We loved every minute of our stay, Kelly, the owner, was so kind and personable and the place was so clean and had everything we needed, can’t wait to go back….JP

Had a great weekend getaway perfect for any couple! Beautiful sunsets, gorgeous beaches and a wonderful apartment with everything you could ask for including a fire pit, grill, outdoor shower and a comfortable bed. Highly recommend and would stay here again.

Beautiful cottage and property. We had a great time and enjoyed kayaking around the lake.

Great little studio cottage for a short getaway in Montauk. Everything is great. I give it 4 stars because it is right on the road so traffic noise is very noticeable.

My girlfriend and I stayed here for a long weekend and everything about the place was perfect. We felt very at home when walking in, it was spotless and the decor was beautiful. We will most definitely be back, and would recommend to anyone!

Had a great time, everything is super close and the place is clean and up to date. Will be returning :)

We were most delightfully pleased with our unit. Everything was newly updated, spotless clean and beautifully appointed. We were welcomed with the most hospitable note. This unit totally exceeded expectations.

We had a great time at the cottage. Super clean and updated, very responsive hosts, perfect location. The perfect escape for us.

This was the perfect place to stay for a few nights! Very clean and great location - 5 minute drive to town, and very fairly priced, great value. I would recommend to others as well as consider for my next stay in Montauk!

Very comfortable unit and beautiful location near the lake. Not ideal if you prefer to walk or hike, but we were able to make it work.

We loved our little bungalow by the lake. It was extremely clean, nicely appointed and very comfortable. A sweet little note with a bag of cookies was a thoughtful nice touch. The only drawback was that we were in the unit closest to the road and at such an angle that the lights would shine through and we could hear the cars pretty loudly since it was close to the road. There were other units closer to the lake that seemed empty. I would highly recommend this place but try to get the units closer to the lake.

We loved this property! Well appointed with everything we needed, extremely clean and great location. Really enjoyed the lake and the beach. The owners provided many extras, such as SUPs, kayaks, firewood, beach gear and parking pass. I highly recommend this property and would stay here again.

Navy Beach was perfect! It was super clean and decor was adorable. Perfect size for 2 people. Kitchen had all the amenities you could want or need. The location is perfect, too. 5-10 minutes from anywhere you’d want to be in Montauk. Definitely would stay here again/recommend to friends!

This rental was absolutely perfect for us. We were in Montauk for a wedding and only wish we could have taken advantage of all that Kelly and Rick's place had to offer. It's decorated beautifully and comfortably and, most importantly, it is immaculately clean and it's clear our hosts care about their property and their guests. Thank you for a great weekend!

Newly decorated, it is at a beautiful location. Dishwasher, Washer/Dryer, huge shower, towels, a zillion pillows, clean and easy to keep clean. It is the perfect get away near everything in Montauk. We really enjoyed our stay.

The Relaxing Lake Retreat had it all for our long off-season weekend in Montauk: steps away from awesome lake views, clean and modern furnishings, a short bike ride to town and the lighthouse, and it was nice and quiet. K was super helpful with recommendations and even stopped by to welcome us and make sure we had everything we needed. We would definitely love to come back!

Initially I had a few apprehensions about staying at an airbnb but this place quickly removed all apprehensions. The place is EXACTLY as advertised and Kelly and Rick are THE NICEST people. We had a situation where our remote control wasn't working and at 10pm Rick came and brought us new batteries and a new remote! The attention to detail here is impeccable. Literally everything you would need is provided. The place is beautiful, convenient and close to everything. Honestly I have no complaints at all. When we come back to Montauk we will only stay at Kelly n Rick' s location, they're awesome!

What an amazing spot!! Set on Lake Montauk this property provided all we needed for a relaxing vacation. The property was charming, immaculate and provided all the necessary amenities. Just a few miles from downtown Montauk and a bike ride to Montauk Lighthouse, the location was perfect. It was peaceful and we enjoyed the amazing sunsets while we roasted marshmallows around the fire pit. The owners were very attentive and provided paddleboards and kayaks as well! What a great way to close out the summer! Can't wait to come back!

My husband and I stayed at Duffy on the lake and had a wonderful relaxing, fun time. The owners were friendly and gave us great suggestions for dining for lunch and dinner. The cabin was clean and nicely decorated. We re looking forward to our visit next year.

Great location, beautiful and clean lodgings, would definitely stay here again

Our family spent Fri-Sun of our Thanksgiving weekend at Duffy's in Montauk. The property is as described and photographed. So clean, that we felt at ease to let our baby run around. The property is maintained very well and we were able to roast marshmallows one night at the fire pit against the lake. The town was quiet, which was just what we wanted as a getaway from NYC. Rick and Kelly were fabulous hosts and were available to answer any questions that we had. We will be sure to stay again in the future!

We had a great time at Duffy's! The unit was immaculate and stocked with everything you could think of! Kelly was extremely accommodating and available for questions. The check in/check out process was seamless. Would definitely stay again!!

We had an amazing time at Duffys!! The unit itself was like something out of a showroom, very clean and pristine. Everything was close by including shopping, restaurants and many beaches. We will be back again soon for sure and we will be staying at Duffys!!

We have been coming to Montauk for years, and we have stayed in several different places. This was the best place we have stayed. It was clean, newly renovated, comfortable, and nicely decorated. It was great being on Lake Montauk. Also, the owners are wonderful hosts. Highly recommended, particularly for those that would prefer a more quiet setting than Montauk village.

My fiance and I just stayed with Kelly and Rick at Duffy's on Lake Montauk. We are both harsh critics and I must say we came away from our week refreshed and impressed. All the details are taken care of. The units are spotless and modern. everything was thought of, literally. inside the unit the bed was comfortable, nice sized living room with a fully equipped flat screen(Roku included for those rainy days.) The unit was a fully washer dryer so you can wash throughout your stay and detergent was available. You can go out to eat or cook. there is a full stove as well as a BBQ outside. Outside the property is beautifully manicured. The grass in the back of the house is right on the water of lake montauk. It has an amazing view and is a great place to read/relax/ swim. They have comfortable chairs, paddleboards, kayak, firepit. All in all if youre looking for someplace to get away, recharge, and have full access to the wonders of montauk it doesn't get better than duffy's on lake montauk. Thank you guys for having us.

I took my wife to Montauk for her birthday. Not knowing the area, I thought this would be a good balance of "away from it all" yet "close enough to town," and thankfully I was right. It's a five minute drive to the heart of the town, and also a five minute drive to Ditch Plains beach (which we rode our bikes to in 10 minutes). As for the home, it's a really efficient use of space that doesn't feel cramped. It's newly renovated, so everything is nice and new. I can't say enough about the place. The only possible negative would be that the outdoor shower has a drain that doesn't work. So the shower is fine, but the water will stand until the next day, which could attract mosquitos. I just took it upon myself to clear the water afterwards. No biggie. I would definitely return!

The studio is very clean, new, and comfortable, and the property has a fire pit by the water for sunset and marshmallows, kayaks, SUP, and a friendly duck. We truly enjoyed staying there. The owners are on top of it, always accessible by phone, and took the time to make our stay as enjoyable as possible, especially for our 5-yr old. We plan on staying here again.