A Waterfront Home for All-Seasons in Door County!

Miscellaneous
Fridge, microwave, oven, stovetop
Miscellaneous
Property grounds
Property grounds
4.8
Outstanding(70 Reviews)

Cottage in Door County, WI

10 guests · 5 bedrooms · 2 baths

Reasons to book

Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Free cancellationFull refund if you change your mind
Includes essentialsGarden, Kitchen or Kitchenette, Internet / Wifi and more

About this cottage rental

Welcome! We know you'll love our waterfront home as you make memories with friends and family.

Kill Kare is a complete and modernized cottage, available to rent throughout the year. Just two miles from the city limits of Sturgeon Bay, you'll feel refreshed and relaxed here. The water is shallow, situated on an area of the bay called ''the flats''. It's known for great fishing, boating, and swimming. During some years, it's possible for an average height adult to walk over 300 yards into the bay before it is over his or her head. Additionally, there is a sand bar, often exposed, about 75 yards off shore, which is a great place to bring the children for a fun diversion. (During the Winter the bay freezes over entirely - perfect for skating, broomball, snowshoeing, or hiking.)

There are no inhabited dwellings on the lots adjacent to Kill Kare, so it truly is a secluded environment. Potawatomi State Park is just across the bay, so the view is unhampered.


There are no city lights to dim your nighttime view of the stars as you gather around the bonfire on the beach. The driveway is long and tree-lined, isolating you from Highway BB and any traffic noise.

''Kill Kare'' is the name that our grandfather, Louis H. Nebel, gave to this wonderful getaway on Wisconsin's Door County Peninsula. Maybe his love of Shakespeare prevailed, envisioning a place where all cares, worries would be killed. He was Door County's first electrical contractor, and though his residence was only two miles away in Sturgeon Bay, like any businessman, he valued his retreat place. The cottage has been our family gathering place ever since, a place where four generations now have forged their fondest memories.

Our grandfather originally purchased this property in November of 1922...for $750! He paid his mortgage off in two years. Then, in 1935 he secured a mortgage of $5,400 to construct the first phase of the building.

Over the years Kill Kare grew in a piecemeal fashion--adding a sun porch and a small upstairs loft. Then, in 1999, our mother, Helen Nebel, saw to it that the building would be expanded and renovated to serve future generations. When she died in 2002 her will specified that the cottage somehow stay in the family, with rentals allowed to provide for upkeep and taxes - but not as an income property, per se.

*Today Kill Kare is a modernized 4 plus bedroom home, secluded and situated on over 100 feet of private sand beach, available for year-round rentals. You'll gather a sense of our family's history here, and perhaps you'll start to gather a sense of your own. We just love this place, reserving enough family time each year to keep the sense of home and heritage alive. And though most of us no longer live in Door County, we make routine pilgrimages back home - to kill our cares. You'll see why.

Amenities

Kitchen or Kitchenette
Internet / Wifi
Fireplace
Parking
Laundry
Balcony or Patio
Dishwasher
TV
Garden
Family friendly

Map of Door County, WI

Reviews

4.8
Outstanding(70 Reviews)
4.8
Aug 2024
This was the perfect cottage for our family! It was a quiet, peaceful lake and location yet close to Sturgeon Bay. The kids loved the sandy beach and swimming right in front of the cottage. The cottage is spacious, clean and well organized. The owner is easy to work with and very accommodating. There were water/sand toys for the kids, life jackets, water shoes and kayaks. Lots of outdoor seating, picnic tables and 2 grills. You don’t need to bring much along. My 4 y/o granddaughter asked if we could visit again. So, yes we’ll be back next summer.
4.8
Oct 2023
All in all a great place to stay. However, if you plan on sitting around the campfire and having a good time past 8:30 PM, the neighbor has sensitive ears, and will not so politely ask you to be quiet!
4.8
Oct 2023
We thought there would be a little more walkability. We were hoping to do a little wandering around the lake/ woods
4.8
Sep 2023
We enjoyed the stay a lot and had good quality family time. Thank you!
4.8
Sep 2023
We had such a wonderful time at Kill Kare! Our kids (5 and 7) loved playing in the sand on the private beach and making s'mores around the fire each night. The sunset was amazing! The house is nicely stocked with everything we needed to cook breakfast and lunch (we ate out at night). Tom, the host, was kind and responsive. We had one small issue and he resolved it quickly. Highly recommend!
4.8
Aug 2023
Beautiful place, we loved it.
4.8
Aug 2023
Our family enjoyed our stay in Door County. The cabin had plenty of space both indoors and out for our family gathering. Unfortunately for us, bad outdoor air quality due to Canadian wildfires hit during our vacation and we couldn't enjoy the outdoors quite as much as we had planned. However--the lake was still clear and refreshing and kids and adults both enjoyed the lake when we could! It was perfect for swimming, paddleboarding and enjoying time on the beach.
4.8
Jun 2023
This is the third year in a row that our group has stayed at this property and it always delivers! We love the lakefront views, the private beach, and the general lake house vibes. Tom is an amazing host, and we can't wait to come back next year!

FAQs

How much does this cottage cost compared to others in Door County?

The average price for a rental in Door County is $503 per night. This rental is $378 above the average.

Is parking included with this cottage?

Yes, parking is listed as an amenity at A Waterfront Home for All-Seasons in Door County!. For more information, we encourage you to contact the property about where to park.

Is there a pool at this cottage?

We didn’t find pool listed as an amenity for this cottage. It may be worth double checking if a pool is important for your stay.

Is A Waterfront Home for All-Seasons in Door County! pet friendly?

Unfortunately, this cottage is not pet-friendly. Try searching again and filter for "Pets Allowed"

What amenities are available at A Waterfront Home for All-Seasons in Door County!?

We found 10 amenities for this rental. This includes kitchen or kitchenette, internet / wifi, fireplace, parking, and laundry.

Explore similar vacation rentals in Door County

Explore all rentals in Door County

Door County travel inspiration

Read our blog