The ONLY house with POOL for rent in Spanish Wells! Five star service.
House in North Eleuthera
10 guests · 4 bedrooms · 4 baths
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Great for petsBring all your friends and family, even the furry ones
High-end valuePrice for this property is higher than average in the area
About this house rental
The perfect choice for family gatherings, romantic interludes or quiet relaxation. Just a short stroll to the beach, the home includes a pool with a large patio, fully equipped outdoor kitchen, dining and living areas, as well as a full outdoor bathroom with rain shower. Air conditioned interiors provide a welcome respite, or open the many windows and delight in the fresh island breeze.
Interiors are decorated in casual island style. The tile floors and area rugs provide the perfect balance between sandy feet and easy luxury. Enjoy cocktails at the bar or view your vacation photos on the large screen smart TV in the adjacent living room area. High speed Internet/Wifi and cable TV are included. The kitchen is well equipped to prepare meals at home (staples are provided); indoor dining provides seating for 10. Start your day with a coffee or tea by the pool (the coffee/tea bar is fully stocked). The main floor also includes a bedroom with full size bed, a full bathroom and laundry room.
Upstairs is a great room with master king size bed (this can be converted upon request to 2 twin size beds). There is a full bath with rain shower and double vanity as well as a large sitting area with a big screen smart TV and numerous games and DVD's for your amusement. There are 2 more bedrooms upstairs; one is furnished with a queen size bed, the other is furnished with a full size bed. All beds are made especially comfortable with memory foam mattresses or toppers and hotel quality bedding and all bedrooms are equipped with TV's. The bedroom of your choice may be set up as a nursery; baby/infant gear is available upon request (pack and play, changing table, diaper pail, toys, etc.). The living room couch can provide sleeping for an additional 2 people.
Wake up to paradise with breakfast on your pool deck, indulge in a peaceful morning swim, then head to the powder sand beach, just a minute away. Beach chairs, towels and umbrellas are included. Or try your hand at fishing or snorkeling with the provided gear. At day's end, indulge in the decadence of an outdoor shower or bath among the trees. Enjoy grilling and dining in the well equipped outdoor poolside kitchen, which includes gas grill, sink, fridge and full compliment of dishes. Take the time to stargaze on a lounge chair or the hammock and revel in the pleasure of this amazing place.
Sanctuary Cottage is located on a quiet street, within easy walking distance of the beach, grocery stores, pharmacy, bank and restaurants The quaint fishing community of Spanish Wells lies just off the coast of North Eleuthera and is easily accessible by plane (at the International Airport, North Eleuthera), boat or ferry (Bahamas Ferries offers daily trips from Nassau to Spanish Wells). Golf carts are available for rent and can be waiting for you at the dock when you arrive. Spanish Wells is picture perfect with historical British Colonial cottages and colorful gardens. There are numerous restaurants and bars to sample our local cuisine and taste our signature drinks. The Spanish Wells Public Park is a favorite spot for locals and tourists alike to watch the sunset, play on the park equipment and jump off the bridge (a popular local swimming spot). This tight-knit community really knows how to celebrate special occasions; events usually include fireworks, food, music, fun and games. Visitors are invited to participate in community events organized around annual holidays.
Spanish Wells is the fishing capital of The Bahamas. There are numerous experienced guides available to take you on an aquatic adventure. Swimming with the pigs, beaching on nearby islands and cays, snorkeling, spear fishing, reef fishing, deep sea fishing and bone fishing are some activities you could include in your venture.
Nearby, the main land of Eleuthera (meaning "Freedom") is worth a visit. Rent a car and explore the freedom of 90 miles of coastline, beaches, Glass Window Bridge, Queen's Bath, Blue Hole and Hatchet Bay Caves. Along the way are little historical communities and numerous fancy hotel/restaurants or native eateries.
Spanish Wells can be easily reached by plane; International flights from the US and domestic flights from other islands (on neighboring North Eleuthera) , ferry services and private boats arrive daily. Though easily reached, this jewel of the sea will feel like a million miles away from the rest of the world; yet provides all the modern conveniences. Sanctuary Cottage will become your island home.
Interiors are decorated in casual island style. The tile floors and area rugs provide the perfect balance between sandy feet and easy luxury. Enjoy cocktails at the bar or view your vacation photos on the large screen smart TV in the adjacent living room area. High speed Internet/Wifi and cable TV are included. The kitchen is well equipped to prepare meals at home (staples are provided); indoor dining provides seating for 10. Start your day with a coffee or tea by the pool (the coffee/tea bar is fully stocked). The main floor also includes a bedroom with full size bed, a full bathroom and laundry room.
Upstairs is a great room with master king size bed (this can be converted upon request to 2 twin size beds). There is a full bath with rain shower and double vanity as well as a large sitting area with a big screen smart TV and numerous games and DVD's for your amusement. There are 2 more bedrooms upstairs; one is furnished with a queen size bed, the other is furnished with a full size bed. All beds are made especially comfortable with memory foam mattresses or toppers and hotel quality bedding and all bedrooms are equipped with TV's. The bedroom of your choice may be set up as a nursery; baby/infant gear is available upon request (pack and play, changing table, diaper pail, toys, etc.). The living room couch can provide sleeping for an additional 2 people.
Wake up to paradise with breakfast on your pool deck, indulge in a peaceful morning swim, then head to the powder sand beach, just a minute away. Beach chairs, towels and umbrellas are included. Or try your hand at fishing or snorkeling with the provided gear. At day's end, indulge in the decadence of an outdoor shower or bath among the trees. Enjoy grilling and dining in the well equipped outdoor poolside kitchen, which includes gas grill, sink, fridge and full compliment of dishes. Take the time to stargaze on a lounge chair or the hammock and revel in the pleasure of this amazing place.
Sanctuary Cottage is located on a quiet street, within easy walking distance of the beach, grocery stores, pharmacy, bank and restaurants The quaint fishing community of Spanish Wells lies just off the coast of North Eleuthera and is easily accessible by plane (at the International Airport, North Eleuthera), boat or ferry (Bahamas Ferries offers daily trips from Nassau to Spanish Wells). Golf carts are available for rent and can be waiting for you at the dock when you arrive. Spanish Wells is picture perfect with historical British Colonial cottages and colorful gardens. There are numerous restaurants and bars to sample our local cuisine and taste our signature drinks. The Spanish Wells Public Park is a favorite spot for locals and tourists alike to watch the sunset, play on the park equipment and jump off the bridge (a popular local swimming spot). This tight-knit community really knows how to celebrate special occasions; events usually include fireworks, food, music, fun and games. Visitors are invited to participate in community events organized around annual holidays.
Spanish Wells is the fishing capital of The Bahamas. There are numerous experienced guides available to take you on an aquatic adventure. Swimming with the pigs, beaching on nearby islands and cays, snorkeling, spear fishing, reef fishing, deep sea fishing and bone fishing are some activities you could include in your venture.
Nearby, the main land of Eleuthera (meaning "Freedom") is worth a visit. Rent a car and explore the freedom of 90 miles of coastline, beaches, Glass Window Bridge, Queen's Bath, Blue Hole and Hatchet Bay Caves. Along the way are little historical communities and numerous fancy hotel/restaurants or native eateries.
Spanish Wells can be easily reached by plane; International flights from the US and domestic flights from other islands (on neighboring North Eleuthera) , ferry services and private boats arrive daily. Though easily reached, this jewel of the sea will feel like a million miles away from the rest of the world; yet provides all the modern conveniences. Sanctuary Cottage will become your island home.
Amenities
Pool
Air conditioner
Pets allowed
Kitchen or Kitchenette
Internet / Wifi
Smoking allowed
Parking
Laundry
Balcony or Patio
Dishwasher
Hot tub or spa
TV
Gym or Fitness Center
Garden
Family friendly
Map of North Eleuthera
$$$$
Ratings and reviews
5.0 / 5.0
Spanish Wells is such a unique place and so is Sanctuary Cottage. The pool made our stay with the kids so much more enjoyable. The island is so charming. Be sure to get ice cream every night. We will definitely be back!
5.0 / 5.0
Everything we needed and wanted. Lots of room to socialize or have quiet time. Close to the beach , food, drink and shopping. Sanctuary cottage is someplace that we plan on taking our entire family again. Did I mention we had a back yard paradise as well, full bath with windows opening into the garden and a pool. We hosted a family luncheon with 13 people and did not need to purchase anything but the food and some of that what caught by those who decided to fish or go Welking. Thank you Rachel.
5.0 / 5.0
The Sanctuary Cottage was the perfect place to stay for our trip. The home was very clean, well kept, and provided everything we needed for a great trip. Having a pool to plop into at the end of a day after being out on a boat, in the sea/sand/sun, was amazing. You can’t beat the location… right in the middle of everything.
Rachel was an amazing host. She jumped through hoops for us a couple of times with a genuine “no problem” smile on her face.
For a family of 5 the house was perfect… could even accommodate more if needed.
If considering renting this place don’t think twice!
5.0 / 5.0
After our first visit to Spanish Wells in 2023, we knew we absolutely had to return this year and stay on the island. We also knew we wanted to bring family with us to share our new found secret vacation spot. Finding Sanctuary Cottage was great decision.
The house had everything we needed and then some. Bringing two toddlers along for the trip, we knew they would need a break from the beach heat/sun, so having the pool at the house was an amazing way to continue enjoying water time, but with some much needed shade. Rachel was amazing. She met us at the dock and helped us get tons of luggage transported to the house and back at the end of the week. She ensured we had everything we needed and gave us the grand tour to get settled in. There was fear the island water may be off for a day and she brought many gallons of water biy to make sure we were well stocked up. The beach and grocery store are only a block away and ultra convenient to the house. If you are lucky enough to find this property available for your trip dates, you should definitely book with Rachel too! Thanks again Rachel!! Until next time!
5.0 / 5.0
I stayed here with my family in the beginning of May(myself, husband, daughter and her boyfriend and our son). When I think of the perfect beach cottage, Sanctuary Cottage would be it! It’s a comfortable, classy beach cottage with all the modern amenities. Beautifully decorated and very well equipped with just about everything you would need. We are beach people, but the pool was great to have after spending the day at the beach. The location is great, with in walking distance to the best beach access and the grocery store. We rented a golf cart to get around all of Spanish Wells and Russel Island. We spent evenings at the church lot too playing pickle ball and basketball ball. We can’t wait to come back and stay here! Thank you Rachel for sharing your amazing rental!
5.0 / 5.0
We spent 16 nights over March break/Easter at the wonderful Sanctuary Cottage. Our group consisted of myself and husband, 2 teen daughters and my parents. Everyone had plenty of space to relax and spread out.
The main floor has a dining table to comfortably seat 8, living room, well appointed kitchen, coffee area, double bedroom, bathroom and laundry room. Upstairs is a large loft style king bedroom (or 2 twins) with curtains for privacy, bathroom and 2 more queen bedrooms along with a living area that has a twin/twin daybed that sleeps 2 more. Beds were all very comfortable. Individual air conditioners in each room. Plenty of towels for everyone including pool/beach towels. We appreciated having the kitchen basics of oils, Saran, seasonings etc. and all of the bathroom extras.
The private backyard oasis has a covered living area and 2 dining areas, an amazing pool with waterfall, lounge chairs, propane grill, outdoor sink and fridge, and a pool cabana with a full bathroom. There is also an outdoor shower in the yard. There are plenty of beach and pool toys, beach umbrella & chairs, towels and coolers. The yard has plenty of coconut trees, banana etc. and the gardens are stunning.
The location was amazing and central. We were a 2 minute walk to the most amazing and huge beach, and same to the grocery store. I definitely recommend renting a golf cart.
I would absolutely recommend renting this beautiful house from Rachel. She was a wonderful host and has thought of everything.
5.0 / 5.0
We loved Spanish Wells and enjoyed our three week stay at Sanctuary Cottage! It was close to beach and a short golf cart ride to restaurants and supermarket. When we weren’t on the beach, we spent most of our time in outdoor area and pool. The outdoor bath was a favorite! We did a full day excursion with Sheldon of Exotic Adventures. You can design your day and I highly recommend. Try the upstairs bar at the Shipyard. Leroy is the best and the views are great. Sunrises and sunsets are a must as well. Thank you Rachel!!
5.0 / 5.0
We've stayed with Rachel countless times over the years, and her lovely cottage ALWAYS delivers. We noticed several improvements this year which goes to show how much care Rachel puts into her properties. The Sanctuary is such a lovely place for rest & relaxation...
5.0 / 5.0
What a lovely cottage. Rachel has it so we'll equipped, and so cutely decorated. And the pool and patio are wonderful and private. It's about 2 blocks to the beach, and 2 to the local grocery store. Perfect location. We stayed 10 nights and had a very relaxing vacation.
5.0 / 5.0
This was a great place to stay and the host was very helpful!
5.0 / 5.0
The house and pool were wonderful. The beach was a short walk away. Rachel was a great host and we enjoyed our week on Spanish wells.
5.0 / 5.0
This house is super! We had an amazing vacation and the pool was divine! Thanks for being a super host.
5.0 / 5.0
The house is perfectly laid out, spacious and everything we needed and more. The house has a lush garden with a private pool that my group and I thoroughly enjoyed especially after long days at the beaches. The air-conditioners functioned very efficiently and this is an important feature while on a summer vacation. Rachel is amazing! Super responsive and a wonderful hostess. Would definitely recommend!
5.0 / 5.0
Lovely family trip
5.0 / 5.0
Rent with confidence!
The house is great, the pool is relaxing, Rachel is a breeze to work with, and Spanish Wells is a safe, beautiful little slice of Heaven.
5.0 / 5.0
We've rented The Sanctuary Cottage from Rachel more than a half-dozen times. Every year we look forward to this welcoming respite from the hustle and bustle of our daily lives. Rachel's creative hospitality is unmatched!
5.0 / 5.0
The pictures do not do this cottage justice. It is impeccably decorated, stocked with so many comforts, spotless, and well maintained. Fresh flowers in several rooms greeted us. The pool with the waterfall feature is stunning. The home feels very private, surrounded by lush tropical vegetation— palm trees, banana, papaya, and other fruit trees and beautiful flowering plants. Rachel is the perfect host, setting up our golf cart rental and car rental on the days we explored Eleuthera. Her whole family is so welcoming. Serenity Cottage was the perfect place to celebrate our 25th wedding anniversary.
5.0 / 5.0
Everything we expected!
5.0 / 5.0
My husband and I booked Sanctuary Cottage last minute when we were looking to extend our stay with our two children on Spanish Wells. The pictures of Sanctuary Cottage do not do it justice. The house was incredibly clean, beds were comfortable and the decor was impeccable. Rachel thought of every little touch when decorating and stocking the house. Our children especially loved the pool and the outdoor bathroom/bathtub. The outdoor space is a true sanctuary - we just wish we didn't have to leave, but we will 100% be back.
5.0 / 5.0
This is our 6th time visiting Spanish Wells and this is always our favourite place to stay. Aside from the perfect physical location and the amazing swimming pool and outdoor area, Rachel, the host, ensures every question is answered, every detail is finalized and considered, and goes above and beyond to make sure our stay here is the best it can be. We will be booking again for sure!
5.0 / 5.0
Great for two families
Sanctuary was perfect for our families! Four adults and five teenagers had "room to move." The outdoor space was great for our "taco night" when enertained three other families! There was plenty of extras that made it easy to live in such as kitchen items and even candles for extra ambiance.
We enjoyed the pool after long days of beaching and boating.
We will definitely recommend Sanctuary to our friends and family when they come to visit us...we are in the process of building a home nearby.
5.0 / 5.0
Outstanding!!!!
Rachel went above and beyond as a host, decorating Sanctuary Cottage with an abundance of fresh flower arrangements upon our arrival. We were in Spanish Wells for our daughter’s wedding, and Rachel was a welcome resource and a stellar communicator. She let us host a welcome cocktail party for the wedding guests and even let us use flowers and greenery from her gardens to decorate for the wedding ceremony as well as the welcome party!!! The place is as pictured, a sanctuary - welcoming, immaculate, well stocked, and super close to the best part of Spanish Well’s pink sand beaches. Soooo worth the money!!! Do not hesitate to book!!!!
5.0 / 5.0
Beautiful and uniquely decorated house aptly named sanctuary. We loved the outdoor area and the pool
Timely communication with Rachel, who was also very gracious and informative- went above and beyond coordinating transportation and orienting us, giving us tips about the area and excursions. Especially appreciated the quiet beach nearby. Thoroughly enjoyed our stay!
5.0 / 5.0
Cozy cottage
A big thank you to Rachel for her sharing her lovely cottage with us. Her attention to detail and friendly hospitality was more than we could have ever asked for. She was very helpful prior to our arrival and even more pleasurable to work with during our stay. This rental has everything you could ever want or need. Very comfortable accommodations and the yard and pool were beyond amazing. We truly loved this little island and the people were really friendly and welcoming. The beaches were fabulous the ocean was crystal clear and the weather was beautiful. I would not hesitate in recommending this rental and it absolutely felt like home.
5.0 / 5.0
Always a pleasure
This marks our 4th stay at The Sanctuary and it NEVER disappoints! The backyard area is an oasis - we never want to leave!
5.0 / 5.0
5 stars are not enough. Truly incredible house & host
It all starts with the host, and Rachel is someone you will wish was your neighbor at home. She met us at the dock with a golf cart to rent that was big enough for our family of 4 with 4 large suitcases. She is the type of person you can't help smile at the entire time you are with. My little boys, even after chdcking out, mentioned missing her house and her. Shes a really incredible person... Her home is incredible too, much nicer in person. It's stocked to the 9's, an insane amount of towels, toys, beach items, cooking utensils, cleaning items and soaps! Its decorated perfectly. It has things your own home doesn't... We loved that there are 3 bedrooms on the top level, which made us feel very safe at night with our kids each in a room close to us. The house is just a couple minute walk to the beach and grocery store... The pool can be heated for a little extra $$ and it got hot, it felt wonderful. -- She has collected so many kids toys and beach gear. If you come here you don't need to bring a thing. If you've thought of it, she's got you covered... Spanish Wells is super cool, super laid back, very friendly. While we like going to new places, it's a true gem and I know when we start talking about our next winters trip, our boys especially will want to come back... Our travels to the Bahamas took us to the main island of Eluthera after here, and we've said several times how much we wished we could take her house with us... If you are considering a trip and reading this review I would strongly suggest booking it right now. --- Enjoy your trip! Thank you from the bottom of my heart Rachel. I hope we meet again.
5.0 / 5.0
Beautiful
Great house, great beach, lovely hostess. Very well stocked with stuff, towels, glassware etc. all easy.
5.0 / 5.0
Perfect place to ring in 2022
We had two families with 5 - 20+ year olds and Sanctuary Cottage was perfect for us to relax and ring in 2022. There were so many small details that made the stay more special - tons of towels, bathrobes, slippers and a stocked kitchen for meal prep. Close to the beach and the pool was fantastic! Rachel was a gracious host and was there for anything we needed. We would definitely stay here again!
5.0 / 5.0
Perfect house for family and friends to relax.
The house was clean and fully equipped. Rachel is the perfect host. The pool and patio is absolutely adorable!
4.0 / 5.0
Hidden Jewel
The main reason I chose this property was for the pool, which was gorgeous in person. With two small kids it was great to swim when we weren’t enjoying the beach. Rachel was great and brought us avocados on a few occasions. We had some issues with the plumbing and she came to address them quickly. Other than that, the only downfall was the constant crowing of roosters at all hours of the day and night. I would recommend bringing sound machines or for the host to add these to the rooms as it is quite annoying. Very close proximity to the beach and local restaurants, ample rooms and beautiful decor. We enjoyed our stay very much and would recommend!
5.0 / 5.0
INCREDIBLE
Our Family had an absolute wonderful time staying at The Rick's home. Everything you could need was there and extremely clean. The owner went way above and beyond everything not just with the home but getting us safely on the island, had our golf cart rentals waiting, and even schedule our ride back to the airport. Super helpful and very willing to make whatever happen we needed! I can speak on behalf of my entire family with you really made this vacation an ever lasting memory!
5.0 / 5.0
AMAZING EXPERIENCE!
Rachel is now someone we consider a friend and family. We are so grateful for the experience and such a wonder trip. Most of which I give credit to Rachel. You can't go wrong with this booking. Have fun!
5.0 / 5.0
AWESOME
Perfect
5.0 / 5.0
Great service and a perfect location with a pool
The cottage was a great home away from home. Rachel provided above host service that beat expectations. They made us feel very relaxed and took care of everything from ferry/taxi, golf cart and boat rental recommendations as well as a car rental for the day to explore the island. It was 6 adults, 3 couples and we had plenty of room to spread out. The beach gear, extra towels and maid services was a plus! Thank you!!
5.0 / 5.0
Great Vacation
We had a great time, the house was comfortable and our host Rachel really nice and helpful. We will definitely return
5.0 / 5.0
Sanctuary cottage is the perfect location to have a relaxing holiday in Spanish Wells
Beautiful property in a great location with all the facilities you need.
Rachael and her team are fantastic to deal with, we enjoyed the entire stay and will be visiting again soon.
5.0 / 5.0
Sanctuary Cottage
We were so happy to be back in the Bahamas and Spanish Wells. Rachel our host was so welcoming and helpful with everything! She responded quickly to any questions. She helped us arrange water ferries and taxis to and from the airport. She arranged for our golf carts, which were great for getting around. The house was clean, accurately described and plenty of room for 4 teenagers and 4 adults. The house was very easy walking distance to the beach. The pool and outside living area were perfect for after our daily excursions and in the evenings. The house was well stocked with all the basics. There were plenty of bath and beach towels. We can’t wait to go back! Thank you Rachel!
5.0 / 5.0
Exceptional
What makes a rental superb is an exceptional host and Rachel is that lady. The pictures don’t give this lovely little house the credit it deserves and I would say you won’t be disappointed. So many extras from lovely bathrobes., slippers lovely bathroom products and a wonderfully stocked kitchen having just spent a month in the Bahamas this was by far my favourite house. Thank you Rachel for a wonderful stay.
5.0 / 5.0
Great vacation at Sanctuary Cottage
We spent a wonderful week at the Cottage. Rachel was very helpful with everything from pick up to departure. And also, helpful with excursions and etc. Our 9 year old Laykelynn loved the pool more than the beach. Lovely place!
2.5 / 5.0
Our stay at Sanctuary Cottage was simply amazing. Our host Rachel was lovely. She was super responsive to our pre-arrival inquiries and continued to be just a call/text away if needed during our stay. The house has everything you need plus some. It was super clean and comfortable. The pool is amazing. Easy walk to a gorgeous beach. We rented a golf cart for our entire stay. I would recommend doing this for convenience and flexibility.We plan to come back again and again...such a wonderful spot to unplug, decompress and just BE (rain or shine!).P.S. This was our first travel excursion since the pandemic started and we felt safe and comfortable on the island.
FAQs
How much does this house cost compared to others in North Eleuthera?
The average price for a rental in North Eleuthera is $652 per night. This rental is $77 above the average.
Is parking included with this house?
Yes, parking is listed as an amenity at The ONLY house with POOL for rent in Spanish Wells! Five star service.. For more information, we encourage you to contact the property about where to park.
Is there a pool at this house?
Yes, a swimming pool is available for use at The ONLY house with POOL for rent in Spanish Wells! Five star service.. Enjoy the water!
Is The ONLY house with POOL for rent in Spanish Wells! Five star service. pet friendly?
Yes! This house is pet-friendly. For more information, we recommend contacting the booking provider about animal policies.
What amenities are available at The ONLY house with POOL for rent in Spanish Wells! Five star service.?
We found 15 amenities for this rental. This includes pool, air conditioner, pets allowed, kitchen or kitchenette, and internet / wifi.
Explore similar vacation rentals in North Eleuthera
Explore all rentals in North EleutheraNorth Eleuthera travel inspiration
Read our blogGuides
Best East Coast Beaches and Getaway Locations You Can’t Miss
Budget Travel
7 Most Affordable Snowbird Destinations for 2025
Guides
Top Activities to Try in Panama City Beach, Florida
Guides
Top Things to Do in Gulf Shores, Alabama: Adventure and Fun Await
Local Culture
Exploring Miami’s Wynwood District: Street Art, Food, and More
Guides
Fun Things to Do in Ocean City, Maryland
Local Culture
A Foodie’s Guide to the Best Dining in Orlando, Florida
Guides
Top Things to Do in Oahu and Honolulu