This was a same day reservation for us. The moment the reservation went in we received a call from a lady that we had to check in bc she had to leave… it was well before 3:00p. She was not very friendly. She told us we had to put breakfast order in writing asap for us to get breakfast next am, and to make sure we check out on time bc the late checkout rm was taken. You are only allowed half hr on the dining room table. Bathroom incredibly small. Hard to sleep, bed squeaks and you could hear everything inside and outside the house. The carpet was disgustingly dirty/stained … luckily it was only one night. We had breakfast somewhere else. We paid close to $800 for one night! Not worth the $$$, would not recommend. The night before we stayed at The Baker House, amazing place!

Lovely winter perch on Easthampton.

Stayed in a room with a pull out bed because there were two of us. We arrived late as we were on a work trip and there weren’t any sheets for the pull out bed, no one to contact. The number we called for 24/7 help was a Dr. office?! Cleaner woke us up at 8am banging her broom against our door. No water in the room or cups. It’s a cute place but too many disappointments for a one night stay.

The staff was incredibly accommodating. They upgraded us to a suite just because. The breakfast was amazing! Lobster rolls!

The Mill House Inn is pure heaven. It is beautiful, comforting, bright and simply lovely. The staff is OUTSTANDING with their genuine care and concern. We feel like we found new friends in Dawn and Kelli. They were SO helpful with shopping ideas, sightseeing trips and a host of other info! I have life threatening food allergies which was addressed every night as I ordered our breakfast for the following morning. The menu and food are superb! We had a slight issue with our room and Kenny the GM upgraded us to a beautiful suite. I hurt my back pretty badly prior to our trip and our original room was on the third floor which was quite cumbersome for me. It was a lovely cozy smaller room, with a dormered ceiling. It was a tad confining for a tall woman with a bad back! Upon Kenny learning all of this, (in addition we were celebrating our 25th wedding anniversary) he most generously upgraded us to a larger 2nd floor suite that was more comfortable for us with my situation! We were beyond shocked but so very appreciative! We met the owner Sylvia and she concurred they wanted us to be comfortable and were pleased they had a suite open to offer us. What truly wonderful people! We were sad to leave and can’t wait to go back. But what wonderful memories we have! We will always remember our 25th anniversary with happy hearts.💝

The ambiance and the service were excellent. They really went out of their way to be of service yet stayed out of the way so you felt like you were the only ones there. Perfect!

Beautiful Inn, friendly staff. Had a great time in gorgeous East Hampton!

The Inn was wonderful but they have gotten a little COVID wacky. You had to have breakfast in your room as an example and they don’t supply a table.

MHI is a wonderful, warm inn situated in the heart of East Hampton. The owners and staff are amazing and treat you like family (in the best ways!). Breakfasts are amazing and access to village and town beaches make it invaluable during the season. Definitely will come back!

false advertisement and terrible service

Lovely stay, had an issue with air and we were given another room immediately. Very comfy and cozy!

We had the most amazing time at the Mill House Inn! It was our first time to the Hamptons and it did not disappoint. Our room was cozy, clean, and the bed was super comfortable. Kenny was wonderful with restaurant recommendations and he even called us 2 weeks before our stay to alert us of the status of things with Covid. Dawn was a delight, attentively catering to our snack/breakfast needs. We absolutely loved it and can’t wait to return to the Mill House Inn. Thanks for making it such an awesome experience!

We had the most amazing time at the Mill House Inn! It was our first time to the Hamptons and it did not disappoint. Our room was cozy, clean, and the bed was super comfortable. Kenny was wonderful with restaurant recommendations and he even called us 2 weeks before our stay to alert us of the status of things with Covid. Dawn was a delight, attentively catering to our snack/breakfast needs. We absolutely loved it and can’t wait to return to the Mill House Inn. Thanks for making it such an awesome experience!

It was very nice.

The property was perfectly located and has almost every creature comfort you could want. The staff was friendly and very customer focused, making it a pleasure to stay. The breakfasts were pretty good as well, all fresh and locally sourced ingredients. All around a pleasurable experience and would definitely return.

Celebrating family birthday nearby, enjoyed our own solace during downtime and appreciated the service, delicious breakfast, staff, and gift bag of fab books!

Great Inn, lovely staff and the finest breakfast in the Hamptons. Highly recommended.

Loved the fresh cookies and squeezed juices. Do try the lobster frittata, yum!

Service, location, space, comfort, and quality are all words that come to mind when I think of my recent stay at the Mill House Inn. At so many other properties in the US, lost is the art of hospitality - not the case here. I haven't received this level of attentive care and detail at another property in quite some time. Having never been to the Hamptons, I took Mom "out East" during her visit this past weekend. After all, she had been hearing me talk about this little slice of heaven for 10+ years. I was torn between (this property) and the Topping Rose House, but ultimately chose the Mill House based on the slightly lower per-night prices and the fact that I simply love East Hampton. From the moment we arrived at the property, we were treated with genuine care and fabulous service, plus invited to enjoy an array of homemade snacks (plus dog food and treats) and beverages at our disposal. The front desk advised that we make reservations for breakfast the next morning (served between 8:30 and 10:30AM), as the in-house dining room would quickly fill up. Our 600+ square foot room included: kitchenette (mini-fridge stocked with alkaline water and seltzer, microwave, sink, cabinets, utensils/cups/plates/silverware), dining table with four chairs, two large and super comfy sofas, spa robes, a fire place, TV, king-sized bed, shower with two heads, two sinks (one for each of us), a separate whirlpool bathtub, and a doggy bed for my pup.

Service, location, space, comfort, and quality are all words that come to mind when I think of my recent stay at the Mill House Inn. At so many other properties in the US, lost is the art of hospitality - not the case here. I haven't received this level of attentive care and detail at another property in quite some time.Having never been to the Hamptons, I took Mom "out East" during her visit this past weekend. After all, she had been hearing me talk about this little slice of heaven for 10+ years. I was torn between (this property) and the Topping Rose House, but ultimately chose the Mill House based on the slightly lower per-night prices and the fact that I simply love East Hampton. From the moment we arrived at the property, we were treated with genuine care and fabulous service, plus invited to enjoy an array of homemade snacks (plus dog food and treats) and beverages at our disposal. The front desk advised that we make reservations for breakfast the next morning (served between 8:30 and 10:30AM), as the in-house dining room would quickly fill up. Our 600+ square foot room included: kitchenette (mini-fridge stocked with alkaline water and seltzer, microwave, sink, cabinets, utensils/cups/plates/silverware), dining table with four chairs, two large and super comfy sofas, spa robes, a fire place, TV, king-sized bed, shower with two heads, two sinks (one for each of us), a separate whirlpool bathtub, and a doggy bed for my pup.

The service was superb. Everyone made our stay very special

3500 dollars for two night and close to no service , this is just ridiculousI feel so bad I have not i had a late check in to the Hotel , a box was waiting for me at the reception with a key and how to get to my room .- in the fridge 4 bottles of water thats it - room was nice but certainly not 1750 USD per night - pillow where not comfy at all - the place is trying to be old fashion with elegance but it is just average the faucet are cheap the tile are cheap the air conditioning from the last century - went for breakfast and been told we can have wait one hour because they cant handle that many people at the same time . having said that it was a very good breakfast but remember 1750 per night -try to get a glass of wine after the beach and told no liquor licence but I can go to the liquor store and buy my own - I cant believe i paid so much money for this experience -i feel so stupid paying that much money for do it yourself is beyond comprehension - the owner of the place cant justify the price they charge

Cozy Inn with more amenities than you could ever want! Staff was very friendly...had a great conversation with the manager. Sara made check in a breeze, and was very informative. Breakfast was amazing! I am looking forward to another trip back.

Of course the Hamptons are expensive but over $375 on a cloudy, cold April weekend for a tiny room with street noise is a bit much. But add to that the %15 mandatory service charge on the price of the room and its ridiculous. The staff was lovely and sweet, but we didnt require nor receive any particular special service. The room was honestly so small it was uncomfortable and the bathroom was so small there was not room for your toothbrush (or a glass) on the sink. Sorry, but no.

Of course the Hamptons are expensive but over $375 on a cloudy, cold April weekend for a tiny room with street noise is a bit much. But add to that the %15 mandatory service charge on the price of the room and it's ridiculous. The staff was lovely and sweet, but we didn't require nor receive any particular special service. The room was honestly so small it was uncomfortable and the bathroom was so small there was not room for your toothbrush (or a glass) on the sink. Sorry, but no.

Luxury and perfect staff attention throughout our stay. Great amenities, soft beds, in room fireplace, amazing breakfasts. This is our new favorite getaway.

Great placed to stay. Staff was a delight and breakfast was unbelievable

Great placed to stay. Staff was a delight and breakfast was unbelievable

The Mill House was great, my wife and I went there over the Xmas holidays. The management & staff could not have been nicer -- they made us feel right at home. J, the General Manager, gave us a wonderful education about coffee, and lots of other topics too! The breakfasts were outstanding. All in all, we had a fine time and would definitely stay at the Mill House when we return to the Hamptons.

Breakfast was the best part of our stay followed by the comfort of the room and amenities in the bathroom.