Because my family lives in the Columbus area, we have been taking our family vacations close to home so the adults and older children can commute back and forth for work. We come to Indian Lake at least every other year. This is the largest and nicest home we have rented, here at the lake. The entire bldg was great. The beds were comfortable, everything in the house was in working order, and even though the 18 of us were loud at times, the neighbors were super friendly. The lake view from the deck was perfect… especially in the morning w my coffee.

Our student organization leaders stayed here to plan for our upcoming year. The facilities were great and relaxing and provided us optimal space to plan!

The good: house layout and amenities were very nice. Beds and rooms are comfortable. The breeze and view from the deck off the lake were fantastic. The bad: the neighbors at the end of the street on the right are rude, nasty people. The little old man yelled at my sister in law about parking down there despite the fact the house owner states we can use it since it is public parking area. The boat dock is not usable. We damaged our rental boat while pulling into and out of the dock. Beware of the exposed bolts on the bottom front left of the dock.

Plenty of room. Great view of lake

Our friend group is large and now we have 8 kids 0-6 to accommodate. This house was the perfect size for us.

Everything was as expected. Nice place.

We loved how clean and cozy it was! Excellent lake views and the cabin like feel we were looking for with all modern day amenities. You won’t be disappointed!

Easy to get to, well maintained, with up to date appliances. Three full bathrooms were a definite plus. The communications with John (manager) were excellent. Fast response time for any questions I had. Would stay again.

The bathrooms were hard for seniors to climb in and out of. The bathroom in the basement needs a total overhaul. You need pillowcases, most of us had to sleep on the shams . We could have used another towel per person. The boat house couldn’t be used and we had to tie up to the neighbors dock. Nice view of the lake from the balcony.

It was great friendly neighbors would book again

The property was just like reported. We had plenty of room to accommodate us all. Wish we had a few more baking pans such as baking dish or cake pan. There were nice cookware and a very nice grill We loved to deck and the table area below the deck. Spent lots of time outside. We will be back next year for sure!

This was the perfect property for our family. Plenty of rooms, bathrooms and common space. Great option if you want to rent a boat for your stay. We rented a boat and used the boat dock. Kids had a blast, fished off the dock! Fire pit is great to have in the evenings. Neighbors were all non-renters but very welcoming and friendly.

The property was OK, but the hot water was so hot that it was dangerous, the fan over the stove did not have a protective cover, needed more towels , additional bedding , blankets and pillows needed to be added, also, I think it should’ve had at least one hair blow dryer.

Large house with many bedrooms to accommodate our Mom/daughter trip. We had a great time!

We came in from Missouri to visit our Ohio family had a great stay. House was big enough for all our needs.

Property is large and spacious. Very clean and home like! We will definitely be booking again in the future!

We had a great time. My only recommendation is to spend some time cleaning up the house. It was dirty inside and out

We got to spend the weekend with our family. The house was great and loved big screen TV. We had movie night with them all.

We had plenty of room inside and out for four generations(12 people) to celebrate Thanksgiving weekend. The view of the lake was spectacular, especially at sunset. We are looking forward to spending time at your property again.

This is an excellent property and has a great view of the lake!

Went to the Minster Octoberfest and used the house for friends and family gather for the weekend. Nice house. Large and comfortable.

This house was perfect for our yearly friends weekend. The house is beautiful and well supplied. John was quick to answer any questions. The only downside is there is only parking for 4 cars and we had 7 because we came from all different parts of the state. Parking at the state park was not a huge problem, just a little inconvenient. Overall, an excellent stay! Getting ready to book for next year!!!

The property was nice and the perfect size for our family, everyone had a bedroom.

Great property plenty of room for the family and nice view of the lake. Pity Indian lake is not very clean currently, how ever Poonton rental helped us to have fun on the water. Thank you - John

The water smelled an tasted so bad the owner recommended that we not drink it.

The house was amazing. I loved the wooden floors but also the soft thick carpet. My kids loved all the rooms and TV. The view was beautiful. The boat dock was compacted with weeds. With the lakes current weed situation it was not ideal for swimming or boating unfortunately. Once the weed part clears up we will be back again.

This property was perfect for our family. We had plenty of room and the location for the fireworks on the lake was amazing! The home is beautiful and well equipped. We would definitely stay here again!

The house was great! John was very responsive when we had questions and was very helpful!

Host had great communication and was flexible to our groups needs. Lots of rooms to stay and everything was perfectly clean. Overall a very nice property with a great view of the lake.

My now husband and I, booked this rental around Christmas of 2021 for our stay this past weekend of June 3-6. From the booking to check out, this property owner was five stars. But nothing could have prepared us for how beautiful the home is both inside and out!! We had a very large group stay in the home over the course of our wedding weekend. It easily accommodated a family of 5 (3 children 10-11 yoa), family of 3 (which included an infant), the parents of the bride, two additional couples, and my husband and I the final night. The home is set up perfectly to allow group gatherings and activities, yet moments of privacy for families and couples. We successfully managed to ALL get ready the day of the wedding in the spacious home which has 3 full baths. Breakfast was an easy task with the kitchen equipment and supplies included. Lots of great memories were made here! From our nights out by the fire, to breakfasts inside, to the beautiful photographs taken by our wedding photographer and friends. Those last minute things you could forget or not think of.. were not an issue at this home! They supplied toilet paper, towels, bedding, kitchenware, washer and dryer, parking, patio furniture, and so much more! Thank you so much for a perfect weekend and stay! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ We hope to be back with our family soon!

We wanted to spend a weekend on the lake with our friends before we moved and this place was perfect! There were no paper towels, which was a minor inconvenience. I also understand people steal them, so maybe that’s why. Overall great experience!

The house was very nice. Good views of the lake. Neighbors were friendly. You are close to the neighbors so getting to know them is helpful. Grocery and restaurant are close by.