I've been fortunate enough to stay in a few 5-star homes/resorts... Starfish Bay far exceeds any of them. The attention to detail and all the amenities is beyond expectations. Every detail has been attended to. The place is immaculate, and the view is nothing short of spectacular. The outside deck is expansive. Lusea and Brandon were in communication making sure we had everything we needed and providing suggestions on activities. They have a caretaker on site who was very attentive and just pleasant to talk with. If there was a higher rating than 5 stars, I would have given it on this review.

Close to the Marsh Harbor airport and about anything else you want to see, this house will surprise you. It's brand new construction, totally off grid and absolutely stunning! The hosts listen closely to suggestions. We made 2 and they're already being acted on. You'll find 2 true master suites. The attention to detail in this home are evident. Don't think off grid means limited. In this case, it means better and more reliable. Paddle boards and kayaks available and you'll want to use them in the calm waters just off your porch. Yes, even the beds are super comfy. As an investor with several short term beach properties, I can only wish my properties were as well equipped and managed. It's the little things that make big differences... shampoos and soaps, spices, coffees, sugars, beach towels, AN APP with suggestions for restaurants, sites, every question you might have about the house... come on! Brandon and Lucy make everyone else look baaaad! Thank you both for making our Abaco experience the best!

Starfish Bay is an exceptional property! The home is absolutely beautiful, in immaculate condition and nicely appointed both inside and out, including items like a gas grill, air fryer, Ninja smoothie maker, and lots of additional linens/beach towels. And the water lapping the rocks just below the deck is as soothing as it is beautiful. Since the property is located at the end of the peninsula, it provides access to both sea and sound which is great. We found ourselves switching from side to side to enjoy the water and views depending on weather and time of day. Having the water toys and dock available was a great bonus. I cannot say enough about our hosts, Brandon and Lucy. Communication was quick and easy from start to finish. It is very apparent that they care deeply about their property and desire to create the perfect getaway for their guests. Our family of 5 stayed at Starfish Bay and rented a boat with hopes of spending all of our time exploring the Abacos by water. Although the weather did not cooperate every day, Brandon was always quick to offer suggestions for alternate places/activities to enjoy. His extensive knowledge of the area greatly enhanced our stay. The caretaker, Roland, was attentive and always had a smile on his face. He was a joy to meet. One thing to note....While the property itself was stunning, Marsh Harbour and much of the island is still recovering from Dorian. If you are exploring the Sea of Abaco and surrounding areas via boat, there are numerous options for activities/dining but those options are limited on the island.

This is a really special property. The house is absolutely spotless and sits directly on the Sea of Abaco with a huge deck just steps from the water and perfect for enjoying the views. It is incredibly well managed by two wonderful people who strive to make your stay memorable. We could not have asked for a better place to stay while looking for our own property in the Abacos. Thanks again to Brandon and Lucy for making our stay so enjoyable.

I’ve spent a ton of time in the Abacos and the location and layout of this property is amazing. You have a calm channel to keep your boat docked in and the ocean in front of your house for snorkeling, paddle boarding and relaxing. The location is also perfect to island hopping. It’s a great getaway for families or solo travel because it’s private and safe. I will definitely be rebooking this property as soon as possible. Also, the owners and the caretaker of the property are super responsive and really helpful. Five stars all the way.

The house is beautiful, and the views are amazing. There is new safe dockage where I felt comfortable leaving my new 35 foot center console. The owners and staff exceeded our expectations. The property manager and groundskeeper were available 24/7 if we need assistance with anything. The house was fully stocked and ready for our arrival. There is still construction going on in the area, we were aware of this prior to booking. It did not cause us any issues. I never heard workers before 7:30 in the morning and only Monday through Friday. One member of our group worked from home the entire trip and had no problems with Internet connection for online meetings. I would recommend this property.