Great property with a fantastic location. Reasonably priced and nice service from front desk, valet, etc. Room was really hot. Uncomfortably stuffy. They don’t turn on the air conditioning until May, so an April stay kept the air in the room quite stale. Otherwise, this was a good choice, and would recommend.

I had a good stay in the Penthouse Suites. They were nice. The price was excellent, and although the rooms are a little dated, they seemed very clean. The housekeeping was excellent (always replacing towels and offering nighttime turn-down). The rooms were noticeably quiet with only the heater running. The temperature was kept at a perfect level for some cold days (not too cold or hot). These suites give a lot of room, but my room was two levels, and I really did not need the top level bathroom. The rooms have half kitchens, so that was great. Overall, this was excellent value compared to staying at another hotel with single small room.

Perfect location. Right coner of the carnegie hall. Safe to walk in night. Friedly staff and wider room space. But fan in the room is a little noisy.

I have stayed in this hotel before with no issue. I was given with a room that had the extractor fans for the whole building located outside the window. The noise was deafening. Also, I could not heat my room and I was cold. I was assured these issues would be resolved early the next morning. The way I was treated the next day was horrific. I was told that I would have to check out by 11am and wait until 4pm to get a new room. The reason I was in New York on Friday was because I had plans on Saturday. I said that if I had to check out, I wouldn’t be checking back in and I wouldn’t be paying for the remainder of the stay. The manager said that was fine. I was also informed that the heating was switched to neutral for the hotel and I could not heat my room. When I checked out (at 1.30pm, after hotels.com spending 45 mins on the phone trying to resolve this ), I informed the staff that they were not authorised to charge anything further to my card. I recorded myself stating that to protect myself. During this, another member of staff came over and acted aggressively to me and then threatened me with the police. I have never experienced such behaviour in a hotel. Big thanks to the doormen who treated me kindly as I was very shaken. All staff I encountered agreed with me that it was excessive noise. My bank contacted me to inform that this property has tried to charge for the WHOLE stay despite my non-authorisation so they acted fraudulently. Hotels.com have not helped

Can not fault this property. Location unbeatable, staff so helpful & even though my style is more minimalist the one bedroom room is so big & comfortable, and offered so much privacy for me and my mum in a one bedroom suite with two bathrooms. I've been lucky enough to stay in some of New York's best hotels and I think I'll return here over all of them for the space and convenience . Thank you to the entire team.

Great location, great hotel. Central park, subways are steps aways. Best location in Manhattan. Rooms are spacious. Service are good.

I would highly recommend this stay for a family or for people spending a long time in New York. Our room was extremely spacious—A living area with kitchenette and small dining table, a bedroom, and two bathrooms. The customer service was terrific. The valet parking was reasonably priced and convenient. There was no self parking, which I would normally opt for. But the valet service was so prompt and convenient that I was glad to have it. The hotel was clean and well appointed. The location was tops. Very close to Central Park, with many delis, small restaurants, and coffee shops close by for a quick bite to eat. The location and the space of the room were the highlights for us. Can’t be beat. The one criticism (though it didn’t bother us at all!) is that the rooms (at least the one we were in) were not updated. The dining table showed a lot of wear and tear, for example. And the decor was not modern. So, if it’s important to you to have a glitzy, modern, Instagrammable hotel, this may not be for you. But if having a spacious room in an unbeatable Manhattan location, and excellent customer service are most important to you, book now!

Staff was great. Hotel was clean. Great gym & lounge. Location is superb for broadway and central park activities!

Excellent in every way!

It was great that everyone served so kindly and diligently.

It was easy to find and had parking

Never stayed at the Manhattan Club. Canceled via Expedia within 1 business day, Expedia told me all was fine to book elsewhere just to find out after the weekend this was not the case. Now the hotel is holding $1000 for a future use within 6 months, which is unlikely for me make. This is a shared 1 star for both the Hotel and Expedia for an absolutely awful and disjointed customer experience.

Great location, clean, good rooms with everithing you need. The staff is great. I don't understand the $500 deposit, I believe it is too much.

We had a great time at The Manhattan Club this past week. We spent 5 nights in one of the penthouse suites and we were not disappointed in the space. Two bathrooms, so much room for our kids and ourselves, nice views, we loved it! A few downsides were the sound of the elevator that made thumping sounds all night long, but eventually got use to it, and some of the furniture was a bit worn down (ie.the chairs lost a few screws). Otherwise, everything was great! Staff was helpful and nice, we felt safe and the location was everything. We’ll definitely stay there again when we go back to NYC!

Room temperature at 75 or more Staff suggestion - open window Horrible experience - service horrible Problems with plumbing

Very comfortable stay

The staff is very hospitable, kind and professional. The decor is up to date and lovely. The lounge is cozy, relaxing and has a nice view at night. There are some knicks in the older furniture pieces and a piece of the carpet in our room was cut short (these LITTLE details are the only reason for 4 stars and not 5). Excellent stay.

Great location and staff. You’re right in the heart of Manhattan.

We went to the Manhattan club to celebrate our mom’s 80th birthday (she lives out of state). We told the hotel the reason for our visit. They were so nice and accommodating. They definitely helped to make her birthday weekend very special with some special touches.

Staff was amazing in every are of the hotel! Thank you we will be back.

Wonderful service, attentive concierge. Rooms look like they haven't been updated since 1995 - the drawers would not stay closed and the decor made things feel dirtier than they were. Unfortunately, we will not be staying at The Manhattan Club again.

Shouldn’t be rated as a 4 star. Rooms are big but very dated and smelled of old furniture. Sofa in my room had stains so did the armchair which was also ripped. No ventilation. Staff are wonderful. Great that the room had a fridge.

Our stay was perfect. Staff was amazing

Chose this hotel for its proximity to Lincoln Center, kitchenette, and ability to check in after midnight. It was a delight with friendly staff, comfortable beds, and ability to walk to everywhere my daughter wanted to go-Central Park, MoMA, 5th Ave/57th street shopping, and more.

Everyone was so welcoming and kind to my family! We will definitely be staying here next time we come to NYC!

Fantastic location, amazing room, great service. Perfect first visit to NYC

Great Location. Comfortable and spacious room. Friendly and helpful staff. Had a great stay - would certainly stay here again!

Very nice room....big for NYC standards.

Amazing room, location and staff!

Great location and condition

Great place to stay in New York City. Very central to many sites. Reception and all staff are excellent and very helpful. Special thanks to Jerry for his assistance with our stay. Highly recommended.

It is very conveniently located