I can’t say enough about our stay at the “Old Mill”! It was a great home base between our sightseeing adventures! Very convenient location to travel to Chicago as well as explore the local area. Although our trip was in March, we were still able to spend an afternoon enjoying the beautiful beach! What a sunset!!! We stayed with our four children ranging from ages 8 to 16. All of them had comfortable living quarters and lots of room to spread out and play games! There was a fooseball table, cards and other board games there for us to use which was great. My husband and I were able to take a few runs around the lakes and enjoy the beautiful area. The house was very clean and had a great hang out living space and bar area. We were able to get takeout from a local restaurant and enjoy some March madness basketball around the bar. Check in and check out was very easy and communication with Kathleen was also very timely and helpful. We would definitely book this house again… my kids are already asking me if we can go back this summer!

We loved our stay at the Old Mill. There was so much room! Plenty of clean and updated bedrooms and bathrooms. Loved the bar area and large kitchen. The view of the lake was very nice from the first floor and great from the main bedroom. We can’t wait to come back.

Plenty of space to hangout with friends separate from the sleeping areas!

We had a great time staying for Christmas for the second time. Perfect location and plenty of room for all of us. Thanks for having us

The lake house was perfect for our annual family weekend. Lots of space and sleeping arrangements let everyone spread out. The main floor has great open spaces to play games and relax. We had great weather to take advantage of the outside area, loved the large deck and seating by the lake. Would highly recommend to any larger groups!

The house was perfect for our big friend group over a wedding weekend. Would love to come back!

It was a commercial space previously (THERE IS A BAR!!) so the layout is unusual, but it is spacious. The deck is great and the parking is easy. Also... plenty of beds and linens. It is super clean too. We had a great stay!

This was our first family vacation in ages. 8 of us total plus dogs. The house and location were perfect for our group. Katie was fantastic to work with. We're already planning on going back as soon as we can.

We had a wonderful vacation. The house and beach were perfect for our family.

This was an excellent place for our family and friends to stay for a week. The house was the perfect size and in excellent condition. The access to the private beach was the icing on the cake. Thank you so much for a wonderful week of memories.

Our group of 14 that included 2 children and 1 dog had plenty of room at this property. On the main floor there are 2 bathrooms a large kitchen dining area, bar area, tv area and still more space! There are 2 large refrigerators which was super helpful. Kitchen was well stocked with plates, silverware, glasses. The only thing lacking was large cooking pots. The location was great, across the street from the lake which includes a fire pit and boat dock. Beautiful views of the lake from several windows and the large deck. Everyone in our group was pleased. The property was clean and beds were comfortable. Ceiling fans in each sleeping room. I do recommend to turn up the a/c before bed as it was a little warm upstairs.

If you’re looking for a fun, quirky place, this is for you. The building was a roadside bar/restaurant that the owner lived above. It’s been converted to a house, but still has a large bar and wide open areas for indoor fun. My children hosted all of their cousins and everyone had a great time. The beach/lake access is very nice. Would highly recommend.

We had a great time! The property is spacious, clean, and great location! Beds are comfy, showers are spacious, beach is perfect. We will be back! We did bring our own Keurig because there is just a coffee pot. Which was not a big deal. The A/C was off on arrival and the house was over 80*, since the beds are all on the upper level it was a very very hot first night of sleeping. High recommend cranking the A/C and shutting curtains upstairs if there in the summer on a hot day!

We really like to location of this property, as well as the big first floor play room

This place was great for our big friend group! Loved the private beach area!

We had a great weekend at this home. The kitchen was fully stocked with dishes, etc, and the amenities were wonderful. It’s a great area not far from Lake Geneva or golf courses.

House overall was ok. It is in a great location and can accommodate a large group. The water is well water and it smelled pretty awful. We also did not feel it was cleaned well before our arrival :( The beds were pretty comfy which was a plus.

12 of us stayed here for NYE weekend and it was perfect. No issues with checking in/out or with the house. Lots of room and the bar was awesome! Quiet area with people fishing on the lake and a bar down the street. Would definitely recommend and thanks again!

Great place.

Great clean place with plenty of space. We were all happy with the layout. Loved the bar and other areas for group gatherings. Yes the water smells, but it wasn’t an issue. I think we all hit our toes at least once on the heavy picnic style bench in the kitchen (slants outward), so be warned. Nice and close to Lake Geneva, 15?min drive max. Didn’t expect a road in between the lake and house, but it was too cold for us to use the beach area anyway Overall, would come back and would recommend to others.

We had a great time at the property. It’s loaded with all we needed for our friend group’s weekend away. The fire pit along the beach is a great touch. Well water was something some people in our group were not used to so I would keep that in mind when booking.

Very spacious and fun house for entertaining. Across the street from the lake with a nice private beach area. Comfortable sleeping arrangements for all.

14 of us stayed here very comfortably for a girls weekend and it was wonderful. Beautiful lake access and a super fun house for a big group. Owners were great and would recommend!

The water was smelling bad

Our big family had a great stay here! The property was as described and the hosts were very responsive.

Property was perfect for what we needed. Great location on the lake and near Milwaukee and Chicago. Owners was very accommodating. Fun spot for large families or groups.

The property was perfect for a group of girlfriends looking to unwind away from the big city. It has a unique layout that offers lots of space for groups and the proximity to Lake Geneva is great for nights out. The bar just a couple doors down was a fun treat as well. I highly recommend this property!

We had a group of 14 here for a bachelorette party and it was a lovely time! It was great to have access to the lake & the house fit us all comfortably. Kate was very responsive if I had any questions!

Great place and great host!

Everything went well.

Our stay at this rental was absolutely perfect. The house had all of the amenities needed for a large group (and then some!) and so many different spaces for us to lounge and unwind. The outdoor space in particular was amazing and you cannot beat the beachfront/dock. (We rented a pontoon boat and could easily dock it right in front of the house.) Kathleen and Brian were great hosts and incredibly helpful/communicative. Highly recommend this property to anyone looking for a relaxing lake trip.

The house is very big with plenty of space and a large outdoor patio. It was clean upon arrival. The beach area is great for the kids. Loved the fire pit and the adirondack chairs. Great fishing and a sandbar out in the middle of the lake as well. Kind of a lot of seaweed around our dock though which bothered the kids when swimming. There is a little bar/restaurant right down the street too. You do have to cross a semi busy street to get to the beach/ water area. For adults it’s totally fine, but with young kids, an adult had to walk them back and forth each time.