Was only there a short time for a wedding but the staff was amazing!! The rooms have been updated and are very nice!!

Quintessential Door County stay! Beautiful golf course, older hotel but absolutely adorable and extremely well-kept. Very friendly staff. Quiet, affordable, and clean!

Very enjoyable stay. Will be back!!

Very nice owners.

Charming 100 yr old lodge. New owners did a nice job.

Wonderful owners. Very friendly. Beautiful place.

Nice place. Very friendly staff

Room was small, bed, and pillows were very hard. Toilet was a bit tricky getting it to flush

Person at front desk was fantastic. Love the history of the place and one of a kind uniqueness

My wife and I stayed for our 30th anniversary. I would highly recommend it, this hotel is definitely not the average hotel. The property, rooms, lobby, patio and lounge are historic and beautiful. The staff is incredibly welcoming and friendly and keep the rooms and facility, clean and spotless.

Beautiful, historic lodge.

My daughter and I stayed here for a weekend getaway and we loved Maxwelton Braes. The on-site tennis and pickle ball courts made us wish we were staying longer. We also loved the patio outside. They even offered us complimentary use of the cruiser bicycles so we could cycle into Bailey Harbor just a mile away. We had an excellent time and would happily go back.

Excellent customer service, appreciated the vintage touches to honor the history of the location. Not a lot of food options and bar closed early (8 PM?) so we dined elsewhere throughout our stay.

Maxwelton Braes is a favorite for us. Great location and the staff is superb! A definite must stay place for quaint cozy experience.

The hotel was old fashioned which I found charming. The property was nice to look at. We did not use the golf course, but it looked well maintained.The rooms were clean, however one our the lamps in my room was in a corner with no outlet and was unusable. Our room had direct tv and a large flat screen tv, but no remote which made watching tv more difficult. I shared a joining room with friends, but they did not have their own bathroom or tv and needed to walk through our bed area to use either item. Overall, I would return to the lodge during a different season where i could utilize more outdoor amenities.

We liked the history of the lodge. It was a beautiful building. We would've liked to see more staff. No one at the front desk and not very welcoming. There was coffee in the morning in the lounge but muffins or rolls would be nice too since there wasn't an open cafe close by.

Love to stay here although room should be updated! Still has cozy charm and nice to stay a bit out of town. Angelina was awesome bartender and host!

Ownership is not committed to running a hotel. The front desk is very seldom staffed. There is no maid service. The dining room is permanently closed, so breakfast is 4 or 5 miles away. Room keys must be picked up at the bar. This historic hotel is now a neglected side-hustle for the main operation, which is the golf course. Stay elsewhere.

Beautiful building; from another era. Common areas for the guests; something you don’t see in newer hotels

There was probably a reason why this property was still available for a last minute Labor Day trip. I guess we could say the room was “vintage”…smelled musty, only one a/c unit in the bedroom so the living area was hot, the bathroom was always damp and the shower was made for someone 5ft tall (not to mention the horrible sulfer smell of the water, but this is somewhat typical for the area). Also thought it was a little odd no one was working when we arrived for check-in and keys were just in an envelope on the desk for us. Could be a great place and it probably was back in the day, but needs some major updates and TLC for the amount they’re charging.

This is a beautiful vintage hotel. If you can appreciate that it was built for the people of a century ago, you’ll love it. If you’re like the Kardashians, it’s not for you. Very comfortable beds, nice rooms, beautiful lodge and grounds. We’ll stay there again!

This review is about the Fairway Cabins, I cannot speak on the lodge rooms. Do yourself a favor and avoid the Fairways! When we arrived around 7pm and there was no one on desk. The confirmation information we received stated check in could be done until 730pm. Instead, our name and the room keys were left out in an unsecure area where anyone could have taken then. We never saw a concierge/desk clerk during our stay. We had several issues with the room which I will share below. The welcome letter that was left with our keys had a number that stated to call/text if needed. It took over 5 hours and two texts before we heard from anyone regarding our troubles. The room had a musty smell that never went away. The water had a hard mineral content which left the sinks stained and a bad taste which was also slightly fishy. We had to buy bottled water to brush our teeth. When booking the room. It stated air conditioning was included; however, what it failed to state was that it was a window unit only in the bedroom and the sofa bed/living room area did not have ac so that room was always uncomfortable. Needless to say, the advertisement is misleading. It got chilly in the evenings and when we went to turn on the heat it didnt work. It required maintenance to come out and fix it which didnt occured until later in the evening the second day. To add insult, they cranked the heat to 90°F on the thermastat and left it there so when we returned, the room was obnoxiously hot.

Was absolutely horrific. The rooms weee dirty, towels used - see pic, and were missing most of the sheets/comforters in the room. Nobody at the reception, phones lead nowhere. Had to wonder around the hotel to find laundry room and wash towels and sheets sobthat people could sleep in the room! Left 2 messages at front desk - not even a callback!!!!! 2 adults had to sleep in their clothes!!!!! I expect a full refund!!!

Quiet and beautiful place to stay

Quiet and beautiful place to stay

No clerk ,no coffee,Bathroom floor slippery

The terrence was nice and pretty but the room was dirty and the toliet was not cleaned. There was still stains on there. Empty toliet roll was on the bathroom floor. Table desk was not cleaned.

The staff were all very welcoming and friendly. It is definitely an older establishment, but very clean. The golf staff were absolutely wonderful! We will be back!

No management present for our entire stay. No formal check-in or check out. The entire place needs updating both inside and out. Limited food and beverage service. I will say the bed was comfortable.

So apparently the property is being sold and thus there is literally nobody there . When I say there was nobody there there was nobody there no is there no staff no guests We had to find our own towels and our own toilet Paper. It was a bit like the shining. With that sad the rooms were fine and they were clean but it was just weird.

Interesting old history. Beautiful woodwork. We called the property several times with a question a day or so ahead & the answering machine said they were not open for the season. When we arrived at the property. there was no one around. After about a half hour, my husband walked around to the upper areas and finally found someone cleaning rooms. Finally got a key to the room.

The lodge was lovely, but our room was small with a nightstand and lamp on one side of the bed so only one person could read or put an item next to the bed. The in room air conditioner took up the limited floor space making it more cramped.