition it was when you arrived.
$200 pet fee covers up to two pets. If you have more, please let us know before reserving.
Please note that the advertised nightly rate is based on a total of up to 6 guests. While we welcome up to 8 guests at this property, additional fees will apply beyond the count of 6. Please input an accurate guest count when booking to ensure proper pricing. As always, please reach out to us with any questions or concerns.
Before you arrive you will be asked to complete guest verification through third-party provider Superhog. This is done to ensure we are keeping up-to-date with short-term rental regulations as well as providing both our guests and our properties with extra protection. Additionally, you will be asked to choose between a damage deposit or a damage waiver. Pet damage is not covered by this policy. Superhog will contact you via email and/or text to complete the verification. Please do so prior to arriving at the property to enable a quick and easy check-in process.
This 4 bedroom, 2 bath property can sleep up to 8 guests and has parking for 6 vehicles. It features a fully screened in porch, upper and lower decks with panoramic views of the lake, a relaxing 6-person hot tub available for use year-round, a private dock with a large sun deck, 1 vertical boat lift (max 4500lbs) and 1 PWC lift (max 1000lbs). Cast a line off the dock for some great fishing, float peacefully in an inflatable tube (we have 2 available for rental!), relax in the oversized hammock or enjoy a paddle around the lake in the 2 kayaks provided for use.
Take a step inside of “Sunset Paradise” to find an immaculately clean, fully furnished, and comfortable living space. A fully stocked kitchen with seating for 6 and a spacious living room with a SMART TV, couches, a double fold out sleeper sofa, and views of the lake greets you immediately. Continue on to find 4 bedrooms and 2 full baths, with sleeping arrangements as follows:
First Floor Bedroom 1: Queen Size Bed, 2 Large Closets
First Floor Bedroom 2: Queen Size Bed
Second Floor Bedroom 1: Queen Size Bed, Sitting Area, Desk, TV, 1 Large Closet
Second Floor Bedroom 2 (this room is accessed by walking through second floor bedroom 1): (2) Twin Beds. Full bath attached
Pillows, sheets, towels, and other linens are provided for your convenience. Heating and air conditioning are provided throughout for comfort in all seasons. This property is equipped with cellular service, 100mbps+ high speed internet & Wi-Fi, and a SMART TV/ DIRECTV. Strictly no smoking. Pets are allowed with an additional $200 pet fee which covers up to 2 pets. Please notify us at booking if you wish you bring a pet. Due to high demand, there is a strict no refund policy on any bookings that include a local event or holiday weekend.
Situated on the eastern shore of Cayuga Lake this comfortable, fully furnished and equipped four-bedroom cottage can be yours to enjoy. Sit back and enjoy your favorite beverage from the cozy living room, in the year-round 6-person hot tub on the large lower deck just a few feet from the water or under the remote controlled awning on the large upper deck.
Guests will have access to the entire property.
Feel free to contact us anytime by phone, text, or email. We want to make your stay as comfortable as possible!
The road this cottage is located on is nice and quiet to ride bikes or take a walk with lake views. There is a state park a few minutes down the road with a playground for kids and boat launches. The surrounding area offers numerous experiences to enjoy. Here are some of our favorites:
*Visit The Spa at the Inns of Aurora
*Enjoy at meal at Dugans Country Grill
*Tour the famous MacKenzie-Childs estate & world famous pottery
*Hike at nearby Long Point State Park
*Wine tasting on the Cayuga Wine trail
*Tour the historic Wells College
*Wells College Golf Course
*Shop in historic Aurora
*Have a fantastic meal at the Aurora Inn
*Encourage exploration at the Sciencenter in Ithaca, NY
*Birdwatch eagles, osprey, and a variety of ducks
*Greek Peak Mountain Resort
*Enjoy a meal at Aurora Brewery
You will need a car to get around. This property has room for 6 cars to park.
The shoreline and lake floor is rocky/slippery. We recommend bringing/wearing water shoes for safety.
Please note that the advertised nightly rate is based on a total of up to 6 guests. While we welcome up to 8 guests at this property, additional fees will apply beyond the count of 6. Please input an accurate guest count when booking to ensure proper pricing. As always, please reach out to us with any questions or concerns.
Spring, Summer, Fall and Winter rentals available.
Looking for more? We have 2 other properties on the same road: “Sunset Oasis” and “Sunset Haven”. “Sunset Paradise” and “Sunset Oasis” are next door to each other and “Sunset Haven” is located 300ft down the road. Renting multiple is a great option for big groups!
Come prepared to enjoy every day. Get up early to see the change in the color of the hills across the lake as the sun rises or watch an afternoon storm roll down the lake leaving the air clean and fresh. Enjoy the lake breeze and the sound of waves lapping against the dock. Fish off the end of the dock in one of the best fishing spots on the lake or enjoy a paddle around the lake in a kayak. Be amazed at the spectacular sunset at the end of the day. Roast marshmallows around the firepit.
There is plenty to see and do! Whatever you choose, we are sure that you will have a fabulous time at “Sunset Paradise”!
We expect guests to respect our home as if it was their own. We also require that the house is left in the condition it was when you arrived.
$200 pet fee covers up to two pets. If you have more, please let us know before reserving.
Please note that the advertised nightly rate is based on a total of up to 6 guests. While we welcome up to 8 guests at this property, additional fees will apply beyond the count of 6. Please input an accurate guest count when booking to ensure proper pricing. As always, please reach out to us with any questions or concerns.
Before you arrive you will be asked to complete guest verification through third-party provider Superhog. This is done to ensure we are keeping up-to-date with short-term rental regulations as well as providing both our guests and our properties with extra protection. Additionally, you will be asked to choose between a damage deposit or a damage waiver. Pet damage is not covered by this policy. Superhog will contact you via email and/or text to complete the verification. Please do so prior to arriving at the property to enable a quick and easy check-in process.
Amenities
Air conditioner
Pets allowed
Kitchen or Kitchenette
Internet / Wifi
Parking
Laundry
Balcony or Patio
Dishwasher
Hot tub or spa
TV
Garden
Family friendly
Map of Cayuga Lake, NY
Reviews
4.9
Outstanding(107 Reviews)4.9
The house was great and exactly as advertised. Everything was clean and well supplied. The owners were easy to reach when needed. We had a great time kayaking and swimming in the lake. The highlight of the trip was definitely watching sunset over the lake in the hot tub. We hope for a return visit someday!
4.9
My adult kids loved the home for its remote location at the same time being on the water.
4.9
We stayed for 9 days at Sunset Paradise. The house was clean and cozy; perfect for both sets of grandparents, me, my sposue and our 2 teen boys. Lake-front accomodations were exactly what we wanted as we spent our days and nights swimming, kayaking, stand up paddleboarding, and boating. The outdoor space with the hot tub were amazing. The house has everything you might have forgotten for all ages. Debbie and Paul offered the option of extra water toys for rent that made our stay even more fun. Great communicafion and responsiveness from Debbie and Paul throughout our stay. Book and you won't regret it!
4.9
Love the house & location! Plenty of space for 4 adults; felt private even tho close to other houses
Boat lift worked great, boat was safe during a terrible storm
Looking forward to coming back next year
4.9
Husband and I took advantage of a weekend away before becoming parents to two girls! It was beautiful—house was amazing. Had all the comforts we could have asked for. Kitchen had a great supply to make any dish! Really enjoyed our time and look forward to bringing our girls back one day! Thank you Paul and Debbie for being amazing too, from showing us the boat lift to being readily available anytime for a question!
4.9
We had a fantastic week here. The house had everything we needed and more. Conveniently located for local attractions. Nice a peaceful location. Will definitely recommend.
4.9
Beautiful area! Always a pleasure to stay! Loved updates to house.
4.9
We spent a beautiful four-day weekend in the prime of the fall foliage season and this was a beautiful lake location for our stay. It did take a bit of a drive to get to the wineries on Seneca lake, but we enjoyed spa treatments, wine tastings, and amazing dinner at the Aurora inn and lots of quality time at the house and around in the area. The rental was easy and the house was in need of some upgrades but in good shape and clean. The owners were sweet and very thoughtful with many little details and recommendations for a great stay. We definitely want to come back again!
4.9
Awesome, well equipped lake house with lovely lake views, pretty sunsets and outstanding amenities. We had 3 generations stay comfortably with plenty of space to cook, visit and relax. The dock and boat lift are easy to use and help get onto the lake. We’ll be back for sure!
4.9
Paul and Debbie are great hosts and very responsive and accommodating. I actually think the pictures don’t do the house justice. The kitchen was remodeled and the connecting living room is ample space for a get together. When the weather is nice, you can really spread out on the screened in porch, the deck overlooking the lake, the lower deck or the fire pit. We found this to be a great spot for our family and would love to come back and book the place next door (same owners) also to accommodate a growing family. Thanks for a great time!
4.9
We loved this property! I have never heard so much quiet in my life! Sitting on the deck early morning w your coffee watching the loons and the ducks was so cool. As far as amenities, it was as if you were walking into a different version of your own home. If you could possibly need it or forget it - it's there!! Location was great even if you plan to hit the wineries on the other side of the lake. Paul was great accommodating a last minute pet. We will be staying again and may look to rent the house next door as well for a larger group.
4.9
We loved our stay at Sunset Paradise! The house is lovely, well-stocked, and has a new, fully screened in porch that is perfect for dining outside. It is right on the lake with beautiful sunset (and moonset) views! We will be back.
4.9
Sunset Paradise is a cozy lakeside house that does really well for a long weekend. Well situated along the lake and nearby some local wineries and breweries, it’s well appointed and maintained for a comfortable weekend!
4.9
This was a wonderful get away with a nice balance of space to have time together and time alone. It was wonderful to be able to listen to the waves and enjoy being so close to the water. We struggled to figure out the hot water in the kitchen but the showers were lovely. We are grateful that the owners were flexible and allowed us to extend our last day into the afternoon.
4.9
We were a party of friends who choose to have Thanksgiving somewhere different every year. We look for cozy, a good kitchen, enough beds and near a body of water. Wow! we got lucky. We had one small problem, called the owner and it was cleared up in about 30 minutes, (on Thanksgiving - yes we felt bad). I, the writer of this review, would highly recommend this beautiful home on the lake. BTW - the kitchen was stocked with condiments, spices, food wraps and a variety of teas.
4.9
Beautiful view easy in to the place
4.9
From the views to the property having everything you need, you cannot go wrong with booking this property. We continue to rent from Paul and Debbie and are always satisfied. You will be too!
4.9
We really enjoyed our time. Having never spent time directly on a lake, we didn’t know what to expect. House had all the necessities. It was clean and comfortable. Did some kayaking and feeding the ducks. Amenities were as stated.
4.9
The property was the perfect relaxing getaway- you won't get closer to the water than this, right up to the bottom step but bring water shoes... the rocks are a little slippery. The views in all directions are really spectacular. The inside is extremely comfortable, air conditioned, comfortable beds, stocked kitchen... you'll find what you need. Nearby quaint town of Aurora was good for any last minute things we had to pick up. The hosts left us a bottle from the neighboring vineyard- very nice touch and they were very responsive with our questions.
Biggest advantage for us was the top level deck setup- it's all enclosed and with our two dogs this was critical for us to be able to relax.. they were able to roam outside on the large shaded deck without having to be tied up. (We still managed to let one slip by us during check out but that was just user error! ;)
We booked very last minute and consider ourselves lucky to have found this home-
4.9
Perfect get away! Location and accommodations are top notch! Debbie and Paul were always available by text, and even helped us dock the boat we rented when a storm popped up. The house has everything you need for a super comfortable stay, and all sorts of little extras to make it feel like home. Cannot thank them enough!
4.9
Sunset Paradise was exactly as described and included well equipped kitchen and baths. Appliances were easy to use, outside gas grill was especially appreciated as well as the washer and dryer. The owners left a bottle of delicious local wine. All rooms were very clean with plenty of towels and clean bed linens. Easy access to the water for the kids with water toys on the lower level. Sunsets watching from tje upper deck were gorgeous. Thoughtful ownership.
4.9
Very nice
4.9
We used the lake house to celebrate my son’s graduation from Cornell. Absolutely great time using the house and enjoying the local community. The local brewery up the street was a outstanding which we ended canceling our Ithaca restaurant reservation and celebrated there for two nights. Great fun. Highly recommended. Would do it again 100 times.
4.9
House was nice and we had fun fishing on the docks. The deck off the house was great and you can really enjoy the sunsets. Would go back...
4.9
We love this property on the lake! The cottage has everything we needed to enjoy a long weekend.
4.9
Great location. House had everything we needed. Hot tub was perfect. Would definitely come back.
FAQs
How much does this cottage cost compared to others in Cayuga Lake?
The average price for a rental in Cayuga Lake is R 6,099 per night. This rental is R 1,191 less expensive than the average.
Is parking included with this cottage?
Yes, parking is listed as an amenity at Sunset Paradise Cottage. For more information, we encourage you to contact the property about where to park.
Is there a pool at this cottage?
We didn’t find pool listed as an amenity for this cottage. It may be worth double checking if a pool is important for your stay.
Is Sunset Paradise Cottage pet friendly?
Yes! This cottage is pet-friendly. For more information, we recommend contacting the booking provider about animal policies.
What amenities are available at Sunset Paradise Cottage?
We found 12 amenities for this rental. This includes air conditioner, pets allowed, kitchen or kitchenette, internet / wifi, and parking.
Explore similar vacation rentals in Cayuga Lake
Explore all rentals in Cayuga LakeCayuga Lake travel inspiration
Read our blogGuides
Top Things to Do in Oahu and Honolulu
Guides
Top Things to Do in Fort Lauderdale, Florida
Guides
Top Things to Do in Miami: From Beaches to Culture
Guides
The Best Things to Do in Orlando: Attractions, Food, and Family Fun
Guides
Things to Do in Galveston, Texas
Guides
Top Things to Do in Myrtle Beach
Guides
Ski Trip Packing List: What to Bring Skiing or Snowboarding
Trends
VacationRenter Holiday Travel Trends 2023