There were a few reasons that we booked our stay here.. They advertise a tiki bar ( where we could have a drink or two then walk to our room. ) And a restaurant (where we could have a good breakfast to start our day) Their add also advertise fishing. As the hotel is on the water.) After checking in we were informed that the tiki bar only has coffee and tea in the morning.. the bar closed down 2 years ago. The restaurant only serves dinner from (what we were told at the front desk "I think They open around 4:30 or 5:00) And as far as the fishing??? They have no fishing signs all around the shoreline and dock. Also the bed was wore out, We slept in the hole in the middle of it.

People upstairs had kids that would run back and fourth all day and night the office close at midnight no one around. If you need and snack or something after 9pm nothing is around unless u want to drive 45 mins. Only 2 restaurants close which is the property restaurant which is over priced and can't follow simple instructions and baby cakes which has a few breakfast sandwiches and coffee.Room was ok property was pretty clean for the most part.

Kind staff..the only thing is that the property lacks of painting..it doesn’t look to nice..but is a 2star inn..I guess you can’t ask for too much

Courteous staff. Our AC broke around 11 pm. Next morning front desk was very accommodating and fair and worked with us to reach a fair compromise

Lobby attendant was very unfriendly. The hotel and the rooms were outdated and very poor cleaning.

Sugarloaf Lodge is a keys landmark. The rooms were clean and comfortable and large with daily maid service. There is a bit of a retro 50s or 60s look to the room but I loved it! Great little quiet place close to many activities and close to Key West. Also love the pool. I will definitely be back.

Sugarloaf Lodge is old Florida. Nothing fancy, absolutely convenient with awesome boat parking and marina. Friendly staff and very clean rooms. We will come back for years to come and enjoy our time there. Perfect location to drive downtown.

Vintage but not all in a good way.

When looking at the door from the inside in the daytime, you could see light coming thru all around the door....which explains all the mosquitoes in the room. They have a sign posted in the room aboit keeping doors shut at night- but that doesn't help when the seal around the door is non- existent.

No coffeemaker/microwave in rooms. Very poor cleaning and hospitality. Cost up/hospitality down! Was a convenient drive to Key West. Beautiful view of ocean.

It is an ok property.

The tiki bar was closed. Place looked better in the advertisement than in real life

Good 👍

We loved the wildlife habitat area around the property only thing we were disappointed in is not being able to fish.

Happy good stayed

Affordable, clean and well kept room. Decor may appear dated to some; for me, it’s “retro”. Great value in the expensive Key West region.

Very nice place to stay, only about 30 minutes from Key West. Nice view from the balcony. And my favorite part? Nearly instant hot water in the shower!

Room clean

The view from our room was awesome tiki bar was not open when we were there and restaurant on property was very expensive

It was clean and quiet. It looked like it hadn't had any upgrades since the 60s or 70s.

Bathroom wasnt handicapped accesible.

It was good enough for two nights. Expensive for no breakfast and no coffee maker in the room. However, it gave us a place to stay while visiting Dry Tortugas NP and the Keys. Note: the towel holder by the sink wasn’t attached to the wall completely (maybe broken) had to call the front desk to report but no one picks up my calls. Fyi.

Loved the retro style. Everything was extremely clean. Will stay again.

Very easy & simple check in and check out. Perfect location if you have a car to drive downtown key west , 20 mins away.

Well, overall good. But, the first room rhe water in the shower was hot or scolding. So they had a gentleman come to take care of it and he wasn't able to fix it. They cleaned another room and we moved. The next room you had to take the lid off the yoilet to flush it and the reomote for the TV only had one button on it that worked. But the positive is the rooms were very clean, comfortable and had beautiful views. The restaurant onsite has amazing food. So if you're a go with the flow type of person you'll love it. Luckily we are.😁

Need room and bathroom improvements

The staff was very friendly and helpful. The location was right on the ocean. Beautiful view. Sunrises were amazing from this location.

We have a wonderful stay quite and super nice

Rooms were clean, pool was nice, good location with Marina Tiki was closed entire time & restaurant was very expensive

good property.

The hotel was old but clean. It hasn't been updated in decades.

Excellent stay close to key west!