10 out of 10. Wonderful place.

Great property, amazing staff and delicious food!

We loved our stay on Block Island. The Atlantic On. Was the perfect place to stay. Great location. Good food and wonderful team.

Lovely relaxing stay at a classic BI hotel. Really enjoyed the on-site dining for dinner, sunset views, and the ability to walk into town or the beach. Would stay again.

Beautiful views from the porch and sitting area

Very nice property. Lots of nice historical touches without the inconvenience of shared bathrooms and no air conditioning.

Great. Small bathroom is only down side but expected.

It was very nice and the service was excellent. Food portions could have been a bit more reasonable. My fois gras was the size of a quarter. Otherwise my wife and I were very pleased.

The Atlantic is an old historic inn that was completely updated two years ago. The whole facility is immaculate. The staff was extremely attentive even though we were there pre-season. We will definitely stay at The Sylsntic if we ever return to Block Island!

Loved the view. Dinner on the porch was excellent!

The restaurant and bar were very enjoyable as were the staff. My only comment would be I would like to see a bigger breakfast menu. A minor point compared to all the positive aspects of your hotel.

The staff was very friendly and helpful. The day we arrived their restraunt wasn’t open yet, so they gave us recommendations for another restaurant.

It was peaceful, walkable, and beautiful!

We had an amazing experience at the Atlantic Inn. Very cute clean rooms and very nice staff. It is a perfect location to walk down town and even the beach. I highly recommend the Atlantic Inn. I will definitely be back in the future!

Excellent property - lovely decor!

This is a lovely hotel that is nicely sighted over looking the ocean, in the distance. Too bad they don’t have any breakfast offerings. It’s unfortunate to have to go off property for that. A shuttle into town center would be helpful too. Overall it is a very relaxing stay and we will be back!!

Nice renovations, great host in Sarah and Greg and the staff. Maybe put the square footage of the rooms in the room descriptions because it was a little tight but we had a great time.

Beautiful, quiet location perched an easy walk above town. Lovely restaurant on site, with casual dining also available on the lawn.

The Atlantic Inn has been renovated nicely and the dinner we had there was delicious! We will definitely return!

I was incredibly impressed with the amazing hospitality of this Inn. As a first timer to Block Island, I was not sure what to expect with no true “hotels” but the service was unparalleled. From arrival they were SO friendly, and kind and assisted with our bags and then the bar/wait staff was phenomenal. With a sick passenger they were wonderful making her soup and keeping me entertained as well. The Inn has some of the best views of the island, great location and very walkable to town and even views of the “zoo” with camels and alpacas and Kanagroos. Can not recommend this spot enough and next time I’m back, I’ll be staying here.

Perfect view

Extremely friendly staff and beautiful property.

I can't say enough about our stay at The Atlantic Inn. Check in was the most pleasant I've ever experienced, thanks to the staff and owner. I was invited to sit in the quaint welcome area and they brought what was needed to me. My husband and I were celebrating our anniversary, and the hotel concierge brought Prosecco and home baked cookies to our room, which we were able to enter early. The staff throughout the hotel were friendly, responsive, and effective. The hotel is walking distance from town, but removed enough to be quiet and peaceful. The food at the restaurant was excellent. We ate at the indoors bar, on the porch, and on the lawn, all with spectacular water views. We brought our motorcycle and there was plenty of parking. The room was small (the bathroom, very small) but lovely and all was in working order, including the AC. Ocean view room with a bonus view of the adjacent zoo/farm. Amenities were great (snacks, water, toiletries). We loved our stay and can't wait to return.

The property was gorgeous and the inside was newly renovated. Our room was adorable and classic. Our only complaint was the first night our AC was not working and it was very warm but by day 2 it seemed to kick in better. The rooms are small but incredibly charming, perfect for a couple! Serene location on top of the hill