Sam was awesome! Very welcoming an had an amazing personality. Treated us like family, took time to show us the property. I would stay there again for sure!

This place was within walking distance to all the Key West hot spots

The property is quiet and everything is walkable.

Great, cozy, well maintained property in close proximity to all that is Duval Street and the Wharf area.

This place is AMAZING! GREAT location, clean, fun, comfy bed…and the gentleman at the front desk is hands down the nicest most fun person I’ve ever met at a hotel ANYWHERE! He made the stay PERFECT! Wow! Will DEFINITELY stay here again!

Very nice and helpful staff even when we arrived at 11 am!

Very friendly staff, great location. Room was small but comfortable.

The Garden House served our need for a comfortable place to stay that was located within walking distance of the main attractions on Duval.

It was a great location. Walking distance to duval street. Quiet in the evenings. Sammy was an awesome host!! Would definitely come back with friends for another stay.

Comfortable, quiet, clean, uncomplicated

The property was beautiful and well kept. Only 2 blocks from Duval Street which was awesome. Sammy was great and breakfast delicious and fresh. Room was small but we were only there at night. Pool was big enough to cool off in. If u are there on Sunday you lose your parking for church from 9: 30 to 11:45. So we went to the Southernmost Point and butterfly museum and neither were crowded that early! Would stay again.

Friendly staff and great breakfast

Sammy Miami is amazballs. Such a joyous and wonderful host. He was accommodating, hardworking and professional service master.

Clean. Great location. Sammy was wonderful!

Nice central too everything

The only good thing about this property is the hospitality of Sammy and the location for walkability. That said, the property manager who was there on our last two days canceled out our entire experience with Sammy and parking was impossible to find within a close distance so once you are there, plan to park your car or pay $30 per day at the adjoining church and that's only if they have space for you. I was aware we booked a tiny queen, but was not prepared for just how tiny it was. There was literally no where to hang or store clothes so we had to keep everything in our suitcases for 5 nights. The small dresser they had was broken and we had to put our suitcases on the floor at night and move them to the bed every morning just to be able to walk around the room. There were paint chips on the ceiling, walls and floors. There were only a couple outlets in the entire room between the sleeping and bathroom areas. My husband and I are not large people and we had to take turns going from the sleeping area to the bathroom through the narrow hallway. The worst part about our stay was when the refrigerator went out and destroyed our fresh catch from the day before that we were planning to enjoy at a local restaurant. This place is not worth the ridiculous price and I would not recommend to any of my family or friends. I'm actually shocked by all of the positive reviews that I read prior to booking.

Pool area was very nice.

Sammy was very helpful, friendly, and went out of his way to be accommodating. We much prefer the personal touch and we got it here. Rooms were fine - no issues and the pool area was cozy and charming. We will definitely stay here again in our next trip. ——- thank you!

Great place, super location (walking distance from main visiting points) and fantastic host!

Great location small but everything you need. Host Samuel was great!

Awesome check in! Love the whole property! So well done and quaint. Our room is very close to the pool and we love it!

Hard to park the car on arrival, and then, it was expensive. I was really surprised to find out there was no one at the « reception”. I had no clue a room could be so small (I was at room # 4 I think)

Great place. Quiet, older place with tons of character and everything we could need to make our stay enjoyable. We plan to return next year.

This is a great place to stay. They have parking and you can easily walk to everywhere from Mallory Square to Southpoint. Duval street is only a few blocks away. The staff is very friendly.

It was convenient. Some of the staff was nice. One of the breakfast staff seemed to be having a good day. The door to our room seemed less than secure. Very small room - not even a chair!

Don’t choose the “tiny queen” room. Ridiculously small room. With luggage in room, so cramped and tiny could barely get around the bed. Bathroom so small, had to sit sideways on toilet. No free parking, unless you keep searching the adjacent street(s) for a rare open spot, otherwise $30/night. Had to laugh at it when we opened the door the first time… but location was great for easy walk to Duval St.

Location

What a great place. Fantastic staff and tremendous location.

Very cute and quaint. Exactly the desired vibe for a first-time Key West experience.

If you want to stay at the Hilton, go stay at the Hilton. If you want to be welcomed like family, stay at the Garden Inn. Being welcomed by Sammy "Miami" was like staying with some quirky long lost relative. I've never been to Key West before, but this type of atmosphere is supposed to be what the area is known for. Laidback, personal, and full of character. Try the waffles, I'm a food snob and even I thought they were good.

The Staff is amazing

Very friendly staff. Checkin and checkout was so easy.