Very clean. Spacious. Modern.

For $450 a night I didn't even have toothpaste in the room. And having to make reservations for breakfast at the bar??? Seriously???

Quiet clean friendly atmosphere.

Payment machine not working elevators stopped working I requested a king bed and a queen was in the room

The roof top deck was very nice. Hotel staff seemed polite.

Distance. It rained during our stay and this made the drive from Philly not good. Other than that/we enjoyed our visit.

Good location.

Room (s) weren’t clean, even after changing rooms. Very small rooms compared to listed size on the website.

Loved the bar. The cocktails and wings were delicious! The room was a nice size, clean and stylish. The location was perfect for our event.

Our room didn't have any hand soap or body wash. The brunch service was very slow. The bed could have been a little firmer.

Wish I had more time to spend here. A+ I had just come from a "4 star hotel" in PA night before where I could not sleep, could not get comfortable, could not block out the road noise. Walked into MC and said THIS is more like it. Instantly comfortable there. Everything was ON POINT.

Upon check in, the front desk rep was not personable, and said "oh here these are for you" and handed me two bottles of water. What?! These should have been in the room already. This made me feel like I was paying $250 to stay at the Red Roof. Lighting fixtures on the wall did not work. A porter came and tried a new bulb but no luck. No building engineer ever returned to fix the light.

I couldn't figure out how to use the coffee machine. A porter named Michael came to the room and showed us how it worked and replenished the coffee supplies. He was very courteous and personable.

Room was almost bare. No clothes storage space. Seemed like it was missing a desk, a wardrobe or dresser, a chair, and some art.

we loved our room, and we even got an upgrade. The restaurant at the lobby was exceptional and your staff very friendly

not enough shower gell

Food wasn’t great from the menu. Not very warm or tasty.

Great location for where I was working. Lots of restaurants within walking distance.

Really nothing

Staff, coffee in room only decaf, asked for some regular was told can't find any but I'll be making some in about 20 minutes

This is a beautiful hotel and the staff is super friendly. They allow dogs which is helpful . Prices at the restaurant and rooftop bar are very reasonable for the area. The rooms are spacious and I especially loved the bathroom.

There's nothing I didn't like.

staff, location, structure

price on parking is higher than it should. breakfast could be cheaper for customers.

I was recommended the hotel because it was closest to my esthetician

I was a solo lady traveler in NJ and in the US for the first time. On the first night of my stay someone entered my room with a key fob while i was in it, of course I was terrified. I went downstairs and reported it to the desk, they didn't apologise to me profusely, i was victim blamed, the receptionist proceeded to tell me he gave another guy the same room number because we had similar surnames anyway I was offered a different room and I kid you not the room offered was a joke, it was dingy, no blinds and way worse than the previous room I had. It was a very stressful experience, I had to call the receptionist again to complain about the room they gave me, he told me well that the room was given to me 20 minutes ago that why was I just complaining about it now. what a joke! I told him I was okay to overlook certain aspects of the room however the room having no blinds was the last straw. The receptionist then asked me what I would like him to do about it. I had to demand he put me in the best room in the hotel, honestly that should have been a given due to the huge blunder they caused. Altogether I had to change rooms 3 times after a long flight with broken suitcases. honestly it was not a good experience only positive I can say is the restaurant in the hotel was nice but no I will not come back to the hotel. if you're a solo traveler and you care about your safety I wouldn't use this hotel either.

Montclair is beautiful and what a wonderful room!! The size, the décor, the furniture, the huge windows with a spectacular view! And probably the nicest bathroom of any hotel I've ever stayed in (loved the walk-in shower)! Nice bar area for a light breakfast. Great location next to lots of amenities and perfect for the Wellmont Theatre. If you like a hike (and are okay with an incline) the Eagle Rock Reservation is reachable on foot and well worth the climb (though be aware there are some parts of the walk up to the reserve which have no path/sidewalk). There's a roof bar which I didn't get chance to visit as it appears to have a smart dress code and I didn't have time to go change. Sounds cool though.

The only real issue for me is that I was a bit surprised and disappointed to have no tea/coffee facilities in the room, considering there was even a fridge. It's unusual (in my experience) to be without this amenity in a 4 star hotel. The rest of this feedback is super minor and absolutely wouldn't stop me staying again, but I'm offering it in the spirit of being constructive in case it's helpful to the hotel: *Additional signage in some of the corridors might be helpful - I got a little lost between the elevator and my room a couple of times before I had the route straight in my head. *Staff were very friendly but most interactions I had throughout my stay were much more time-consuming than they ought to have been (e.g. taking a very long time to make a coffee and take payment, despite me being the only customer at the time), or weren't straightforward (e.g. issues with payments being put through on the wrong card despite a full explanation beforehand). *Some of the furnishings in the room need a little TLC (broken plant pot, peeling wallpaper, quite a lot of veneer chipped away from both sides of the ottoman).

I liked to modern and sleekness of our room, I also liked how there was a bar downstairs, plus it’s pet friendly.

What I didn’t like is that they charged me a extra $100 on top of the $550 for 2 nights I had to pay :’))