Historic Lambert's Cove Church & Parsonage
5.0
Outstanding(17 Reviews)House in Tisbury, MA
6 guests · 3 bedrooms · 4 baths
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Includes essentialsGarden, Kitchen or Kitchenette, Air conditioner and more
Book with confidenceWe partner with the top travel sites so you know you're getting a great deal on the perfect rental
About this house rental
Built in 1846 and meticulously renovated in 2009, this historic property – once the oldest Methodist Church on Martha’s Vineyard – is now a stunning vacation home, capturing the ambiance of the Romantic Era through the elegance of exceptional contemporary design.
Set on ¾ of an acre on Lambert’s Cove Road and comprising 2,714 square feet of open-plan living space, the property provides accommodation for up to six people and includes two residential buildings, offering an ideal balance of community and privacy among guests.
The Parsonage is a 2-bedroom, 2-bathroom house with full kitchen. French doors open out from the living & dining areas onto a rustic granite patio, complete with outdoor lounge seating, barbeque grill, and fire pit.
The Church is a master suite with king-sized bed, kitchenette, and full bath with soaking tub and shower. Historic details have been preserved throughout, including the pressed tin ceiling, wide plank wood floors, and original lighting fixtures. Even the bell in the tower can be rung! (Its tone is C#.)
The Church & Parsonage share an outdoor shower.
Each building has its own wood-burning stove (in addition to radiant heat and air conditioning).
Washer & drier are located in the basement of the Parsonage.
Nestled against the woods in pastoral West Tisbury, a ten-minute drive in either direction will take you into town. To the east: Vineyard Haven – home of the iconic Black Dog Tavern, Martha’s Vineyard Film Center, Cronig’s Market, and Bunch of Grapes Bookstore, as well as the island’s only year-round ferry terminal. To the West: West Tisbury town center – site of the treasured Alley’s General Store, West Tisbury Library, and Grange Hall, where during the season you’ll find the West Tisbury Farmer’s Market and the Vineyard Artisans Festival.
The property is walking-distance to Lambert’s Cove Beach, Ice House Pond, and Uncle Seth's Pond, and is conveniently located to numerous Land Bank and Trustees of Reservations properties, as well as to the gem-of-a-find Polly Hill Arboretum and (in August) the annual Agricultural Fair!
This unique combination of style, history, comfort, design, and location make a sojourn at Lambert’s Cove Church & Parsonage truly special. Come experience the tranquility of the days of Thoreau and Emerson in this thoroughly modern Martha’s Vineyard residence.
Set on ¾ of an acre on Lambert’s Cove Road and comprising 2,714 square feet of open-plan living space, the property provides accommodation for up to six people and includes two residential buildings, offering an ideal balance of community and privacy among guests.
The Parsonage is a 2-bedroom, 2-bathroom house with full kitchen. French doors open out from the living & dining areas onto a rustic granite patio, complete with outdoor lounge seating, barbeque grill, and fire pit.
The Church is a master suite with king-sized bed, kitchenette, and full bath with soaking tub and shower. Historic details have been preserved throughout, including the pressed tin ceiling, wide plank wood floors, and original lighting fixtures. Even the bell in the tower can be rung! (Its tone is C#.)
The Church & Parsonage share an outdoor shower.
Each building has its own wood-burning stove (in addition to radiant heat and air conditioning).
Washer & drier are located in the basement of the Parsonage.
Nestled against the woods in pastoral West Tisbury, a ten-minute drive in either direction will take you into town. To the east: Vineyard Haven – home of the iconic Black Dog Tavern, Martha’s Vineyard Film Center, Cronig’s Market, and Bunch of Grapes Bookstore, as well as the island’s only year-round ferry terminal. To the West: West Tisbury town center – site of the treasured Alley’s General Store, West Tisbury Library, and Grange Hall, where during the season you’ll find the West Tisbury Farmer’s Market and the Vineyard Artisans Festival.
The property is walking-distance to Lambert’s Cove Beach, Ice House Pond, and Uncle Seth's Pond, and is conveniently located to numerous Land Bank and Trustees of Reservations properties, as well as to the gem-of-a-find Polly Hill Arboretum and (in August) the annual Agricultural Fair!
This unique combination of style, history, comfort, design, and location make a sojourn at Lambert’s Cove Church & Parsonage truly special. Come experience the tranquility of the days of Thoreau and Emerson in this thoroughly modern Martha’s Vineyard residence.
Amenities
Air conditioner
Kitchen or Kitchenette
Internet / Wifi
Parking
Laundry
Balcony or Patio
Dishwasher
Hot tub or spa
TV
Garden
Family friendly
Map of Tisbury, MA
Reviews
5.0
Outstanding(17 Reviews)5.0
Absolutely fantastic!
5.0
A wonderful find — excellent in every way.
5.0
Stunning!
This property is so well done... I can't imagine what it took to turn a church and the associated parsonage into a luxurious, chic mini compound. The layout of the parsonage is perfect, well appointed, with everything you could want. The finishes are and fixtures are top of the line. Impeccably clean. Just wonderful. The church took my breath away. The listing photos are great but don't convey the impressive volume of space. The unique repurposed oil chandelier, amazing sound system, comfortable TV area, bathroom (with water pressure we could only dream about in the city!) right out of Architectural Digest, and more fluffy towels than anyone could possibly use, and so much more!! We loved this place. Thank you
5.0
Great place.
Beautiful and unique stay. Lamberts and the most beautiful pond around, can’t beat it. Wonderful.
5.0
Heaven on Earth
Beautifully maintained property. So pretty and close to the beach for a quick walk to see the sunset.
5.0
A+ on all fronts for me: chic, well located, lovely owners, responsive property manager, and all details that matter.
5.0
A+ on all fronts for me: chic, well located, lovely owners, responsive property manager, and all details that matter.
5.0
PERFECT.
A+ on all fronts for me: chic, well located, lovely owners, responsive property manager, and all details that matter.
5.0
Fabulous, unique, impeccable property
We and extended family stayed at the Church & Parsonage for a week and we couldn't have been happier. Both properties are beautifully and uniquely decorated, everything was impeccably clean and in working order, and there were so many thoughtful touches (the Aesop arrival boxes, well equipped kitchens, coffee in the Church, comfortable beach chairs, beach wagons). The owner was very friendly and responsive and so was the property manager, who helped us organize a midweek clean between guests and helped with ferry logistics. The property is located a short walk from the beautiful Lambert's Cove beach (on a somewhat busy and narrow road so be careful walking) and near many island attractions and restaurants. Thank you for an awesome week and I hope we can come back again.
5.0
The Church and Parsonage did not disappoint! Truly a perfect - centrally located property - :10 minute walk to a pristine beach at Lamberts Cove - short drive to your choice of town centers... Oak Bluff, VH or Edgartown. Propertly provides a unique and terrific layout and is furnished tastefully and comfortably. Owner and team made the booking and process seamless and were available when needed - but it's such perfection and so well equipped - we did not need to contact them once we were settled. DEFINATELY would book again!
5.0
Sublime FIRST time on The Vineyard - we will be back!
The Church and Parsonage did not disappoint! Truly a perfect - centrally located property - :10 minute walk to a pristine beach at Lamberts Cove - short drive to your choice of town centers... Oak Bluff, VH or Edgartown. Propertly provides a unique and terrific layout and is furnished tastefully and comfortably. Owner and team made the booking and process seamless and were available when needed - but it's such perfection and so well equipped - we did not need to contact them once we were settled. DEFINATELY would book again!
5.0
We had an incredible time at Sarah and David’s exquisite home. The property, design, layout and decor were all exceptional. Even though it was rainy weather we had a magical time because their home is so special. We can’t say enough good things and will be remembering the trip fondly with hopes to return!
5.0
We had a great time at the church and parsonage. Plenty of space and privacy. Very close to the beach. Awesome back patio. The owners should be very proud of this property. It is well maintained. Clearly a lot of thought went into the renovation. Historic space and beautiful interior. Easy ride to Vineyard Haven. Thank you for a great stay!
5.0
Luxury and historic charm
We had a great time at the church and parsonage. Plenty of space and privacy. Very close to the beach. Awesome back patio. The owners should be very proud of this property. It is well maintained. Clearly a lot of thought went into the renovation. Historic space and beautiful interior. Easy ride to Vineyard Haven. Thank you for a great stay!
5.0
Stunning home and location!
We had an incredible time at Sarah and David’s exquisite home. The property, design, layout and decor were all exceptional. Even though it was rainy weather we had a magical time because their home is so special. We can’t say enough good things and will be remembering the trip fondly with hopes to return!
5.0
Perfect Up Island Retreat
We had a wonderful and relaxing stay. The owners were extremely conscientious in setting up this very special home and we had everything we needed. This property is beautifully renovated and well located near Lambert’s Cove Beach. We hope to be back!
5.0
We had a lovely stay at the Parsonage/Church. Everything was top notch, plenty of space for a small party (3), everything worked as expected, and the house offers ample room inside and out to just hang out (and work remotely, if need be).We've always loved Lamberts Cove Road through years and this property has a great location and was a super easy 5-7 minute walk to the beach (which is amazing). The owner (Sarah) was very easy to work with, helpful, and responsive to any questions etc. Can't wait to come back again.
5.0
Awesome property
We had a lovely stay at the Parsonage/Church.
Everything was top notch, plenty of space for a small party (3), everything worked as expected, and the house offers ample room inside and out to just hang out (and work remotely, if need be).
We've always loved Lamberts Cove Road through years and this property has a great location and was a super easy 5-7 minute walk to the beach (which is amazing). The owner (Sarah) was very easy to work with, helpful, and responsive to any questions etc. Can't wait to come back again.
5.0
Great proximity to the beach and beautifully decorated and unique home. We had a wonderful time!
5.0
Fantastic stay
Great proximity to the beach and beautifully decorated and unique home. We had a wonderful time!
5.0
Beautiful spot and perfectly outfitted!
Our stay exceeded our expectations! From Aesop soap, big white terry cloth robes, detailed instructions on use of all the amenities and unique interiors, we enjoyed every minute. Would definitely book again!
5.0
Quiet family getaway during Covid-19
We had a fantastic time. Hanging out in back yard, biking beach and BBQ. Absolutely perfect.
The church is so cool!
5.0
Amazing stay at Lamberts Cove Church + Parsonage
We had an amazing family vacation at this beautiful property. The owners went above and beyond to make sure we had everything we needed for our trip including beach equipment, beach passes, information about the island etc..It is key in MV to have access to the beach, especially if you have young kids, and the walk to Lamberts Cove beach was easy and convenient. We could not asked for a better family vacation!
FAQs
How much does this house cost compared to others in Tisbury?
The average price for a rental in Tisbury is R 9,943 per night. This rental is R 6,135 above the average.
Is parking included with this house?
Yes, parking is listed as an amenity at Historic Lambert's Cove Church & Parsonage. For more information, we encourage you to contact the property about where to park.
Is there a pool at this house?
We didn’t find pool listed as an amenity for this house. It may be worth double checking if a pool is important for your stay.
Is Historic Lambert's Cove Church & Parsonage pet friendly?
Unfortunately, this house is not pet-friendly. Try searching again and filter for "Pets Allowed"
What amenities are available at Historic Lambert's Cove Church & Parsonage?
We found 11 amenities for this rental. This includes air conditioner, kitchen or kitchenette, internet / wifi, parking, and laundry.
Explore similar vacation rentals in Tisbury
Explore all rentals in TisburyTisbury travel inspiration
Read our blogGuides
Top Things to Do in Oahu and Honolulu
Guides
Top Things to Do in Fort Lauderdale, Florida
Guides
Top Things to Do in Miami: From Beaches to Culture
Guides
The Best Things to Do in Orlando: Attractions, Food, and Family Fun
Guides
Things to Do in Galveston, Texas
Guides
Top Things to Do in Myrtle Beach
Guides
Ski Trip Packing List: What to Bring Skiing or Snowboarding
Trends
VacationRenter Holiday Travel Trends 2023