Great location. Very peaceful. House needs updating. Pool needs a cover. Spent a lot of time cleaning bugs out of pool. Arrival time is too late in the day and check out times to early. Seems two days are wasted. Overall we throughly enjoyed our time.

Very clean, nice location. Kids had a ball in the pool. Would recommend new bedsprings on some of the beds. Also some of the dishes had cracks/chips. A k-cup coffeemaker would help. But overall, a great stay.

Quick trip with 3 adult kids, daughter in law, toddler, and spouse.

We were a little disappointed when we got there cause the pool wasn’t in working order. Heater had not been on and after my husband worked on it… he got the heater to work. The one bathroom shower did not work only faucet for babies to take a bath so we all had to share one shower. I do have to say they did try to fix everything to the best of their ability. Also the ice maker in freezer was not working

All 3 toilets were rocky. Not solid. Spiders on the outside of the house. Take a hose and spray it off. My husband took a broom and wiped the front doors down. Other then that we loved it.

This was the perfect spot for you girls weekend getaway. The house was big enough and a great location. The private pool made for a nice spot with lots of room for everyone to lounge. The outdoor dining was wonderful to soak up the last few nice weekends of summer. The house was nice, there wasn’t a ton of resources to do all the cooking we did at the house. The plates were chipped and in rough shape and there were Cob webs all over but that was a quick fix.

Nice stay, quick response to any questions we had. Thank You again!

To start off a 5-7 pm Check-In is ridiculous when check out is 10am. The property needs a lot of work. Remotes Missing for 2 Ceiling Fans so you can’t use them. Another Ceiling Fan is so loud and shaking you are afraid to use it. Ice Machine did not work. Refrigerator door brackets missing so you lose all that space for condiments. When you open one of the kitchen cabinets the inside side wall falls down. The Pool Cover was taken off and throw in the yard so it is killing the grass and holding water which is attracting Mosquitoes besides terrible to look at. The landscaping is all over-grown and really makes the house look bad from the outside. The house has no extra bedding at all. Lastly at 6:30am on our last day the house fire alarm went off for no reason waking everyone up and scaring us. When I emailed the office the reply was - Sorry for the wake up call -II will have maintenance check on it after you leave. We go every year on vacation with the same friends and stay in a house. We have never been this disappointed in a place.

Wonderful place, clean and inviting! Had everything we needed for a group of 5 women! Bluefish rentals were great communicators as well for early check in. Will definitely be renting for my family of 5. Ideal location -walk to everything .

First vacation in a long time it was just what we needed... Nice house, great pool with perfect weather for the last week of September and great location.

This house was perfect. 6 of us got away for the weekend and visited some breweries and wineries. The house was perfect, plenty of space for everyone to sleep and spread out. The heated pool was a dream and the house was super close to town so we could walk and shop and eat out. I will for sure stay there again! The whole rental process was great and clear with great communication.

Overall we enjoyed our stay. The property could have been a little cleaner. There were cob webs in the corners and dead bugs around the floor. I would recommend bringing extra pillows and blankets if you have a full 12 people staying there. The pool was wonderful. Super clean and warm. They supplied pretty much everything we needed in the kitchen and bathrooms. Overall we really enjoyed our stay

We had a lovely stay at Anchors Away! The heated pool was perfect and where we spent most of our time. The only downside was bees (we stayed the last week of August) who liked to buzz around the grill when we cooked. There was an apple tree hanging over it that they couldn’t resist. Cutting back the landscaping and the trees a bit would likely help the problem. We had most everything we needed in the kitchen, though aluminum foil and plastic wrap were missing. The place was very clean and well stocked with towels. The location was excellent as you could easily walk to downtown (we had some delicious ice cream one day). The association beach was really a hazard and should be blocked off - basically a steep corner with giant rocks and large waves. For an adult sightseer it might be worth a quick visit but I wouldn’t bring kids. The directions to the beach we’re not accurate either - no white fence anymore and sign is hidden. The public beach however is a quick drive and was quite nice and not too crazy crowded on a weekday in late August. People were respecting social distancing. There was some confusion with check-out procedures not being consistent (emailed vs posted sign in the place) but we just went with the easier set of procedures and called it good. The early check out and late check in were a bummer but understandable what with COVID cleaning procedures. All in all we would stay again - the heated pool and location was perfect.

Loved everything about this house. Pool was amazing with a lot of lawn chairs and tables even pool toys. Had everything in house we needed. The only suggestion I have is that the kitchen garbage bags were poor quality and kitchen didn’t have any salt and pepper. Also ceiling fan in tv room and master bedroom did not work.

the pool is the centerpiece, great pool area. rest of property is decent, one newly remodeled bathroom, an issue with a faucet that was quickly repaired. walking distance to much of the town and beach.

We were originally scheduled to stay at the Harbor Grand as guests and were horrified when we learned a week before our trip that it had caught on fire! We had never used a service like this before and were skeptical. However, it was very easy! The house was perfect and exactly what we were looking for. We will definitely be staying here again.

Perfect spot for a weekend getaway! The heated pool was really nice.

This property is a great spot in New Buffalo! The heated pool was a great feature, especially with kids. The property was well maintained. I would note that two of the bedrooms adjoin, as that wasn’t clear from the listing. Also, the property said it had a DVD player but there wasn’t one in the house. The property manager did not return my call about that. Besides that, it was a great stay.

nice house for family gathering

We loved hanging by the heated private pool with our adult kids and grandkids! There was a lot of patio furniture and lounge chairs and a great grass area to play bean bags. Inside was spacious with two separate living areas. We really enjoyed our stay even though the weather didn’t cooperate. The only reason we didn’t give 5 stars is two things: 1) the kitchen including plates and utensils were not the cleanest, we re-washed everything and wiped out cabinets when we first arrived so we could eat and feel like it was clean. 2) the furnace/air conditioner was incredibly loud. It created a lot of white noise when running which was good at night but made communications inside more difficult. Besides these things, we had a very enjoyable stay and we would recommend for a family/friend stay.

We loved the house. It was convenient for visiting the wineries. We were able to bring our own dinner Friday night and cook it there. We also enjoyed being able to just stay in and play games. The house was clean and adorable. We would definitely stay again.