Waterfront Estate on Shelter Island - 200 Feet of Waterfront - 100 Foot Dock

9.8

Outstanding(27 Reviews)

House in Shelter Island, NY

8 guests · 4 bedrooms · 3 baths

Reasons to book

Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating

Top-tier experienceOne of the higher cost properties in the area

Includes essentialsGarden, Pool, Kitchen or Kitchenette and more

About this house rental

Year round retreat on your own private waterfront estate with a meticulously renovated 1816 cedar shake house. Water views from almost every room! You will enjoy a private 2 acre parcel with a private dock on Shelter Island's beautiful Coecles Harbor. A covered entry porch opens to a delightful living room with fireplace, newly renovated kitchen, dining area, sunporch and deck. There is also a main floor master bedroom suite with spacious marble bath. The second floor features a 2nd master bedroom with ensuite full bath and private waterside balcony deck, plus two additional bedrooms and full bath. Sweeping lawns with sheltering trees lead gracefully to the waterfront dock. This wonderful property is the perfect summer retreat for swimming, fishing and boating enthusiasts. Strong Wi-Fi on both floors. 5G extender.

Keywords: Two acres of beautiful waterfront with fully renovated waterfront house, with marble baths, large french doors facing the harbor, opening to a large deck. Very large yard to water 200 feet of waterfront in yard with dock.

NOTE: There is no lifeguard on duty at our property. Swimmers swim at their own risk.

Amenities

Pool

Air conditioner

Kitchen or Kitchenette

Internet / Wifi

Fireplace

Parking

Laundry

Balcony or Patio

Dishwasher

Garden

Map of Shelter Island, NY

Nearby attractions

Montauk Point State Park

23 mi

Mystic Aquarium

27.9 mi

Gillette Castle State Park

24.4 mi

Montauk Lighthouse Museum

24.2 mi

$$$$

Waterfront Estate on Shelter Island - 200 Feet of Waterfront - 100 Foot Dock

$$$$

9.8

Outstanding(27 Reviews)

House in Shelter Island, NY

8 guests · 4 bedrooms · 3 baths

Reasons to book

Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating

Top-tier experienceOne of the higher cost properties in the area

Includes essentialsGarden, Pool, Kitchen or Kitchenette and more

About this house rental

Amenities

Pool

Air conditioner

Kitchen or Kitchenette

Internet / Wifi

Fireplace

Parking

Laundry

Balcony or Patio

Dishwasher

Garden

Map of Shelter Island, NY

Nearby attractions

Montauk Point State Park

23 mi

Mystic Aquarium

27.9 mi

Gillette Castle State Park

24.4 mi

Montauk Lighthouse Museum

24.2 mi

Reviews

9.8

Outstanding(27 Reviews)

10.0

Aug 2023

Classic shelter island house on the water. Close to everything and super quiet location.

10.0

Jul 2023

As we drove down the block we realized there would be no photo to give you the feeling you would have going into the long driveway. The house sits on a beautiful large piece of property. The location is very peaceful. The view from the backyard was fantastic. The 🌅 sunrises were beautiful. The house has a deck in the back perfect to have a nice dinner. One of my favorite area was the porch with windows and screens. A great place to work or sit and relax. The master bed and bath were perfect size and very accommodating. The other bedrooms were equally as nice. Everyone in my family felt it was one of the nicest homes we have rented. It was also the first time staying on Shelter Island and we love it. Our host was very timely helping us with any questions we had. The photos listed, but no photo could capture the beautiful, peaceful home and property

10.0

Jan 2023

Incredibly beautiful location on harbor with breathtaking sunrise - close to everything , well equipped, 2 comfortable masters and 2 smaller bedrooms - very homey

10.0

Aug 2022

This rental is outstanding; highly recommended! We loved every minute of our stay, and would certainly rent it again if available.

8.0

Jul 2022

Lovely property and view. Hard to access water from dock as steps are not well maintained but the views are beautiful. The kitchen is very well equipped except guests should bring a knife sharpener ! All rooms are very well decorated and comfortable. Takes a genius to figure out audiovisual system and even the very accommodating host had difficulty trying to explain it. But we seldom wanted to watch VCR or TV and we loved our stay!

10.0

Sep 2021

We enjoyed paddleboarding off the dock, particularly. We had to cut our visit a little short because of the storm. Plenty of nooks for people to work remotely. Edward was very responsive to any little request! Send beach towels overnight, et cetera.

10.0

Sep 2020

On the day we were set to depart, my grandson grabbed his fishing rod, walked down to the water, and caught himself a striped bass from the dock (no bait needed). It was a fitting end to a wonderful month-long stay on Shelter Island. Life couldn’t have been easier on North Cartwright. Each day, several times, we walked out the door and onto the dock to wash some lures or take a dip, relaxed in the living room overlooking Coecles Harbor, had a chat while completing a Puzzle of the North Ferry in 1815 on the lovely screened in porch, or took a lounge on the spacious deck. If baking is your thing, as it is mine, the kitchen is well stocked; cooking on the new grill (bought while we were there, as a matter of fact) was a breeze too. And through it all, Edward couldn’t have been more helpful. If we needed anything, he was happy to oblige. As for Shelter Island itself, this was our first time staying, and it exceeded our expectations, both for its spacious beauty and its calm pace of life. All in all, my family heartily recommends.

10.0

Jun 2020

We stayed at Edward and Tracy’s oasis in Shelter island for a month. Words cannot express the magic of this house and property. We created lifelong memories, taking advantage of the amazing view, lawn and dock. We came during C-19 to shelter in place and escape NYC and there couldn’t have been a more perfect place with ample workstations, super fast wifi, a kitchen with all the gadgets for your at-home chef dreams and tranquility in the beautifully made up bedrooms that felt like you were in a boutique hotel! Edward and Tracy really made us feel safe, making sure we had ample supplies and ensuring the house was fully sanitized before we stayed. There is so much to do at the property that you don't ever need to leave including swimming off the dock, lovely picnics on the lawn at sun set, grilling on the patio, taking a bath that overlooks the water and meditating on the dock. This was perfect for us to shelter in place in shelter island :) Although we never really needed to leave we do highly recommend the lobster and oysters from Commander Cody after going for hikes in the nature preserve a mile away…! We couldn’t recommend their home more, we feel very grateful for Edward and Tracy opening up their house and they were an absolute pleasure in all of our communications and all. We cannot wait to go back. Thank you Edward and Tracy!

10.0

Jul 2018

Rented this house for the month of June, 2018. Loved every second of it and hated to leave. The house is at the end of a quiet drive and looks out onto Coecles Harbor. The view is stunning. Everything about the house- the layout, the furniture, the linens, the view of the harbor- everything exudes beauty, comfort and calm. As if the house itself isn’t perfect enough, the owners Edward and Tracey are the nicest people you will ever speak to or meet. They are easy to work with, are very reasonable and accommodating, and responsive. I do not have the slightest negative comment to make about the house, the owners or my trip. If I could go back tomorrow I would.

10.0

Jun 2018

This home was a perfect spot for our 3 generations to spend time relaxing on and exploring Shelter Island. The master bedroom on the first floor and 3 additional private bedrooms on the second floor suited us well. The enormous yards both front and back made us feel we were the only ones on the Island. There was no one else in sight. We enjoyed cocktails and apps on the deck with the views of the water and under fabulous tall trees. The dock was a great place from which to swim and feel the warm sun. Without moving the car you can bike anywhere on the island or take long walks into the Center or out onto Ram Island. We also took a lovely walk through Mashomack Preserve which offers 12 miles of inland and coastal trails. An afternoon on Silver Beach provided some sand. The cozy living room was just the place to watch the storms across the water when we had a rainy day.

10.0

Apr 2018

Shelter Island was a very cool vacation destination. This rental house was charming. Bedrooms were very comfortable - providing excellent nights' sleep and spectacular sunrises over the water. Were snowed in one day but had brought in plenty of food so with hot coffee and tea and some DVDs, we were set. So easy to use the ferry to get to wineries on the north fork and sightseeing and shopping on the south fork. It was a great stay. Perhaps we will try this again when the weather is warmer. Thank you Edward for your hospitality.

5.0

Dec 2017

We are old hats at the Home Away game and have stayed in many many homes over the years. Our trip of 4 nights during the Thanksgiving holiday to this lovely Shelter Island property was really amazing. This is property must be ranked as one of the best amongst some pretty tough competitors. Firstly, the owner Edward was absolutely fantastic to work with. He is a consummate professional, responsive, and so communicative, and simply said, so nice. Secondly, the home was exactly as described: clean, serene, functional, historic but cozy, relaxing, and so user-friendly. We spent time walking the grounds, cooking in the kitchen that overlooks the harbor, and sitting by roaring fires while sipping Irish Coffees, what could be better? To top it all off, the house truly feels like a home, not a rarely used second house. Aside from the great photos and look of the property, part of the reason we wanted to stay at the home was all of the great previously written reviews. After our stay, I am happy to add to that roster and we will plan to surely be back again. Edward - thank you again for all of the communications leading up to our trip, it was a blast!

5.0

Dec 2017

We are "old hats" at the Home Away game and have rented properties all over the country, some were great, some were subpar. This Shelter Island home is ranked at the very top of the list for many reasons. Firstly, Edward (property owner) was absolutely amazing to communicate with. He is flexible, communicative, and so helpful. Secondly, the house itself was more than a house, it truly is a home. It is warm, cozy, clean, and has a real cared for feel. Unlike some home rentals, where you feel that the property is a second house used for income and seldom cared for and enjoyed by the actual owners, this home feels very lived in, loved, and very up to date. You feel that in the home immediately upon entering! Further, the property was beautiful, quiet, serene, and a the home has a real "step out of time" while still feeling so comfortable, what a perfect blend, just amazing (house dates to the early 1800's). The kitchen is highly functional, the bedrooms are clean and quaint, all linens were in top repair, and the fireplace (wood burning) was just awesome for those cold nights. The house was larger than we expected, but still very comfortable for a small party of just two! Really delightful. The house, property, and the fantastic owner make this an easy answer to any desired seaside North East vacation. We are looking forward to many returns in the future. It was an awesome 4 day holiday. Thank you again, Edward!!

5.0

Oct 2017

Absolutely beautiful property. Edward was extremely accommodating. Our time at the home was better than we imagined. We left wishing we could stay longer! We'll definitely be coming back.

5.0

Jul 2017

Our 2nd year at Ed's shelter island house. House was clean and well kept. House is just as pictures show. We had 8 of us 4 adults and 4 kids. Kids enjoyed all activities we bought with us on the well kept yard. We had power wheels, bikes, slip-in slide, a pool, corn hole, catch baseball &football, we brought a small blow up pool and kayaks. We had our boat out on the dock which was great we went somewhere everyday. House was pleanty of room for us and look forward to going back for years to come. I would recommend this house to anyone going to shelter island for a vacation as it has gorgeous views of harbor and very peaceful property.

FAQs

How much does this house cost compared to others in Shelter Island?

The average price for a rental in Shelter Island is $720 per night. This rental is $44 above the average.

Is parking included with this house?

Yes, parking is listed as an amenity at Waterfront Estate on Shelter Island - 200 Feet of Waterfront - 100 Foot Dock. For more information, we encourage you to contact the property about where to park.

Is there a pool at this house?

Yes, a swimming pool is available for use at Waterfront Estate on Shelter Island - 200 Feet of Waterfront - 100 Foot Dock. Enjoy the water!

Is Waterfront Estate on Shelter Island - 200 Feet of Waterfront - 100 Foot Dock pet friendly?

Unfortunately, this house is not pet-friendly. Try searching again and filter for "Pets Allowed"

What amenities are available at Waterfront Estate on Shelter Island - 200 Feet of Waterfront - 100 Foot Dock?

We found 11 amenities for this rental. This includes pool, air conditioner, kitchen or kitchenette, internet / wifi, and fireplace.

Explore similar vacation rentals in Shelter Island

Explore all rentals in Shelter Island

8.0

Very good(22 Reviews)

House on Chase Creek

Bed and Breakfast

in Shelter Island Heights

1 sofa bed, 1 queen bed

Garden · Air conditioner · Internet / Wifi

Indulge in a peaceful retreat at House on Chase Creek, our elegant Bed and Breakfast in Shelter Island. Enjoy amenities including Air conditioner, Fireplace and Internet / Wifi, and more.

$$$$

Waterfront Estate on Shelter Island - 200 Feet of Waterfront - 100 Foot Dock

House in Shelter Island, NY

Reasons to book

About this house rental

Amenities

Map of Shelter Island, NY

Nearby attractions

Waterfront Estate on Shelter Island - 200 Feet of Waterfront - 100 Foot Dock

House in Shelter Island, NY

Reasons to book

About this house rental

Amenities

Map of Shelter Island, NY

Nearby attractions

Reviews

FAQs

How much does this house cost compared to others in Shelter Island?

Is parking included with this house?

Is there a pool at this house?

Is Waterfront Estate on Shelter Island - 200 Feet of Waterfront - 100 Foot Dock pet friendly?

What amenities are available at Waterfront Estate on Shelter Island - 200 Feet of Waterfront - 100 Foot Dock?

Explore similar vacation rentals in Shelter Island

Shelter Island travel inspiration

Related vacation destinations

Keep exploring