Excellent second visit to Rodman Hall! Nicely renovated in a more traditional, rather than modern, style. Nice rooms, great remote communication from the staff at the Stone Mill Inn. Highly recommended!!

This property and its grounds are beautiful. I will definitely stay again if I’m in the area.

This quiet and private property is as beautiful in person as it is in the photos. Our rooms, The Merritt Suite, was spacious and beautifully furnished. The common areas on all three floors are stunning. Rodman Hall was an excellent location near a quaint downtown area and within easy reach of many wineries and orchards. We enjoyed our stay immensely. It is a wonderful place for an event or wedding. The building and grounds would make a lavish backdrop.

Excellent Location , Service and Beautiful place

One of a kind ambience hotel!

What a great new place to stay in St. Catherines! The mansion is absolutely beautiful, with updated amenities. Location is superb - an easy 10 minute walk to many dining options downtown. Service was excellent. We will definitely be back.

Rodman Hall is like no other. Converted from a family mansion, with other uses in between, the detail is beautifully authentic. Our room was exceedingly comfortable and elegant. The grounds are magnificent. In busy downtown Saint Catherine’s, it is a retreat. I would give it more than five stars if I could do so. We certainly plan to come again.

A very beautiful property and rather unique accomodation. While highly recommended it is importamt to understand this is not a full service hotel. Very much enjoyed our stay.

It’s an elegant old mansion and while the room was comfortable there were lots of odd quirks. The lighting in the rooms and bathrooms was poor. In addition there wasn’t any information about the property upon self check in, eg is there coffee in the am etc. also the outside lights were left on all night which streamed through the drapes making it difficult to sleep. It was an ok stay and quaint but I wouldn’t go rushing back.

Rodham Hall is a beautiful, stately manor that transports you back in time to the most elegant and beautiful finishes of the 19th century but with the modern conveniences of today.

Very pretty

Beautiful hidden gem in St. Catharines. Quiet and clean. Large rooms. Loved it and we’ll be back.

Amazing renovation. Step back in time. Lovely.

Good

It's heritage, kind of vintage. Would love to stay everytime

Absolutely beautiful, don't forget room 101, between Murdock Mysteries and Downton Abbey

Nice area. Central.

The room we got was smaller than what our pictures on expedia lead us to believe but we still gave it 5 stars as the property itself was amazing, inside and out. Things to know. Our room did have a toilet and sink but no shower. There was 2 community washrooms with showers. Our room 303 3rd floor front left corner of the property. Did have a mascerator connected to the plumbing. Whenever we flushed the toilet or ran the bathroom faucet in our room, it would make a crazy loud grinding noise. Scared the crap out of us and im sure it scared our neighbors too at 1am. That was our only issue with the property but we understood trying to make plumbing work in something built in 1856. Again amazing property. Don't hesitate to book.

My wife and I visited Rodman Hall to attend a wedding in town. This is a very unique and special place. We were blown away by the attention to detail and care take to restore the property to its original 19th century look. Would highly recommend.

Merritt Suite is lovely

The property is beautiful! The rooms are comfortable and spacious and the gardens are lovely. The building is very secure. I appreciated the continental breakfast each morning. There was no front desk or staff apart from the gentleman who laid out the breakfast. I would stay here again.

This is a beautifully renovated home that is a cornerstone of history for the area. The owner, Nino, gave us the grand tour and I do mean grand. Be sure to check out the history of Rodman Hall so before you go. There is no restaurant on the grounds, which are beautiful, but there are plenty downtown which is a short drive away.

Definitely not what I was expecting from the description of a boutique hotel. I was very surprised to find I was the only person at the property - no staff or other guests. I was given a key code for the front door and for my room. It was unnerving and creepy to be staying alone. The toiletries were bulk purchase from costco and there was a dodgy Keurig machine in a corner of a dining room that I found - not something I ended up trying. The building itself was beautiful and the furnishings were nice, but the grounds are tired and need some love. It could be a good place if you were hosting an event or for a group, but I would not recommend as a hotel.

Very expensive for not having any staff or real amenities. No information in the room on absolutely anything. A little creepy at night. One big old empty house. $400.00 not worth it.

Great place!

It was a lovely experience and beautiful restored property. I would have loved if they had the option of coffee in the room or nearby in the lobby.

They upgraded the room for free my wedding night. Checking in is as simple as getting an email and putting in a door code.

It is quiet and comfortable place for a couple.

The location and building and rooms themselves are unique and special. The servicing less so - no front desk, so you rely on virtual support staff, and, while friendly, they did not deliver on critically reassuring info such as building and room passcodes until after the admittance time, and only by our renewed request, via cell, at the site. Too late! No bar fridge, and no good info on site amenities ahead of time. That said, a beautifully restored historic building with unique character - just needs better support.

The hotel is absolutely beautiful.

It was a very unique hotel. Lots of history. Beautiful space beautiful rooms and grounds. No staff other than the cleaning staff who were great! But the instructions were very clear and sent to you the day before. Only thing is not all the rooms have washrooms some need to share. If mobility is an issue make sure to book on the main floor, no elevator we were on the 3rd floor and both of us are in pretty good shape but found it a bit difficult with luggage and bags. Wedding venue is gorgeous and staff were great for the venue and bar space. Good food.

Highly recommend to stay