Our family and friends stayed here for a weekend, and the location was perfect. Right on the bay and near the stores. Roberto was great to work with and was very accessible. A great place for a weekend at the beach.

We have been renting in Fair Harbor for years but this rental has been the best..BY FAR! There is NO better view in Fair Harbor. Wake to views of the ferry pulling back not there dock & the calm Great South Bay. The sunset view, from the front porch, is life-changing. The home is about 100 years old but lovingly maintained with all the cozy comforts you need for a beach vacation. Roberto was a fantastic host & communication was seamless. We have found our dream beach house & will DEFINITELY be renting again!

We have rented this house a few times and just loved it - especially my 21/19 year olds and their friends. What makes it great: location! Great for paddle boarders, kayakers, sunset watchers. Second, Roberto & Phy provide everything. You aren't scrounging for day 1 paper towels, utensils, oil for the bike chains. They are so generous as well when you have a problem (I swear Roberto has ESP - we call and he or someone shows up in 5 minutes). That is a big deal at a rental. Third, the outside options - back deck is huge with two tables. Two front areas - front deck and the "sand pit" seating area (our favorite) are great. AND a screened in porch for bug averse. We had 20 people from 2 houses for dinner no issues. It is a beach cottage and not fancy. But really what more do you need than this? Truly magical times here!

We have rented this house a few times and just loved it - especially my 21/19 year olds and their friends. What makes it great: location! Great for paddle boarders, kayakers, sunset watchers. Second, Roberto & Phy provide everything. You aren't scrounging for day 1 paper towels, utensils, oil for the bike chains. They are so generous as well when you have a problem (I swear Roberto has ESP - we call and he or someone shows up in 5 minutes). That is a big deal at a rental. Third, the outside options - back deck is huge with two tables. Two front areas - front deck and the "sand pit" seating area (our favorite) are great. AND a screened in porch for bug averse. We had 20 people from 2 houses for dinner no issues. It is a beach cottage and not fancy. But really what more do you need than this? Truly magical times here!

The house was amazing! The most convenient location! Such a cozy beautiful home and the host was extremely attentive.

The house was amazing! The most convenient location! Such a cozy beautiful home and the host was extremely attentive.

I had a wonderful time staying at this property. It's location can't be beat as the bayside beach is right off the front porch and two houses away from the local liquor store, restaurant and grocer. We had never been to fire island before, and all we can say is that it is magical and the Fair Harbor Village has a wonderful laid back vibe.

We had a great time at Roberto's cottage. It is a beautiful old house with lots of charm and fit our needs very well. The location right next to the ferry and at the bay is excellent and we enjoyed spending time on the back porch, which had enough space for our group of 9. Roberto and his family were super helpful with the whole process, gave us great local recommendations and made sure we had an excellent stay. Thank you very everything!