Wonderful Rustic Lake House On Cayuga Lake only 2.5 Miles From Downtown Ithaca!

9.8

Outstanding(34 Reviews)

House in Cayuga Lake, NY

6 guests · 5 bedrooms · 3 baths

Reasons to book

Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating

Great for petsBring all your friends and family, even the furry ones

Includes essentialsGarden, Pets allowed, Kitchen or Kitchenette and more

About this house rental

Fabulous rustic lake property on Cayuga Lake (circa 1890) only 2.5 miles from downtown Ithaca. 330 feet of frontage with full sun all day and awesome sunsets. Huge dock! Hot tub! Deep water! Incredible lawns and surprisingly private. Age requirement for guests (excluding kids) is 30+.

In case it is not clear in the booking process, our nightly rate is for 2 people and it is an additional $75 per night per person over 2 people, up to our maximum of 6 people.

Our lake house has 5 bedrooms:
Queen Master bedroom downstairs.
King Master bedroom upstairs.
2 Queen bedrooms upstairs.
1 Full size bedroom upstairs.

And we have 2.5 baths (one downstairs, one upstairs and 1/2 bath in third floor attic).

Our hot tub sits on the water's edge and our dock is HUGE, with a covered seating portion and water slide.

Ithaca is a wonderful small town in the heart of the Finger Lakes. Home to Cornell University, Ithaca College, many wineries and a rich culture, Ithaca is a great town to visit!

We have plenty of room for parking (another bonus)! Can fit 5 cars pretty easily. Public transportation does not make its way up the lake. But you an always walk down the railroad tracks 2 miles right into town. Or, you can paddle your way to the Ithaca Farmer's Market, to Stewart Park, Cass Park or Allan Treman State Park.

Amenities

Pets allowed

Kitchen or Kitchenette

Internet / Wifi

Parking

Laundry

Balcony or Patio

Dishwasher

Hot tub or spa

Garden

Map of Cayuga Lake, NY

Nearby attractions

Watkins Glen State Park

19.8 mi

Taughannock Falls State Park

6.5 mi

Buttermilk Falls State Park

4.5 mi

Ithaca Falls Natural Area

2.1 mi

$$$$

Wonderful Rustic Lake House On Cayuga Lake only 2.5 Miles From Downtown Ithaca!

$$$$

9.8

Outstanding(34 Reviews)

House in Cayuga Lake, NY

6 guests · 5 bedrooms · 3 baths

Reasons to book

Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating

Great for petsBring all your friends and family, even the furry ones

Includes essentialsGarden, Pets allowed, Kitchen or Kitchenette and more

About this house rental

Amenities

Pets allowed

Kitchen or Kitchenette

Internet / Wifi

Parking

Laundry

Balcony or Patio

Dishwasher

Hot tub or spa

Garden

Map of Cayuga Lake, NY

Nearby attractions

Watkins Glen State Park

19.8 mi

Taughannock Falls State Park

6.5 mi

Buttermilk Falls State Park

4.5 mi

Ithaca Falls Natural Area

2.1 mi

Reviews

9.8

Outstanding(34 Reviews)

10.0

May 2024

Great cabin with lovely views of the lake and fabulous dock for fishing and relaxing. Lots of outdoor space to dine…great stay for our graduation weekend with close proximity to Ithaca town and campus.

10.0

May 2024

We had an unexpected event and Zach was amazing accommodating us for our return visit. The property is fantastic and so comfortable. We look forward to staying again!

10.0

Apr 2024

The place was awesome!!! Can’t wait to stay again.

10.0

Mar 2024

I would definitely stay there again.

10.0

May 2023

The property was perfect for us! Zach was a great host and very attentive! Super relaxing evenings watching the sunset over the water and close to everything! Thanks Zach! Enjoy your summer!!

10.0

May 2023

Our daughter graduated from Ithaca and we booked this home for our family to all be together. Lovely lake location and convenient to campus and town. Cooked at home to stay out of the graduation crowds and the kitchen was very nice set up with all that we would need. Stay here . . . You will LOVE it!

10.0

Apr 2023

The house was as described and pictured, a mix of old school charm with modern upgrades. The dock is amazing and great for hanging out inside or outside. Close to food and hiking.

10.0

Mar 2023

Awesome spot to decompress after stressful college daily tours during a snow filled winter weekend. Amazing home that has a lot of stories to tell. The huge ceilings, beautiful refinished floors, outdoor porches at every level, comfy beds, and plenty of space for our mature dogs to explore off lead. The owner is great! We cannot wait to revisit in warm weather. Highly recommend :)

10.0

Feb 2023

We were up for a week hoping for snow for our dogs, no snow but a great house. Zach couldn't have been nicer or more helpful! The beds were comfortable. The house was in a good location and the dock is amazing. The driveway is steep so please follow the drive in instructions. Thanks again Zach for your quick responses and the great home away from home.

10.0

Dec 2022

The four of us, all adults, had a relaxing stay during an historic winter storm that pummeled parts of the state. The wind was cold, but we figured out how to use supplemental heaters that were plenty adequate. We enjoyed the hot tub, which we are not familiar with, and somehow the heat setting got set for a standby mode, so it was not hot enough to use for most of the stay. Our host was hospitable and welcoming.

10.0

Nov 2022

Plenty of room. Lovely views.

10.0

Sep 2022

This house is truly lakefront and well-equipped! Couldn't have asked for more - we were a short drive to Cornell as well as the wineries, and got to enjoy the huge dock and lake amenities. We had tons of space, as well. The house has everything you could want. Zach mentions in his listing, but just want to emphasize, that driveway is not for the faint of heart! But follow his instructions and you'll survive :)

10.0

Jun 2022

Charming historic lake house! Beautiful views from every deck with plenty of seating. The yard and dock provided hours of enjoyment for our family. Overall very comfortable with everything that we needed.

3.0

May 2022

Great hosts and location! The house is rustic and charming but maybe not a good fit for anyone afraid of spiders or snakes. Driveway is a bit tricky too. It was convenient to get to Cornell and has very nice views.

10.0

May 2022

The owner was extremely responsive at all stages. The house was perfect for our needs and even nicer than pictured. We felt comfortable and welcomed.

10.0

May 2022

This property is rustic but cozy, lots of outdoor space to enjoy right on the lake. Great location close to lots of hiking spots and wineries. Thanks Zach, we had a blast!!

5.0

Mar 2022

Beautiful house incredibly spacious with very friendly host. Thank you so much we loved our stay!!

5.0

Nov 2021

We rented the property for IC Parent's weekend. Zack was a wonderful host! The property is absolutely gorgeous! There is a a bedroom on the first floor which was perfect for my elderly in-laws.

5.0

May 2021

The description of the property does not do it justice. Amazing waterfront property with everything that you need for a great time by the lake, and convenient to Ithaca. Only warning is about driveway entrance, short, steep and crooked, but we all survived. Zach was available for any questions that we had and a great host. We lucked out with the weather for a great graduation weekend.

5.0

May 2021

We had a lovely 4 day weekend at this lake house. The views, particularly the sunsets, are amazing. The house had available pretty much anything you needed for recreation (life vests, kayaks, fishing gear) and the swings at the end of the dock were a lot of fun. I gently caution potential guests to understand the information that Zach very plainly discloses about the angle of the driveway. Despite having ample warnings (and I appreciate him making sure we were aware of the best way to approach the driveway) the angle is such that if your car is fairly low to the ground you may have scraping. Wouldn’t be a big deal for a SUV but I imagine something like a sports car would have trouble. We drove a minivan and scraped 4 out of 6 times. Just something to consider when planning your trip. The home itself is older and decorated in a rustic/eclectic way, which was very nice. The kitchen was adequate and open to the living room, which was perfect for our gathering. Zach was friendly and approachable. I would return again (maybe in an SUV next time).

5.0

Oct 2020

Lovely place on the lake, great views. Though it was too cold when we visited, I can imagine that this will be a lot of fun in warmer weather

5.0

Oct 2019

Wonderful lake house with everything you would want or need. A joy to be there in the morning or evening. Can't wait to come back!

FAQs

How much does this house cost compared to others in Cayuga Lake?

The average price for a rental in Cayuga Lake is $325 per night. This rental is $79 less expensive than the average.

Is parking included with this house?

Yes, parking is listed as an amenity at Wonderful Rustic Lake House On Cayuga Lake only 2.5 Miles From Downtown Ithaca!. For more information, we encourage you to contact the property about where to park.

Is there a pool at this house?

We didn’t find pool listed as an amenity for this house. It may be worth double checking if a pool is important for your stay.

Is Wonderful Rustic Lake House On Cayuga Lake only 2.5 Miles From Downtown Ithaca! pet friendly?

Yes! This house is pet-friendly. For more information, we recommend contacting the booking provider about animal policies.

What amenities are available at Wonderful Rustic Lake House On Cayuga Lake only 2.5 Miles From Downtown Ithaca!?

We found 10 amenities for this rental. This includes pets allowed, kitchen or kitchenette, internet / wifi, parking, and laundry.

Explore similar vacation rentals in Cayuga Lake

Explore all rentals in Cayuga Lake

10.0

Outstanding(1 Review)

Auburn Vacation Rental Home Near Owasco Lake!

House

in Auburn

Garden · Kitchen or Kitchenette · Air conditioner

This House for $239 in Cayuga Lake, is perfect for your next (business stay, family stay, couples stay, getaway vacation, etc.)

$$$$

Wonderful Rustic Lake House On Cayuga Lake only 2.5 Miles From Downtown Ithaca!

House in Cayuga Lake, NY

Reasons to book

About this house rental

Amenities

Map of Cayuga Lake, NY

Nearby attractions

Wonderful Rustic Lake House On Cayuga Lake only 2.5 Miles From Downtown Ithaca!

House in Cayuga Lake, NY

Reasons to book

About this house rental

Amenities

Map of Cayuga Lake, NY

Nearby attractions

Reviews

FAQs

How much does this house cost compared to others in Cayuga Lake?

Is parking included with this house?

Is there a pool at this house?

Is Wonderful Rustic Lake House On Cayuga Lake only 2.5 Miles From Downtown Ithaca! pet friendly?

What amenities are available at Wonderful Rustic Lake House On Cayuga Lake only 2.5 Miles From Downtown Ithaca!?

Explore similar vacation rentals in Cayuga Lake

Cayuga Lake travel inspiration

Related vacation destinations

Keep exploring