Staff and service was excellent. Location, views and room were great as well.

Staff and service was excellent. Location, views and room were great as well.

The price does not match what you expect. For 600+ a night, you would think a TV in the room, complimentary waters (like most hotels do), or towels that fit an adult body would have the bare minimum of service. There is a resort fee which I am not sure what that applies for since they don’t offer much. I would not return nor recommend this hotel to others. I actually told friends of mine that they should look at any other place because I don’t think it’s worth the cost.

Really enjoyed our first trip to Block Island and staying at the Atlantic Inn! We had a 2nd floor room with an ocean view and king size bed. PROS: staff was super sweet; check in and check out easy and accommodating- rose on check in; restaurant for dinner lovely, drinks on porch and lawn lovely; location was close enough to town to walk but far enough to be quiet (the hill HARD on the bike tho haha). CONS: room had tiny bath and window that would not stay open- shower the size of a phone booth & no closet; breakfast was a waste of money- better to walk to town; no designated entry; could have offered bikes for rent; was our 1 year anniversary and even though i mentioned it to the reception staff and dining staff- no one did anything special- not even a note in the room- sort of a let down.

Really enjoyed our first trip to Block Island and staying at the Atlantic Inn! We had a 2nd floor room with an ocean view and king size bed. PROS: staff was super sweet; check in and check out easy and accommodating- rose on check in; restaurant for dinner lovely, drinks on porch and lawn lovely; location was close enough to town to walk but far enough to be quiet (the hill HARD on the bike tho haha). CONS: room had tiny bath and window that would not stay open- shower the size of a phone booth & no closet; breakfast was a waste of money- better to walk to town; no designated entry; could have offered bikes for rent; was our 1 year anniversary and even though i mentioned it to the reception staff and dining staff- no one did anything special- not even a note in the room- sort of a let down.

The price does not match what you expect. For 600+ a night, you would think a TV in the room, complimentary waters (like most hotels do), or towels that fit an adult body would have the bare minimum of service. There is a resort fee which I am not sure what that applies for since they don’t offer much. I would not return nor recommend this hotel to others. I actually told friends of mine that they should look at any other place because I don’t think it’s worth the cost.

Great place. Cozy rooms, amazing food, best view in Block Island!

Great place. Cozy rooms, amazing food, best view in Block Island!

10 out of 10. Wonderful place.

10 out of 10. Wonderful place.

Great property, amazing staff and delicious food!

Great property, amazing staff and delicious food!

We loved our stay on Block Island. The Atlantic On. Was the perfect place to stay. Great location. Good food and wonderful team.

We loved our stay on Block Island. The Atlantic On. Was the perfect place to stay. Great location. Good food and wonderful team.

Lovely relaxing stay at a classic BI hotel. Really enjoyed the on-site dining for dinner, sunset views, and the ability to walk into town or the beach. Would stay again.

Lovely relaxing stay at a classic BI hotel. Really enjoyed the on-site dining for dinner, sunset views, and the ability to walk into town or the beach. Would stay again.

Beautiful views from the porch and sitting area

Beautiful views from the porch and sitting area

Very nice property. Lots of nice historical touches without the inconvenience of shared bathrooms and no air conditioning.

Very nice property. Lots of nice historical touches without the inconvenience of shared bathrooms and no air conditioning.

Great. Small bathroom is only down side but expected.

Great. Small bathroom is only down side but expected.

It was very nice and the service was excellent. Food portions could have been a bit more reasonable. My fois gras was the size of a quarter. Otherwise my wife and I were very pleased.

It was very nice and the service was excellent. Food portions could have been a bit more reasonable. My fois gras was the size of a quarter. Otherwise my wife and I were very pleased.

The Atlantic is an old historic inn that was completely updated two years ago. The whole facility is immaculate. The staff was extremely attentive even though we were there pre-season. We will definitely stay at The Sylsntic if we ever return to Block Island!

The Atlantic is an old historic inn that was completely updated two years ago. The whole facility is immaculate. The staff was extremely attentive even though we were there pre-season. We will definitely stay at The Sylsntic if we ever return to Block Island!

Loved the view. Dinner on the porch was excellent!

Loved the view. Dinner on the porch was excellent!

The restaurant and bar were very enjoyable as were the staff. My only comment would be I would like to see a bigger breakfast menu. A minor point compared to all the positive aspects of your hotel.

The restaurant and bar were very enjoyable as were the staff. My only comment would be I would like to see a bigger breakfast menu. A minor point compared to all the positive aspects of your hotel.

The staff was very friendly and helpful. The day we arrived their restraunt wasn’t open yet, so they gave us recommendations for another restaurant.

The staff was very friendly and helpful. The day we arrived their restraunt wasn’t open yet, so they gave us recommendations for another restaurant.