We would like to make this our vacationing place every year. This was our first visit to Montauk. The BeachComber is gorgeous. Our room was luxurious and our view was picturesque. The rep who checked is in Naissa,(forgive me for incorrect spelling) was most polite. Only issue was guest above us or construction going on from the banging noise. The Beachcomber still gets 5 stars.

amazing!

Spectacular property. I used to live in Montauk and this stay took us back to my childhood!!

Spectacular property. I used to live in Montauk and this stay took us back to my childhood!!

The place was great !

We stayed Labor Day weekend. And have stayed before. Location to beach is perfect. Walk across the street to a private beach. Ryan at the pool was very friendly and made sure the tools were followed. The pool is large with plenty of seating and very clean. Gym on site very clean. Rental chairs for beach if needed. Carmen, who cleaned was fantastic. George the maintenance person very nice and fixed our screen door quickly. The office staff and property manager were all helpful and were able to get us in our two rooms even a little early. The property is a coop so each room is decorated and furnished differently. Our studio rooms bed was not the best, could have used a new mattress but the room we had for our adult children was a one bedroom with pull out coach and it was lovely. Rooms are spacious. We had Oceanside studio which comes with everything you need. And we also had a one bedroom which had a big deck and was very spacious. When booking ask questions about room types and locations. Our room was a short walk to beach some at top of hill can be longer. A short walk to town. We will be back.

Love the balconies and the quiet beach access! The staff was so nice as well.

Unit we had was clean but had a musty smell. Staff came to spray. It improved but still was there when no windows open.

Unit we had was clean but had a musty smell. Staff came to spray. It improved but still was there when no windows open.

Great location, good amenities.

It was our third stay at the Beachcomber and just like the past two times we made so many memories! The weather cooperated. We walked into town on various occasions to shop and eat. We went to the beach and explored all of the trails by the light house. Another awesome long weekend in the books!

Perfect

It was just a little annoying that there was a coffee pot with no coffee available. Anywhere I’ve ever gone they have coffee in the rooms.

The place was well kept and in a perfect location. Cant wait to go back!

The place was well kept and in a perfect location. Cant wait to go back!

Great stay!

Staff was unprofessional and aggressive. Pushed me out to leave before check out and still charged me a late check out fee.

Absolutely loved this property! Our studio was amazing. Will definitely be back. :)

Staff was unprofessional and aggressive. Pushed me out to leave before check out and still charged me a late check out fee.

Great stay!

Absolutely loved this property! Our studio was amazing. Will definitely be back. :)

Parking tight

Close to main area of Montauk

Parking tight

Close to main area of Montauk

Much nicer than expected based on the dated photos.

Much nicer than expected based on the dated photos.

Parking is too limited

Parking is too limited

Was fine for a 2 night staycation. CONS: Room was dated and in poor condition: all lamps and TV in power cords; broken cabinets, lightbulbs out, AC so loud could not run at night. PROS: lovely view even from lower level, nice pool And gym, walkable

Was fine for a 2 night staycation. CONS: Room was dated and in poor condition: all lamps and TV in power cords; broken cabinets, lightbulbs out, AC so loud could not run at night. PROS: lovely view even from lower level, nice pool And gym, walkable

Easy walk to the beach, close to town. Staff went above and beyond - rooms could be updated a bit but overall 10/10 stay!