Luxe 4 Bed/3 Bath Stunning Full Lakefront Private Beach/Chautauqua/Lily Dale
5.0
Outstanding(182 Reviews)House in Lake Erie, OH
10 guests · 4 bedrooms · 3 baths
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Free cancellationFull refund if you change your mind
Great for petsBring all your friends and family, even the furry ones
About this house rental
THE BLUE OAR LAKEHOUSE/Chautauqua/Lilydale/The Red House Wedding Barn
This newly renovated 4 bedroom, 3 full bathroom house, with central air, is sure to impress your guests. Luxury on the lake. Located directly on Cassadaga Lakes with gorgeous full lake views. Property features a private dock with gorgeous new lakefront landscaping, firepit, and private pea gravel beach area. Public boat launch. Small town, quiet year round family neighborhood on Cassadaga Lakes. 3 minutes to Lily Dale - you can even kayak or bike there! Just 55 minutes from Holiday Valley Ski Resort. Bemus Point on Chautauqua Lake is a 20 minute back roads drive. Tarbox Road Recording Studio is a 4 minute drive. Property is in the heart of Amish Country.
WINTER MONTHS
This cozy house on the lake is stocked with warm blankets and you can snuggle up to the fireplace with mulled wine and hot cocoa with gorgeous views of the frozen lake. Snowshoes are provided for our guests! You can also cross country ski or take a day trip to 2 ski resorts (Peak n’ Peek or Holiday Valley). A beautiful way to spend a winter weekend out of the city.
VISIT ON INSTAGRAM FOR LOTS OF PHOTOS! @blueoarlakehouse
INTERIOR FEATURES
KITCHEN
Kitchen is Fully Stocked. Samsung refrigerator with ice/water maker, Kitchen Aid convection range, LG dishwasher, septic-safe garbage disposal, industrial sink faucet, microwave, Cuisinart blender, 4 slice toaster, Kitchen Aid Mixer, Keurig Coffee Maker, cloth napkins, dish towels, dishes, baking dishes, variety of serving platters, knives, cookware & stainless steel flatware. Kitchen nook for morning coffee.
BEDROOMS
4 bedrooms and 3 full bathrooms. Sleeps 8 comfortably. Pack-n-play and highchair for little ones.
FIRST FLOOR BEDROOM
Queen bedroom with full bathroom & tub. This bathroom has a shower seat, grab bars and hand held shower head.
SECOND FLOOR BEDROOMS
Master Suite features King RH Leather Bed with Tempur-Pedic mattress, wall-to-wall modern carpeting, cove ceiling with recessed lighting, double sink vanity and soaking whirlpool jet tub.
Queen bedroom with Queen bed.
Twin bedroom with 2 Twin beds.
Both bedrooms share a large full bathroom with tub. Stacked Washer and Dryer in 2nd floor bathroom.
Each bathroom features custom cararra marble tile.
INTERIORS
Hardwood floors throughout house.
Separate dining and livingroom. Table seats 6, plus two wingback chairs for cocktails. Livingroom features HUGE sectional, TV, ceiling fan, electric fireplace, and amazing view of lake with access to front porch.
A small office off the front foyer is great for getting work done.
OTHER AMENITIES
LG stackable washer and dryer on second floor.
Central Air. Ceiling fans. Nest Thermostat.
Cable TV and WiFi. New Electric Fireplace!!
Keurig.
OUTSIDE FEATURES
Gorgeous covered front porch with rocking chairs and porch swing with amazing full view of the lake. New Private Floating dock with 4 adirondack chairs for enjoying the view. New private lakefront landscaping down to the waterfront with pea gravel beach area and firepit! Large driveway that can hold multiple vehicles. Large 4 car garage, 2 car parking pad and a covered patio features a propane grill and 2 large picnic tables for entertaining. Outdoor fire pit for evening smores. 4 kayaks, 2 paddle boards, 1 pedal boat, 1 child's kayak, 1 floating mat, 4 bikes and yard games. Large backyard!
There is a public boat launch available if you are bringing your own boat. You can dock tie up to our private floating dock!
AREA FUN
Farm stands, Amish Country, Southern Tier Brewery, Ellicottville Brewery, Bemus Point, Lily Dale, Tarbox Road Recording Studio, Wineries, The Red House Wedding Barn, Chautauqua Lake, kayaking, hiking, biking, fishing, Holiday Valley Ski Resort, Peek n' Peak Ski Resort, & snowmobiling are some of the fun activities you'll find near this beautiful get-a-way. You'll never want to leave!
CLEANING PROTOCOL
The Blue Oar has always gone above and beyond to ensure a clean environment for our guests including bleaching all white bath towels and bed linens, and sanitizing all bathrooms and kitchen with antibacterial and bleach cleaners. We also wash all duvet covers (these are the pillowcases for the comforters) between EVERY stay!
QUESTIONS?
If you have any questions, big or small, please do not hesitate to text or call Kim Collins at 412.445.2720. I am here to help in any way I can.
We hope you have an awesome time making memories at the Blue Oar!
This newly renovated 4 bedroom, 3 full bathroom house, with central air, is sure to impress your guests. Luxury on the lake. Located directly on Cassadaga Lakes with gorgeous full lake views. Property features a private dock with gorgeous new lakefront landscaping, firepit, and private pea gravel beach area. Public boat launch. Small town, quiet year round family neighborhood on Cassadaga Lakes. 3 minutes to Lily Dale - you can even kayak or bike there! Just 55 minutes from Holiday Valley Ski Resort. Bemus Point on Chautauqua Lake is a 20 minute back roads drive. Tarbox Road Recording Studio is a 4 minute drive. Property is in the heart of Amish Country.
WINTER MONTHS
This cozy house on the lake is stocked with warm blankets and you can snuggle up to the fireplace with mulled wine and hot cocoa with gorgeous views of the frozen lake. Snowshoes are provided for our guests! You can also cross country ski or take a day trip to 2 ski resorts (Peak n’ Peek or Holiday Valley). A beautiful way to spend a winter weekend out of the city.
VISIT ON INSTAGRAM FOR LOTS OF PHOTOS! @blueoarlakehouse
INTERIOR FEATURES
KITCHEN
Kitchen is Fully Stocked. Samsung refrigerator with ice/water maker, Kitchen Aid convection range, LG dishwasher, septic-safe garbage disposal, industrial sink faucet, microwave, Cuisinart blender, 4 slice toaster, Kitchen Aid Mixer, Keurig Coffee Maker, cloth napkins, dish towels, dishes, baking dishes, variety of serving platters, knives, cookware & stainless steel flatware. Kitchen nook for morning coffee.
BEDROOMS
4 bedrooms and 3 full bathrooms. Sleeps 8 comfortably. Pack-n-play and highchair for little ones.
FIRST FLOOR BEDROOM
Queen bedroom with full bathroom & tub. This bathroom has a shower seat, grab bars and hand held shower head.
SECOND FLOOR BEDROOMS
Master Suite features King RH Leather Bed with Tempur-Pedic mattress, wall-to-wall modern carpeting, cove ceiling with recessed lighting, double sink vanity and soaking whirlpool jet tub.
Queen bedroom with Queen bed.
Twin bedroom with 2 Twin beds.
Both bedrooms share a large full bathroom with tub. Stacked Washer and Dryer in 2nd floor bathroom.
Each bathroom features custom cararra marble tile.
INTERIORS
Hardwood floors throughout house.
Separate dining and livingroom. Table seats 6, plus two wingback chairs for cocktails. Livingroom features HUGE sectional, TV, ceiling fan, electric fireplace, and amazing view of lake with access to front porch.
A small office off the front foyer is great for getting work done.
OTHER AMENITIES
LG stackable washer and dryer on second floor.
Central Air. Ceiling fans. Nest Thermostat.
Cable TV and WiFi. New Electric Fireplace!!
Keurig.
OUTSIDE FEATURES
Gorgeous covered front porch with rocking chairs and porch swing with amazing full view of the lake. New Private Floating dock with 4 adirondack chairs for enjoying the view. New private lakefront landscaping down to the waterfront with pea gravel beach area and firepit! Large driveway that can hold multiple vehicles. Large 4 car garage, 2 car parking pad and a covered patio features a propane grill and 2 large picnic tables for entertaining. Outdoor fire pit for evening smores. 4 kayaks, 2 paddle boards, 1 pedal boat, 1 child's kayak, 1 floating mat, 4 bikes and yard games. Large backyard!
There is a public boat launch available if you are bringing your own boat. You can dock tie up to our private floating dock!
AREA FUN
Farm stands, Amish Country, Southern Tier Brewery, Ellicottville Brewery, Bemus Point, Lily Dale, Tarbox Road Recording Studio, Wineries, The Red House Wedding Barn, Chautauqua Lake, kayaking, hiking, biking, fishing, Holiday Valley Ski Resort, Peek n' Peak Ski Resort, & snowmobiling are some of the fun activities you'll find near this beautiful get-a-way. You'll never want to leave!
CLEANING PROTOCOL
The Blue Oar has always gone above and beyond to ensure a clean environment for our guests including bleaching all white bath towels and bed linens, and sanitizing all bathrooms and kitchen with antibacterial and bleach cleaners. We also wash all duvet covers (these are the pillowcases for the comforters) between EVERY stay!
QUESTIONS?
If you have any questions, big or small, please do not hesitate to text or call Kim Collins at 412.445.2720. I am here to help in any way I can.
We hope you have an awesome time making memories at the Blue Oar!
Amenities
Air conditioner
Pets allowed
Kitchen or Kitchenette
Internet / Wifi
Fireplace
Parking
Laundry
Balcony or Patio
Dishwasher
TV
Garden
Family friendly
Map of Lake Erie, OH
Reviews
5.0
Outstanding(182 Reviews)5.0
This was our first visit but won’t be our last! The property is even better than advertised. There was so much to do there even on the rainy days! Thanks so much!!
5.0
This property was excellent! It literally had everything and beyond what we were expecting. The house was very clean and had all the supplies again beyond what was expected. We had a few days with rain so the large garage was great to play games in along with picnic tables that was under roofing to keep us dry was very convenient. I would definitely recommend this property and Kim was extremely prompt and a pleasure to communicate with when we had questions. Consider this property for your next get away!
5.0
The property is as advertised. Super clean and well appointed! Everything is labeled and clear about how to utilize and care for the property while living there. Highly recommend!
5.0
The property was amazing. Anything we needed was provided (we even were in the lake and said how nice it’d be to have pool noodles, go and look in the garage and she has them!) and the host was very nice and communicative. We’ve all agreed that we’ll be back next year!
5.0
Absolutely wonderful place. Fun, kitchy, cool, lux, cozy interiors. Picturesque views both lakeside and backyard. Extras everywhere. Kim was lovely to work with, responsive and helpful. The only thing we were missing was more time!
5.0
This was our 2nd time staying at your lake house. Your home is so well taken care of. We loved the various upgrades that you have made. Your attendtion to detail is amazing. The house was clean and equipt with everything we could need. Thank you again. We look forward to returning in the future.
5.0
This lake house did not disappoint. The pictures are nothing compared to the real thing. You step into a high-quality design architecture digest-worthy home. From the landscaping, and beautifully decorated home to the well-stocked kitchen. I usually have to buy a ton of items to make my family comfortable however not at Kim's Lake house. They thought of everything. Ample silverware, toiletries, cushions, TVs, and even a reading and computer nook. You never know how much a home could bring you joy until you stay at a home like this.
We were in love with the lake view, and the quiet peaceful neighborhood. Slept so comfortably in the king-size bed together with all the other rooms so well portioned and positioned in the home. The master suite was so comfortable that just that room would have been enough for me for the entire stay.
All I can say is thank you Kim for your kindness with our last-minute updates. Your prompt responses throughout made this so easy.
Thank you for sharing your beautiful home with me and my family. I hope to return again very soon.
5.0
I've stayed at many VRBOs over the years but Blue Oar has really set the bar high for me from now on. Firstly, the location setting was perfect. A quiet street with gorgeous lake views that can be enjoyed from the large front porch with comfy seating to include a relaxing porch swing. There is plenty of parking. And lots of outside space as well, not only there at the house, but at the private beach area that has a cool firepit and a dock with seating. When we were there it was too early in the season to enjoy the lake but during the summer I imagine it would be amazing with the many water activities you could enjoy. I want to complement the owners for how well appointed their rental is. We enjoyed cooking several of our meals in the kitchen and it was as well appointed as any of our own homes. Everything you could need is provided. The bathrooms were equally well appointed and the house is so charming. We loved the living area, with the comfortable couches and seating and a couple of us needed to check into work and made good use of the little office/library room just off the front entryway area. They had also provided many board games and we used the dining table area in the evenings to enjoy playing games. There were little extras here and there throughout the house that we discovered during our stay. Rarely do you find a rental property where you feel "at home" but Blue Oar felt like a home away from home for me, and the rest of our friend group as well. Thank you!
5.0
This is such a beautiful home with space for everyone and so well-appointed! We’d love to go back in the summer to enjoy the lake activities!
5.0
Loved the homely Christmasy feel. Comfortable, cosy and well appointed. The cottage, especially the kitchen is highly organised and well stocked. Kim has thought of everything!
5.0
Spent the Christmas holiday with family and it was more than we hoped for. The home was exquisitely decorated and we all had a wonderful time. We are already planning on staying here again next year. Highly recommend this property, you will not be disappointed!
5.0
Phenomenal location by the lake with everything you could ask for in a lake house! Exactly as described! Lots of room, comfortable beds, fully equipped kitchen, lots of little details right on point! Couldn't be happier. Excellent host with amazing communication. We WILL be back!!!! Thank you!!!!!
5.0
We had a girls weekend here. The house is decorated so cute inside and out! We all had plenty of comfortable space and more importantly when 6 of us needed to shower there was plenty of hot water! The kitchen is so well stocked and everything was so lovely. We all were looking for a weekend to come back! This is such a gem and we had such a good time!
5.0
This was our second visit to the beautiful Blue Oar. This time we were celebrating our 40 year college reunion at nearby SUNY Fredonia. The Blue Oar is a wonderfully updated older home, tastefully decorated and very well appointed. It was clean, comfortable and very warm and inviting. We will be back and would highly recommend.
5.0
Our stay at the Blue Oar was relaxing. Everything we needed was there and the house was as advertised. We booked it again.
5.0
My mother in law loved her weekend getaway at the Blue Oar to celebrate her birthday. The house was very clean, nicely decorated, and had plenty of space for a family weekend.
We spent an entire day using the outdoor amenties at the house. The fire pit, paddleboat, and kayaks were all great.
If we are ever in the area again, we will absolutely come back!
5.0
Wonderful 60th annivarsary for my parents.
5.0
Everything was perfect & it was amazingly equipped with everything you could possibly need!!!
5.0
The property is beautiful and extremely well-equipped. The beds were very comfortable and the kitchen was a joy to use to prepare our meals. There are numerous outdoor games, etc in the huge garage which we enjoyed using.
Neighborhood was lovely and a nice place to walk and ride bikes . My family wants to return again next year.
5.0
The Blue Oar was a lovely property for a short family lake getaway. Incredibly well appointed with lots of yard games and lake activities! Lovely, quiet neighborhood. Highly recommend.
The surrounding towns do seem to shut down after Labor Day, so that is just something to be aware of when booking dates! We had a hard time finding open restaurants.
5.0
We had the best weekend at the Blue Oar. Was the best stocked VRBO I’ve ever seen, with every possible amenity and extra. I messaged the owner with several questions leading up to our stay, and Kim was immediate and helpful in her responses. The property was clean and impeccably decorated. We will absolutely be staying again!
5.0
This recent trip was our 6th year at the Blue Oar and it never fails to disappoint. My family and I took full advantage of the amenities, and were pleased to find a smaller kayak for children to use. After so many years, we finally decided to head to the Stockton Hotel for dinner and came away very impressed. We made our usual trips to the Dunkirk beaches and Midway for the kids, as well as Bemus Point, which is a short trip away. We've already booked for next year and look forward to checking out the Blie Canoe as well.
5.0
We were looking for a nice peaceful place to relax and we definitely found it. From waking up each morning to the beautiful view, to spending the day kayaking and then end it with a cozy fire all by the lake, it was perfect.
5.0
We all had a great time at this beautiful home. Has everything you need and is located in a nice quiet area.
5.0
We had a fantastic time at Blue Oar in Cassadaga. Kim is an amazing host, so energetic and informative. The house is beautifully decorated and every need thoughtfully considered. We watched beautiful sunrises over Lake Cassadaga from the front porch. There is a huge backyard and all the countless treasures inside the garage (bikes, games, toys). We had our own private pier and fire pit which we loved! At the pier, the paddleboat was a hit, along with the kayaks and paddle boards. There was plenty to do for kids and adults alike. You really can't do better in a rental, given the quality of home and all that's provided. We took away nothing but great memories.
5.0
This property is absolutely gorgeous and the amenities are top notch! Our whole family had an amazing Memorial Day weekend with so many things for everyone to do — paddle boards, kayaks, paddle boat, fishing and biking. The owner has literally thought of everything. We had perfect weather so the outdoor activities were paramount. Even if the weather did not cooperate, we would have had plenty to do inside. The kitchen was great as were the bedrooms and bathrooms. So cozy in the living room and porch— plenty of room for all of us! We’ve already booked our stay for next year!
5.0
The house and entire property are very well appointed and cozy. Beautiful views of Cassadaga Lake. The amenities are top notch and the owner was very accommodating . There is no need to leave the house and property because it is so dreamy and relaxing. The porch and dockside area are amazing! This house is perfect for all seasons of the year. Definitely a home that we will be returning to.
5.0
The house was perfect!! The decor looked like it was straight out of a pottery barn catalog. We had a wide age range of family staying at house and they thought of everything. The first floor bathroom and bedroom was perfect for someone with limited mobilty. This place would be awesome in the summer with all the fun lake stuff they have, and the chairs right on the lake. Would love to check this place out in the summer.
5.0
We had a great time with family celebrated our father birthday and all his kids and grand kids came Great time pertly of room
5.0
Kim made the whole process so easy. We got there and the house was beautifully decorated for Christmas. There are lots of places to tuck in with a good book. The kitchen is an absolute dream and exceptionally well-equipped. Our family was over the moon. Thank you and plan to be back again!
5.0
We loved everything about the house. It was perfect in every way.
5.0
My sisters, husband, and I needed a place to be close to our father's family and this was the perfect place. We were lucky to have a beautiful fall week but look forward to coming back during the summer to enjoy the lakeside amenities, including a fire pit with plenty of firewood. We stayed during Halloween, Kim provided a huge bowl of candy, unbeknownst to us this was the main trick or treating route - it made for a perfect way to spend a perfect fall evening. Can't wait to come back!
5.0
Utterly charming! We had a relaxing three days. The Blue Oar is beautifully appointed top to bottom. The view of the lake is very peaceful. The landscaping and fall decorations were so welcoming. We will definitely return for another visit. The Blue Oar is a gem! Many thanks!!
5.0
For our 59th anniversary, there was Fall foliage, a lake so peaceful you could see fish jump, a lovely property outfitted with EVERY POSSIBILE NEED. Room layout the best, for our family, plan to do out 60th anniversary next year..God Willing! Donna
5.0
There is no other way to describe this property other than perfection!!! Third time my friends and I have stayed in this beautiful home and it's never a disappointment. Everything needed for a comfortable and enjoyable stay is provided. Plenty of cooking utensils, dishes, kitchen gadgets at your fingertips. The entire house is squeaky clean. The electric fireplace adds a warm and comfy touch. Plenty of firewood wood available if needed. The deck area is great for enjoying the lake with a warm cup of cocoa or coffee. Kim does a remarkable job with this beautiful and homey VRBO rental. Thank youi so much.
5.0
Beautiful house and property
5.0
The Blue Oar is a fantastic vacation spot. The house is very well stocked and has tons of activities to do inside and out. Games, bikes, kayaks, SUP, pedal boat, etc. It is also just a half hour drive to some nice towns with more things to do and see. The lake is quiet and it is very relaxing to sit on the private dock and take in the beautiful surroundings. The house is very well organized and had everything we needed to prepare meals for 7 people.
5.0
We've been coming to the Blue Oar for some time and it's a really wonderful house with all the amenities adults and children could hope for. Already booked for next summer
5.0
We have been renting this for the last 5 years it is always a great experience! Kim the owner pays attention to every detail. My family loves staying here!
5.0
This is a gorgeous house inside and outside. Every space is really comfortable and well thought out. We thoroughly enjoyed the home and the waterfront taking advantage of all the amenities.
FAQs
How much does this house cost compared to others in Lake Erie?
The average price for a rental in Lake Erie is $257 per night. This rental is $546 above the average.
Is parking included with this house?
Yes, parking is listed as an amenity at Luxe 4 Bed/3 Bath Stunning Full Lakefront Private Beach/Chautauqua/Lily Dale. For more information, we encourage you to contact the property about where to park.
Is there a pool at this house?
We didn’t find pool listed as an amenity for this house. It may be worth double checking if a pool is important for your stay.
Is Luxe 4 Bed/3 Bath Stunning Full Lakefront Private Beach/Chautauqua/Lily Dale pet friendly?
Yes! This house is pet-friendly. For more information, we recommend contacting the booking provider about animal policies.
What amenities are available at Luxe 4 Bed/3 Bath Stunning Full Lakefront Private Beach/Chautauqua/Lily Dale?
We found 12 amenities for this rental. This includes air conditioner, pets allowed, kitchen or kitchenette, internet / wifi, and fireplace.
Explore similar vacation rentals in Lake Erie
Explore all rentals in Lake ErieLake Erie travel inspiration
Read our blogGuides
Top Things to Do in Oahu and Honolulu
Guides
Top Things to Do in Fort Lauderdale, Florida
Guides
Top Things to Do in Miami: From Beaches to Culture
Guides
The Best Things to Do in Orlando: Attractions, Food, and Family Fun
Guides
Things to Do in Galveston, Texas
Guides
Top Things to Do in Myrtle Beach
Guides
Ski Trip Packing List: What to Bring Skiing or Snowboarding
Trends
VacationRenter Holiday Travel Trends 2023