It was really great. I love the bar that they had there and it was in a great location where so many things were walkable and the free bikes and beach towels is also a nice touch. I would definitely go there again.

Great

Great

Great place enjoyed it only thing is it’s loud at night cause of the restraunts and bars outside but other than that perfect place to stay

Great place enjoyed it only thing is it’s loud at night cause of the restraunts and bars outside but other than that perfect place to stay

Best spot in Greenport

Best spot in Greenport

A clean, beautiful stay right in the heart of Greenport. Friendly, accommodating staff. Overall great experience. Absolutely great stay and we will be back soon!

A guests worst nightmare. Don’t stay at this hotel The staff and GM lack decency for their hotel guests and won’t disclose if the hotel has been rented out for a large scale event. If the rooms aren’t completely blocked out, beware, you could be exiled to your room of the 13 room hotel, as the square will be closed to non- event guests. You cannot use the hotel bar, restaurants, any of the restaurants in the square and imagine a large event is steps away from your room, dance floor, dj and announcements at full blast for 5 hours. The hotel did not respond a week after I left several messages for them and the staff on site during our stay did not have a plan for their paying guest not part of the event and never disclosed this information at any time during our stay. They refused to acknowledge a large scale private event that closed out the hotel and surroundings spaces would be an inconvenience to their other guests. Can you imagine?!

A guests worst nightmare. Don’t stay at this hotel The staff and GM lack decency for their hotel guests and won’t disclose if the hotel has been rented out for a large scale event. If the rooms aren’t completely blocked out, beware, you could be exiled to your room of the 13 room hotel, as the square will be closed to non- event guests. You cannot use the hotel bar, restaurants, any of the restaurants in the square and imagine a large event is steps away from your room, dance floor, dj and announcements at full blast for 5 hours. The hotel did not respond a week after I left several messages for them and the staff on site during our stay did not have a plan for their paying guest not part of the event and never disclosed this information at any time during our stay. They refused to acknowledge a large scale private event that closed out the hotel and surroundings spaces would be an inconvenience to their other guests. Can you imagine?!

We stayed during the final night before move into our new house wanting a quiet night before the move. What we discovered is that there is a bar located below the room and an outdoor cafe below the window. The hotel room throbbed with the bass of the music late into the night. It was a miserable stay. If you are at all health conscious, you won’t enjoy the breakfast and will want to skip it and go out. It was, overall, a miserable stay.

We stayed during the final night before move into our new house wanting a quiet night before the move. What we discovered is that there is a bar located below the room and an outdoor cafe below the window. The hotel room throbbed with the bass of the music late into the night. It was a miserable stay. If you are at all health conscious, you won’t enjoy the breakfast and will want to skip it and go out. It was, overall, a miserable stay.

A beautiful and very relaxing place to stay. Really appreciated the little touches like a breakfast basket delivered to your doorstep in the morning! Very friendly and helpful staff too. Perfect place for a Long Island getaway!

A beautiful and very relaxing place to stay. Really appreciated the little touches like a breakfast basket delivered to your doorstep in the morning! Very friendly and helpful staff too. Perfect place for a Long Island getaway!

We live locally but wanted to try it out in the off season for a quick staycation. Our stay was a sweet treat! Inviting decor and we enjoyed our breakfast in bed. We made mimosas with the fresh OJ!

We live locally but wanted to try it out in the off season for a quick staycation. Our stay was a sweet treat! Inviting decor and we enjoyed our breakfast in bed. We made mimosas with the fresh OJ!

Great stay and service.

Great stay and service.

It was a lovely stay around NYE celebrations. The staff was very responsive, just wish they would seemed a bit happier to be there. Hard to find anyone with a smile. We tried to engage in conversations to let them know we appreciated them but maybe the management team needs to have a team building or take the team for dinner or something. And cheer everyone up!

It was a lovely stay around NYE celebrations. The staff was very responsive, just wish they would seemed a bit happier to be there. Hard to find anyone with a smile. We tried to engage in conversations to let them know we appreciated them but maybe the management team needs to have a team building or take the team for dinner or something. And cheer everyone up!

Great stay!

Great stay!

The overall service was excellent and the room was clean quiet and comfortable. The staff was very attentive to detail and made my stay hassle free.

The overall service was excellent and the room was clean quiet and comfortable. The staff was very attentive to detail and made my stay hassle free.

We loved our stay here! We wanted a quiet, quick local getaway and this was the perfect place. The staff was extremely nice and the room was clean and fun. The breakfast basket delivered to the room was the cutest. We will definitely be visiting again.

We loved our stay here! We wanted a quiet, quick local getaway and this was the perfect place. The staff was extremely nice and the room was clean and fun. The breakfast basket delivered to the room was the cutest. We will definitely be visiting again.

Clean, responsive and courteous

Clean, responsive and courteous

Avoid this hotel if you go to sleep before 3 am. Our room was above an empty storefront or so I thought. It turned into a bar at night and we had to listen to people yelling and the door opening and closing until 3 am. In addition, there are outdoor bars with live music on the property. We couldn’t sleep and checked out a day early but the hotel wouldn’t refund our money, relying on something we signed saying we wouldn’t be refunded if we left early. We didn’t expect that the conditions would be so bad that we had to check out, we had not planned on it. We lost $850 and a night of our vacation because the hotel was deceptive in its description of the property. Luxury to me usually means being able to sleep at a decent hour. If you are over 25 or go to sleep before 3 am, avoid this hotel. It’s a shame because the rooms are nice and the property is nice during the day. What they don’t tell you is that you essentially are living in the middle of a bar at night. The management acts like it advises you of the noise on the website. It is deceptive by putting in one line under a room stating where the room is located. That does NOT state you can’t sleep.

Avoid this hotel if you go to sleep before 3 am. Our room was above an empty storefront or so I thought. It turned into a bar at night and we had to listen to people yelling and the door opening and closing until 3 am. In addition, there are outdoor bars with live music on the property. We couldn’t sleep and checked out a day early but the hotel wouldn’t refund our money, relying on something we signed saying we wouldn’t be refunded if we left early. We didn’t expect that the conditions would be so bad that we had to check out, we had not planned on it. We lost $850 and a night of our vacation because the hotel was deceptive in its description of the property. Luxury to me usually means being able to sleep at a decent hour. If you are over 25 or go to sleep before 3 am, avoid this hotel. It’s a shame because the rooms are nice and the property is nice during the day. What they don’t tell you is that you essentially are living in the middle of a bar at night. The management acts like it advises you of the noise on the website. It is deceptive by putting in one line under a room stating where the room is located. That does NOT state you can’t sleep.

Rooms were nicely decorated. Staff very nice.

We must express our deep dissatisfaction with our stay at American Beech. Throughout our extensive travels, we have never encountered a situation where our accommodations were situated directly above a bar and restaurant, where you could hear every sound. There is no sound proofing or attempt to minimize the noise. The continuous music and loud noise, which commenced at 5pm and persisted until well after 1am, rendered it impossible for us to focus on work or get a restful night's sleep.