Our crews arrived to unmade beds, beers in the sink, bathroom garbage full, dog hairs on the bed and bedding. Didn’t look or smell clean. 0 out 10 for the cleaning. Everything else, was ok.

The proximity to Hedgehog Harbor was incredible! So much water fowl—gulls, terns, pelicans—action to watch!! Magnificent sunsets, even with the wildfire haze! Wonderful history of this house. We thoroughly enjoyed our stay and would like to return. :)

Check in was a bit dicey. Upon arrival, we found it had not been cleaned and certain expecrations not met (key on table, WIFI not present, side storm door was open, coffee table was flipped upside down on couch, used towel in bathroom, etc). A quick phone call to manager was well received. She was very apologetic and quickly offered to make things right. The nex day, housekeepers were in and cleaned and took care of issues. Remainder of stay was quite confortable and acceptable.

Got to meet Lyle who grew up in this house and gave us a sense of the family history. He by the way, was very quick to answer our call for fireplace pellets. The house could use some upkeep and exterior clean up but was comfortable and cozy. Loved having the grill and more importantly, the firepit outside allowed a view of the star filled night sky. Amazingly, blissfully quiet and peaceful. A wonderful get away.

Clean, comfortable. Great location. Could use some sprucing up- particularly outdoors.

We stayed here for a couple nights! All was well. It’s like a fishing cottage- great views, relaxing, out of the way, no frills.

Retro, mostly clean, quiet, place to stay. Had all the essentials to make a stay relaxing. Had lots of room but only one bathroom. Since we were not in a hurry that was no big deal. Nice water view and saw lots of wildlife. The squirrels were the most entertaining! We had beautiful weather, it would have been nice to be able to open up the windows and let the fresh air in. The window were either full of cobwebs and spiders or the windows did not open. They did have all the air conditioning that you need though! The beds were super comfortable and nice bedding! The stairs were a little creaky but that played into the old charm of the place. We locked ourselves out of the house by accident and they returned our call and sent someone to open the door! We learned the area is very safe and no need to lock doors but we all came from big cities and have a habit of locking doors. We played games they provided one night and had fun. Did not have good cell reception but we were trying to get away from technology, so that’s was good. The one thing that was missing in the kitchen was wine glasses, but did have a wine opener. Looks like they are slowly updating some of the things in the house. Everything was in good working order! The only regret was not making a fire out back.

Very rustic place could use some updating. A really peaceful neighborhood when the neighbor isnt driving his truck right by your windows and everyone leaves after holiday . We loved the view of lake michgan siting in the glider and chairs outside. Coffee in the morning was awesome and our two dogs enjoyed themselves too when thay could be out after everyone next door were gone tho looks like you aren't letting people bring the dogs anymore good luck with that !!!there is still rentals that allow.The house was cozy comfy once we settled in for the week. I must say it would have been nice to have wifi to actually watch our shows at night thank goodness for utube TV to get through the week. all and all it was a beautiful stay and we did get to do all the stuff we love and go to all the stores to shop . we love door county and come every year and still will. Thank You for letting us stay in your historic lodge home. m.

Quaint old fishing cottage that had everything we needed: view, amenities and QUIET! We were there for relaxation & this property is perfect for that. Cute shops nearby, water ferry too for trip to Washington Island. Found 3 area parks nearby to visit & they all had spectacular views of Lake Michigan: Port des Morts, Isle View & Liberty Grove.

This property has the location for a serenity spot on the lake. Sunsets were awesome. Plenty of area to sit out side and just absorb the surroundings. Cabin is older, but clean. Has the basics for a comfortable stay. Views were spectacular.

Our first night was cold due to an apparent miscommunication, but once things were smoothed out it was a great place to stay. The manager was responsive and helpful when we were able to connect. We would certainly go again! A fall trip is on our minds. One important tip: there's very very spotty cell service and few cell providers whose service is consistent, especially this far out. Without WiFi it's hard to communicate/clarify plans, and in the off season the options for businesses with open WiFi are fewer. We'll manage our plans differently next trip.

Our first night was cold due to an apparent miscommunication, but once things were smoothed out it was a great place to stay. The manager was responsive and helpful when we were able to connect. We would certainly go again! A fall trip is on our minds. One important tip: there's very very spotty cell service and few cell providers whose service is consistent, especially this far out. Without WiFi it's hard to communicate/clarify plans, and in the off season the options for businesses with open WiFi are fewer. We'll manage our plans differently next trip.

We enjoyed staying at this house. It truly is a “no frills” place but it’s very well kept and has a cool old vibe to it. The house is a good size and there’s a lot of space to move around on the main floor. There’s no wifi and only about 6 TV channels so bring the board games! We would stay here again especially in the summer.

A clean and peaceful no frills fishing cottage. Beautiful view! It was very peaceful and quiet. Just what we needed to recharge and get away. Thank you so much for sharing this little gem!

We enjoyed staying at this house. It truly is a “no frills” place but it’s very well kept and has a cool old vibe to it. The house is a good size and there’s a lot of space to move around on the main floor. There’s no wifi and only about 6 TV channels so bring the board games! We would stay here again especially in the summer.

A clean and peaceful no frills fishing cottage. Beautiful view! It was very peaceful and quiet. Just what we needed to recharge and get away. Thank you so much for sharing this little gem!

Even though this is a no-frills cabin that is in need of some maintenance, it does offer a great view of the lake with a firepit and wood provided. We really enjoyed sitting by the fire and watching the beautiful sunset. Our dog had a great time too!

Place smelled of cigarettes, bathroom, kitchen and floor was dirty. Found garbage under beds, no clean coffee cups. Spent time cleaning and purchased candles to try and eliminate smell. Property manager visited and did nothing.

Place smelled of cigarettes, bathroom, kitchen and floor was dirty. Found garbage under beds, no clean coffee cups. Spent time cleaning and purchased candles to try and eliminate smell. Property manager visited and did nothing.

Even though this is a no-frills cabin that is in need of some maintenance, it does offer a great view of the lake with a firepit and wood provided. We really enjoyed sitting by the fire and watching the beautiful sunset. Our dog had a great time too!

Great communication, friendly, accommodating. I can't say enough good things about the people involved with this property. The cottage was just perfect for a family getaway and we had a great time.

This place has huge potential and could easily be a five star accommodation. The view is tremendous, with splendid Lake Michigan vistas. There is a lovely backyard with a great fire pit and plenty of open space for the kids to run and play. There is NO LAKE ACCESS from this property, which seems strange since the property directly abuts the breakwater. However, the property line ends with the lawn and there is no access to the lake at all. This does not take anything away from the property though. It is a lovely and idyllic lakeside retreat. The house is definitely older, but it has great character and is spacious and airy on the ground floor. The upstairs bedrooms are a little cramped, but fine for sleeping. There is no central air conditioning, but the owner has provided window A/C units in almost every room so comfort is not an issue. The main bedroom on the ground floor is the most spacious and comfortable. The furniture is a little dated, but fine. The lack of a second bathroom can be a little problematic if there is a large group sharing (there were seven of us and we managed, but there were waits). The creaky old staircase is steep, so those with mobility issues should stay down. There is no Wi-Fi here and cellular reception was very spotty so those who need to be online may find that frustrating. The owner has dealt with many of the issues brought up by previous reviewers, so they seem to be embracing an attitude of continuous improvement. There was a lack of cutlery and we ran out of forks and spoons often. There is a beautiful gas grill in the back, but no grilling tools could be found other than a pair of flimsy tongs, so we improvised. Also, we wanted to load and run the dishwasher, but could not find the detergent! We ended up handwashing everything but there was a lack of dishtowels. Finally, the side door was very difficult to close due to a faulty latch. There is nothing here that was so bad it warrants harsh criticism, just some minor attention to detail would improve the guest experience significantly. The property manager was responsive, friendly, and very helpful. We enjoyed our time here and would come back. Sure, there is room for a little improvement, but the location and beauty of this spot more than makes up for the very minor inconveniences we encountered. My final advice to the owners would to put together a little binder will all the instructions and expectations for guests.

Great communication, friendly, accommodating. I can't say enough good things about the people involved with this property. The cottage was just perfect for a family getaway and we had a great time.

This place has huge potential and could easily be a five star accommodation. The view is tremendous, with splendid Lake Michigan vistas. There is a lovely backyard with a great fire pit and plenty of open space for the kids to run and play. There is NO LAKE ACCESS from this property, which seems strange since the property directly abuts the breakwater. However, the property line ends with the lawn and there is no access to the lake at all. This does not take anything away from the property though. It is a lovely and idyllic lakeside retreat. The house is definitely older, but it has great character and is spacious and airy on the ground floor. The upstairs bedrooms are a little cramped, but fine for sleeping. There is no central air conditioning, but the owner has provided window A/C units in almost every room so comfort is not an issue. The main bedroom on the ground floor is the most spacious and comfortable. The furniture is a little dated, but fine. The lack of a second bathroom can be a little problematic if there is a large group sharing (there were seven of us and we managed, but there were waits). The creaky old staircase is steep, so those with mobility issues should stay down. There is no Wi-Fi here and cellular reception was very spotty so those who need to be online may find that frustrating. The owner has dealt with many of the issues brought up by previous reviewers, so they seem to be embracing an attitude of continuous improvement. There was a lack of cutlery and we ran out of forks and spoons often. There is a beautiful gas grill in the back, but no grilling tools could be found other than a pair of flimsy tongs, so we improvised. Also, we wanted to load and run the dishwasher, but could not find the detergent! We ended up handwashing everything but there was a lack of dishtowels. Finally, the side door was very difficult to close due to a faulty latch. There is nothing here that was so bad it warrants harsh criticism, just some minor attention to detail would improve the guest experience significantly. The property manager was responsive, friendly, and very helpful. We enjoyed our time here and would come back. Sure, there is room for a little improvement, but the location and beauty of this spot more than makes up for the very minor inconveniences we encountered. My final advice to the owners would to put together a little binder will all the instructions and expectations for guests.

My family and our friends choose a private cabin in WI every year. We've been doing this for 7 years now. This cabin has the old feel as stated in the property description. But it's simply perfect for a stay when you just want to relax. I would suggest the owner leave a information check in/check out sheet for us. There was no obvious info. Also some board games would be nice. Otherwise it was perfect. And we experienced some friendly ghosts.

My family and our friends choose a private cabin in WI every year. We've been doing this for 7 years now. This cabin has the old feel as stated in the property description. But it's simply perfect for a stay when you just want to relax. I would suggest the owner leave a information check in/check out sheet for us. There was no obvious info. Also some board games would be nice. Otherwise it was perfect. And we experienced some friendly ghosts.

Lovely quiet neighborhood with water view and two great sunsets while we were there. We enjoyed our conversations with the on-site property manager, Lyle.

Ants in kicken.Need some house improvements.

Lovely quiet neighborhood with water view and two great sunsets while we were there. We enjoyed our conversations with the on-site property manager, Lyle.

Ants in kicken.Need some house improvements.

Knowing we were staying in an original fishing lodge that has stayed in the family for four generations was special enough. Across the bay was a commercial fishing business where we could watch the seagulls following tugs come in every morning with their haul of fish. We went there and was able to purchase as much whitefish as we wished. It was very interesting to watch their speedy processing of the fish. The family that owned the cottage we stayed in were most accommodating and friendly. I would recommend that they update the bedroom on the main floor. The bed and bedding need to be replaced.

Knowing we were staying in an original fishing lodge that has stayed in the family for four generations was special enough. Across the bay was a commercial fishing business where we could watch the seagulls following tugs come in every morning with their haul of fish. We went there and was able to purchase as much whitefish as we wished. It was very interesting to watch their speedy processing of the fish. The family that owned the cottage we stayed in were most accommodating and friendly. I would recommend that they update the bedroom on the main floor. The bed and bedding need to be replaced.