Lovely apartment- perfect for a stay in Sag Harbor. The view from the kitchen is outstanding, the beds comfortable and the sitting room is cozy. Walking distance to town. As others have noted, the stairs are steep to the upstairs bedrooms but manageable with the handrails. Would stay there again in the future.

It was a lovely property, beautiful location that was easily found and accessible to local fare. However, we were told there was a private beach, which was not what we considered "beach." It is a marshy wade to the water's edge, at best. I was unaware that we would be staying on 2 levels which was accessed via a third flight of steps. All steps were very small and hand rails were not well anchored in places. Much more "rustic" than what the photos were able to capture, especially the top floor of our apartment. It was definitely not safe for the 3 of us, women ages 62 -70, it was difficult and scary with steep narrow steps and wobbly hand rails. This is NOT a handicap accessible property. This was my first time booking a VRBO so maybe I just missed the fine print.

Really wonderful and easy... great location!

We had a wonderful stay at Paris’s beautiful property. It was exactly as advertised. The view was beautiful, the apartment was very clean, and Paris was a great host!

I visited Paris’ house with my mom, sister, and two dogs. The house has so much charm and an amazing view of the water. It was an easy walk into downtown sag harbor. We definitely want to stay again!

Beautiful sunrises and sunsets, air conditioning during a heat wave. Comfortable and lovely. Magical. I would love to stay here again.

The views of the cove and the nesting Ospreys were wonderful, and just a 10-minute walk to all the restaurants and shops in Sag Harbor. Paris was a great host. We enjoyed our stay and hope to return.

Beautiful Stay for 2 in 2nd floor Back Apartment. Paris and Clifton were great hosts and we enjoyed checking out Downtown Sag Harbor a short walk away. Don't delay, book today :)

The cottage was perfect! The view was amazing. The apartment was roomy and comfortable. Paris and Clifton could not have been nicer or easier to work with. The village was in walking distance. There was also a deli just a few doors down that was a nice little surprise. I’d go for coffee and pastries in the morning. I walked everywhere. Will definitely return.

Paris was an exceptional host. I loved his property. It was right on the water and such an easy walk to town for dinners. I wish I could stay forever. It was clean and perfect. A real slice of heaven

Paris' house was so charming, clean, and scenic. Every morning and evening we looked out to a beautiful pond surrounded by trees. It was like something out of a movie....truly spectacular! Location is central to town and it's easy to walk anywhere.

This was our first time visiting Sag Harbor. The house was the perfect place to stay. Fantastic location, fascinating history, kind hosts, clean, and comfortable. The views were spectacular. We enjoyed drinking coffee each morning while watching the birds on the water. We didn’t want to leave and can’t wait to return!

This was our first time visiting Sag Harbor. The house was the perfect place to stay. Fantastic location, fascinating history, kind hosts, clean, and comfortable. The views were spectacular. We enjoyed drinking coffee each morning while watching the birds on the water. We didn’t want to leave and can’t wait to return!

Lovely stay for my family. Walking distance to town and stunning water and sunrise views. Will stay here again.

The whaling captain’s house has both character and a great view. The listing is accurate. The house and grounds are clean and well maintained. The kitchen is simply, but thoughtfully stocked. The beds are comfortable and the rooms are cozy and maintained at a comfortable temperature. The owners are friendly yet respectful of privacy. The house is ideally situated. It is a very short walk to town and a short bike ride to Shelter Island and the Elizabeth Morton Wildlife Refuge. Great place. We stayed for a friends weekend. There are 4 beds in this apartment, and we each had our space. I would love to return with my husband and stay in the cottage next time.

The whaling captain’s house has both character and a great view. The listing is accurate. The house and grounds are clean and well maintained. The kitchen is simply, but thoughtfully stocked. The beds are comfortable and the rooms are cozy and maintained at a comfortable temperature. The owners are friendly yet respectful of privacy. The house is ideally situated. It is a very short walk to town and a short bike ride to Shelter Island and the Elizabeth Morton Wildlife Refuge. Great place. We stayed for a friends weekend. There are 4 beds in this apartment, and we each had our space. I would love to return with my husband and stay in the cottage next time.

This was a return visit to this bright, airy, & extremely comfortable Sag Harbor find. The views are beautiful, and the location is both very private and very convenient to all. The owners are lovely & tend to everything you need.

This was a return visit to this bright, airy, & extremely comfortable Sag Harbor find. The views are beautiful, and the location is both very private and very convenient to all. The owners are lovely & tend to everything you need.

My stay at this property was pretty close to perfect. Paris( the owner) met me at the house and gave me a warm and gracious greeting. The apartment and common areas were filled with antiques, original woodwork and flooring and early American art. All of the above were accompanied by what appeared to be new kitchen appliances and modern bathroom fixtures. Every room was spotlessly clean with comfortable attractive furniture. Added to all this was the matchless view of Otter Pond. The entire property was much better than advertised.

My stay at this property was pretty close to perfect. Paris( the owner) met me at the house and gave me a warm and gracious greeting. The apartment and common areas were filled with antiques, original woodwork and flooring and early American art. All of the above were accompanied by what appeared to be new kitchen appliances and modern bathroom fixtures. Every room was spotlessly clean with comfortable attractive furniture. Added to all this was the matchless view of Otter Pond. The entire property was much better than advertised.

We had a beautiful, restful time at this charming, tastefully decorated apartment within walking distance to down town Sag Harbor. The unit was both clean and comfortable. I made dinner in the lovely eat in kitchen with a view of the cove from the window. The owners were kind and responsive. Really can't ask for much more.

We had a beautiful, restful time at this charming, tastefully decorated apartment within walking distance to down town Sag Harbor. The unit was both clean and comfortable. I made dinner in the lovely eat in kitchen with a view of the cove from the window. The owners were kind and responsive. Really can't ask for much more.

Walk to town from this historic home . Beautiful view of a quiet inlet cove from the kitchen and back yard. Perfect size for 2 to stay and let’s you step back in time to when Sag Harbor a quaint maritime based village. I will return next visit to the Hamptons. To stay here.

We enjoyed our stay and would definitely come back. Paris was an authentic, gracious host. The place was immaculate and provided all the comforts we needed to feel at home. The perfect views of the inlet and watching the sunset on the water was icing on the cake.

Comfortable apartment on a beautiful property within walking distance of Sag Harbor. Great location and friendly host.

My daughter and I and her dog stayed in the upstairs apartment of Paris and Clifton’s whaling captain’s home. Location a few blocks from Sag Harbor so an easy walk. View was amazing over lake. Apartment was perfect for us. We loved it and would stay again.

My family and I had a wonderful stay at Whaling Captain Pierson's Apartment. The apartment was absolutely beautiful - tasteful decor, comfy beds and sofas, stunning views and a very well equipped kitchen. I wish my house was so beautifully decorated...We also *very* much appreciated the welcome bottle of wine. The location couldn't have been better - right on the water, but also a short walk to town. Parking on the street was very safe and easy. I hope that we'll be able to come here again one day very soon.

My family and I had a wonderful stay at Whaling Captain Pierson's Apartment. The apartment was absolutely beautiful - tasteful decor, comfy beds and sofas, stunning views and a very well equipped kitchen. I wish my house was so beautifully decorated... We also *very* much appreciated the welcome bottle of wine. The location couldn't have been better - right on the water, but also a short walk to town. Parking on the street was very safe and easy. I hope that we'll be able to come here again one day very soon.

I had an extended stay at this property and it is a hidden gem. A great place to stay for a short or extended stay. Hosts are extremely gracious and easy to deal with. I hope to return for another stay.

I had an extended stay at this property and it is a hidden gem. A great place to stay for a short or extended stay. Hosts are extremely gracious and easy to deal with. I hope to return for another stay.

Paris and Clifton, you made a long overdue girls weekend so superb! This wonderful spot is super clean and very easy to walk to the village. Hosts are so gracious and we felt very comfortable. Thank you so much! We will book in the future.

Paris and Clifton, you made a long overdue girls weekend so superb! This wonderful spot is super clean and very easy to walk to the village. Hosts are so gracious and we felt very comfortable. Thank you so much! We will book in the future.