Very central location, old world charm, clean and comfortable.

Walls paper thin.

"Old school" charm. Comfortable seating when not sleeping. Walking distance to everything in town.

The bed was a a little firm for me but acceptable.

close to the town, very clean

room was very small

In the main lobby, the vintage/antique details are lovely! The rooms have actual keys, and the property has tried to stay relevant to the period the hotel was founded which I appreciate. the staff were all friendly and helpful!

We stayed in the garden suites so I can’t speak to the rooms in the main hotel. Our room smelled like old things - difficult to describe, but like old carpet and old upholstery that holds smells. Some of the furniture was period appropriate, but some of it wasn’t and just looked and felt old and outdated rather than well done, purposely antique details. the fireplace tiles (redone) we’re cracked, and the bathroom was dated rather than “classic.” The bed was not comfortable, and the pillows were too full and stiff. There needed to be more pillows for sleeping other than the king sized shams that are difficult to sleep on.

I liked the location

Room was tiny, the internet didn't works, bed was uncomfortable.....

Everything

Some things not working

I was so cold me and my lady froze the plug in heater was broke and it was freezing all night

cold cold cold

the stile

location was right in town .Easy walking distance to all restaurants and shops , as well as waterfront just a couple blocks away .

Very deceptive picture of hotel vs actual rooms . We went to hotel only to find out the restaurant and bar were closed and that our room was not in hotel ,but rather in decrepit old building in back parking lot . The only view was of a bush in window that looked out to parking lot . The room was clean but very dated at best . We had to make reservations with only a few days notice , so we took what we could get . Would never consider staying here again . The guy who check us in could not of looked less interested in helping us find the place we were to stay or asking us if we had any questions . " you are not staying in hotel , go up street to water tower and take right turn . The rooms are back behind in a parking lot " . "Ok , thanks "

great location, neat old building, sweet downstairs lounge area with tea and coffee 24/7.

my room was tiny

The location was great--within easy walking distance of the shoreline, shops, and restaurants. The staff were friendly and accessible. Checkin and checkout were simple. The balconies on the second floor are great when the weather is pleasant.

The hotel has "great bones" as they say, but could really use some attention. The wallpaper and carpets are worn and the shower door could be replaced. On the whole the hotel feels a bit tired for the price we paid through booking.com, which was nearly double the normal rate. The photos on Booking were not a fair representation of our actual room. The "queen" sized bed was actually a double. Given that it was winter and we had no control over the thermostat, we were rather cold overnight.

location.

heating in room.

The location is the best in Mendocino. Sitting on the balcony watching both sunrise and sunset is priceless. And the authentic decorations from old days make this a different experience that you don’t forget.

The room was a bit small and the bed not big enough for two adults. Wi-Fi was unstable.

Staff was great, Hotel is still beautiful and in a great location.

No mention that the bar, restaurant are both closed, the fireplace in lobby is out of order (?????) no housekeeping! It’s very very very bare bones at the moment. NOT at all like my last stay. New owners take note!!!

location!!! price!! lobby with comfortable choices to relax, coffee tea bar open and free all day long.

bedding

location

run down very ready for an update - all amenities closed

Location in town

I loved the decor, the location and the locals

great location!

we only had HOT water. They had us shower in another room. Not at all convenient though doable. Coffee pot did not work. Ownership is under change so much work needs to be done on this place.