My family had the best weekend staying at this property with some of our close friends to celebrate my husband’s 40th birthday. The home is beautiful, super clean and just a great set up for both kids and adults. The owner was great and super responsive. We hope to rent this home again sometime soon!

This property is IDEAL for families or large groups. We had a group of 6 families and everyone had their own space. The basement is MASSIVE with tons of toys and play space for kids. The property has tons for kids to do outside (playground, putting green, tennis court, and pool). The location is perfect...5 minutes by car from East Hampton, 30 minutes to Southampton, and about 30 minutes to Montauk. Check-in was seamless and the property was as-described. Only had 2 gripes...1. Although heated, the pool was still cold in mid/late September (somewhat to be expected) and 2. the upstairs floor plan is fairly open but there is no TV in that area. This would have been ideal for kids to take a break or for adults to watch fall football etc. while preparing meals/hanging out during down-time. Overall 5 stars!

Our family had a wonderful time. The house is perfect for kids. Owner was very responsive during our entire stay and checked in with me to make sure everything was ok. My SIL left some personal belongings at the house and the owner went above and beyond to get them back to us!

This was an awesome house for a night away with some friends. It was wintertime so we could not take advantage of the beautiful backyard but still had a blast! Plenty of space in the house for a group of people.

Loved our stay! Beautiful pool and tennis court and so many books and toys for the kids to be entertained on rainy days! Plenty of beach towels and toys, and everything was very clean as well.

From the moment the payment was given, the experience became a nightmare. HomeAway lists Mitchell as the owner, but it was Ilgenfritz who we dealt with. She was not responsive to emails or calls such that we thought it was a scam and had to contact HomeAway directly. We paid in full months in advance and contracted with her to check in at 10:00am with the deposit to be returned 1 week after checkout. The owner does not keep to her own contract. When we arrived at the house at 11:30AM, it was not ready and the cleaning staff was frantic as they were just called in. Owner “forgot” and thought check in was at 4pm. We had to wait in 90deg heat outside in the car while they finished as the house smelled of chemicals. The inside of the house was cleaned perfunctorily, the outside was not even touched. The grass was not cut or sprayed allowing for ticks that we had encountered; garbage, cigarette butts and shattered glass littered the outside and deck. Pool was also filthy lined with bugs and an oily film coating the water. The house was not well stocked even for basic toilet paper and paper towels. Owner was notified including pics of above. She actually later blamed us for not telling her sooner! She said that her cleaning crew will clean the exterior, but they never did. The only reason I stayed for the arranged time was because my whole family had already scheduled time out of work for this get-together, so we tried to make the most out of it. The owner’s disregard for renters and agreed upon contract is demonstrable. Afterwards, she broke contract yet again when she did not return the deposit 1wk of checkout. Three weeks went by after checkout and only after I followed up with her to question her did she suddenly remember to return the deposit. Not an honest person folks. Further, she tried to prevent me from posting a review while still having my deposit in her possession. She still has not refunded the cleaning fee of several hundred dollars she said she would. It is the owner’s responsibility to have a clean and safe house for renters before their arrival, but with this owner, that seems to be asking too much. She blames the renters for her own negligence and dereliction of duty. I would never recommend this property to anyone. Horrible, dangerous, and dirty place and owner. You have been warned.

Sag harbour is close enough and the peaceful surroundings provided a great holiday and venue for golf at shinnecock