The location was great. The rooms and hotel is very clean. The rooms are very small

The rooms are tiny but have loads of character and are welll-appointed. There’s super noisy construction outside so may not be the best of you plan to work from your room but the staff were amazing (especially Gia) and the hotel was thoughtfully appointed and well-located. I would stay here again.

The rooms are tiny but have loads of character and are welll-appointed. There’s super noisy construction outside so may not be the best of you plan to work from your room but the staff were amazing (especially Gia) and the hotel was thoughtfully appointed and well-located. I would stay here again.

Everyone I interacted with was amazing, and especially Samantha at the front desk! She was so helpful and sweet, and was able to help me with my issue. Wonderful stay, and my partner and I are looking forward to now having this as our "go-to" place to stay, now that we've moved out of the city!

Everyone I interacted with was amazing, and especially Samantha at the front desk! She was so helpful and sweet, and was able to help me with my issue. Wonderful stay, and my partner and I are looking forward to now having this as our "go-to" place to stay, now that we've moved out of the city!

Lovely staff, great vibe. They are not kidding about the rooms being tiny- almost too small for 2 people. And probably more expensive than it should be for that size.

Lovely staff, great vibe. They are not kidding about the rooms being tiny- almost too small for 2 people. And probably more expensive than it should be for that size.

Nice, comfortable hotel in a good location. Very small rooms for the price paid. I wound stay here again off season, but better options available when prices are high

Nice, comfortable hotel in a good location. Very small rooms for the price paid. I wound stay here again off season, but better options available when prices are high

Before you book your stay here, make sure you check and see what size your room is. I expect a hotel room I stay in to at least fit me. The space was tiny, wish some taken up by a portable AC unit that was in there. The bathroom door did not fully open because it would hit the bed and so I had to walk sideways into there anytime I wanted to take a shower, brush my teeth, etc. The staff were lovely the the place was very old-fashioned and not what I expect from a hotel stay in NYC.

Before you book your stay here, make sure you check and see what size your room is. I expect a hotel room I stay in to at least fit me. The space was tiny, wish some taken up by a portable AC unit that was in there. The bathroom door did not fully open because it would hit the bed and so I had to walk sideways into there anytime I wanted to take a shower, brush my teeth, etc. The staff were lovely the the place was very old-fashioned and not what I expect from a hotel stay in NYC.

Pretty good stay

Really great historic hotel.

Fire alarm went off in the middle of the night no contact from staff just other guests yelling false alarm. No apologies, explanation or concessions for the scare and inconvenience. Also phone in room was not working so I could not contact staff.

Fire alarm went off in the middle of the night no contact from staff just other guests yelling false alarm. No apologies, explanation or concessions for the scare and inconvenience. Also phone in room was not working so I could not contact staff.

It was pretty good until fire alarm went off at 1:30am as false alarm. My room was nice and very quiet

It was pretty good until fire alarm went off at 1:30am as false alarm. My room was nice and very quiet

Staff was great. Only comment queen mattress second night was uncomfortable The hotel is amazing location. Great breakfast and staff were lovely to deal with

Convenient location. Charming but showing its age.

Convenient location. Charming but showing its age.

Terrible concierge service for what is supposed to be a 4.5 star hotel. Does not look or feel like a 4.5 star hotel.

Terrible concierge service for what is supposed to be a 4.5 star hotel. Does not look or feel like a 4.5 star hotel.

I've stayed at the Marlton Hotel before, on recommendation of a friend. I find it charming, adorable and perfectly suited for a stay in NYC. The rooms are TINY but I prefer a tiny room that is well thought out, with nice amenities than a large room with no character. One of the best things about the Marlton is the common areas, the living room, the adorable bar and the gorgeous dining area. Perfect for business meetings/breakfast with old friends, etc. Love it.

I've stayed at the Marlton Hotel before, on recommendation of a friend. I find it charming, adorable and perfectly suited for a stay in NYC. The rooms are TINY but I prefer a tiny room that is well thought out, with nice amenities than a large room with no character. One of the best things about the Marlton is the common areas, the living room, the adorable bar and the gorgeous dining area. Perfect for business meetings/breakfast with old friends, etc. Love it.

Typical very small nyc hotel room but great quality bed and linens.

Typical very small nyc hotel room but great quality bed and linens.

We stayed here for drop off weekend for our daughter at The New school. What a wonderful stay! Charming lounge and rooms, wonderful staff, simple/easy breakfast, close to the school, good restaurants, and anything else you could want. Highly recommend and would stay here again in the future.

While the rooms are a bit small, they are elegantly furnished and comfortable. The staff is very helpful and courteous. The restaurant and public areas are great.

We stayed here for drop off weekend for our daughter at The New school. What a wonderful stay! Charming lounge and rooms, wonderful staff, simple/easy breakfast, close to the school, good restaurants, and anything else you could want. Highly recommend and would stay here again in the future.

understated elegance in a great part of NYC. My go-to hotel when I visit.

understated elegance in a great part of NYC. My go-to hotel when I visit.

I was in New York for a two day business meeting nearby. The Marlton Hotel in Greenwich Village was a quaint departure from the ordinary. This hotel is a step back in time - small but clean rooms, old style fixtures and appeal, highly accommodating, friendly staff.