I hesitate to leave a review at all with fear that this rental will be discovered, but couldn’t go without singing its praises! My husband and I felt perfectly at home from the moment we arrived. With a fenced in backyard, there was plenty of room for our dog to run around. The house was clean, comfortable, and had more than enough space for us two. Mike, the host, was incredibly friendly, professional, and respectful of our privacy. He gave us great recommendations on restaurants and markets. We took advantage of the fresh meat and seafood you can buy on the island, and cooked several of our dinners on the house’s grill. The location was excellent too—in a quiet neighborhood and close to our favorite beaches in Eel Point and Madaket. This was without a doubt the best time we’ve ever had in Nantucket. Cannot wait to visit again!!!

Comfortable cottage in a beautiful neighborhood adjacent to Linda Loring Nature preserve, within 15 minute walk to 40th pole beach or only a several minutes drive to gorgeous Madaket area beaches. Patio and small yard was a plus, and so appreciated it was dog friendly. Responsive owners. Enjoyable stay!

We loved our stay at the Eel Point Cottage, short hike to a remote beach within a nature a preserve. Mike and Dave have really thought of everything that one would need to relax. Close to town, great sunsets at a Madaket and restaurants in town.