We had a wonderful weekend at The Goat and Cherry in Sister Bay. The accommodations were perfect for a large group. Everyone loved the hot tub and fire pit! The communication from Tom was great and very helpful. We're planning our stay for next year!

Very quiet neighborhood with a large yard

The pictures are a great representation of the property. Just off the main drag in Sister Bay, the location could not be beat. Tom was easy to communicate with and responsive to messages. Perfect getaway spot for a couple, family or group of friends.

We had a relaxing stay at this property! The property was clean and and had everything that we needed to enjoy our stay. We especially loved the outdoor hot tub! The property is very close to shops and restaurants. My family would definitely stay here again!

Enjoyed the home and the outdoor property/amenities as well. 4 BDRM home with plenty of space to be together both upstairs and on the main floor with two separate TV rooms available. Big kitchen/tv room upstairs with amazing fire place and plenty of room to all hang out together. Back yard had beautiful firepit and a wonderful hot tub with its own roll structure to add a bit more privacy as well. Working with Tom was incredible as he went above and beyond with his communication to make sure all of our needs and expectations were being met. I would absolutely rent this property from Tom again and can't thank him enough for making our family feel so appreciated and looked over.

The location was great! Plenty of room for our family! communication and checkin process were flawless!

Nothing bad to say about this place...some ppl nit-pick over the darndest things, but we thought this place was the bomb-diggetty! :) Everything you'd ever need was pretty much already there. The fire pit & gazebo covered hot tub was our high light. Much needed vaca for us girls & it did not disappoint... close to everything! Would definitely stay here again! Tom (the host) was very fast on responding to any of our questions also.

There are a number of things that could use attention in the house that an owner staying in the property would find needed fixing: a broken drawer in the kitchen that we put back together, closet doors that we adjusted to close better, a crank out window that would lose it's guide and not be able to crank back in, refrigerator filter that needed cleaning so it cooled properly and pushed out door screens. We were surprised that the air-conditioning is only in the upstairs living room, the rest of the house relies on windows and ceiling fans for cooling. That's a problem with the downstairs twin bedroom. It only has a door leading to a small backyard deck and doesn't have a screen door. The carpet in that room could use replacing with tile as there is a strong mildew smell, most likely from people accessing the house from the hot tub and dripping water onto the carpet. One of the twin bed mattresses could also use replacing as it dips in the middle. However, the house was a perfect size for our group, had a nice layout, a very nice large yard and superb location. I'm conflicted on submitting this review because the house overall was very nice and Tom was responsive to our need for more towels and replacing a nonfunctional ceiling fan. For the amount of money we spent, it could be five stars but needs some repairs besides the ones we performed.