The whole enchalada!

Smart TV
Fridge, microwave, coffee/tea maker, toaster
Outdoor pool
Exterior
Property grounds
4.8
Outstanding(6 Reviews)

House in Geneseo, NY

14 guests · 5 bedrooms · 4 baths

Reasons to book

Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Free cancellationFull refund if you change your mind
Great for petsBring all your friends and family, even the furry ones

About this house rental

Note: Despite any verbiage added by the listing website or ads you may see, you do not get the whole 15,000 square-foot house.! I’ve got to live somewhere!

You do get all four B & B units in out historic 1835 Hartford House in Geneseo New York with a private entrance and quarters that are totally separate from anybody else!

This includes five bedrooms with 6 beds, two kitchenette areas and 4 bathrooms. Sleeps 11 or more depending on if you want to use two large couches and our two available rollaway beds.

Relax by our large in-ground pool which you will enjoy exclusively, or hike our 70 acres of fields and woods teeming with wild life. If you take the “whole enchilada“ you also get exclusive use of our veranda overlooking the Genesee Valley.

Our kitchenette areas currently do not have a stove, but they do have kitchen appliances including refrigerator, microwave, toaster and coffee maker. There is also a gas grill and fire pit by the pool area.

Also on the property is the Genesee Volley Tennis and Croquet club so bring your racket and your tennis shoes to enjoy our Har Tru court. Croquet equipment is supplied and we would be happy to show you the rules of our unique version of "golf" croquet. Contact us after you make your reservation if you want to play in either our tennis or croquet leagues on weekdays.

We are in the Village of Geneseo, within walking distance to downtown and SUNY Geneseo, and a short drive to Conesus Lake or Letchworth State Park. Pets welcome in Unit #1, The Garden Suite only.

If the “whole enchilada” is too much for you, the property is also listed on this site with just three units (VRBO # 2336515) or you can take just the pool-side Garden Suite (VRBO #?2335772) with separate private entrance.

The property is also available for weddings and events from May through Oct. 15. Sorry, only The Garden Suite is open year-round so this listing can not be booked from Oct. 15- May 1

Amenities

Pool
Air conditioner
Pets allowed
Kitchen or Kitchenette
Internet / Wifi
Parking
Laundry
Garden

Map of Geneseo, NY

Reviews

4.8
Outstanding(6 Reviews)
4.8
Jul 2024
We stayed the weekend for our wedding. Had a great time and loved the property!
4.8
Jul 2023
A unique experience. The view from the verandah was lovely, and the perfect place to sit with a glass of wine and enjoy the end of a busy day of hiking. It accomodated our extended family if 11. The pool was refreshing but not heated. The owner gave a behind the scene tour of the rooms not opened for guests. He was a font of historical knowledge.
4.8
Jun 2023
Our family stayed at this property for a wedding. It was very well stocked with supplies and comfortable. We took advantage of the peaceful setting to sit on the veranda enjoying the view, as well as the use of the tennis court and tennis equipment. Would stay here again.
4.8
Aug 2022
We stayed as a family of 9 who had come to a wedding. We enjoyed the pool, the spectacular views and the many spots to relax. The owner/manager was helpful and pleasant.
4.8
Jun 2022
We could not have had a better time. We held our barbeque on the back porch for our entire group of 35 and it was perfect. If you ever have a Geneseo reunion this is a fabulous spot with an amazing amount of history.
4.8
Jun 2022
Great Geneseo Reunion
Great Geneseo Reunion
We could not have had a better time. We held our barbeque on the back porch for our entire group of 35 and it was perfect. If you ever have a Geneseo reunion this is a fabulous spot with an amazing amount of history.
4.8
Jul 2021
Our stay at The Hartford House was just what we needed; we found peace in the stunningly beautiful vistas. We spent a good deal of time just enjoying the view from veranda at the back of the house where we started and ended each day. There is a good-sized, well maintained pool, which gave us respite when the heat was unbearable. One of the real plusses was that our dog, who is a 160 pound mastiff, was in heaven wandering the grounds at will. We found the rooms in the house charmingly decorated and loved the array of books on a wide range of topics that included nature and history. Our favorite books were the ones that gave insight into the history of the house, its original owners, and the development of the region. We plan to return to the house in the future--it is in a perfect location to visit the lakes, the wineries, and other amazing places in this stunningly beautiful region.
4.8
Jul 2021
Tranquility & Renewal
Tranquility & Renewal
Our stay at The Hartford House was just what we needed; we found peace in the stunningly beautiful vistas. We spent a good deal of time just enjoying the view from veranda at the back of the house where we started and ended each day. There is a good-sized, well maintained pool, which gave us respite when the heat was unbearable. One of the real plusses was that our dog, who is a 160 pound mastiff, was in heaven wandering the grounds at will. We found the rooms in the house charmingly decorated and loved the array of books on a wide range of topics that included nature and history. Our favorite books were the ones that gave insight into the history of the house, its original owners, and the development of the region. We plan to return to the house in the future--it is in a perfect location to visit the lakes, the wineries, and other amazing places in this stunningly beautiful region.

FAQs

How much does this house cost compared to others in Geneseo?

The average price for a rental in Geneseo is $321 per night. This rental is $637 above the average.

Is parking included with this house?

Yes, parking is listed as an amenity at The whole enchalada!. For more information, we encourage you to contact the property about where to park.

Is there a pool at this house?

Yes, a swimming pool is available for use at The whole enchalada!. Enjoy the water!

Is The whole enchalada! pet friendly?

Yes! This house is pet-friendly. For more information, we recommend contacting the booking provider about animal policies.

What amenities are available at The whole enchalada!?

We found 8 amenities for this rental. This includes pool, air conditioner, pets allowed, kitchen or kitchenette, and internet / wifi.

Explore similar vacation rentals in Geneseo

Explore all rentals in Geneseo

Geneseo travel inspiration

Read our blog