The property is wonderful. It was a tad bit too cold for the pool, but we had a boat rented and island hopped everyday! Treasure Cay is so beautiful and the people are very hospitable. Merril and his wife are fabulous hosts with incredible recommendations and resources available for all of your needs! We can’t wait to plan our next Abacos adventure!!

Beautiful spot Owners very nice & attentive Great time

Enjoyed our stay in Treasure Cay! Lovely house and beautiful views!

House was beautiful!!! Dock was perfect and great having a pool to cool off in !!! We will definitely be back!

We absolutely loved our stay at the Sugar Shack! The views from the back deck/pool are spectacular. The house is well equipped with things for cooking, relaxing in the pool and beds are super comfy. There are plenty of kayaks and getting in and out of the water is very easy. There were six of us staying at the house and we had plenty of room to be together or get some quiet time alone. We'll definitely book again :)

Loved having coffee outside in the morning! The beach across the way is fun to swim or kayak to. So pretty! The dock fit our 39 foot center console. Power and water on the dock. The pool cleared up over time. House was clean. Beds comfortable. Ac worked well. Dishwasher broken. Loved seeing turtles 🐢 from the dock!

Best at everything you want in a vacation Vrbo. So nice and comfortable with beautiful views and nice amenities.

The Sugar Shack is in one of the most beautiful spots on TC. Perfectly located with a spectacular view of the water and the beach. It was peaceful and we felt very safe. The owner Merrill was easy to contact and a pleasure to deal with. About the house: The beds, living room and dining room furniture are brand new, very comfortable and clean. The house and property had more than enough space for our group of 4. The kitchen is fairly well stocked with spices, dishes, cookware, utensils and some condiments in the fridge. Outside: The patio is newly tiled and beautiful with plenty of comfortable seating. The Tiki hut was a great place to sit and relax. The pool was nice, but unfortunately, too cold for all but one of us. (65 degrees) Loved the kayak but there was only one paddle for four kayaks.(we did find another paddle in a bedroom closet the day we left). Door to the blue bathroom drags on the floor if you don’t lift it. There are some water floats and plenty of beach towels. A lot of time was spent on the amazing beaches and the dock. We saw a dolphin, a turtle, lots of small fish, crabs and 4 spotted eagle rays right in front of the dock. A few small issues that we had were that the ice maker was broken, the dishwasher did not work(saw one in the pictures and assumed), the blenders didn’t work, we asked the housekeeper to come back to take care of some cleaning that was overlooked(Shantell is great). The power goes out almost every day but only for a very short period. None of the issues we had negatively affected our stay here. One must take into consideration that Abaco is still recovering from hurricane Dorian. There are only 2 places to eat at on TC. Florence's cinnamon rolls are a must! If you can, rent a boat and captain to take you to the outlying Cay’s. It’s worth it.