By far the best home rental I have ever stayed in - from cleanliness to available supplies (full kitchen, beach needs, speakers) to the generous and frequent communication from the hosts, we were blown away.

All around amazing! Every aspect of the house! Owner very responsive and provided great intel for island fun! Get there!

We can't say enough about how much we love this house.

Stayed almost a full week and everything was perfect. We had a wonderful relaxing stay. I would highly recommend a stay.

Exceptionally well furnished and equipped, ideally located only 5 minute walk from Wade beach, Jason and Josh are the perfect hosts. No need for us to consider any other property on Shelter Island, we will keep coming back whenever possible.

The house is just as we remembered it LY. Welcoming, comfortable, with all the trimmings. During our stay we had a terrible storm and our host stuck with us thru thick and thin. We look forward to another return

The home was perfect for a week away to relax and enjoy this special island. Immaculate and comfortable with the best chill vibe. Can’t wait to come back!

Incredibly well equipped, clean, lovely home. Hosts were very generous and helpful.

This was our second stay at the house for this summer and it was even better than the first time. The property is immaculate, the kitchen is exceptionally equipped, and the rest of the house impeccably furnished. The five-minute walk to the beach is also a plus. We will definitely come back and plan to become regular guests.

Ample gathering spaces, inside and out. Outfitted with all the details. We loved it and highly recommend.

Our stay was outstanding. The house is extremely well furnished and decorated. Jason has a remarkable eye for details and an impeccable taste, and made us feeling immediately at home. This property is truly a gem

My wife and I have rented many vacation houses over the years, and this one proved more painful than all the others for one reason: we hated to leave it! The house itself is superbly livable, and the owners have done a terrific job of making it handsome, as well: the mid-Century modern furniture is a pleasure to be around, as is the very striking--but never intrusive--artwork that brightens the walls. The second floor is truly a little apartment in itself, affording a measure of luxurious privacy if one should so desire. The beds are without exception supremely comfortable; all the kitchen is far beyond fully equipped, the appliances only the best. In short, this lovely property combines the best qualities of a charming home and a top-notch hotel, and we hope to return to it many times in the future.

Though we've lived in Manhattan for many years, my husband and I had never been to Shelter Island. After staying here for a week, we fell in love not only with the island, but also this house. Open, chic, and immaculate are a few words I would use to describe this special place. We adored the beautiful midcentury furnishings, the close (walkable) proximity to the beach, the cross breeze that came through the sliding doors on each side of the house and the location that was private yet close to both ferries and the best restaurants on the island. The owners have truly thought of everything. From bikes, to hotel-style bathroom amenities (fresh shampoos, soaps) beach gear (towels, umbrellas, chairs, coolers) to the stocked, perfectly organized kitchen with every appliance or tool you could ever need. Jason is as gracious as they come. He genuinely wants you to feel the love for Shelter Island. His recommendations for activities and restaurants are spot on. We created such special memories at this house and plan to rent it year after year.

We (myself, sister, niece and my mother) rented this beautiful house at the end of July. First, working with Jason is a breeze. He is extremely detailed in his emails about the house and consistently offers his availability to answer any questions. He also makes great suggestions for dinner and shopping. Secondly, the house is BEAUTIFUL. A simply designed home, yet elegant with importantly placed art around. Everything in the home is immaculate, clean and mostly white (not a house for kids). They have bikes and rafts for use as well as a grill. Basically everything you need for vacation home. We had a great time and very much enjoyed the house and Shelter Island. Shelter Island is quiet and relaxed and minutes from Sag Harbor and Greenport. We loved the house so much I might even rent again next year...

We stayed at this property in August and couldn't have been happier with our choice. The home was immaculate on our arrival, and was just as described and as shown in the pictures. It had been recently redone and in great condition. The look and feel is contemporary, very light and bright, and also very comfortable. The house has an open feel, but the wooded grounds keep things secluded. Everything on Shelter Island was easy to get to, and the location is minutes from the South Ferry, which makes it convenient to drive to Sag Harbor or The Hamptons. The owner was fantastic. Easy to work with and extremely helpful, assisting with recommendations of things to do and see...he really cared about making sure that we had a great stay, which we did. We would certainly recommend this property without hesitation!

Everything about this rental was perfect... beginning with the accurate location, rental appearance and amenity description to the nearby activities and restaurants. Words to describe this home would include clean, well maintained, private, and sophisticated. We would highly recommend this property to others. It was a pleasure dealing with the owners-their attention to detail and prompt response to all communication made it feel like we were dealing with close friends or family. We had one our best vacations ever.

We had a wonderful stay here during August 2014. And would certainly come back.

Had a fabulous time at this superb house! Beautifully appointed both inside and out. Lovely , relaxing ! Would highly recommend for a peaceful getaway! The people on the island are very helpful and friendly. The restaurants and beaches are wonderful