Luxury Water Front Cabin on Island Park Reservoir With Private Bay And Dock
Cabin in Idaho
20 guests · 9 bedrooms · 7 baths
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Top-tier experienceOne of the higher cost properties in the area
Includes essentialsKitchen or Kitchenette, Air conditioner, Internet / Wifi and more
About this cabin rental
Welcome to O’Toole Haven, a luxury lakefront cabin with your own private U-shaped dock, two waverunner ramps and private bay behind the security of the gated community on Bill’s Island. With over 5,500 beautifully appointed square feet of luxury cabin living, our Haven is nestled in the privacy of the pine tree forest with stunning views and lake front access to Island Park Reservoir. Our air conditioned resort-like feel is perfect for large families, large gatherings, family reunions or whatever your needs are, comfortably accommodating 25 people with 7 private bedrooms, 2 bunk rooms and 6 1/2 bathrooms, a large living room, a huge game room and a fully furnished spacious kitchen with two ovens and both a main level and upstairs laundry. There is a downstairs bedroom with King bed, bath with large shower, laundry room with washing machine and 2 dryers and large storage area. The master bedroom is away from the noise and has a king bed with private balcony. The master bath has a shower and a room off of the master with two twin beds. There are 4 bedrooms upstairs with King beds, three with private balconies and each with their own private Bathroom. there is also a 1/2 bath upstairs just off the family room with stackable washer and dryer. There is also 2 large bunk rooms with 3 triple-deck bunk-beds (sleeps 9) provides the perfect arrangement for the kids/cousins to enjoy the Bunk Rooms while adults sleep peacefully in their private bedroom. Three smart Tv’s 85", 75" and a 60" and DVD player. A beautiful romantic river rock fireplace in the main level Living room and a huge upstairs Game/Play/Media Room that also has ping-pong, foosball and a card table. Only 25 minutes to West Yellowstone. Cleaning procedures have been implemented for your safety and peace of mind. From arrival to departure, O’Toole Haven will touch on every sense. From the beautiful panoramic vistas on the back porch and back yard of the lake and the mountains beyond to the tasty catch-of-the-day or post-boating burgers and hot dogs that are grilled on the 6-burner barbecue grill. From the warmth and friendship sitting by the lakeside fire pit while roasting s’mores and telling campfire stories to the peaceful sounds of birds, crickets and distant boats filled with joyous sounds of kids. O'Toole Haven is the place to create lifetime memories!
Amenities
Air conditioner
Kitchen or Kitchenette
Internet / Wifi
Fireplace
Parking
Laundry
Balcony or Patio
Dishwasher
TV
Family friendly
Map of Idaho
$$$$
Ratings and reviews
Summary of reviews
The property offers spacious and renovated rooms, extensive entertainment options, and a private dock by the lake, creating a perfect vacation spot.
5.0 / 5.0
Great time enjoying the lake, home, and surrounding areas. Perfect place for memories and fun!
5.0 / 5.0
Such a great house! Rooms were all bigger than they seem in the pictures. Very private area. Seems like there's no one around. Firepit and dock area were perfect!
5.0 / 5.0
Wonderful lake home. Lori was great to work with. Would definitely stay here again!
5.0 / 5.0
We have stayed at the O’Toole cabin on famous Bill’s Island in Island Park, Idaho for years. It is always the highlight of our summer. This time we enjoyed the new renovations there. An entire new wing of bedrooms with private bathrooms, an enormous bunkhouse and upstairs playroom. We were blown away with all this space and large comfy beds. It was above and beyond our expectations!!!
5.0 / 5.0
The home was wonderful. Plenty of group space. Plenty of private space. Being able to walk through the back yard to the lake was such a joy. The dock was very nice for the kayak, canoe, and paddle boards. It rained a lot, unfortunately, but the house has a nice mud room and garage where we could take off our muddy shoes and keep the house clean. There was plenty of entertainment in the house when it was raining too much. When the sun peeked out we took advantage and played in the lake. The hosts were very quick to communicate when we needed them.
5.0 / 5.0
Hosted a group of clients mid May 2023. Property was as advertised and suited our group perfectly. Property manger was easy to communicate/work with. Property offered easy access to Yellowstone Park and manageable access to Grand Teton. Would highly recommend!
5.0 / 5.0
Family vacation
We really enjoyed our stay in the lake lodge!! It fit our large family really well!!
5.0 / 5.0
Great for Family Vacation
Beautiful house on Island Park Reservoir with dock so you can catch fish without having to drive. Plenty of space for a family of 19 to eat, hang out and visit. Two living areas, large deck and large dining area off the kitchen. Seven bedrooms so everyone had their own room. Kitchen was well-equipped. Two refrigerators stored enough food and drinks for a week. We had a great time!.
5.0 / 5.0
Fantastic!
Lots of comfy beds, 2 refrigerators, garage and driveway space. Perfect boat dock s as d private bay. Truly a dream vacation place!
5.0 / 5.0
Beautiful home and location
Our first stay here and we would love to come back again.
4.0 / 5.0
Great location
Excellent
5.0 / 5.0
Family friendly housing
We had a wonderful time and appreciate Lori and Shane's assistance with our stay being cancelled last year because of COVID. They were very accommodating to our needs. I would highly recommend this place.
5.0 / 5.0
Family Reunion
The home is beautiful. Lorie and Shane made it easy to access their property.
5.0 / 5.0
Great getaway
This property is very clean and enjoyable for such a variety of activities. All are already on the listing. Be aware that the water may be a little colder than other areas if you want to bring wet suits.
5.0 / 5.0
Very nice place. really enjoyed.
Everthing was very good!
5.0 / 5.0
We look forward to a return stay
The location of this property is hard to beat! The house was clean and the layout was perfect for our group with multiple families. We hope to stay here again when we travel back to Island Park.
5.0 / 5.0
Beautiful property-Beautiful location
We loved our week in the beautiful house! There are wonderful views from almost every window. It feels very private and secure. The beds were comfortable and we enjoyed cooking and eating together at the big table. Ending the day at the fire pit was perfect!
We would love to stay here again if the opportunity arose!
5.0 / 5.0
Wonderful cabin for family retreat.
Our family thoroughly enjoyed staying at this cabin on the reservoir. We loved having the dock out back where the we spent all day boating, kayaking, and swimming. The cabin itself was roomy with enough space for everyone to have a bed. The tv and play room was a nice gathering place for the kids/teens with another (quieter) living space for the adults to gather downstairs. The kitchen was well stocked will all the necessities. Everything was clean and in good repair. We are already discussing what week we should book for next year!
5.0 / 5.0
Wonderful family cabin
We had a great time for our family reunion at your cabin. It was very comfortable and accommodating. Thank you!
5.0 / 5.0
Great Location
We had a great time in Island Park. This house was perfect for us. The location on the water was just what we wanted. The dock was fantastic. It is set in a little cove so you have a little protection from all of the other boaters. The kids loved the game room. Lots of room. Perfect for large families.
5.0 / 5.0
Perfect lakeside family getaway!
The cabin and location could not have been more perfect for our family! It had everything we wanted; private dock, waterside fire pit, grill, amazing patio and wonderful indoor space! Lorie was very attentive and easy to get in touch with. The check-in process was also a breeze. We had way too much fun and will definitely be back!!
5.0 / 5.0
Practically perfect
We used this cabin as a home base for a family reunion in Island Park. Pros: It was roomy and cozy; felt secluded despite having neighbors; had ample parking; the game area was fun for the kids and kept the noise contained; the dock and backyard were beautiful, and even though we didn't use any watercraft, everyone loved swimming; the location was great. The only con was the wifi and cell service. It was basically non-existent, which wouldn't be a huge problem except that when you are sharing gate keys, it's hard to get a message from someone waiting to be let in to the island, or to otherwise coordinate when traveling with many people. But we made it work. Would definitely recommend and hope to return!
5.0 / 5.0
Great Family Trip
This house helped make our trip wonderful. We enjoyed sitting by the campfire every night, playing in the sand and on the dock everyday, as well as enjoying the beautiful area at Yellowstone, on ATVs, and hiking. Thank you for a great time!
5.0 / 5.0
Wilson reunion
We had a wonderful week at the O'toole
5.0 / 5.0
Perfect!
This property is perfect! We have had our family vacation here at the O'Toole cabin for years now. Lorie (the owner) is so prompt and caring about any needs. The private bay with a gradual, sandy slope for the little ones is so nice. The dock is fantastic! We enjoy having two wings for those with young children and those without. Thanks again Lorie for making this place our family's favorite!
5.0 / 5.0
Our Family had a great time
This property was clean and good order. We had enough room for our kids and grandkids and thoroughly enjoyed our stay. It felt private yet was in a great location.
5.0 / 5.0
Family and Friend National Park Get-away!
We booked this beautiful home for two families (15 in total) to meet at a central location to vacation in Yellowstone, Big Sky, and the Grand Tetons. The home was a perfect fit for our group. There was plenty of space for everyone, the kitchen was well equip, and the game room was a great gathering spot. The beds were very comfortable, the sheets soft and clean.
The location of the home was great, nestled away on the lake. We had snow and colder weather, so we were only able to get on the lake a couple of times, but we enjoyed kayaking and watching the elk in the morning across the lake. We saw a moose and her babies each morning as we left for the parks.
The house was centrally located and easy to get to West Yellowstone, Big Sky, Jackson Hole, and the Grand Tetons! We enjoyed every moment of our vacation and are so grateful to have had such a great home to create lifelong memories!
Thank you for sharing your home!
The Chason-Nicholson Families
5.0 / 5.0
Family Vaca!
Beautiful home, great location for a large family vacation.
5.0 / 5.0
Wonderful Lakefront Cabin
Our family had a wonderful vacation in this beautiful lakefront cabin. We had everything we needed to make our stay very comfortable. Having the lake right in the back yard was an extra bonus that the kids loved! As parents and grandparents, we were able to watch them from the comfort of the back yard with chairs provided that were right next to the shore. Our grandkids loved staying in the same room all together on the bunk beds and having the ping pong table and fooz ball table right there to play with. We also loved the tv with a great sound system in the same room to watch movies and a table for those that wanted to play games. This was the perfect place for a great family vacation! We only wished we could have stayed longer to enjoy this beautiful forest setting and all that Island Park offers.
5.0 / 5.0
Our stay was marvelous.. the house was beautiful and accommodated our large family nicely.
We had excellent weather. All of my grandchildren ranging from 1 to 9 yrs old and my 4 children were very comfortable. We pushed the limits on the fridge..wished there was a 2nd one in the garage but all in all a great time and bonding experience for the kids.
5.0 / 5.0
Great property and jump off point to Yellowstone
Had a great time at the property. House was clean and comfortable, the dock was fantastic, caught 20 trout one night and docked two waverunners from the local lodge another day. Campfire area was great for s’mores and ghost stories and the size of the house was perfect for our party of 9 adults and 9 kids. 30 minute drive into Yellowstone. Saw bears, elk and deer around the resovoir. Kitchen was big, bigger than the pictures make it look, and was large enough to accommodate multiple people making meals.
5.0 / 5.0
Fantastic waterfront vacation paradise!!!
This property was everything it was claimed to be, and more. All members of our family were quite pleased with the space, accommodations and cleanliness. The owners were ready, willing and able to fulfill any and all special requests that we had with the use of the property, and issues that did arise were quickly and effectively resolved to our utmost satisfaction. I would encourage anyone to use this property for their vacation.
We spent numerous days going to Yellowstone and Grand Teton National Parks, as the house was a quick 30 minutes to the west entrance of Yellowstone. There are hundreds, if not thousands, of trails for hiking and ATV riding, starting within a few minutes from the property, and going for miles and miles. There are a multitude of other activities, such as horseback riding, fishing and rafting, to name a few, within reasonable proximity to the property.
To sum things up, this location provided our family with an unforgettable and thrilling vacation!!!
5.0 / 5.0
Fantastic house and property!
We rented 3 houses on Bill's Island for a family reunion with 28 adults and children. The O"Toole house was beyond our expectations. The key pad on the garage made it easier for people in other houses to stop over even when everyone was off taking a tour of Yellowstone. And the house was beautiful. The two ovens were a bonus for cooking large meals and the two dryers in the laundry room helped keep the beach towels ready after swimming. Everything was perfect and Lori and Shane were great to work with on reservations and answering questions before we arrived. It was a terrific reunion! Ann Nichols
FAQs
How much does this cabin cost compared to others in Idaho?
The average price for a rental in Idaho is $335 per night. This rental is $1,867 above the average.
Is parking included with this cabin?
Yes, parking is listed as an amenity at Luxury Water Front Cabin on Island Park Reservoir With Private Bay And Dock. For more information, we encourage you to contact the property about where to park.
Is there a pool at this cabin?
We didn’t find pool listed as an amenity for this cabin. It may be worth double checking if a pool is important for your stay.
Is Luxury Water Front Cabin on Island Park Reservoir With Private Bay And Dock pet friendly?
Unfortunately, this cabin is not pet-friendly. Try searching again and filter for "Pets Allowed"
What amenities are available at Luxury Water Front Cabin on Island Park Reservoir With Private Bay And Dock?
We found 10 amenities for this rental. This includes air conditioner, kitchen or kitchenette, internet / wifi, fireplace, and parking.
Explore similar vacation rentals in Idaho
Explore all rentals in IdahoIdaho travel inspiration
Read our blogResearch
Road Trip Routes to Witness Incredible Astronomical Events in 2023 and 2024
Budget Travel
Top 30 Most Affordable Ski Resorts in the U.S.
Guides
The Ultimate U.S. Bucket List: Top Activities in Every State
Guides
High Country Escapes: Get Stoked with These Ski Getaways for Every Budget
Budget Travel
Cheap Family Vacations That Are Both Unforgettable and Affordable
Budget Travel
Best Staycation Cities in the United States: 50 States Edition
Budget Travel
2021 Travel Planning: Getting the Most Bang for Your Buck
Budget Travel
Rocky Mountain Ski Resorts with the Best Lift Ticket Prices