DestinationShelter Island, NY
Add dates
Guests1

Ideal for 2 families, private, pool, close to beaches and marina Sleeps 12

Outdoor pool, a heated pool
Fridge, microwave, oven, stovetop
Terrace/patio
Outdoor dining
Property grounds
10.0
Outstanding(1 Review)

House in Shelter Island, NY

12 guests · 7 bedrooms · 3 baths

Reasons to book

Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Great for petsBring all your friends and family, even the furry ones
Top-tier experienceOne of the higher cost properties in the area

About this house rental

Welcome to Casa di Famiglia! Close to nature and the water, this family compound will rejuvenate your spirit. This property consists of a 3 bedroom 2 bath farmhouse that sleeps 6 including a queen pull out couch in the office. Also on the property is a 3 bedroom 1 bath pool house that sleeps 6 and has a living area with a kitchenette. The pool house is open from June 1st to October 15th. There is a lovely, private heated pool and a beautiful private backyard for relaxing and playing games. Enjoy morning coffee on the side porch and in the evening sit by the outdoor fire on the patio. Included in the rental are bikes to enjoy cycling around this beautiful island and kayaks to launch only 1/4 mile down the road. This property borders town nature walking trails ideal for viewing the diverse wildlife in the area. A water front restaurant, bar and The Island Boatyard Marina are walking distance from the house. This island is a boating paradise with boating charters available at the marina. The beach is a 5 minute drive. Between listening to all the bird song, smelling the salt air and relaxing in this most serene space, your visit to Casa di Famiglia will be a memorable one!

Amenities

Pool
Air conditioner
Pets allowed
Kitchen or Kitchenette
Internet / Wifi
Fireplace
Parking
Laundry
Balcony or Patio
Dishwasher
TV
Garden
Family friendly

Map of Shelter Island, NY

city location on map
pin

Nearby attractions

Montauk Point State Park
39.3 mi
Search properties near Montauk Point State Park
Mystic Aquarium
48.4 mi
Search properties near Mystic Aquarium
Gillette Castle State Park
41.4 mi
Search properties near Gillette Castle State Park
Montauk Lighthouse Museum
41.2 mi
Search properties near Montauk Lighthouse Museum
$$$$
vrbo logo

Reviews

10.0
Outstanding(1 Review)
10.0
Aug 2023
This is a charming and gracious home! Comfortable and spacious. Well cared for and spotlessly clean. It’s a home that provides guests with everything they need. Fresh linens. Perfect mattresses. Soft pillows and heaps of fluffy towels. High speed WiFi. Wonderful air conditioning in every room. All the kitchen appliances you”ll want and the perfect laundry room with snazzy, modern machines that hum. The house is also perfectly situated on the island for east access to everywhere you want to be. The pool house is an amazing bonus. The grounds are beautiful with mature trees and big green lawns. Our stay was truly wonderful and our hosts most helpful, accessible and kind. We’d love to return next Summer and can’t recommend this house enough!!

FAQs

How much does this house cost compared to others in Shelter Island?

The average price for a rental in Shelter Island is $1,130 per night. This rental is $56 less expensive than the average.

Is parking included with this house?

Yes, parking is listed as an amenity at Ideal for 2 families, private, pool, close to beaches and marina Sleeps 12. For more information, we encourage you to contact the property about where to park.

Is there a pool at this house?

Yes, a swimming pool is available for use at Ideal for 2 families, private, pool, close to beaches and marina Sleeps 12. Enjoy the water!

Is Ideal for 2 families, private, pool, close to beaches and marina Sleeps 12 pet friendly?

Yes! This house is pet-friendly. For more information, we recommend contacting the booking provider about animal policies.

What amenities are available at Ideal for 2 families, private, pool, close to beaches and marina Sleeps 12?

We found 13 amenities for this rental. This includes pool, air conditioner, pets allowed, kitchen or kitchenette, and internet / wifi.

Explore similar vacation rentals in Shelter Island

Explore all rentals in Shelter Island
Property view
8.0
Very good(22 Reviews)
House on Chase Creek
Bed and Breakfast
 in Shelter Island Heights
1 sofa bed, 1 queen bed
Garden · Air conditioner · Internet / Wifi

Indulge in a peaceful retreat at House on Chase Creek, our elegant Bed and Breakfast in Shelter Island. Enjoy amenities including Air conditioner, Fireplace and Internet / Wifi, and more.

$$$$
booking logo
View deal
Property view
Ahoy There
House
 in Shelter Island
8 guests · 4 bedrooms · 2 baths
Pool · Pets allowed · Family friendly

The best choice in Shelter Island for House, for $1,558 per night for your (business stay, family stay, couples stay, getaway vacation, etc.)

$$$$
plumguide logo
View deal
View from property
9.4
Outstanding(66 Reviews)
House on Chase Creek
Bed and Breakfast
 in Shelter Island Heights
2 guests · 1 bedroom · 1 bath
Garden · Air conditioner · Internet / Wifi

Experience the best of Shelter Island with this Bed and Breakfast available for $187. This property is equipped with amenities including Air conditioner, Internet / Wifi and Balcony or Patio, and more.

$$$$
hotelscom logo
View deal
Beach towels
9.8
Outstanding(50 Reviews)
Peaceful and Private Shelter Island Getaway
House
 in Shelter Island
5 guests · 3 bedrooms · 2 baths
Garden · Pets allowed · Kitchen or Kitchenette

This House for $494 in Shelter Island, is perfect for your next (business stay, family stay, couples stay, getaway vacation, etc.)

$$$$
vrbo logo
View deal
View from property
9.4
Outstanding(65 Reviews)
House on Chase Creek
Bed and Breakfast
 in Shelter Island Heights
1 king bed
Garden · Air conditioner · Internet / Wifi

Looking for a memorable stay in Shelter Island? Our Bed and Breakfast might just be what you're looking for. Enjoy amenities including Air conditioner, Internet / Wifi and Balcony or Patio, and more during your stay.

$$$$
expedia logo
View deal
Outdoor pool
9.7
Outstanding(50 Reviews)
Perfect Family Summer Vacation Home Close to beach 18x42 pool
House
 in Shelter Island
6 guests · 3 bedrooms · 3 baths
Garden · Pool · Pets allowed

Experience the best of Shelter Island with this House available for $1,056. This property is equipped with amenities including Air conditioner, Dishwasher and Internet / Wifi, and more.

$$$$
vrbo logo
View deal
Outdoor pool, a heated pool
9.9
Outstanding(40 Reviews)
Work and Play Special! Extended Stay Discount at a hideaway with Stellar Wifi!
House
 in Shelter Island
10 guests · 5 bedrooms · 3 baths
Garden · Pool · Pets allowed

Experience vacation in Shelter Island with our House, Work and Play Special! Extended Stay Discount at a hideaway with Stellar Wifi! . Enjoy amenities such as Air conditioner, Dishwasher and Internet / Wifi, and more.

$$$$
vrbo logo
View deal
A heated pool
9.6
Outstanding(37 Reviews)
NEWLY RENOVATED WITH POOL, HOT TUB, AND FIREPLACE!
House
 in Shelter Island
6 guests · 3 bedrooms · 3 baths
Garden · Pool · Kitchen or Kitchenette

Indulge in a peaceful retreat at NEWLY RENOVATED WITH POOL, HOT TUB, AND FIREPLACE! , our elegant House in Shelter Island. Enjoy amenities including Air conditioner, Dishwasher and Fireplace, and more.

$$$$
vrbo logo
View deal
A heated pool
10.0
Outstanding(34 Reviews)
Farmhouse Nestled by Meadow, Pool, Near Beaches and Centrally Located!
House
 in Shelter Island
8 guests · 4 bedrooms · 3 baths
Garden · Pool · Kitchen or Kitchenette

Indulge in a peaceful retreat at Farmhouse Nestled by Meadow, Pool, Near Beaches and Centrally Located!, our elegant House in Shelter Island. Enjoy amenities including Air conditioner, Dishwasher and Fireplace, and more.

$$$$
vrbo logo
View deal
Property view
Villa Menantic
Villa
 in Shelter Island
8 guests · 4 bedrooms · 3 baths
Pool · Pets allowed · Family friendly

Soak up the beauty of Shelter Island in our Villa, Villa Menantic. With a range of amenities such as Family friendly, Pool and Pets allowed, you'll feel right at home.

$$$$
plumguide logo
View deal
Property grounds
9.8
Outstanding(36 Reviews)
Relaxing Shelter Island Getaway - great for families and couples!
House
 in Shelter Island Heights
6 guests · 3 bedrooms · 1 bath
Garden · Kitchen or Kitchenette · Air conditioner

This inviting House in Shelter Island can fit your needs for many types of vacations, at $405 per night.

$$$$
vrbo logo
View deal
Outdoor dining
8.6
Excellent(27 Reviews)
The Chequit
Hotel
 in Shelter Island Heights
3star
2 guests · 1 bedroom · 1 bath
Internet / Wifi · Parking

Experience vacation in Shelter Island with our Hotel, The Chequit. Enjoy amenities such as Internet / Wifi and Parking, and more.

$$$$
hotelscom logo
View deal
Exterior
9.6
Outstanding(33 Reviews)
Charming, Renovated Island Cottage - Shelter Island License #: 012-2017
Cottage
 in Shelter Island
4 guests · 3 bedrooms · 1 bath
Garden · Kitchen or Kitchenette · Air conditioner

This inviting Cottage in Shelter Island can fit your needs for many types of vacations, at $526 per night.

$$$$
vrbo logo
View deal
Outdoor dining
8.4
Excellent(27 Reviews)
The Chequit
Hotel
 in Shelter Island Heights
3star
1 king bed
Internet / Wifi · Parking

Hotel in Shelter Island, for $567 per night is great for your next (business stay, family stays, couples stay, getaway vacation, etc.)

$$$$
expedia logo
View deal
A heated pool
10.0
Outstanding(28 Reviews)
Stunning, modern home with all new baths and heated Gunite pool near Wades Beach
House
 in Shelter Island
8 guests · 4 bedrooms · 4 baths
Garden · Pool · Kitchen or Kitchenette

House in Shelter Island, for $1,227 per night is great for your next (business stay, family stays, couples stay, getaway vacation, etc.)

$$$$
vrbo logo
View deal
Start earning One Key rewards
Terrace/patio
9.6
Outstanding(28 Reviews)
Cozy Shelter Island Cottage, walk to beaches and Mashomack Preserve
House
 in Shelter Island
6 guests · 3 bedrooms · 2 baths
Garden · Pool · Kitchen or Kitchenette

This House in Shelter Island, is the right price for your (business stay, family stays, couples stay, getaway vacation, etc.) today!

$$$$
vrbo logo
View deal
Beachfront
Property view
10.0
Outstanding(1 Review)
Shelter Island Retreat with Outdoor Pool!
House
 in Shelter Island
Pool · Kitchen or Kitchenette · Air conditioner

Looking for a business stay, family stay, couples stay, getaway vacation, or traveling to Shelter Island, at $119 per night for your next great vacation.

$$$$
booking logo
View deal
Property view
Port & Starboard
Apartment
 in Shelter Island
12 guests · 6 bedrooms · 5 baths
Pool · Pets allowed · Beachfront or waterfront

Enjoy the best of Shelter Island in our Apartment, Port & Starboard. A stunning property with amenities including Beachfront or waterfront, Family friendly and Pool, and more.

$$$$
plumguide logo
View deal
Fridge, oven, stovetop, dishwasher
10.0
Outstanding(26 Reviews)
Private wooded summer house 5 minute walk to Wades Beach
House
 in Shelter Island
6 guests · 4 bedrooms · 2 baths
Garden · Kitchen or Kitchenette · Air conditioner

This attractive House in Shelter Island, $1,336 per night for your (business stay, family stay, couples stay, getaway vacation, etc.)

$$$$
vrbo logo
View deal
Marina
9.8
Outstanding(27 Reviews)
Waterfront Estate on Shelter Island - 200 Feet of Waterfront - 100 Foot Dock
House
 in Shelter Island
8 guests · 4 bedrooms · 3 baths
Garden · Pool · Kitchen or Kitchenette

Experience the best of Shelter Island with this House available for $1,243. This property is equipped with amenities including Air conditioner, Dishwasher and Fireplace, and more.

$$$$
vrbo logo
View deal
Sun loungers, beach towels
10.0
Outstanding(22 Reviews)
Lovely home by the sea with dock and heated Gunite pool!
House
 in Shelter Island
10 guests · 4 bedrooms · 3 baths
Garden · Pool · Pets allowed

Looking for a memorable stay in Shelter Island? Our House might just be what you're looking for. Enjoy amenities including Air conditioner, Dishwasher and Fireplace, and more during your stay.

$$$$
vrbo logo
View deal
Exterior
8.0
Very good(17 Reviews)
The Rams Head Inn
Inn
 in Shelter Island Heights
2 guests · 1 bedroom · 1 bath
Garden · Air conditioner · Internet / Wifi

This Inn in Shelter Island, is the right price for your (business stay, family stays, couples stay, getaway vacation, etc.) today!

$$$$
hotelscom logo
View deal
Beach nearby, sun loungers, beach towels
10.0
Outstanding(19 Reviews)
Waterfront House With Dock And Private Beach
House
 in Shelter Island
6 guests · 3 bedrooms · 3 baths
Garden · Kitchen or Kitchenette · Air conditioner
Most favorited

Looking to create some memories in Shelter Island? Look no further than our House, Waterfront House With Dock And Private Beach. Enjoy top-rated amenities including Air conditioner, Dishwasher and Fireplace, and more.

$$$$
vrbo logo
View deal
Exterior
8.0
Very good(17 Reviews)
The Rams Head Inn
Inn
 in Shelter Island Heights
2 king beds
Garden · Air conditioner · Internet / Wifi

This Inn for $582 in Shelter Island, is perfect for your next (business stay, family stay, couples stay, getaway vacation, etc.)

$$$$
expedia logo
View deal
Outdoor dining
10.0
Outstanding(12 Reviews)
Kick back and unwind
House
 in Shelter Island Heights
6 guests · 3 bedrooms · 3 baths
Garden · Pets allowed · Kitchen or Kitchenette

This inviting House in Shelter Island can fit your needs for many types of vacations, at $794 per night.

$$$$
vrbo logo
View deal
Property view
Grand Optimist
Apartment
 in Shelter Island
8 guests · 4 bedrooms · 3 baths
Pool · Pets allowed · Family friendly

Experience vacation in Shelter Island with our Apartment, Grand Optimist. Enjoy amenities such as Family friendly, Pool and Pets allowed, and more.

$$$$
plumguide logo
View deal
TV, fireplace, books, printers
10.0
Outstanding(12 Reviews)
Shelter Island Sun Filled Modern Waterfront Home with Dock
House
 in Shelter Island
6 guests · 3 bedrooms · 5 baths
Garden · Kitchen or Kitchenette · Air conditioner

Looking to create some memories in Shelter Island? Look no further than our House, Shelter Island Sun Filled Modern Waterfront Home with Dock . Enjoy top-rated amenities including Air conditioner, Dishwasher and Fireplace, and more.

$$$$
vrbo logo
View deal
TV, fireplace, stereo
9.4
Outstanding(11 Reviews)
Lovely Shelter Island cottage with panoramic bay views, secluded, screened...
House
 in Shelter Island
8 guests · 5 bedrooms · 2 baths
Pets allowed · Kitchen or Kitchenette · Air conditioner

Experience the best of Shelter Island with this House available for $601. This property is equipped with amenities including Air conditioner, Fireplace and Laundry, and more.

$$$$
vrbo logo
View deal
Start earning One Key rewards
TV, fireplace, DVD player, books
9.4
Outstanding(11 Reviews)
Waterfront Home on Beautiful Shelter Island w/Large Deep Water Dock
House
 in Shelter Island
12 guests · 6 bedrooms · 3 baths
Garden · Kitchen or Kitchenette · Air conditioner

Discover the beauty of Shelter Island with a stay at Waterfront Home on Beautiful Shelter Island w/Large Deep Water Dock, a top rated House with amenities such as Air conditioner, Dishwasher and Fireplace, and more.

$$$$
vrbo logo
View deal
Fridge, microwave, oven, stovetop
10.0
Outstanding(10 Reviews)
Shelter Island Hidden Waterfront Gem
House
 in Shelter Island
8 guests · 3 bedrooms · 3 baths
Pets allowed · Kitchen or Kitchenette · Air conditioner

This House for $896 in Shelter Island, is perfect for your next (business stay, family stay, couples stay, getaway vacation, etc.)

$$$$
vrbo logo
View deal

Shelter Island travel inspiration

Read our blog
Guides
Top Things to Do in Gulf Shores, Alabama: Adventure and Fun Await
Local Culture
Exploring Miami’s Wynwood District: Street Art, Food, and More
Guides
Fun Things to Do in Ocean City, Maryland
Local Culture
A Foodie’s Guide to the Best Dining in Orlando, Florida
Guides
Top Things to Do in Oahu and Honolulu
Guides
Top Things to Do in Fort Lauderdale, Florida
Guides
Top Things to Do in Miami: From Beaches to Culture
Guides
The Best Things to Do in Orlando: Attractions, Food, and Family Fun