We had another great week. Can’t say enough good things about this property and owners. If I keep recommending we this home we won’t have a place to stay next year. Great location with proximity to everything.

Very good

Pros: The location was great with easy access to the beach, restaurants, grocery stores, etc. There was plenty of seating on both the front and back porches so that you can enjoy the view. The owner was nice. Cons: 1) We were asked 1 week before our vacation if it was ok for them to have exterior painting done during our stay. We felt like we had to agree since the owners would be on premise and we didn't know if that would impact further interaction. 2) We were told 2 days before our arrival that the place had rats. That didn't leave time to make other arrangements and had us wondering if this was another issue to try to get us to cancel. 3) The owner didn't tell us until mid-vacation that they would be leaving but 2 couples would be staying instead. We knew we'd have to deal with the owners upstairs but didn't realize we'd have to deal with a kid running around upstairs and having to share the pool with others. 4) Upon arrival we noticed that the dishwasher was full of dirty dishes. The sink and dishwasher had a leak so we couldn't use the dishwasher and had to clean up the mess each time and deal with maintenance. 5) Other issues: filthy shower curtain liner (we had to buy bleach cleaner to clean it), one sink was clogged, one handle to flush the toilet was broken (my husband had to fix it), and the grill was filthy and broken, and the living room furniture is outdoor furniture with metal arms, so it wasn't comfortable.

We had a great time

My family and I stayed at the property for one week, and it was simply wonderful. My two children (ages 4 and 6) loved the private pool, close access to the beach, and the two balconies to check out things. The home was very spacious, and there was plenty of room. The front two bedrooms almost feel separated from the back two bedrooms, which was perfect for us. Cornelia was an amazing host. She was easy to communicate with and extremely helpful to us, and my kids loved seeing her walking her dog. If you are looking for a place to rent in Garden City and want space and privacy, this is it.

The house had everything we needed, the pool was awesome, and the owners were so gracious to accommodate our staggered arrivals!

The house was more than we all expected.. the pool was an excellent bonus. Plenty of parking.. no issues at all .. AAA+

The location of this property is wonderful. Easy beach and pier access. The pool is a nice bonus. The unit definitely could use some updating, a good cleaning and furniture replacement. Pool area would benefit from a good cleanout and power wash. Enjoyed the rockers on the front porch with the beach view.