We absolutely loved our stay at Sully by the Sea. The location was great and community and amenities were all well maintained and cared for. We rented a golf cart and could easily get back and forth with beach front access. The house was great for our group of 9 which included 6 kids and allowed for a lot of different sleeping arrangements. The house was well stocked with everything you needed for the week. My husband kept saying they thought of everything. The host were amazing and responsive and really helped us in a pinch. This was our 30th year in Garden City and we’ve stayed in a few different set ups (houses, condos, etc) and this was definitely on our list to visit again.

Great house to share with family and friends. Recommend and would rent again. Beach is across the street and several restaurants with music entertainment, good food and fun about a mile away.

I will absolutely stay here again!! Clean, close to the beach and very responsive

This beach home has everything you need for a perfect family vacation! It’s beautiful and fully stocked, not to mention it’s in walking distance from the beach! The owners are wonderful, very helpful and respond to any questions in a quick manner! Our family will definitely be back to visit again soon!

Honest review. The house was awesome very nice, very well laid out and roomy for 10 of us everything we needed was available to use only had one issue but trust me the there was a lot of positives the floors needed sweeping when we first got in they were sandy other than that it was very very clean. A couple things we found out after making the reservation. One even though this is a golf cart community you cannot bring your own golf cart in I thought this was strange until I found you can rent them for $400 a week this has nothing to do with the the house rental at all that’s on the community for being greedy and the golf carts cannot be taken out of community. Two the gate passes you have to purchase there $20 each you get $10 back when you return them that’s was not known till I talked to the owner but we worked that out she was very nice by the way. The property easily within walking distance to the beach big plus the pool is a little bit of a hike and taking a car is recommended but parking is very limited. Also I saw the security giving tickets to cars parked in golf cart spots just a fyi. If I were to rate this house 8.5/10 beach access 9/10 pool access 5/10 restaurant within 3 miles 8.5/10.

The house was great! Property was just as listed. Easy Beach access! Oceanside Village was a great little community to stay in and we will definitely come back!

We will definitely be back to stay! The kitchen is fully stocked, the bathrooms are updated and pretty, the living space is open and comfortable, and the outdoor areas are great for relaxing. Located one street from the beach, you can’t go wrong!

Staying at Sully South by the Sea was a perfect place for our vacation. The home was so beautiful and has everything you could possibly need for a vacation. The decor is amazing and so welcoming. Very close to the beach. Very kid friendly. Hope to stay again.

This property was great.It was clean and beautiful.

Renting this property through VRBO was extremely easy! The website provided all of the process information, pictures of the property, contact information, price, etc. I needed in order to make a quick vacation decision for my family. This beach vacation was just perfect!!

Very clean. Spacious inside and out. Very family friendly area.

We've been coming to garden city for 6 years now and this is definitely the best place we've stayed! We will be back!

This place was amazing. It truly had everything we needed and more. The home was very comfortable and really close to the beach and some shopping. I can't find a single complaint.